BACKGROUND: Sequencing of bacterial genomes became an essential approach to study pathogen virulence and the phylogenetic relationship among close related strains. Bacterium Enterococcus faecium emerged as an important nosocomial pathogen that were often associated with resistance to common antibiotics in hospitals. With highly divergent gene contents, it presented a challenge to the next generation sequencing (NGS) technologies featuring high-throughput and shorter read-length. This study was designed to investigate the properties and systematic biases of NGS technologies and evaluate critical parameters influencing the outcomes of hybrid assemblies using combinations of NGS data. RESULTS: A hospital strain of E. faecium was sequenced using three different NGS platforms: 454 GS-FLX, Illumina GAIIx, and ABI SOLiD4.0, to approximately 28-, 500-, and 400-fold coverage depth. We built a pipeline that merged contigs from each NGS data into hybrid assemblies. The results revealed that each single NGS assembly had a ceiling in continuity that could not be overcome by simply increasing data coverage depth. Each NGS technology displayed some intrinsic properties, i.e. base calling error, systematic bias, etc. The gaps and low coverage regions of each NGS assembly were associated with lower GC contents. In order to optimize the hybrid assembly approach, we tested with varying amount and different combination of NGS data, and obtained optimal conditions for assembly continuity. We also, for the first time, showed that SOLiD data could help make much improved assemblies of E. faecium genome using the hybrid approach when combined with other type of NGS data. CONCLUSIONS: The current study addressed the difficult issue of how to most effectively construct a complete microbial genome using today's state of the art sequencing technologies. We characterized the sequence data and genome assembly from each NGS technologies, tested conditions for hybrid assembly with combinations of NGS data, and obtained optimized parameters for achieving most cost-efficiency assembly. Our study helped form some guidelines to direct genomic work on other microorganisms, thus have important practical implications.
BACKGROUND: Sequencing of bacterial genomes became an essential approach to study pathogen virulence and the phylogenetic relationship among close related strains. Bacterium Enterococcus faecium emerged as an important nosocomial pathogen that were often associated with resistance to common antibiotics in hospitals. With highly divergent gene contents, it presented a challenge to the next generation sequencing (NGS) technologies featuring high-throughput and shorter read-length. This study was designed to investigate the properties and systematic biases of NGS technologies and evaluate critical parameters influencing the outcomes of hybrid assemblies using combinations of NGS data. RESULTS: A hospital strain of E. faecium was sequenced using three different NGS platforms: 454 GS-FLX, Illumina GAIIx, and ABI SOLiD4.0, to approximately 28-, 500-, and 400-fold coverage depth. We built a pipeline that merged contigs from each NGS data into hybrid assemblies. The results revealed that each single NGS assembly had a ceiling in continuity that could not be overcome by simply increasing data coverage depth. Each NGS technology displayed some intrinsic properties, i.e. base calling error, systematic bias, etc. The gaps and low coverage regions of each NGS assembly were associated with lower GC contents. In order to optimize the hybrid assembly approach, we tested with varying amount and different combination of NGS data, and obtained optimal conditions for assembly continuity. We also, for the first time, showed that SOLiD data could help make much improved assemblies of E. faecium genome using the hybrid approach when combined with other type of NGS data. CONCLUSIONS: The current study addressed the difficult issue of how to most effectively construct a complete microbial genome using today's state of the art sequencing technologies. We characterized the sequence data and genome assembly from each NGS technologies, tested conditions for hybrid assembly with combinations of NGS data, and obtained optimized parameters for achieving most cost-efficiency assembly. Our study helped form some guidelines to direct genomic work on other microorganisms, thus have important practical implications.
Authors: Marcel Margulies; Michael Egholm; William E Altman; Said Attiya; Joel S Bader; Lisa A Bemben; Jan Berka; Michael S Braverman; Yi-Ju Chen; Zhoutao Chen; Scott B Dewell; Lei Du; Joseph M Fierro; Xavier V Gomes; Brian C Godwin; Wen He; Scott Helgesen; Chun Heen Ho; Chun He Ho; Gerard P Irzyk; Szilveszter C Jando; Maria L I Alenquer; Thomas P Jarvie; Kshama B Jirage; Jong-Bum Kim; James R Knight; Janna R Lanza; John H Leamon; Steven M Lefkowitz; Ming Lei; Jing Li; Kenton L Lohman; Hong Lu; Vinod B Makhijani; Keith E McDade; Michael P McKenna; Eugene W Myers; Elizabeth Nickerson; John R Nobile; Ramona Plant; Bernard P Puc; Michael T Ronan; George T Roth; Gary J Sarkis; Jan Fredrik Simons; John W Simpson; Maithreyan Srinivasan; Karrie R Tartaro; Alexander Tomasz; Kari A Vogt; Greg A Volkmer; Shally H Wang; Yong Wang; Michael P Weiner; Pengguang Yu; Richard F Begley; Jonathan M Rothberg Journal: Nature Date: 2005-07-31 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: S F Altschul; T L Madden; A A Schäffer; J Zhang; Z Zhang; W Miller; D J Lipman Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 1997-09-01 Impact factor: 16.971
Authors: Margaret M C Lam; Torsten Seemann; Dieter M Bulach; Simon L Gladman; Honglei Chen; Volker Haring; Robert J Moore; Susan Ballard; M Lindsay Grayson; Paul D R Johnson; Benjamin P Howden; Timothy P Stinear Journal: J Bacteriol Date: 2012-02-24 Impact factor: 3.490
Authors: Rob J L Willems; Janetta Top; Marga van Santen; D Ashley Robinson; Teresa M Coque; Fernando Baquero; Hajo Grundmann; Marc J M Bonten Journal: Emerg Infect Dis Date: 2005-06 Impact factor: 6.883
Authors: Helen L Leavis; Rob J L Willems; Willem J B van Wamel; Frank H Schuren; Martien P M Caspers; Marc J M Bonten Journal: PLoS Pathog Date: 2007-01 Impact factor: 6.823
Authors: John J Schellenberg; Tobin J Verbeke; Peter McQueen; Oleg V Krokhin; Xiangli Zhang; Graham Alvare; Brian Fristensky; Gerhard G Thallinger; Bernard Henrissat; John A Wilkins; David B Levin; Richard Sparling Journal: BMC Genomics Date: 2014-07-07 Impact factor: 3.969
Authors: Laura Wosinska; Calum J Walsh; Paula M O'Connor; Elaine M Lawton; Paul D Cotter; Caitriona M Guinane; Orla O'Sullivan Journal: Microorganisms Date: 2022-03-24