Severe lower respiratory tract infection in infants and toddlers from a non-affluent population: viral etiology and co-detection as risk factors.

BACKGROUND: Lower respiratory tract infection (LRTI) is a major cause of pediatric morbidity and mortality, especially among non-affluent communities. In this study we determine the impact of respiratory viruses and how viral co-detections/infections can affect clinical LRTI severity in children in a hospital setting.
METHODS: Patients younger than 3 years of age admitted to a tertiary hospital in Brazil during the months of high prevalence of respiratory viruses had samples collected from nasopharyngeal aspiration. These samples were tested for 13 different respiratory viruses through real-time PCR (rt-PCR). Patients were followed during hospitalization, and clinical data and population characteristics were collected during that period and at discharge to evaluate severity markers, especially length of hospital stay and oxygen use. Univariate regression analyses identified potential risk factors and multivariate logistic regressions were used to determine the impact of specific viral detections as well as viral co-detections in relation to clinical outcomes.
RESULTS: We analyzed 260 episodes of LRTI with a viral detection rate of 85% (n = 222). Co-detection was observed in 65% of all virus-positive episodes. The most prevalent virus was Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) (54%), followed by Human Metapneumovirus (hMPV) (32%) and Human Rhinovirus (HRV) (21%). In the multivariate models, infants with co-detection of HRV + RSV stayed 4.5 extra days (p = 0.004), when compared to infants without the co-detection. The same trends were observed for the outcome of days of supplemental oxygen use.
CONCLUSIONS: Although RSV remains as the main cause of LRTI in infants our study indicates an increase in the length of hospital stay and oxygen use in infants with HRV detected by RT-PCR compared to those without HRV. Moreover, one can speculate that when HRV is detected simultaneously with RSV there is an additive effect that may be reflected in more severe clinical outcome. Also, our study identified a significant number of children infected by recently identified viruses, such as hMPV and Human Bocavirus (HBov), and this is a novel finding for poor communities from developing countries.

Background

Lower respiratory tract infections (LRTI) represent an important public health burden in the first years of life accounting for approximately one fifth of all deaths in children below five years of age, especially in developing countries [1]. The specific role of newly identified viruses on LRTIs, like Human Metapneumovirus (hMPV), has been studied in recent years [2]. However, its impact among non-affluent populations has been scarcely evaluated. In such locales, infants with respiratory syncytial virus (RSV)-associated LRTIs present a three times greater risk of a fatal event, when compared to their peers in developed countries [3].

Although RSV is well recognized as the main agent associated with severe LRTIs, recent data indicate that other viruses may play a significant role in these clinical outcomes. Human rhinovirus (HRV) seems to be of particular interest, as the most prevalent virus in respiratory illnesses even in the first years of life [4,5], being associated with severe acute bronchiolitis, especially among children of atopic parents [6]. Moreover, a recent study showed that, in a population of preterm infants, HRV was the most prevalent agent associated with severe bronchiolitis [7]. Also of interest is the fact that wheeze-related HRV infection in the first year of life is associated with an increased risk for developing asthma later in life [8], and that this effect was greater than the observed in relation to RSV [9].

The impact on severity of early life respiratory infections may be also affected by viral co-detections diagnosed through sensitive PCR analyses. Some studies have shown a positive association between viral co-detection and worse clinical outcomes [10,11], while others have failed to show results in the same direction [12-14].

The aims of our study were to determine the current impact of newly identified viruses on the severity of LRTI in infants seen in the emergency room and pediatric wards from a tertiary hospital in a developing country, and how specific viruses alone or in co-detections increased the degree of clinical severity of disease.

Methods

Subjects and study design

Infants and toddlers younger than three years of age, with a diagnosis of LRTI, admitted to the emergency room (ER) or pediatric wards of a tertiary hospital in Porto Alegre, southern Brazil, were recruited for this study, during the months of greatest prevalence for acute pediatric respiratory viral illnesses (i.e., from April to November) in 2007 [4,15]. The great majority of patients seen in this particular setting come from low-income families, with health coverage provided by the Brazilian free-access public health system.

LRTI was defined by the presence of signs and symptoms of an acute respiratory infection (cough, nasal discharge, oropharyngeal hyperemia, with or without fever), and lower respiratory signs (tachypnea, retractions, prolonged expiratory time, or crackles/wheezing on auscultation). Chest radiographs were taken only at medical assistant discretion, to avoid unnecessary X-ray exposure, and thus were not used for diagnostic purposes. Children who were admitted in the ER with signs and symptoms of a LRTI for at least 6 hours were considered eligible, once symptoms had started within the previous 5 days. Patients with other co-morbidities such as neuromuscular diseases, previous cardiopulmonary disorders, immunodeficiencies, or important congenital anomalies were excluded. We also excluded patients with a hospitalization due to LRTI in the previous 30 days. Bacterial pneumonia was excluded by clinical presentation and chest X-rays findings.

Within the first 24 hours of hospitalization, medical information was collected from parents or guardians through a standardized questionnaire. Data regarding clinical conditions at admission, vital signs, and signs of respiratory distress were obtained from the medical charts. Information on use of medications, clinical course of the disease until discharge, use of supplemental oxygen, and length of hospital stay were prospectively collected. These two latter variables were used as the main clinical outcomes, serving as surrogates for clinical severity. Supplemental oxygen was withdrawn when pulse oximetry was equal or greater than 94% in room air for at least 6 hours, as this is the standard clinical procedure in the hospital. Sample size was estimated based on few previous similar studies, since data analyzing the association between viral co-detection and our main outcomes was scarce at the time this project was planned [16-18].

Nasopharyngeal sample collection

Nasopharyngeal aspiration with a standardized technique using vacuum and a sterile collector were performed in all children within the first 48 hours of admission. Samples were immediately split into aliquots, including one in TRIzol®, and stored at −80°C, until shipment to the Laboratory of Viral Pathogenesis, at the University of São Paulo School of Medicine, Ribeirão Preto.

Viral detection by individual real-time RT-PCR

To isolate RNA from nasal aspirates, 250 μL were extracted according to the manufacturer’s protocol (Invitrogen, Carlsbard, USA). DNA was extracted from a sample of 200 μL of nasal aspirate using the Wizard Genomic DNA® purification kit, following manufacturer’s instructions (Promega, Madison, USA). The detection of viruses was done by Real Time PCR, using the Taqman System® (Applied Biosystems, New Jersey, USA), with specific primers and probes in a thermal cycler (7300 Real Time PCR system® - Applied Biosystems). Real Time PCR reactions for cellular gene (β-actin) were also performed for internal quality control.

For viruses with a RNA genome (i.e., HRV, Influenza Virus-A [FLUAV], human parainfluenza virus [HPIV], RSV, hMPV and human coronavirus [HCoV]), the transcription into cDNA was done with reverse transcriptase (high capacity cDNA reverse transcription kit®, Applied Biosystems), using 1 μg from the extracted RNA, according to the manufacturers’ protocol. The qPCR assays were performed using 3 μL of the DNA extraction or cDNA (approximately 150 ng), 0.33 pmoles for primers, 0.17 pmoles for probes and 7.5 μL of master mix of TaqMan® (Applied Biosystems). Amplifications were performed with 45 cycles of denaturation at 95°C for 15 seconds and annealing-extension at 60°C for one minute, except for hMPV, when annealing was done at 55°C for 30 seconds, and extension at 60°C for one minute.

Statistical analysis

Demographics were summarized as mean or median and range according to their distribution. Characteristics among groups were compared, accordingly, using two-sample t-test, Mann–Whitney, Chi-square or Fisher’s exact test.

Generalized linear models (Tweedie model with Identity link function) were used to analyze the relationships between main outcomes (length of stay in the hospital and time in use of supplemental oxygen) and the predictor variables (virus detection [yes/no], sex, age, prematurity (i.e. <37 weeks of gestation), maternal smoking during pregnancy, family asthma). All variables with a significance of p < 0.15 were considered in the univariate models and those with significance of p < 0.05 in the multivariate analysis. All analyses were performed using SPSS v.18 (SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL).

This study was approved by the local Institutional Ethics Committees (06/03467 - Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio Grande do Sul and 4856/2004 – Universidade de São Paulo). Parents or legal guardians read and signed an informed consent approved for this study.

Results

Two hundred and sixty patients were enrolled in the study. Characteristics of the patients recruited are presented in Table 1. In the whole sample there were more boys than girls, almost half of children were younger than six months, 24% of all children were born premature, 29% had been exposed to tobacco during gestation, and more than a half had a family history of asthma (parents or siblings). Overall, median hospital length was 6 days and median supplemental oxygen requirement was 5 days.

Table 1

Characteristics and outcomes of the population included in the study (260 children)

Sex, female, n (%)	103 (40)
Age, months, median (range)	5 (1-35)
Age, <6 months, n (%)	128 (49)
Maternal smoking during pregnancy, n (%)	74 (29)
Prematurity, n (%)	62 (24)
Family history of asthma*, n (%)	149 (58)
LOS+, days, median (range)	4 (2-8)
Use of oxygen, days, median (range)	3 (1-6)

+ LOS: length of hospital stay; * for parents and/or siblings.

The presence of viruses was detected by PCR in 222 (85%) of all LRTI episodes. Co-detection was present in 146/260 (56%). The frequencies of viral detection and co-detection are shown in Table 2. The most common single infection was related to RSV (54%), followed by hMPV (32%), and HRV (21%).

Table 2

Viral detection by RT-PCR, among 260 children

Overall prevalence of viruses	n (%)
No vírus detected	38 (14.1)
RSV	139 (53.5)
hMPV	84 (32.3)
HRV	54 (20.8)
HBov	27 (10.4)
Influenza (A or B)	33 (12.7)
Para-influenza (1 or 2)	17 (6.5)
Adenovirus	17 (6.5)
Coronavirus	3 (1.2)
Co-detections	n (%)
RSV + HRV	22 (8.5)
RSV + HMPV	37 (14.2)
RSV + Others*	26 (10.0)
HRV + Others**	29 (11.2)
HMPV + Others***	16 (6.1)
HMPV + Others***	16 (6.1)

RSV: Respiratory sincytial virus; HMPV: Human metapneumovirus; HRV: Human rhinovirus.

* Bocavirus + influenza A or B.

** HMPV + influenza A or B.

*** Bocavirus + influenza A or B.

During the surveyed time RSV has shown an incidence peak in the beginning of the cold season (i.e. from april to November) in the southern hemisphere, followed in late winter by peaks of hMPV, HRV, and HBov (Figure 1). Other viruses such as HPIV and Human Adenovirus (HAdv) showed low but constant rates throughout the season.

Figure 1

Monthly numbers of samples positive for the different viruses from the subjects studied.

In the univariate analyses, length of hospital stay and need of supplemental oxygen were significantly associated with age (≤6 months), maternal smoking during pregnancy and with family history of asthma (parents and/or siblings) (Table 3). Infants younger than 6 months of age stayed in hospital 3.8 days longer than older infants (p < 0.001), and those with a family history of asthma stayed 2.4 days longer than those without a family history of asthma (p < 001). Also, infants 6 months of age or younger needed supplemental oxygen for an extra 3.8 days, when compared to older infants/children. A similar finding was observed for children with a family history of asthma, who required 2.4 extra days of oxygen compared to those without the family history of asthma (Table 3). Other risk factors, such as breastfeeding, indoor smoking, current parental smoking, siblings, and overcrowding were not significantly associated with neither of the main outcomes.

Table 3

Univariate analyses of risk factors for length of hospital stay and days with supplemental oxygen (n = 260)

	Length of hospital stay			Days with supplemental oxygen
	β*	(95% CI)	p	β*	(95% CI)	p
Sex, female	0.4	(-0.9 - 1.7)	0.553	0.5	(-0.6 - 1.7)	0.372
Age, <6 months	3.8	(2.7 - 5)	<0.001	3.8	(2.8 - 4.9)	<0.001
Prematurity	0.4	(-1.0 - 1.9)	0.570	0.4	(-1.0 - 1.7)	0.605
Maternal smoking during pregnancy	1.2	(-0.2 - 2.6)	0.106	1.3	(-0.02 - 2.7)	0.054
Family Hx asthma	2.4	(1.2 - 3.6)	<0.001	2.4	(1.3 - 3.5)	<0.001

Hx: history; * number of extra days, compared to negative counterparts.

Infants with positive PCR for HRV alone as well as those co-detected with RSV and HRV also had significantly longer hospital stays (3.2 days, p = 0.001; and 5.5 days, p = 0.002, respectively) than those with other detected viruses. Extended time in use of supplemental oxygen was also associated with HRV (2.8 days, p = 0.002) and RSV (3.7 days, p = 0.013), but also with Influenza virus A or B (2.2 days, p = 0.042), when compared to those with other viruses in single or in co-detection.

Infants with HRV-LRTIs stayed an extra 2.2 days in hospital (p = 0.011), for a total of 7.7 (95% CI: 6.1-9.3) days when compared to those with other infections, after adjusting for potential confounding variables (Table 4). Table 5 shows that infants with combined HRV and RSV positive PCR in the same samples stayed 4.5 extra days (p = 0.004) than those without HRV and RSV in these adjusted models (that included sex, age ≤ 6 versus >6 months, prematurity, family history of asthma and maternal smoking during pregnancy), (95% CI: 7.0-13.0) days. Time in use of supplemental oxygen followed the same association trends. Infants with proven RSV infections needed 4.75 (95% CI: 3.97-5.53) extra days of oxygen, while those with HRV used supplemental oxygen for 1.4 extra days, and those with RSV and HRV co-detection for 2.2 days, when compared to infants presenting positive PCRs for other viruses alone or in combinations. Figure 2 illustrates the association between HRV and RSV + HRV co-detection with increased length of hospital stay and oxygen use, and this effect is especially significant for infants younger than 6 months of age. Influenza viruses were not associated with longer use of supplemental oxygen when controlling for the demographic variables.

Table 4

Multivariate analysis for length of hospital stay (dependent variable), and HRV adjusting other risk factors

	Yes		No		β*	95% CI	P
	Mean	(95% CI)	Mean	(95% CI)
HRV	7.7	(6.1 - 9.3)	5.5	(4.7 - 6.2)	2.2	(0.5 - 3.9)	0.011
Sex (female)	6.8	(5.6 - 8.0)	6.3	(5.4 - 7.3)	0.4	(-0.6 - 1.5)	0.419
Age <6 months	8.2	(7.0 - 9.3)	5.0	(3.9 - 6.0)	3.2	(2.0 - 4.3)	<0.001
Family Hx of asthma	7.2	(6.2 - 8.2)	6.0	(4.8 - 7.1)	1.2	(0.1 - 2.3)	0.035
Prematurity	6.7	(5.4 - 7.9)	6.5	(5.5 - 7.4)	-0.2	(-1.4 - 1.0)	0.749
Maternal smoking	6.8	(5.6 - 8.2)	6.3	(5.3 - 7.2)	0.6	(-0.6 - 1.8)	0.354

Hx: history; * number of extra days in hospital, compared to negative counterparts.

Table 5

Multivariate analysis for length of hospital stay (dependent variable) and HRV + RSV (co-detection), adjusting for other risk factors

	Yes		No		β*	(95% CI)	P
	Mean	(95% CI)	Mean	(95% CI)
RSV + HRV	10.0	(7.0 - 13.0)	5.5	(4.8 - 6.3)	4.5	(1.4 - 7.5)	0.004
Age, <6 months	9.4	(7.7 - 11.1)	6.1	(4.6 - 7.7)	3.3	(2.2 - 4.5)	<0.001
Sex (female)	7.9	(6.2 - 9.6)	7.6	(6.0 - 9.2)	0.3	(-0.7 - 1.4)	0.517
Family Hx of asthma	8.3	(6.7 - 9.9)	7.2	(5.5 - 8.9)	1.1	(0.04 - 2.2)	0.043
Prematurity	7.8	(6.1 - 9.5)	7.7	(6.1 - 9.4)	-0.04	(-1.2 - 1.2)	0.952
Maternal smoking	8.1	(6.3 - 9.9)	7.4	(5.9 - 8.9)	0.7	(-0.5 - 2.0)	0.243

Hx: History; * number of extra days in hospital, compared to negative counterparts.

Figure 2

Comparison of RSV, HRV and RSV plus HRV in regards to: (A) length of hospital stay and (B) days of supplemental oxygen use. Black circles: group of infants ≤ 6 months of age; white circles: group of infants > 6 months of age. The groups of HRV and RSV + HRV were significantly different (p < 0.05), when compared by age. Values expressed as mean ± SD of days.

Discussion

Our results suggest that infants with severe LRTI and positive PCR for HRV, alone or in co-detection with RSV, stayed hospitalized longer periods and utilized more supplemental oxygen, when compared to children infected by other viruses, including those with RSV-alone. Our data also reinforce previous findings that identified RSV as the major agent associated with severe LRTIs among children in a hospital setting, in populations of low socio-economic status, where other environmental and social variables potentially play a role [16,17]. Infants younger than six months and those with a family history of asthma/recurrent wheeze are also at greater risk for disease severity.

RSV was the most frequently detected virus, accounting for a high burden of LRTIs in our population. Although it is not possible to establish an unequivocal correlation between LRTIs and upper airway viral detection, the finding of RSV in over 50% of hospitalized children in our study strongly suggests that its impact is still indeed very high in this region, regardless of the presence of newly identified viruses. These results are in accordance with recently published studies in Brazil, which also identified RSV as the main agent responsible for severe LRTI, especially in a hospital setting. Nascimento and coworkers have shown an overall viral detection rate of 93% from nasopharyngeal samples in a small group of children below 2 years of age, and reported RSV as the most prevalent virus (63.6%) [19]. Another study aiming to investigate the role of HBov and hMPV in LRTIs in southern Brazil also showed similar results (at least one positive virus in 90% of the samples and RSV positive in 49.3%) [20]. The high detection rate of RSV in children with LRTI in a hospital setting such as ours is consistent with most studies worldwide and the burden due to viral respiratory disease seems as high in these locales as they are in more developed countries. A recent analysis of children admitted into the hospital due to acute bronchiolitis in Texas, USA, has shown a steady increase in admissions over a 5-year period and this has been credited mostly to RSV [21]. This increasing role for severe viral LRTIs, observed also in other studies, is probably explained by a series of complex environmental and social changes that seem to affect how viruses spread in communities.

Some studies have reported different clinical outcomes for specific viruses causing LRTIs, especially in the presence of co-detections, such as with RSV and HBov [22,23], while others did not reproduce such findings [17,24,25] and these associations remain unclear. A lack of association between an overall finding of any viral co-detection and LRTI severity was reported in studies performed in non-affluent countries [2,12,26], as well as in developed countries [13,14]. In our study, patients detected with HRV alone and RSV + HRV presented increased length of hospitalization and increased time of supplemental oxygen use. Papadopoulos et al. has shown a five-fold increase in clinical severity in infants with acute bronchiolitis due to HRV, compared to those infected only with RSV. Compared to those with positive RSV samples without HRV co-detection, infants with HRV were older, had lower birth weights and were hospitalized earlier [16]. Some explanations for apparently contradictory findings in a myriad of studies could be attributed to the lack of uniform criteria for subject inclusion and standardized statistical analysis [14]. Other plausible explanations are the natural variation in HRV prevalence in different seasons and possible variations in the prevalence of type C HRV. This agent is associated with more severe disease and was already described as a major cause of LRTI in infants from non-affluent countries [27,28]. Unfortunately, in our study, we were not able to determine the prevalence of HRV subtypes, and this stands as an interesting subject for further research.

The association of HRV (alone or with RSV) with LRTI severity and atopy has not been widely studied. The relationship between persistent wheezing at 3 years and at 6 years versus relevant HRV infection in early life is well established [9,29], but there are few studies looking at these relationships in the first year of life. A recent study suggests that the relationship between HRV in early life LRTI and subsequent recurrent wheeze/asthma is dependent on allergic sensitization, which seems to precede the viral insult in a causal model [30]. This association we have found between HRV with increased severity (using the surrogates of length of hospital stay and days in supplemental oxygen) is a major finding. Hence, the association between HRV infection, increased severity and atopy remains to be better clarified.

It has already been shown that HRV is able to reduce cell proliferation and decreases the self-repair capacity of bronchial epithelial cells [31]. Therefore, our data may suggest that in certain subsets of patients the burden of HRV in acute LRTI should be considered distinct from that of other viruses. Another plausible explanation for our findings could be the possibility of HRV persistence in the airways leading to an “over detection” of the virus, simultaneously with those infected only by RSV [32]. In our study this hypothesis seems improbable since we detected a clear worsening in the clinical markers in patients with RSV that were also detected with HRV.

Another interesting finding of our study was the high prevalence of newly described viruses. hMPV was detected in almost one third of all episodes, but did not seem to affect the main outcomes studied here, in the way RSV and HRV have done. While the recognition of the impact of human hMPV is increasing, its prevalence is still probably underestimated in clinical practice, since laboratory testing has become widely available only in recent years [18,24,33]. HBov was also detected in a large number of nasal samples and it was very frequently associated (co-detected) with other agents. In our study, only 2/27 patients with HBov had this virus detected as single agent. The overall HBov detection rate was higher in our data compared to previous studies [34,35], and this may be explained again by natural seasonal variations. It is also interesting to notice the seasonal pattern of both hMPV and HBov, which present their peak prevalence rates in late winter, right after the RSV peak, which occurs earlier in winter.

The main limitation of our study is the lack of surveillance in consecutive years, which could have biased results in case of an outbreak of one specific virus in a given year. Our eight months of viral surveillance could potentially have failed to detect any atypical outbreak, which did not seem likely to have occurred. Also, reliable tests capable of ruling out bacterial co-detection were not available at the time of the study. This could have underestimated the burden of bacteria in our sample and the co-detection of viruses and bacteria remains an interesting issue for further studies.

Conclusion

In our study, RSV was the most prevalent viral agent in hospitalized patients with LRTI and the co-detection of HRV in patients with RSV infection increased hospital stay and days in use of supplemental oxygen. Interestingly, even in developing countries, the role of recently discovered viruses needs to be further studied in order to identify novel risk factors of susceptibility/severity, and new treatment targets for these agents. We also highlight the role of HRV as an important risk factor for severe LRTI, particularly when simultaneously associated with RSV, which strongly suggests that co-detection may also mean co-infection, since the combination of the two agents seem to affect clinical outcomes. Longitudinal studies with control groups are necessary to confirm these results in populations at greater risk for severe respiratory disease.

Abbreviations

LRTI: Lower respiratory tract infection; RT-PCR: Real-time polymerase chain reaction; RSV: Respiratory syncytial virus; hMPV: Human metapneumovirus; HRV: Human rhinovirus; HBov: Human bocavirus; ER: Emergency room; FLUA: Influenza virus A; HPIV: Human parainfluenza virus; HCov: Human coronavirus; HAdv: Human adenovirus

Competing interests

This study was supported by Abbott Laboratórios do Brasil Ltda (academic grant), from an unrestricted investigator-generated proposal.

Authors’ contributions

ERS and RS participated in all steps of the study. PMP participated in the design of the study, in data analysis and manuscript review. E.A. participated in study design and in the RT-PCR essays. FEP, LSD and JLPM participated in the RT-PCR essays. RM and EES performed the statistical analysis and have reviewed the manuscript. MHJ participated in the data collection. OS and JDR participated in the conception and design of the study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Pre-publication history

The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:

http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2334/13/41/prepub