PURPOSE: The main objective of the present study was the investigation of possible influence of lens opacification on macular pigment optical density (MPOD) measurements. METHODS: Eighty-six eyes of 64 patients (mean age 73.4 ± 8.3 years) were included in the study. MPOD was prospectively measured using the one-wavelength reflection method (Visucam500, Carl Zeiss Meditec AG) before and after cataract extraction, with implantation of a blue-light filtering intraocular lens (AlconSN60WF). The median of the maximum optical density (MaxOD) and the median of the mean optical density (MeanOD) measurements of macular pigment across the subject group were evaluated. RESULTS: Statistically significant differences were noticed between pre-operative and post-operative measurements, the absolute values were generally lower after cataract extraction. The following median (lower/upper quartile) differences across the group were determined: MaxOD -33.8 % (-46.2 to -19.1 %), MeanOD -44.0 % (-54.6 to -26.6 %). Larger changes were observed in elderly patients [<70 years of age (n = 25 eyes): MaxOD -13.4 % (-20.5 to 3.6 %), MeanOD -23.6 % (-30.5 to -15.3 %) versus patients ≥70 years (n = 61 eyes) MaxOD -40.5 % (-53.2 to -30.1 %), MeanOD -47.2 % (-57.8 to -40.1 %)] and in patients with progressed stage of cataract. MaxOD for lens opacification grade 1 (n = 9 eyes): -27.4 % (-42.1 to -19.6 %), grade 2 (n = 26 eyes): -35.0 % (-44.2 to -25.3 %), grade 3 (n = 21 eyes): -34.4 % (-45.4 to -11.4 %), grade 4 (n = 25 eyes): -32.6 % (-53.2 to -6.4 %), and grade 5 (n = 5 eyes): -53.5 % (-61.7 to -38.7 %) and MeanOD for cataract stage 1 (n = 9 eyes): -42.6 % (-46.0 to -26.0 %), stage 2 (n = 26 eyes): -44.1 % (-51.8 to -26.2 %), stage 3 (n = 21 eyes): -45.7 % (-54.7 to -24.7 %), stage 4 (n = 25 eyes): -39.5 % (-59.4 to -26.1 %), and stage 5 (n = 5 eyes): -57.0 % (-66.1 to -51.4 %). CONCLUSIONS: As established by comparison of pre- to post-operative measurements, cataract presented a strong effect on MPOD measured by one-wavelength reflection method. Particular care should therefore be taken when evaluating MPOD using this method in elderly patients with progressed stage of cataract. Future optimization of correcting parameters of scattered light and consideration of cataract influence may allow more precise evaluation of MPOD.
PURPOSE: The main objective of the present study was the investigation of possible influence of lens opacification on macular pigment optical density (MPOD) measurements. METHODS: Eighty-six eyes of 64 patients (mean age 73.4 ± 8.3 years) were included in the study. MPOD was prospectively measured using the one-wavelength reflection method (Visucam500, Carl Zeiss Meditec AG) before and after cataract extraction, with implantation of a blue-light filtering intraocular lens (AlconSN60WF). The median of the maximum optical density (MaxOD) and the median of the mean optical density (MeanOD) measurements of macular pigment across the subject group were evaluated. RESULTS: Statistically significant differences were noticed between pre-operative and post-operative measurements, the absolute values were generally lower after cataract extraction. The following median (lower/upper quartile) differences across the group were determined: MaxOD -33.8 % (-46.2 to -19.1 %), MeanOD -44.0 % (-54.6 to -26.6 %). Larger changes were observed in elderly patients [<70 years of age (n = 25 eyes): MaxOD -13.4 % (-20.5 to 3.6 %), MeanOD -23.6 % (-30.5 to -15.3 %) versus patients ≥70 years (n = 61 eyes) MaxOD -40.5 % (-53.2 to -30.1 %), MeanOD -47.2 % (-57.8 to -40.1 %)] and in patients with progressed stage of cataract. MaxOD for lens opacification grade 1 (n = 9 eyes): -27.4 % (-42.1 to -19.6 %), grade 2 (n = 26 eyes): -35.0 % (-44.2 to -25.3 %), grade 3 (n = 21 eyes): -34.4 % (-45.4 to -11.4 %), grade 4 (n = 25 eyes): -32.6 % (-53.2 to -6.4 %), and grade 5 (n = 5 eyes): -53.5 % (-61.7 to -38.7 %) and MeanOD for cataract stage 1 (n = 9 eyes): -42.6 % (-46.0 to -26.0 %), stage 2 (n = 26 eyes): -44.1 % (-51.8 to -26.2 %), stage 3 (n = 21 eyes): -45.7 % (-54.7 to -24.7 %), stage 4 (n = 25 eyes): -39.5 % (-59.4 to -26.1 %), and stage 5 (n = 5 eyes): -57.0 % (-66.1 to -51.4 %). CONCLUSIONS: As established by comparison of pre- to post-operative measurements, cataract presented a strong effect on MPOD measured by one-wavelength reflection method. Particular care should therefore be taken when evaluating MPOD using this method in elderly patients with progressed stage of cataract. Future optimization of correcting parameters of scattered light and consideration of cataract influence may allow more precise evaluation of MPOD.
Authors: John Nolan; Orla O'Donovan; Heather Kavanagh; Jim Stack; Michael Harrison; Annalouise Muldoon; John Mellerio; Stephen Beatty Journal: Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci Date: 2004-11 Impact factor: 4.799
Authors: B R Hammond; E J Johnson; R M Russell; N I Krinsky; K J Yeum; R B Edwards; D M Snodderly Journal: Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci Date: 1997-08 Impact factor: 4.799
Authors: Paul S Bernstein; François C Delori; Stuart Richer; Frederik J M van Kuijk; Adam J Wenzel Journal: Vision Res Date: 2009-10-23 Impact factor: 1.886
Authors: Grant A Rutledge; Steven G Pratt; Stuart P Richer; Byki Huntjens; C Blake Perry; Gunilla Pratt; Carla Podella Journal: BMC Ophthalmol Date: 2020-12-02 Impact factor: 2.209
Authors: Christopher D Conrady; James P Bell; Brian M Besch; Aruna Gorusupudi; Kelliann Farnsworth; Igor Ermakov; Mohsen Sharifzadeh; Maia Ermakova; Werner Gellermann; Paul S Bernstein Journal: Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci Date: 2017-07-01 Impact factor: 4.799