| Literature DB >> 24705501 |
Liwei Liu1, Lars Herfindal2, Jouni Jokela3, Tania Keiko Shishido4, Matti Wahlsten5, Stein Ove Døskeland6, Kaarina Sivonen7.
Abstract
In this study, we investigated forty cyanobacterial isolates from biofilms, gastropods, brackish water and symbiotic lichen habitats. Their aqueous and organic extracts were used to screen for apoptosis-inducing activity against acute myeloid leukemia cells. A total of 28 extracts showed cytotoxicity against rat acute myeloid leukemia (IPC-81) cells. The design of the screen made it possible to eliminate known toxins, such as microcystins and nodularin, or known metabolites with anti-leukemic activity, such as adenosine and its analogs. A cytotoxicity test on human embryonic kidney (HEK293T) fibroblasts indicated that 21 of the 28 extracts containing anti-acute myeloid leukemia (AML) activity showed selectivity in favor of leukemia cells. Extracts L26-O and L30-O were able to partly overcome the chemotherapy resistance induced by the oncogenic protein Bcl-2, whereas extract L1-O overcame protection from the deletion of the tumor suppressor protein p53. In conclusion, cyanobacteria are a prolific resource for anti-leukemia compounds that have potential for pharmaceutical applications. Based on the variety of cellular responses, we also conclude that the different anti-leukemic compounds in the cyanobacterial extracts target different elements of the death machinery of mammalian cells.Entities:
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2014 PMID: 24705501 PMCID: PMC4012442 DOI: 10.3390/md12042036
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Mar Drugs ISSN: 1660-3397 Impact factor: 5.118
The cyanobacteria strain studied. All Nostoc strains are lichen symbionts. Coordinates: 59°49ʹ55″ N, 23°5ʹ10″ E (Kobben) and 59°49ʹ11–22″ N, 22°58ʹ34″–59ʹ10″ E (Hanko Casino sea shore (HC)).
| Code | Genus | Strain | Live habitat; Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| L1 | HAN 24/1 | Rock pond water, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L2 | HAN 33/2 | Brown/yellow biofilm, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L3 | HAN 38/3 | Red biofilm, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L4 | HAN 6/4 | Growth on rock waterline, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L5 | HAN 17/1 | Red biofilm, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L6 | HAN 21/4 | Gastropod 10 cm under water, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L7 | HAN 15/1 | Gastropod from waterline, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L8 | HAN 21/3 | Gastropod 10 cm under water, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L9 | HAN 37/3 | Green biofilm, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L10 | HAN 21/5 | Gastropod 10 cm under water, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L11 | HAN 36/2 | Biofilm, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L12 | HAN 22/1 | Black biofilm, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L13 | HAN 22/2 | Black biofilm, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L14 | HAN 6/3 | Growth on rock waterline, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L15 | HAN 8/1 | Biofilm, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L16 | HAN 38/2 | Red biofilm, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L17 | HAN 3/19 | Green biofilm, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L18 | HAN 33/1 | Brown/yellow biofilm, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L19 | HAN 37/1 | Green biofilm, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L20 | HAN 16/1 | Waterplant from shallow water, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L21 | HAN 37/2 | Green biofilm, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L22 | HAN 26/2 | Black biofilm, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L23 | HAN 30/2 | Green biofilm and Gastropod, HC, Hanko, Finland | |
| L24 | HAN 20/2 | Black grains from rock surface, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L25 | HAN 15/2 | Gastropod from waterline, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L26 | HAN 21/1 | Gastropod 10 cm under water, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L27 | HAN 16/2 | Waterplant from shallow water, Kobben, Hanko, Finland | |
| L28 | UK 2aImII | ||
| L29 | UK 222IIc | ||
| L30 | 113.5 | ||
| L31 | UK 92Ic | ||
| L32 | UK 89 | ||
| L33 | UK 81I | ||
| L34 | UK 222Ib | ||
| L35 | UK 60II | ||
| L36 | N135.9.1 | lichen, unknown | |
| L37 | N138 | lichen, unknown | |
| L38 | UK 104 | ||
| L39 | UK 220Ib | ||
| L40 | N134.1 | lichen, unknown |
Figure 1Leukemia cell death induced by cyanobacteria extracts. IPC-81 cells were incubated with extracts from a 5-mg biomass/mL cell suspension for 24 h before fixation in 2% buffered formaldehyde (pH 7.4). The X-axis gives the strain numbers (see Table 1 for details). Cell death was assessed by microscopic assessment of the surface and nuclear morphology. Horizontal lines show 30% (low) and 70% (high) apoptosis levels. A: aqueous; O: organic.
Figure 2Human embryonic kidney (HEK293T) cell death induced by cyanobacteria extracts. HEK293T cells were incubated with extracts from a 5-mg biomass/ml cell suspension for 24 h before fixation in 2% buffered formaldehyde (pH 7.4). Cell death was assessed by microscopic assessment of surface and nuclear morphology. Horizontal lines show 30% (low) and 70% (high) apoptosis levels. A: aqueous; O: organic.
Figure 3The presence of adenosine deaminase-sensitive compounds in cyanobacterial extracts. Cyanobacterial extracts were added to normal medium or medium containing adenosine deaminase and left to incubate at 30 min before the addition of IPC-81 cells. The cells were further incubated for 24 h before fixation and assessment of cell death, as described in the legend for Figure 1. As a control, adenosine was added to the medium with or without adenosine deaminase (left panel).
Figure 4Cell death morphology in OATP1B3-transfected HEK293T cells treated with cyanobacterial extracts. HEK293T cells were transfected with OATP1B3 cells, as described in the Methods section, and treated with 5 mg/mL cyanobacterial extracts for 90 min before fixation in 2% buffered formaldehyde. (A,D,G) Normal morphology; (D,G) after treatment of extracts showing no bioactivity; (B,C) early and late apoptotic cells induced by 800 nM nodularin; (E) the nodularin-like response from cyanobacterial extract; (H) cell rounding and small blebs, which could be the signs of early apoptosis; (F,I) severe necrosis, perhaps induced by membrane-damaging compounds. A-extracts (D–G) are aqueous, and O-extracts (H,I) are organic. The scale bar represents 15 μm.
The presence of microcystin and microcystin-like activity in selected cyanobacteria extracts.
| Extract | Microcystin-like activity in OATP-transfected HEK293 cells | Microcystins by LC-MS (nM) |
|---|---|---|
| L1-A | − | − |
| L7-A | − | 3.9 |
| L9-A | − | − |
| L12-A | − | − |
| L19-A | − | − |
| L20-A | − | − |
| L26-A | − | − |
| L30 A | ND | 3.8 |
| L31-A | + | 2100 |
| L32-A | ++ | 2700 |
| L33-A | + | 5100 |
| L35-A | / | 2600 |
| L36-A | − | 620 |
| L37-A | + | 13,000 |
| L38-A | − | 54 |
| L39-A | + | 2200 |
| L40-A | + | 1300 |
| L1-O | − | − |
| L10-O | − | − |
| L19-O | − | − |
| L25-O | − | − |
| L26-O | − | − |
| L32-O | − | 43 |
| L33-O | − | 89 |
| L38-O | − | 5.6 |
The + signifies the presence of bioactivity-inducing microcystin-like apoptotic morphology in OATP1B3-transfected HEK293 cells (second column) or the detection of microcystin or nodularin by LC-MS (third column). +, present, but less than 30% apoptosis; ++, strong (30%–100% apoptosis); −, absent; /, unknown; ND = not determined due to necrotic morphology.
The involvement of the chemotherapy resistance gene in apoptosis caused by potent cyanobacteria extracts. A comparison of the EC50 values of potent cyanobacterial extracts against IPC-81 and Molm-13 cell lines.
| Extract | EC50 (IPC-81) | Bcl-2 a | p53 b | EC50 (Molm-13) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| L19-A | 2.4 | - | 0 | 2.1 |
| L26-A | >3.1 | - | 0 | >3.1 |
| L30-A | 0.8 | - | - | <0.5 |
| L36-A | >4.8 | - | 0 | >4.8 |
| L1-O | 0.3 | - | - | <0.3 |
| L26-O | <0.3 | + | 0 | <<0.3 |
| L30-O | ND | + | ND | ND |
a -, extract not able to overcome resistance from Bcl-2; +, extract induces cell death also in cells overexpressing Bcl-2; b 0, no change in cell response dependent on the p53 status; −, absence of p53 protects cells from cyanobacterial extract; +, absence of P53 sensitizes cells to cyanobacterial extract; ND, not determined.