Janice J Eng1, Birgit Reime2. 1. Department of Physical Therapy, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada janice.eng@ubc.ca. 2. Department of Applied Health Sciences, Furtwangen University, Furtwangen, Germany.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The objective was to conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies that examined the effects of structured exercise on depressive symptoms in stroke patients. METHODS: We searched for published randomized controlled trials that evaluated the effect of structured exercise programs (e.g. functional, resistance, or aerobic training) on depressive symptoms. The mean effect size, a 95% confidence interval (CI) and I-squared (I2) for heterogeneity were estimated. Sensitivity analyses were conducted. RESULTS: Thirteen studies (n = 1022) were included in the meta-analysis. Exercise resulted in less depressive symptoms immediately after the exercise program ended, standardized mean difference = -0.13 [95% CI = -0.26, -0.01], I2 = 6%, p = 0.03, but these effects were not retained with longer term follow-up. Exercise appeared to have a positive effect on depressive symptoms across both the subacute (≤6 months post stroke) and chronic stage of recovery (>6 months). There was a significant effect of exercise on depressive symptoms when higher intensity studies were pooled, but not for lower intensity exercise protocols. Antidepressant medication use was not documented in the majority of studies and thus, its potential confounding interaction with exercise could not be assessed. CONCLUSIONS: Exercise may be a potential treatment to prevent or reduce depressive symptoms in individuals with subacute and chronic stroke.
OBJECTIVE: The objective was to conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies that examined the effects of structured exercise on depressive symptoms in strokepatients. METHODS: We searched for published randomized controlled trials that evaluated the effect of structured exercise programs (e.g. functional, resistance, or aerobic training) on depressive symptoms. The mean effect size, a 95% confidence interval (CI) and I-squared (I2) for heterogeneity were estimated. Sensitivity analyses were conducted. RESULTS: Thirteen studies (n = 1022) were included in the meta-analysis. Exercise resulted in less depressive symptoms immediately after the exercise program ended, standardized mean difference = -0.13 [95% CI = -0.26, -0.01], I2 = 6%, p = 0.03, but these effects were not retained with longer term follow-up. Exercise appeared to have a positive effect on depressive symptoms across both the subacute (≤6 months post stroke) and chronic stage of recovery (>6 months). There was a significant effect of exercise on depressive symptoms when higher intensity studies were pooled, but not for lower intensity exercise protocols. Antidepressant medication use was not documented in the majority of studies and thus, its potential confounding interaction with exercise could not be assessed. CONCLUSIONS: Exercise may be a potential treatment to prevent or reduce depressive symptoms in individuals with subacute and chronic stroke.
Authors: Paul D Thompson; David Buchner; Ileana L Pina; Gary J Balady; Mark A Williams; Bess H Marcus; Kathy Berra; Steven N Blair; Fernando Costa; Barry Franklin; Gerald F Fletcher; Neil F Gordon; Russell R Pate; Beatriz L Rodriguez; Antronette K Yancey; Nanette K Wenger Journal: Circulation Date: 2003-06-24 Impact factor: 29.690
Authors: Carol Ewing Garber; Bryan Blissmer; Michael R Deschenes; Barry A Franklin; Michael J Lamonte; I-Min Lee; David C Nieman; David P Swain Journal: Med Sci Sports Exerc Date: 2011-07 Impact factor: 5.411
Authors: Gillian E Mead; Carolyn A Greig; Irene Cunningham; Susan J Lewis; Susie Dinan; David H Saunders; Claire Fitzsimons; Archie Young Journal: J Am Geriatr Soc Date: 2007-06 Impact factor: 5.562
Authors: Gillian E Mead; Wendy Morley; Paul Campbell; Carolyn A Greig; Marion McMurdo; Debbie A Lawlor Journal: Cochrane Database Syst Rev Date: 2009-07-08
Authors: David H Saunders; Mark Sanderson; Sara Hayes; Maeve Kilrane; Carolyn A Greig; Miriam Brazzelli; Gillian E Mead Journal: Cochrane Database Syst Rev Date: 2016-03-24
Authors: Daniel E Forman; Ross Arena; Rebecca Boxer; Mary A Dolansky; Janice J Eng; Jerome L Fleg; Mark Haykowsky; Arshad Jahangir; Leonard A Kaminsky; Dalane W Kitzman; Eldrin F Lewis; Jonathan Myers; Gordon R Reeves; Win-Kuang Shen Journal: Circulation Date: 2017-03-23 Impact factor: 29.690
Authors: Anson B Rosenfeldt; Susan M Linder; Sara Davidson; Cynthia Clark; Nicole M Zimmerman; John J Lee; Jay L Alberts Journal: Arch Phys Med Rehabil Date: 2018-12-10 Impact factor: 3.966
Authors: Tharshanah Thayabaranathan; Nadine E Andrew; Monique F Kilkenny; Rene Stolwyk; Amanda G Thrift; Rohan Grimley; Trisha Johnston; Vijaya Sundararajan; Natasha A Lannin; Dominique A Cadilhac Journal: Qual Life Res Date: 2018-08-04 Impact factor: 4.147