Fungal air quality in hospital rooms: a case study in Tehran, Iran.

Fungi are usually presented in indoor environments and cause of many diseases. The aim of this descriptive study was to investigate the level of fungal contamination in hospital rooms. Sampling was conducted with an Andersen one-stage viable impactor (Quick Take-30) and counting plates containing a fungus-selective medium. A total of 120 air samples from ten hospital environments were performed. Airborne fungi concentrations were determined 72-120 hours after sampling. Total mean concentration of detected fungi in the hospital rooms was 55 ± 56 (mean ± SD) cfu/m3. The findings of the fungal concentration in the various hospital rooms revealed different levels of contamination: the lowest mean counts (37 ± 17 cfu/m3) were observed in NS 1 (Nursing Stations 1), and the highest (97 ± 217 cfu/m3) were reported in Orthopedics Operating Room (OOR). The most common fungal genus isolated were Penicillium (70%), Aspergillus (14%), Cladosporium (12%), Alternaria (2%) and others (2%). The obtained results showed that fungal concentrations in the present study were nearly high and these conditions should be considered as a risk factor for patients and other persons in the hospital.

Introduction

In hospital facilities Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) is a critical factor in preventing infections. Unpleasant hospital IAQ may lead to hospital-acquired infections, sick hospital syndrome, and various occupational risks [1]. A large number of studies have showed that various percentages of hospital infections were caused by fungi, such as Candida albicans and diverse species of Aspergillus, Cladosporium, and Penicillium. [2-5]. Fungal air quality in the hospital environment affected by various factors, such as the presence of construction activity and a favorable microclimate. Since exposure to fungi can cause serious health problems, it is clearly essential, in the above-mentioned risk situations, to evaluate the level of contamination in the hospital environments and to use those evaluations to determine the risk of infection for patients and staff alike, in that the use of air conditioning systems does not provide complete protection against fungi [2,6-8]. Various studies have investigated the fungal air quality in hospital environments. Perdelli et al. [2] studied various environments in 10 hospitals and found the average concentration of airborne fungi was 19 ± 19 cfu/m3. Fungal air quality of three hospitals was studied in Greec by Panagopoulou et al., and reported that the median concentration of airborne fungi was ranged between 5.5 and 10.6 cfu/m3[6]. In other study conducted by Li and Hou [9], Bioaerosol characteristics were investigated in hospital clean rooms. They found that the concentrations of fungi varied from 0 to 319 cfu/m3.

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the level of airborne fungal contamination in various hospital rooms in Shariati Hospital, Tehran, Iran.

Materials and methods

Hospital environments

The present study was conducted in ten rooms of Shariati Hospital in city of Tehran, Iran. The air sampling occurred during January to April 2012, and 120 samples were examined. In the hospital, ten rooms in two floors (first and second) were studied and categorized into: Operating Rooms (OR) (8 rooms: General Operating Room 1(GOR1), Orthopedics Operating Room (OOR), Nerves Operating Room (NOR), General Operating Room 2 (GOR2), Urology Operating Room (UOR), Women Operating Room (WOR), Emergency Operating Room (EOR), Maxillofacial Operating Room (MOR)) and Nursing Stations (NS) (2 stations).

Air sampling

Sample collection was performed in respiratory height (about 1.5 m) for 2 minutes using an Andersen one-stage viable impactor (Quick Take-30, SKC, USA) at an airflow rate of 28.3 L/min [10-12], and SKC BioStage single-stage viable cascade impactors equipped with 100 mm diameter Petri dishes containing Sabouraud dextrose agar medium, supplemented with chloramphenicol. Before the air sampling, the head was cleaned with 70% alcohol [13]. The Petri dishes were closed and delivered to the Central Laboratory of Public Health School, Tehran University of Medical Sciences. Indoor air temperature and relative humidity were measured using a digital PHB-318.

Fungi incubation and identification

This step was according to other study [2] in brief, the plates were incubated at 25°C and counted after 72-120 hours and reported as colony forming unit (cfu/m3). When suspect colonies were detected, they were isolated with plates containing Sabouraud plus chloramphenicol medium. The incubation temperature was 25°C. The airborne fungi concentrations were identified using both microscopic and macroscopic methods for each colony isolated.

Data analysis

Descriptive statistics by the SPSS software version 20 are used for data analysis in this study.

Results

Relative humidity and temperature of indoor air ranged from 16% to 42% and 19°C to 26°C, respectively. Total mean of airborne fungal concentration was 55 ± 56 cfu/m3. Analysis of the fungal concentration in the various types of rooms shown different levels of contamination: the lowest mean values (37 ± 17 cfu/m3) were detected in Nursing Stations 1 (NS 1), and the highest (97 ± 217 cfu/m3) were detected in Orthopedics Operating Room (OOR) (Table  1).

Table 1

Descriptive statistics for total detected airborne fungi and environment conditions of hospital rooms

Floor	Hospital rooms	No. of Samples	Mean (cfu/m3) (Min-Max)	SD	Indoor environment conditions (Mean)
					T (°C)	RH (%)
First	GOR11	12	43(18-159)	52	22	31
	OOR2		97(18-707)	217	22	30
	NOR3		40(18-71)	18	23	27
	GOR24		42(18-88)	25	23	27
	UOR5		58(18-300)	83	22	29
	NS16		37(18-71)	17	23	26
Second	WOR7		53(18-283)	43	23	25
	EOR8		71(18-141)	43	23	26
	MOR9		47(18-88)	26	24	28
	NS210		62(18-141)	37	26	26
Total		120	55(18-707)	56	23(19-26)	27(16-42)

1GOR: General Operating Room.

2OOR: Orthopedics Operating Room.

3NOR: Nerves Operating Room.

4GOR2: General Operating Room 2.

5UOR: Urology Operating Room.

6NS 1: Nursing Stations1.

7WOR: Women Operating Room.

8EOR: Emergency Operating Room.

9MOR: Maxillofacial Operating Room.

10NS 2: Nursing Stations 2.

Table  2 presents the concentration of airborne fungi genera in various hospital rooms. The results showed the dominant fungal species were Penicillium (70%), Aspergillus (14%), Cladosporium (12%), Alternaria (2%) and others (2%). Also the highest mean concentration of Penicillium, Aspergillus, Cladosporium and Alternaria were detected in OOR, NS 1, NS 1 and OOR, respectively.

Table 2

Concentration of airborne fungi genera in various hospital rooms (Mean ± SD) in cfu/m

Floor	Hospital rooms	Fungi genera
		Penicillium	Aspergillus	Cladosporium	Alternaria	Other
First	GOR11	44 ± 57	18 ± 1	-	-	-
	OOR2	144 ± 276	35 ± 1	18 ± 1	35 ± 1	-
	NOR3	33 ± 21	35 ± 1	35 ± 1	-	-
	GOR24	46 ± 32	90 ± 1	-	-	35 ± 1
	UOR5	85 ± 108	36 ± 1	-	-	-
	NS16	38 ± 21	106 ± 1	18 ± 1	-	-
Second	WOR7	65 ± 107	18 ± 1	15 ± 1	-	53 ± 1
	EOR8	51 ± 41	28 ± 9	35 ± 12	-	-
	MOR9	39 ± 19	53 ± 1	53 ± 49	-	18 ± 1
	NS210	41 ± 35	53 ± 1	62 ± 62	18 ± 1	-
Total mean (first and second floor)		59 ± 34	47 ± 30	34 ± 18	27 ± 12	35 ± 18

“-” means not detected.

1GOR: General Operating Room.

2OOR: Orthopedics Operating Room.

3NOR: Nerves Operating Room.

4GOR2: General Operating Room 2.

5UOR: Urology Operating Room.

6NS 1: Nursing Stations1.

7WOR: Women Operating Room.

8EOR: Emergency Operating Room.

9MOR: Maxillofacial Operating Room.

10NS 2: Nursing Stations 2.

The degree of contamination by the fungal genera identified was calculated in percentage terms for each type of hospital room (Figure  1). Overall, the genus least frequently encountered was Alternaria, which displayed its maximum value of 8%. Penicillium species were detected in 75% of the WOR monitored, but contamination by these species was less frequent in EOR and GOR2 and these species had a more uniform distribution in the various locations; it was documented in approximately one-half of the tested areas in each type of environment. Aspergillus organisms were detected in 33% of WOR and NS2 and 25% of EOR, MOR and UOR rooms. Also, Cladosporium species were detected in 33% of WOR rooms.

Figure 1

Percentage of hospital environments contaminated by various genera of fungi.

Discussion

To investigate the fungal air quality, 120 samples were collected from ten rooms of Shariati hospital. The results showed that total concentration of detected fungi in the hospital rooms was 55 ± 56 (mean ± SD) cfu/m3. Also the obtained results showed the most frequent fungal genus isolated were Penicillium, Aspergillus and Cladosporium that is consistent with other studies [2,14,15].

Fungal air quality in hospital environments was investigated by the numerous researchers. In a study carried out by Sautour et al., in France indoor fungal contamination was conducted during 18-month. They found that the average concentration of viable fungi in indoor air was 4.2 cfu/m3 and the most frequently detected airborne fungi were Penicillium spp. (27- 38%) and Aspergillus spp [16]. Thus the average concentration of fungi reported in their study is much lower than those detected in the present study. Fungal contamination (Penicillium and Aspergillus) of hospital rooms has been investigated in Lithuania and air borne fungi were ranged from 26 to 78 cfu/m3[14].

The results of the present study show various levels of contamination in all the hospital rooms, even though all areas are equipped with air conditioning systems. Such contamination may be caused or exacerbated by a range of factors, such as noncompliance with procedural norms (e.g., the frequent opening of doors among the operating theater and the outer environment) and inefficient operation or inadequate maintenance of the air conditioning system, which can allows unfiltered outside air to enter the operating theater. Overall, the mean concentrations of airborne fungi measured in the present study were higher than those recorded in other studies [6-8]. Moreover, our results show that the concentration of airborne fungi is significantly high in rooms and seems this concentration is important risks factor for patients and staff in these rooms. According our observations opening doors and windows are the most important factors that cause these high concentrations of airborne fungi in the rooms. Construction and demolition at the hospital campus during the study is other factor to high concentration of airborne fungi.

Conclusion

In hospital environments indoor air quality is an important factor in preventing infections. Levels of airborne fungal contamination in various hospital rooms in Shariati Hospital, Tehran, Iran have been investigated. The results showed that fungal concentrations were high and these conditions should be considered as a risk factor for patients and other persons in the hospital.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors’ contributions

All authors have made extensive contribution throughout the completion of this manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.