Voriconazole or amphotericin B as primary therapy yields distinct early serum galactomannan trends related to outcomes in invasive aspergillosis.

An improved number of anti-fungal drugs are currently available for the treatment of invasive aspergillosis (IA). While serial galactomannan index (GMI) measurement can be used to monitor response to treatment, the extent to which different anti-fungal regimens can affect galactomannan levels is unknown. In 147 IA patients receiving either voriconazole (VCZ) or conventional amphotericin B (CAB) in a multicentre clinical trial, we performed post-hoc analyses of GMI trends in relation to outcomes. The generalized estimation equations approach was used to estimate changes in the effect size for GMI over time within patients. Patients who received VCZ primary therapy and had good treatment response 12 weeks later showed earlier decreases in GMI values at Week 1 and Week 2 (p = 0.001 and 0.046 respectively) as compared to patients who only received CAB. At end-of-randomized therapy (EORT), which was a pre-set secondary assessment point for all patients who switched from randomized primary (CAB or VCZ) to an alternative anti-fungal drug, treatment failure was associated with increasing GMI at Weeks 1 and 2 in CAB-primary treated patients (p = 0.022 and 0.046 respectively). These distinct trends highlight the variations in GMI kinetics with the use of different anti-fungal drugs and their implications in relation to IA treatment response.

RCT Entities:   Population Interventions Outcomes

Introduction

Invasive aspergillosis (IA) is the most common opportunistic mold infection in immunocompromised patients and leads to significant morbidity and mortality. The presence of neutropenia and the concurrent use immunomodulatory agents not only hinder the ability of the host to mount an efficient inflammatory response against the pathogen but also make the monitoring of response to anti-fungal treatment difficult. Galactomannan is a distinct polysaccharide component of the Aspergillus cell wall and its quantification can serve as a surrogate marker for fungal burden [1]. The detection of galactomannan with the Platelia Aspergillus EIA, the galactomannan index (GMI) has been adopted as a criterion in the diagnosis of IA [2], [3] and it has also been suggested that serial determination of serum GMI may be useful for monitoring the response to treatment [4]. Recently, we explored the prognostic usefulness of serial GMI measurements and reported that early GMI trends at Week 1 and Week 2 of anti-fungal treatment were of value for predicting eventual clinical outcomes [5]. Our analysis was based on the well-characterized IA patient cohort in the landmark multicenter Global Aspergillosis Study, which compared the efficacy of voriconazole (VCZ) versus conventional amphotericin B deoxycholate (CAB) as primary therapy for IA [6]. However the influence of the respective anti-fungal agents on GMI trends was not delineated in the above study.

Voriconazole has since become the recommended primary drug of choice for treatment of IA [7]. However, alternative anti-fungal regimens, including amphotericin-based formulations and the echinocandins, continue to be prescribed for IA patients when voriconazole use is contraindicated due to intolerance, or in the setting of azole-resistant Aspergillus species [8]. Furthermore, in those regions where healthcare resources remain restricted, amphotericin B deoxycholate continues to be a commonly used anti-fungal agent [9]. The respective therapies may exhibit differing efficacies and may also differentially influence GMI measurements. This could have a critical bearing on the interpretation of serial GMI trends in relation to clinical response. However in this context, the effect of anti-fungal regimens on GMI trends during treatment has never been studied.

Our hypothesis was that anti-fungal drugs could have distinct influences on early GMI trends that may subsequently predict clinical outcome. We tested this hypothesis, post-hoc, in a well-characterized cohort of study patients who received either VCZ or CAB for the primary treatment of IA.

Patients and Methods

The patients studied were from Protocol 150–307 of the Global Comparative Aspergillosis Study, a multicenter randomized trial conducted in Europe, Australia and Israel that compared the efficacy of VCZ versus CAB for the primary treatment of IA. The lead organiser of the study was the European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer (EORTC) (with the respective protocol identifiers EORTC-19961 and ClinicalTrials.gov NCT00003031). The protocol was approved by the appropriate institutional review boards in all participating centers, and written informed consent was obtained from all patients. The selection of patients and conduct of the trial were as previously published [6]. Patients assessed by the attending physician as having no response or intolerance to the initial randomized drug (VCZ or CAB) could be switched to other licensed antifungal therapy (OLAT). Blood specimens were obtained serially from trial patients at baseline, upon recruitment, and at Weeks 1, 2 and 4 following commencement of randomized anti-fungal therapy. The current study was a post-hoc analysis of serial serum GM trends of patients receiving anti-fungal treatment for IA. Serum GM was measured at a central laboratory (Health Protection Agency Mycology Reference Laboratory, Bristol, U.K.) within 2 years upon completion of the trial and was performed according to the manufacturer's instructions (Platelia Aspergillus EIA, Bio-Rad Laboratories, Marne-la-Coquette, France). Random testing for stability of the stored samples showed an average GMI decrease of 11% over 13 months. Acute kidney injury (AKI) was defined as a 2-fold increase in serum creatinine during anti-fungal therapy in relation to the baseline level before starting treatment, or a level >3 mg/dL (265 µmol/L) if the baseline value was >1.5 mg/dL (133 µmol/L) [6].

Outcome measures were assessed by an independent and blinded data review committee (DRC) based on reviews of clinical, mycological and systematically-collected radiological data. As the primary end-point, satisfactory clinical response was defined as a complete or partial response at Week 12 after commencement of anti-fungal therapy (W12 Response); poor response was defined as treatment failure or stable disease (W12 Non-response), in accordance with the pre-established assessment criteria of the DRC. In cases whereby death had occurred prior to the stipulated DRC assessment time-point or that the clinical data was insufficient to determine an objective response, the DRC W12 Response was set as ‘indeterminate’. End-of-initial randomized therapy (EORT) was a secondary endpoint reached when pre-specified criteria to stop the randomized therapy and switch to OLAT were attained. In patients who remained on their initial randomized therapy until week 12, the EORT assessment and the Week 12 assessment were the same. Post-hoc assessment of the clinical response at EORT by the DRC (v.i.z. satisfactory, unsatisfactory or indeterminate) used the same criteria as for the W12 Response. The other definitive outcome measure was all-cause survival at 12 weeks after the start of anti-fungal treatment.

In our analysis, only the GMI of patients who continued to receive the primary randomized anti-fungal agent (CAB or VCZ) at the specified intervals of therapy (v.i.z. Weeks 1, 2 and 4) were considered. Patients who were switched from the primary trial drug to OLAT were dropped from the analysis at the point of drug switch. The time profile of GMI or ΔGMI (GMI-change between 2 specified time-points) for the different outcomes at week 12 (based on clinical response and survival at week 12) are presented graphically by plotting the mean per time-point. The generalized estimation equations (GEE) approach is used to test and estimate changes in the effect size for GMI, accounting for repeated measurements over time within patients. A Gaussian family distribution is specified along with an identity link function and an exchangeable correlation structure. Where relevant, sensitivity analysis incorporating renal impairment as variable was performed. All statistical evaluations were performed using STATA release 12.0 (StataCorp, College Station, TX). The threshold for statistical significance is set at p<0.05.

Results

Data from one hundred and forty-seven patients with proven and probable IA [2] and who had GMI measurements performed were studied, based on the modified intention-to-treat analysis [6]. Of these patients, 77 were randomized to receive CAB, while 70 received VCZ as primary therapy. The demographics of these study patients are as described in Table 1. Treatment success at W12 for patients who received CAB as primary therapy was 37.7% as compared to 55.7% for VCZ. Treatment success at the EORT assessment for patients who were randomized to receive CAB was 18.3% versus 54.3% for those randomized to VCZ (p<0.001). Survival at end of study (at Week 12) was 66.2% for patients initially randomized to CAB and 74.3% for patients initially randomized to VCZ.

Table 1

Demographics characteristics of study cohort of 147 patients.

Characteristics	Patients (n = 147)		P value
	CAB N = 77 (%)	VCZ N = 70 (%)
Sex
Male	51 (66.2)	48 (68.6)	0.861
Female	26 (33.8)	22 (31.4)
Certainty of Disease
Proven IA	8 (10.4)	9 (12.8)	0.797
Probable IA	69 (89.6)	61 (87.2)
Neutropenia	45 (58.4)	44 (62.9)	0.353
Underlying Disease
Leukaemia/Lymphoma	59 (76.6)	45 (64.3)	0.526
HSCT	14 (18.2)	19 (27.1)
Week 12 Response
Satisfactory	29 (37.7)	39 (55.7)
Unsatisfactory	15 (19.4)	10 (14.3)	0.09
Indeterminate	33 (42.9)	21 (30.0)
EORT Response
Satisfactory	14 (18.2)	38 (54.3)
Unsatisfactory	55 (71.4)	19 (27.1)	0.001
Indeterminate	8 (10.4)	13 (18.6)
Week 12 Survival
Alive	51 (66.2)	52 (74.3)	0.368
Dead	26 (33.8)	18 (25.7)

CAB: conventional amphotericin B deoxycholate. VCZ: voriconazole. IA: invasive aspergillosis. HSCT: hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. EORT Response: End-of-initial randomized therapy response. The comparison of demographic and clinical characteristics between patients who received CAB or VCZ was made using the chi-squared or ANOVA test as appropriate.

Serial GMI trends in relation to the specified outcomes (satisfactory or unsatisfactory response) were studied categorically between patients who received either VCZ or CAB as primary therapy (Figures 1A–F). In these analyses, patients with an ‘indeterminate’ response, as assessed by the DRC, were excluded; thus, only those with a DRC-determined non-response at either Week 12 or EORT were assessed and compared with treated patients who had responded to therapy (Figures 1A–D). We also performed analyses that included the ‘indeterminate’ response cases (but classed them as ‘non-response’) at either Week 12 or EORT and obtained similar results (data not shown).

Figure 1

A–F Galactomannan index (GMI) trends of patients receiving as primary therapy, either conventional amphotericin B (CAB, Panels A,C,E) or voriconazole (VCZ, Panels B,D,F) in relation to the respective outcomes.

Geometric GMI (y-axis) means was plotted over indicated time intervals. Only the GMI of patients who continued to receive the primary randomized anti-fungal agent (CAB or VCZ) at the specified intervals of therapy were considered. Patients who were switched from the primary trial drug to OLAT were dropped from the analysis at the point of drug switch. Table below each Panel indicates the number of patients still receiving the respective primary antifungal therapy (v.i.z. CAB or VCZ) over time in each arm. The P value is indicative of the difference in the ΔGMIs between the two outcome-stratified arms from Baseline to the indicated study interval (v.i.z. Weeks 1, 2 or 4) as enclosed by the horizontal bars.

Patients who were randomized to VCZ and had a satisfactory response at Wk12 showed a decreasing GMI at Week 1 and Week 2 relative to the GMI at baseline, as compared to those who eventually failed treatment (p = 0.001 and p = 0.046 respectively, Figure 1B). However, for patients randomized to receive CAB, this early difference in GMI trend between W12 responders and non-responders was delayed and not evident until Week 4 (Figure 1A).

At EORT, patients randomized to receive CAB (Figure 1C) and assessed not to have responded to treatment showed persistently elevated Baseline-to-Week 2 and Baseline-to-Week 4 GMI relative to patients who responded to CAB (p = 0.022 and p = 0.046 respectively). In VCZ patients, there was no difference in GMI trends between those who had a satisfactory or unsatisfactory EORT response (Figure 1D).

For both antifungal drugs, initial GMI trends (between Baseline and Week 2) were generally not prognostic for eventual survival in this analysis. Notably, however, in patients randomized to CAB, those who died before Week 12 showed a significantly greater Baseline-to-Week 4 decrease in GMI as compared to the Week 12 survivors (Figure 1E).

Discussion

GMI quantification has been proposed as a surrogate for fungal burden [1] and treatment response [4]. In this study we show that temporal galactomannan trends are distinct in patients receiving different antifungal treatment regimens. In IA patients who received VCZ as primary therapy, a significant drop in GMI from baseline to Week 1 was prognostic for a satisfactory clinical response at Week 12, while persistence of an elevated GMI was associated with eventual treatment failure (Figure 1B). However, GMI trends suggesting failure on CAB treatment were seen later, at Week 4 of therapy (Figure 1A). In summary, the distinction between responders and non-responders was seen earlier in patients on primary VCZ treatment than in those receiving CAB. Progressive reduction of GMI however, was not a surrogate for eventual survival.

Quantification of fungal burden in animal models treated with either VCZ or CAB has shown that the former was more effective in clearance of Aspergillus with reduced tissue colony counts [10], from which galactomannan might be a surrogate for fungal load [1]. Interestingly, in the VCZ primary treatment arm, the promptness of response as reflected by clear GMI reduction within the 1st 2 weeks of therapy was associated with a satisfactory response at Week 12. Early persistence of elevated GMI, on the other hand, may well indicate significant residual fungal burden as a result of slow response to treatment (Figures 1A–B). In contrast, in patients receiving CAB as primary therapy, prediction of eventual the response using GMI as surrogate was only possible at Week 4.

In CAB-treated patients, a persistently high (or unchanged) GMI from baseline to Week 2 or Week 4 (Figure 1C) was linked to the likelihood of switching earlier than VCZ to another antifungal therapy at EORT. However, it is notable that only a minority (4 patients) had switched from CAB to OLAT on the grounds of poor primary treatment response as assessed by the primary physician. The major indication for the switch to OLAT was drug (especially renal/electrolyte) intolerance [11]. CAB-associated intolerance is thus a potential confounder that may herald an unsatisfactory IA response to primary CAB treatment.

The capacity of amphotericin B to alter renal function is well recognized and galactomannan levels are partly determined by glomerular filtration rate, as it is also detectable in urine. As such, the delayed changes in serial GMI observed in patients receiving CAB, as compared to VCZ, might be influenced by differing rates of renal clearance of circulating galactomannan. Indeed clinically, the dissociation between GMI and IA treatment response in the setting of renal failure has already been described [12]. However, the extent to which amphotericin B and the development of acute kidney injury affect the kinetics of renal clearance over time is not well understood. To address this aspect in the patients who had received CAB as primary therapy, we further incorporated AKI as a variable in our analyses. The observed GMI trend differences between responders and non-responders at EORT remained largely unchanged (Baseline-to-Week 2 GMI change p = 0.022 became 0.026, and Baseline-to-Week 4 GMI change p = 0.046 became 0.064 respectively). The Baseline-to Week 4 GMI trend difference between W12 survivors and non-survivors (p = 0.014) became p = 0.05 with AKI as a co-variate. The above analyses suggested that renal impairment in patients receiving CAB did not influence GMI trend results to a significant extent.

Alternatively, these differences in GMI trends could be related to the mode of action of both drugs. As a polyene, amphotericin B acts principally through binding to ergosterol in the fungal plasma membrane and creating transmembrane pores which induce cell permeability and eventually death [13]. Voriconazole, a triazole, inhibits ergosterol synthesis through P450 cytochrome-mediated lanosterol demethylation [14]. Galactomannan, on the other hand, is a polysaccharide moiety within the Aspergillus cell wall lying exterior to the cell membrane [15]. So while both drugs exert their effects at the level of the cell membrane, observations have been made that azoles and polyenes can induce different changes to the fungal cell wall structure and composition [16]–[18]. Thus, they may also differentially influence the galactomannan content and shedding.

The statistical difference in the GMI trend for survival in CAB-treated subjects is unexpected. The GMI drop between Baseline and Week 4 for CAB seems linked to the likelihood of mortality at 12 weeks. This was discordant in relation to the GMI trends at Week 12 or at the EORT Response described above. This may be a chance occurrence, as differences in the magnitude of change between the survivors and non-survivors, while statistically significant, were small (Figure 1E). This is further mitigated by an observation in similar IA patients (of which the study cohort here is a subset) that mortality beyond 6 weeks of IA diagnosis and treatment was more likely related to the status of underlying primary disease than the effectiveness of anti-fungal treatment [19]. Nonetheless, it remains to be well established whether circulating galactomannan levels can be influenced by other important factors, such as the patient's primary disease and concurrent infections. Nonetheless concern that piperacillin-tazobactam usage might have significantly confounded GMI level is largely unfounded as this antibiotic saw its approval for use towards the end of the clinical trial (for Protocol 130–307 outside the US).

In conclusion, we demonstrate here that different anti-fungal treatments yield distinct early GMI trends that may have prognostic value. The increasing number of different classes of anti-fungals currently in use against IA highlights the need to further understand the variety of disease responses with different drugs classes and the kinetics of biomarker monitoring. Our findings illustrate this point and have potentially significant implications for the management of IA.