| Literature DB >> 24069070 |
Frank Stenner-Liewen1, Heike Liewen, Richard Cathomas, Christoph Renner, Ulf Petrausch, Tullio Sulser, Katharina Spanaus, Hans Helge Seifert, Räto Thomas Strebel, Alexander Knuth, Panagiotis Samaras, Michael Müntener.
Abstract
Pomegranate has been shown to prolong PSA doubling time in early prostate cancer, but no data from a placebo controlled trial has been published yet. The objective of this study was to prospectively evaluate the impact of pomegranate juice in patients with prostate cancer. We conducted a phase IIb, double blinded, randomized placebo controlled trial in patients with histologically confirmed prostate cancer. Only patients with a PSA value ≥ 5ng/ml were included. The subjects consumed 500 ml of pomegranate juice or 500 ml of placebo beverage every day for a 4 week period. Thereafter, all patients received 250 ml of the pomegranate juice daily for another 4 weeks. PSA values were taken at baseline, day 14, 28 and on day 56. The primary endpoint was the detection of a significant difference in PSA serum levels between the groups after one month of treatment. Pain scores and adherence to intervention were recorded using patient diaries. 102 patients were enrolled. The majority of patients had castration resistant prostate cancer (68%). 98 received either pomegranate juice or placebo between October 2008 and May 2011. Adherence to protocol was good, with 94 patients (96%) completing the first period and 87 patients (89%) completing both periods. No grade 3 or higher toxicities occurred within the study. No differences were detected between the two groups with regard to PSA kinetics and pain scores. Consumption of pomegranate juice as an adjunct intervention in men with advanced prostate cancer does not result in significant PSA declines compared to placebo.Entities:
Keywords: PSA; Pomegranate juice; ellagig acids; nutraceutical; polyphenols.; prostate cancer
Year: 2013 PMID: 24069070 PMCID: PMC3781990 DOI: 10.7150/jca.7123
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Cancer ISSN: 1837-9664 Impact factor: 4.207
Figure 1Trial profile.
Patients' characteristics.
| Characteristics | Placebo ( | Pomegranate ( | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Age (y) | 72±8.4 | 73±8.6 | NS |
| Age > 64 yrs | 40 | 36 | NS |
| Age > 69 yrs | 29 | 29 | NS |
| ECOG PS 0 | 74% | 75% | NS |
| ECOG PS 1 | 20% | 21% | NS |
| ECOG PS 2 | 7% | 4% | NS |
| Gleason Score <8 | 57% (20/35) | 46% (16/35) | NS |
| Gleason Score ≥8 | 43% (15/35) | 54% (19/35) | NS |
| T0 | 4% (1/29) | 0% (0/35) | NS |
| T1 | 17% (5/29) | 17% (6/35) | NS |
| T2 | 41% (12/29) | 17% (6/35) | NS |
| T3 | 31% (9/29) | 51% (18/35) | .036 |
| T4 | 7% (2/29) | 15% (5/35) | NS |
| N0 | 78% (22/28) | 55% (17/31) | NS |
| N1 | 22% (6/28) | 45% (14/31) | NS |
| M1 | 18% (5/28) | 44% (15/34) | .032 |
| PSA (Median, Mean, SD) | 19, 90±222 ng/ml | 21, 60±82 ng/ml | NS |
| CRPC | 67% (31/46) | 63% (30/48) | NS |
| RP | 17% (8/46) | 15% (7/48) | NS |
| RT | 24% (11/46) | 17% (8/48) | NS |
| RP+RT | 22% (10/46) | 11% (5/48) | NS |
| Watchful waiting | 26% (13/46) | 29% (14/48) | NS |
| ADT (continued) | 39% (18/46) | 46% (22/48) | NS |
| Docetaxel | 15% (7/46) | 10% (5/48) | NS |
NS= not significant, CRPC= castration resistant prostate cancer.
Data presented as mean ± standard deviation or n (%).
n=0 for ECOG> and n=0 for Gleason Score <5 and n=0 for N3 status.
RP radical prostatectomy; RT, radiotherapy; ADT, Androgen deprivation therapy.
TNM documented at diagnosis.
* percentages in the treatment section do not add up to 100%, as patients may have had multiple interventions.
Response evaluation.
| treatment | PSA Progression | PSA Stabilisation | response* |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Placebo (n=46) | 19 (41%) | 26 (57%) | 0 (0%), 1 (2%) |
| B PJ high (n=48) | 18 (38%) | 27 (56%) | 0 (0%), 3 (6%) |
| A PJ low (n=42) | 10(24%) | 31 (74%) | 0 (0%), 1 (2%) |
| B PJ low (n=45) | 13 (29%) | 31 (69%) | 0 (0%), 1 (2%) |
| A Placebo+PJ low (n=42) | 18 (43%) | 21 (53%) | 1 (2%), 1 (2%) |
| B PJ high+low (n=45) | 18 (40%) | 24 (53%) | 0 (0%), 3 (7%) |
| A Placebo (n=31) | 16 (52%) | 14 (45%) | 0 (0%), 1 (3%) |
| B PJ high (n=30) | 12 (40%) | 16 (53%) | 0 (0%), 2 (7%) |
| A PJ low (n=27) | 10(37%) | 16 (59%) | 0 (0%), 1 (4%) |
| B PJ low (n=28) | 12 (43%) | 15 (54%) | 0 (0%), 1 (3%) |
| A Placebo+PJ low (n=27) | 15 (56%) | 11 (40%) | 1 (4%), 0 (0%) |
| B PJ high+low (n=28) | 16 (57%) | 11 (39%) | 0 (0%), 1 (4%) |
| A Placebo (n=15) | 3(20%) | 12 (80%) | 0 (0%), 0 (0%) |
| B PJ high (n=18) | 4 (22%) | 12 (67%) | 0 (0%), 2 (11%) |
| A PJ low (n=15) | 3(20%) | 11 (73%) | 1 (7%), 0 (0%) |
| B PJ low (n=17) | 1 (6%) | 16 (94%) | 0 (0%), 0 (0%) |
| A Placebo+PJ low (n=15) | 3(20%) | 11 (73%) | 0 (0%), 1 (7%) |
| B PJ high+low (n=17) | 3 (17%) | 12 (71%) | 0 (0%), 2 (12%) |
*Objective response (PSA) defined as PSA decline >50% in bold, responses ≥ 30% in italics **Day 1-28 represents the placebo-controlled phase of the studyProgressive disease was defined as a PSA increase of ≥ 25%Stable disease were all PSA values between OR and PD.
PJ high refers to a daily intake of 1147 mg/day polyphenol gallic acid (first period) PJ low 573 mg/day polyphenol gallic acid consumed by all subjects from day 28 on (second period)
p-values not displayed as there were no significant differences
Figure 2Waterfall plots of percentage PSA changes from patients within the first period (day 1-28) 2A and the total period (day 1-56) 2B.
Comparison of this study with previously reported clinical studies.
| Criteria | Pantuck | Paller | Stenner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Study design | Single arm Phase II | 2 intervention Arms | Placebo controlled |
| Observation period | 18months/progression | 18months/progression | 2months |
| PSA (ng/ml) | 0.5-5 | 0.5-5 | >5 |
| [Median; Mean,SD] | [1.05; 2.23±2.58] | [NR] | [19.7; 74.5±166] |
| Metastatic disease allowed | No | No | Yes[23%] |
| Grading | Gleason ≤7 | Gleason any | no restriction |
| [% Gleason ≥8] | [0%] | [10%] | [49%] |
| Pretreatment allowed | S, RT | S, RT, B, C | S, RT, B, C |
| PJ, Gallic Acid equivalent | 570mg/ml (8 oz.) | 1 and 3 Caps* | 1146mg/ml (phase1) |
| Daily intake | (1 caps= 8 oz.) | 573mg/ml (phase2) | |
| Duration of treatment | 12 months | 18months+ | 2months |
Abbreviations: S, surgery; RT, radiotherapy; B, brachytherapy; C, cryotherapysquare brackets [] indicate data collected within respective study. NR data not reported
*One POMx capsule is equivalent to an 8 oz. glass of juice