BACKGROUND: Numerous laboratories in Italy use radioimmunoassay to determine concentrations of sex hormones (FSH, LH, testosterone). A comparison of assay methods is thus an important starting point for the achievement of universally accepted reference values. AIM: To carry out an external quality assessment for FSH, LH, and testosterone. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Fifteen aliquots from 5 serum pools were assayed in multiple replicates by 16 Italian laboratories with 5 automated immunoassays (Abbott Architect, DiaSorin Liaison, Perkin-Elmer AutoDelfia, Roche Elecsys, Siemens Immulite 2000), and 1 radioimmunoassay (Adaltis). RESULTS: The variance was below 12% for FSH, between 11.61% and 14.76% for LH, and between 9.57% and 12.48% for testosterone. Assay precision was good, except for Elecsys at low concentrations of FSH and for Immulite at low concentrations of LH and testosterone. ARCHITECT showed a negative bias for FSH and LH and a positive bias for testosterone; Liaison a positive bias for LH; Elecsys a positive bias for FSH and a negative bias for testosterone; Immulite a positive bias for FSH; AutoDelfia a negative bias for FSH and a positive bias for testosterone. Reference ranges at the low end varied widely, even among laboratories using the same assay. CONCLUSIONS: The analytical performances of widely used immunoassays for FSH, LH, and testosterone show a fair to strong degree of consistency. A careful evaluation of reference ranges by clinical and laboratory experts needs to be carried out, in order to reach a consensus.
BACKGROUND: Numerous laboratories in Italy use radioimmunoassay to determine concentrations of sex hormones (FSH, LH, testosterone). A comparison of assay methods is thus an important starting point for the achievement of universally accepted reference values. AIM: To carry out an external quality assessment for FSH, LH, and testosterone. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Fifteen aliquots from 5 serum pools were assayed in multiple replicates by 16 Italian laboratories with 5 automated immunoassays (Abbott Architect, DiaSorin Liaison, Perkin-Elmer AutoDelfia, Roche Elecsys, Siemens Immulite 2000), and 1 radioimmunoassay (Adaltis). RESULTS: The variance was below 12% for FSH, between 11.61% and 14.76% for LH, and between 9.57% and 12.48% for testosterone. Assay precision was good, except for Elecsys at low concentrations of FSH and for Immulite at low concentrations of LH and testosterone. ARCHITECT showed a negative bias for FSH and LH and a positive bias for testosterone; Liaison a positive bias for LH; Elecsys a positive bias for FSH and a negative bias for testosterone; Immulite a positive bias for FSH; AutoDelfia a negative bias for FSH and a positive bias for testosterone. Reference ranges at the low end varied widely, even among laboratories using the same assay. CONCLUSIONS: The analytical performances of widely used immunoassays for FSH, LH, and testosterone show a fair to strong degree of consistency. A careful evaluation of reference ranges by clinical and laboratory experts needs to be carried out, in order to reach a consensus.
Authors: Christina Wang; Don H Catlin; Laurence M Demers; Borislav Starcevic; Ronald S Swerdloff Journal: J Clin Endocrinol Metab Date: 2004-02 Impact factor: 5.958
Authors: Reto Stricker; Raphael Eberhart; Marie-Christine Chevailler; Frank A Quinn; Paul Bischof; René Stricker Journal: Clin Chem Lab Med Date: 2006 Impact factor: 3.694
Authors: A Lenzi; G Balercia; A Bellastella; A Colao; A Fabbri; C Foresta; M Galdiero; L Gandini; C Krausz; G Lombardi; F Lombardo; M Maggi; A Radicioni; R Selice; A A Sinisi; G Forti Journal: J Endocrinol Invest Date: 2009-12-01 Impact factor: 4.256
Authors: D Francomano; A Ilacqua; A Cortese; G Tartaglia; A Lenzi; M Inghilleri; A Aversa Journal: J Endocrinol Invest Date: 2016-10-17 Impact factor: 4.256
Authors: M Spaziani; S Granato; N Liberati; F M Rossi; N Tahani; C Pozza; D Gianfrilli; G Papi; A Anzuini; A Lenzi; L Tarani; A F Radicioni Journal: J Endocrinol Invest Date: 2020-05-06 Impact factor: 4.256
Authors: M Spaziani; C Tarantino; C Pozza; A Anzuini; F Panimolle; G Papi; D Gianfrilli; A Lenzi; A F Radicioni Journal: J Endocrinol Invest Date: 2020-10-24 Impact factor: 4.256
Authors: Thomas W Kelsey; Lauren McConville; Angela B Edgar; Alex I Ungurianu; Rod T Mitchell; Richard A Anderson; W Hamish B Wallace Journal: PLoS One Date: 2017-07-20 Impact factor: 3.240