| Literature DB >> 24530148 |
Grace P K Chiang1, E Anthony S Nelson2, Timothy J H S Pang3, Shu Kei Law4, W Goggins4, Johnny Y C Chan5, Margaret Ip6, Paul K S Chan6.
Abstract
Sentinel laboratory surveillance from one hospital and passive discharge diagnosis (Clinical Management System, CMS) data from all public Hospital Authority (HA) hospitals were used to estimate disease burden and incidence of rotavirus in hospitalised Hong Kong children over 14 rotavirus seasons (1 July 1997 to 31 March 2011). A primary diagnosis of a gastroenteritis-related disorder was noted in 9.8% of children aged below 5 years, and a primary or secondary diagnosis in 11.8%. Any CMS diagnosis of rotavirus (ICD 008.61) was initially used to derive incidence estimates of rotavirus by age group. Rotavirus was recorded as any primary or any secondary diagnosis in 1.6% of children below 5 years of age. The unadjusted incidence rates per 100,000 person-years based on any CMS diagnosis of rotavirus were: 249 (0 to <1m); 612 (1 to <2m); 1066 (2 to <6m); 1383 (6 to <11m); 959 (1 to <2y); 406 (2 to <3y); 233 (3 to <4y); 124 (4 to <5y). Overall the rotavirus incidence was 1071 in children below 2 years and 542 in children below 5 years of age, with the incidence rates trending up during the time period (p=0.001). A similar but less marked upward trend (p=0.046) was noted for the incidence of all-cause gastroenteritis. Laboratory results from a single surveillance hospital (1 July 2000 to 31 March 2011) were then linked to these CMS codes to derive adjustment factors for possible over- and under-diagnosis of rotavirus based on CMS codes alone. This analysis suggested that a CMS diagnosis of rotavirus alone likely under-reported true incidence by a factor of between 1.59 and 2.02 in children below 5 years of age. Despite the availability of rotavirus vaccines in the private sector since 2006, no reduction in the incidence of hospitalisation for either rotavirus or all-cause gastroenteritis was noted in Hong Kong children below 5 years of age over 14 rotavirus seasons (1997-2011).Entities:
Keywords: Disease burden; Gastroenteritis; Incidence; Rotavirus; Surveillance
Mesh:
Year: 2014 PMID: 24530148 PMCID: PMC7115370 DOI: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2014.01.065
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Vaccine ISSN: 0264-410X Impact factor: 3.641
Diarrhoea-associated hospitalizations by reported diagnosis (primary diagnosis only) from Clinical Management System (CMS) among 100,330 children aged 0 to <18 years admitted to the Prince of Wales Hospital, Hong Kong (1 July 2000 to 31 March 2011) compared with actual results from the laboratory for patients who had stool specimens sent for rotavirus testing to derive three adjustment factors to account for possible over or under-diagnosis of rotavirus based on CMS ICD diagnosis.
| Age | No. of admission | No. (%) with CMS diagnosis of gastroenteritis (GE) | No. (%) with rotavirus CMS ICD diagnosis (008.61) (CMSRV+) | No. (%) stool specimen sent to lab | No. (%) with GE and stool specimen sent to lab | No. (%) with GE and stool specimen NOT sent to lab | No. (%) diagnosed rotavirus positive (RVLAB+) | RVLAB+ and CMSRV+ | RVLAB+ and CMSRV− | RVLAB− and CMSRV+ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 to <12m | 37,488 | 2312 (6.2%) | 342 (0.9%) | 3438 (9.2%) | 1759 (76.1%) | 553 (23.9%) | 552 (1.5%) | 336 | 216 | 4 |
| 12 to <24m | 9049 | 1675 (18.5%) | 384 (4.2%) | 1876 (20.7%) | 1291 (77.1%) | 384 (22.9%) | 586 (6.5%) | 382 | 204 | 1 |
| 24 to <36m | 7189 | 1020 (14.2%) | 183 (2.5%) | 937 (13.0%) | 640 (62.7%) | 380 (37.3%) | 297 (4.1%) | 177 | 120 | 3 |
| 36 to <48m | 6653 | 812 (12.2%) | 115 (1.7%) | 666 (10.0%) | 433 (53.3%) | 379 (46.7%) | 174 (2.6%) | 112 | 62 | 1 |
| 48 to <60m | 4918 | 562 (11.4%) | 61 (1.2%) | 397 (8.1%) | 262 (46.6%) | 300 (53.4%) | 101 (2.1%) | 58 | 43 | 1 |
| 0d to <24m | 46,537 | 3987 (8.6%) | 726 (1.6%) | 5314 (11.4%) | 3050 (76.5%) | 937 (23.5%) | 1138 (2.4%) | 718 | 420 | 5 |
| 0d to <60m | 65,297 | 6381 (9.8%) | 1085 (1.7%) | 7314 (11.2%) | 4385 (68.7%) | 1996 (31.3%) | 1710 (2.6%) | 1065 | 645 | 10 |
| 0 to <18y | 100,330 | 8595 (8.6%) | 1222 (1.2%) | 8705 (8.7%) | 5150 (59.9%) | 3445 (40.1%) | 1954 (1.9%) | 1196 | 758 | 10 |
Primary diagnosis code only.
Fig. 1Incidence of hospitalisation by age for children aged below 5 years of age for rotavirus gastroenteritis (primary or secondary ICD code = 008.61) with and without application of adjustment factors derived from laboratory surveillance at one hospital, Hong Kong (1 July 1997 to 31 March 2011).
Incidence rates for hospitalisation with rotavirus and gastroenteritis per 100,000 person-years in Hong Kong (1 July 1997 to 31 March 2011).
| Estimates based on ANY CMS diagnosis of rotavirus (ICD9-CM 008.61) with NO adjustment | Estimates based on ANY CMS diagnosis of rotavirus (ICD9-CM 008.61) with adjustment for under- and over-CMS RV diagnosis based on data from Prince of Wales Hospital (adjustment factor 1) | Estimates based on ANY CMS diagnosis of rotavirus (ICD9-CM 008.61) with adjustment for under- and over-CMS RV diagnosis and failure to send stool on all gastroenteritis-related admissions based on data from Prince of Wales Hospital (smoothed adjustment factor 2 omitting first month of life) | Estimates based on assumption that laboratory confirmed rotavirus admissions as a proportion of all admissions by age group identified in Prince of Wales Hospital (laboratory confirmation) is the same proportion of all admissions to all HA hospitals (smoothed adjustment factor 3 with unsmoothed value for first month of life) | Estimates based on primary ICD diagnosis of gastroenteritis | Estimates based on ANY primary OR secondary ICD diagnosis of gastroenteritis | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0m | 249 | 396 | – | 529 | 2520 | 4380 |
| 1m | 612 | 973 | 925 | 2047 | 8745 | 9923 |
| 2 to <6m | 1066 | 1695 | 1684 | 1837 | 7224 | 8683 |
| 6m to <1y | 1383 | 2200 | 2389 | 2674 | 8428 | 10,376 |
| 1 to <2y | 959 | 1526 | 1908 | 1727 | 4473 | 5284 |
| 2 to <3y | 406 | 646 | 965 | 814 | 2532 | 3007 |
| 3 to <4y | 233 | 371 | 655 | 455 | 1775 | 2099 |
| 4 to <5y | 124 | 198 | 406 | 233 | 1143 | 1338 |
| 5 to <10y | 33 | 446 | 515 | |||
| 10 to <14y | 5 | 136 | 163 | |||
| 14 to <18y | 1 | 65 | 84 | |||
| <24m | 1071 | 1704 | 1798 | 2000 | 6108 | 7378 |
| <60m | 542 | 863 | 1093 | 1029 | 3347 | 4011 |
See Appendix 3 for description of adjustment factors 1, 2, and 3.
Fig. 2Incidence of hospitalisation by rotavirus season for children aged below 5 years of age for all-cause gastroenteritis (GE) (primary diagnosis only, grey bars), rotavirus gastroenteritis (primary or secondary ICD code = 008.61, black bars), or with application of adjustment factor 2 derived from laboratory surveillance at one hospital (see text, white bars), Hong Kong (1 July 1997 to 31 March 2011). *Asian Rotavirus Surveillance Network study period. #Rotavirus vaccine licensed for private sector use in Hong Kong. ^Population adjusted to account for shorter final study year 1 July 2010 to 31 March 2011 (9 months).
Fig. 3Cumulative risk of a Hong Kong child being admitted with rotavirus diarrhoea by the age of 5 years (assumes that proportion of laboratory confirmed rotavirus positive admissions at Prince of Wales Hospital is the same in all Hospital Authority hospitals in Hong Kong). *Asian Rotavirus Surveillance Network study period. #Rotavirus vaccine licensed for private sector use in Hong Kong. ^Population adjusted to account for shorter final study year 1 July 2010 to 31 March 2011 (9 months).