BACKGROUND: Determining bacterial abundance variation is the first step in understanding bacterial similarity between individuals. Categorization of bacterial communities into groups or community classes is the subsequent step in describing microbial distribution based on abundance patterns. Here, we present an analysis of the groupings of bacterial communities in stool, nasal, skin, vaginal and oral habitats in a healthy cohort of 236 subjects from the Human Microbiome Project. RESULTS: We identify distinct community group patterns in the anterior nares, four skin sites, and vagina at the genus level. We also confirm three enterotypes previously identified in stools. We identify two clusters with low silhouette values in most oral sites, in which bacterial communities are more homogeneous. Subjects sharing a community class in one habitat do not necessarily share a community class in another, except in the three vaginal sites and the symmetric habitats of the left and right retroauricular creases. Demographic factors, including gender, age, and ethnicity, significantly influence community composition in several habitats. Community classes in the vagina, retroauricular crease and stool are stable over approximately 200 days. CONCLUSION: The community composition, association of demographic factors with community classes, and demonstration of community stability deepen our understanding of the variability and dynamics of human microbiomes. This also has significant implications for experimental designs that seek microbial correlations with clinical phenotypes.
BACKGROUND: Determining bacterial abundance variation is the first step in understanding bacterial similarity between individuals. Categorization of bacterial communities into groups or community classes is the subsequent step in describing microbial distribution based on abundance patterns. Here, we present an analysis of the groupings of bacterial communities in stool, nasal, skin, vaginal and oral habitats in a healthy cohort of 236 subjects from the Human Microbiome Project. RESULTS: We identify distinct community group patterns in the anterior nares, four skin sites, and vagina at the genus level. We also confirm three enterotypes previously identified in stools. We identify two clusters with low silhouette values in most oral sites, in which bacterial communities are more homogeneous. Subjects sharing a community class in one habitat do not necessarily share a community class in another, except in the three vaginal sites and the symmetric habitats of the left and right retroauricular creases. Demographic factors, including gender, age, and ethnicity, significantly influence community composition in several habitats. Community classes in the vagina, retroauricular crease and stool are stable over approximately 200 days. CONCLUSION: The community composition, association of demographic factors with community classes, and demonstration of community stability deepen our understanding of the variability and dynamics of human microbiomes. This also has significant implications for experimental designs that seek microbial correlations with clinical phenotypes.
Authors: Jacques Ravel; Pawel Gajer; Zaid Abdo; G Maria Schneider; Sara S K Koenig; Stacey L McCulle; Shara Karlebach; Reshma Gorle; Jennifer Russell; Carol O Tacket; Rebecca M Brotman; Catherine C Davis; Kevin Ault; Ligia Peralta; Larry J Forney Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2010-06-03 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Brian J Haas; Dirk Gevers; Ashlee M Earl; Mike Feldgarden; Doyle V Ward; Georgia Giannoukos; Dawn Ciulla; Diana Tabbaa; Sarah K Highlander; Erica Sodergren; Barbara Methé; Todd Z DeSantis; Joseph F Petrosino; Rob Knight; Bruce W Birren Journal: Genome Res Date: 2011-01-06 Impact factor: 9.043
Authors: Marcus J Claesson; Siobhán Cusack; Orla O'Sullivan; Rachel Greene-Diniz; Heleen de Weerd; Edel Flannery; Julian R Marchesi; Daniel Falush; Timothy Dinan; Gerald Fitzgerald; Catherine Stanton; Douwe van Sinderen; Michael O'Connor; Norma Harnedy; Kieran O'Connor; Colm Henry; Denis O'Mahony; Anthony P Fitzgerald; Fergus Shanahan; Cillian Twomey; Colin Hill; R Paul Ross; Paul W O'Toole Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2010-06-22 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Floyd E Dewhirst; Tuste Chen; Jacques Izard; Bruce J Paster; Anne C R Tanner; Wen-Han Yu; Abirami Lakshmanan; William G Wade Journal: J Bacteriol Date: 2010-07-23 Impact factor: 3.490
Authors: Manimozhiyan Arumugam; Jeroen Raes; Eric Pelletier; Denis Le Paslier; Takuji Yamada; Daniel R Mende; Gabriel R Fernandes; Julien Tap; Thomas Bruls; Jean-Michel Batto; Marcelo Bertalan; Natalia Borruel; Francesc Casellas; Leyden Fernandez; Laurent Gautier; Torben Hansen; Masahira Hattori; Tetsuya Hayashi; Michiel Kleerebezem; Ken Kurokawa; Marion Leclerc; Florence Levenez; Chaysavanh Manichanh; H Bjørn Nielsen; Trine Nielsen; Nicolas Pons; Julie Poulain; Junjie Qin; Thomas Sicheritz-Ponten; Sebastian Tims; David Torrents; Edgardo Ugarte; Erwin G Zoetendal; Jun Wang; Francisco Guarner; Oluf Pedersen; Willem M de Vos; Søren Brunak; Joel Doré; María Antolín; François Artiguenave; Hervé M Blottiere; Mathieu Almeida; Christian Brechot; Carlos Cara; Christian Chervaux; Antonella Cultrone; Christine Delorme; Gérard Denariaz; Rozenn Dervyn; Konrad U Foerstner; Carsten Friss; Maarten van de Guchte; Eric Guedon; Florence Haimet; Wolfgang Huber; Johan van Hylckama-Vlieg; Alexandre Jamet; Catherine Juste; Ghalia Kaci; Jan Knol; Omar Lakhdari; Severine Layec; Karine Le Roux; Emmanuelle Maguin; Alexandre Mérieux; Raquel Melo Minardi; Christine M'rini; Jean Muller; Raish Oozeer; Julian Parkhill; Pierre Renault; Maria Rescigno; Nicolas Sanchez; Shinichi Sunagawa; Antonio Torrejon; Keith Turner; Gaetana Vandemeulebrouck; Encarna Varela; Yohanan Winogradsky; Georg Zeller; Jean Weissenbach; S Dusko Ehrlich; Peer Bork Journal: Nature Date: 2011-04-20 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Elizabeth A Grice; Heidi H Kong; Sean Conlan; Clayton B Deming; Joie Davis; Alice C Young; Gerard G Bouffard; Robert W Blakesley; Patrick R Murray; Eric D Green; Maria L Turner; Julia A Segre Journal: Science Date: 2009-05-29 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Gary D Wu; Jun Chen; Christian Hoffmann; Kyle Bittinger; Ying-Yu Chen; Sue A Keilbaugh; Meenakshi Bewtra; Dan Knights; William A Walters; Rob Knight; Rohini Sinha; Erin Gilroy; Kernika Gupta; Robert Baldassano; Lisa Nessel; Hongzhe Li; Frederic D Bushman; James D Lewis Journal: Science Date: 2011-09-01 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Nisha B Patel; Raul Y Tito; Alexandra J Obregón-Tito; Lindsey O'Neal; Omar Trujillo-Villaroel; Luis Marin-Reyes; Luzmila Troncoso-Corzo; Emilio Guija-Poma; Cecil M Lewis; Paul A Lawson Journal: Int J Syst Evol Microbiol Date: 2016-02-23 Impact factor: 2.747
Authors: Paul I Costea; Falk Hildebrand; Manimozhiyan Arumugam; Fredrik Bäckhed; Martin J Blaser; Frederic D Bushman; Willem M de Vos; S Dusko Ehrlich; Claire M Fraser; Masahira Hattori; Curtis Huttenhower; Ian B Jeffery; Dan Knights; James D Lewis; Ruth E Ley; Howard Ochman; Paul W O'Toole; Christopher Quince; David A Relman; Fergus Shanahan; Shinichi Sunagawa; Jun Wang; George M Weinstock; Gary D Wu; Georg Zeller; Liping Zhao; Jeroen Raes; Rob Knight; Peer Bork Journal: Nat Microbiol Date: 2017-12-18 Impact factor: 17.745
Authors: B Y Hong; A Hoare; A Cardenas; A K Dupuy; L Choquette; A L Salner; P K Schauer; U Hegde; D E Peterson; A Dongari-Bagtzoglou; L D Strausbaugh; P I Diaz Journal: J Dent Res Date: 2020-04-21 Impact factor: 6.116
Authors: Lindsey O'Neal; Alexandra J Obregón-Tito; Raul Y Tito; Andrew T Ozga; Susan I Polo; Cecil M Lewis; Paul A Lawson Journal: Anaerobe Date: 2015-06-26 Impact factor: 3.331
Authors: Wouter A A de Steenhuijsen Piters; Elisabeth A M Sanders; Debby Bogaert Journal: Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci Date: 2015-08-19 Impact factor: 6.237
Authors: Alex E Mohr; Ralf Jäger; Katie C Carpenter; Chad M Kerksick; Martin Purpura; Jeremy R Townsend; Nicholas P West; Katherine Black; Michael Gleeson; David B Pyne; Shawn D Wells; Shawn M Arent; Richard B Kreider; Bill I Campbell; Laurent Bannock; Jonathan Scheiman; Craig J Wissent; Marco Pane; Douglas S Kalman; Jamie N Pugh; Carmen P Ortega-Santos; Jessica A Ter Haar; Paul J Arciero; Jose Antonio Journal: J Int Soc Sports Nutr Date: 2020-05-12 Impact factor: 5.150