Does streptomycin cause an error catastrophe?

We have examined the interpretation that streptomycin kills a bacterial culture by initiating the so-called error catastrophe. In particular, we asked whether the increased translational error rate induced by the antibiotic gives rise to an autocatalytic loss of functional fidelity of the devices responsible for gene expression, which ultimately causes the death of the culture. We have analyzed the performance characteristics of one of these devices, namely the ribosome in streptomycin-treated bacteria. We find that, although the treated ribosomes are constructed from error-containing proteins, they are not significantly different in elongation rate and fidelity from those ribosomes taken from untreated bacteria. We conclude that the bacteriocidal effect of streptomycin is not due to the initiation of an error catastrophe.