| Literature DB >> 22649602 |
O A Patutina1, N L Mironova, V V Vlassov, M A Zenkova.
Abstract
Currently, the main way to fight cancer is still chemotherapy. This method of treatment is at the height of its capacity, so, setting aside the need for further improvements in traditional treatments for neoplasia, it is vital to develop now approaches toward treating malignant tumors. This paper reviews innovational experimental approaches to treating malignant malformations based on the use of gene-targeted drugs, such as antisense oligonucleotides (asON), small interfering RNA (siRNA), ribozymes, and DNAzymes, which can all inhibit oncogene expression. The target genes for these drugs are thoroughly characterized, and the main results from pre-clinical and first-step clinical trials of these drugs are presented. It is shown that the gene-targeted oligonucleotides show considerable variations in their effect on tumor tissue, depending on the target gene in question. The effects range from slowing and stopping the proliferation of tumor cells to suppressing their invasive capabilities. Despite their similarity, not all the antisense drugs targeting the same region of the mRNA of the target-gene were equally effective. The result is determined by the combination of the drug type used and the region of the target-gene mRNA that it complements.Entities:
Year: 2009 PMID: 22649602 PMCID: PMC3347510
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Acta Naturae ISSN: 2075-8251 Impact factor: 1.845
Fig. 1.How antisense oligonucleotides (asON) work. (a) RNA is cleaved as a part of a heteroduplex with the asON by Rnase H. (b) Blockage of translation caused by binding of the oligonucleotide onto the mRNA
Fig. 2.How RNA interference happens
Fig. 3.Processes of ribozyme action (a) and DNAzyme action (b)
A list of target genes for drugs based on gene-targeted nucleic acids
| Carcinogenic events | Target gene | Function | Drugs used to suppress function |
| Proliferation |
Ras oncogenes ( | Part of the cellular signal transduction system and regulates a wide range of processes, such as proliferation, differentiation, and survival [42] | asON, ribozymes, siRNA |
| Activates the proliferation of tumor cells (regulates the cell cycle and telomerase activity) [49, 160] | asON, siRNA, DNAzymes | ||
| Is involved in the cellular signal transduction and controls proliferation and cell survival [53, 54] | asON, ribozymes, DNAzymes | ||
| Is involved in lipid transport, cell division, and apoptosis; supports cell survival in response to therapy; and increases tumor drug resistance [57, 58] | asON | ||
| Activates the MAPK and PI-3K signal pathways, which stimulate proliferation and mitogenesis and inhibit apoptosis [61–63] | asON | ||
| Blocking of apoptosis | Negativly regulates apoptosis by blocking the excretion of cytochrome c from the mitochondria into the cytoplasm [67] | asON, siRNA, ribozymes | |
| Regulates cell division (interacts with microtubules in the mitotic spindle and promotes mitotic entry through G2/М checkpoint) and suppresses apoptosis (inhibits the inner caspase-9-dependant apoptosis pathway) [73, 74] | asON, ribozymes | ||
| Stimulates a mitogenic and antiapoptotic signal mediated by Ras-regulated signal pathways [81, 82] | Ribozymes, DNAzymes, siRNA | ||
| Activates the MAPK/ERK cascade and negative regulation of apoptosis by inactivating the proapoptotic Bad protein [88, 90] | asON | ||
| Drug resistance | Forms transmemrane channels for ATP-dependant expulsion of drugs out of the cell, which endows tumors with drug resistance [95–97] | asON, siRNA, ribozymes | |
| Intracellular detoxication of anticancer drugs [95] | Ribozymes | ||
| Dysfunction of tumor suppressor genes | Hypermethylation and inactivation of tumor suppressor genes [102, 103] | asON | |
| Increase of tumor cell lifespan | Hyperactivation of the telomere repeat elongation machinery and, as a result, an increase in the malignancy and the lifespan of transformed cells [109] | asON, ribozymes | |
| DNA synthesis arrest | Controls the amount of deoxyribonucleotides needed for DNA synthesis via regulating the conversion of ribonucleotides into deoxy ribonucleotides [113] | asON, siRNA | |
| Tumor angiogenesis | Active neovascularization and suppression of the anti-tumor immune response [119, 120] | asON, ribozymes, DNAzymes, siRNA | |
| Activation of signal transduction pathways, which lead to the stimulation of tumor progression events such as proliferation, invasion, and apoptosis inhibition [127,128] | asON, ribozymes | ||
| Increases the translation of growth factors such as VEGF, С-myc, surviving, etc. [133 - 135] | asON | ||
| IGrowth factor, promotes active tumor growth and vascularization [137 - 139] | Ribozymes | ||
| Is a tyrosine kinase PTN receptor, facilitates its function, thus promoting tumor vascularization [141] | Ribozymes | ||
| Tumor invasion | Elimination of components of the extracellular matrix and basal membrane and promotes tumor invasion [144 – 146] | Ribozymes, siRNA | |
| Activation of FGF-2, which induces tumor cell proliferation and increases the invasive and angiogenic potential [148] | Ribozymes | ||
| Activates proliferation and tumor invasion and is involved in establishment of the MDR phenotype [154,155] | DNAzymes | ||
| Regulates adhesion and invasion into the extracellular matrix [158] | siRNA | ||
| Stimulates metastatic processes [159] | siRNA |
Results of nucleic acid-based drugs testing in vitro
| Target-genes | Drug | Tumor type | Effect |
| asON | Carcinoma of the uteral cervix [161], hepatoma [162] | A decrease in H-ras-luciferase-mRNA level by 98% [161]; inhibition of cellular growth by 87.8%, block of the entry into the S-pahse of the cell cycle, apoptosis induction [162] | |
| Ribozyme | Melanoma, throat carcinoma, bladder tumor | Decrease in H-ras expression; retardation of proliferation and an increase in the level of differentiation of tumor cells [ 43–47] | |
| siRNA | Ovary, pancreatic [163], lung [165] carcinoma | 80% decrease in the protein level [165], suppression of proliferation [163,164], changes in the cell-cycle schedule, and increased number of apoptotic cells [163] | |
| asON | Leukemia [170], mammary carcinoma [171] | 50%–95% decrease in c-myc expression [170, 171]; complete cell cycle arrest in the G0/G1 phase [172] | |
| Ribozyme | Hepatoma | 1.7-fold decrease of the protein level and 1.85-fold drop in porliferative activity [173] | |
| siRNA | Epidermoid carcinoma, neuroblastoma [175], mammary carcinoma and lung adenocarcinoma [176] | 60–92% decrease in mRNA level and 55–85% inhibition of protein synthesis [175,176]; slowing and blockage of cell division [175] | |
| asON | Lung carcinoma | 90–95% decrease in PKC-α mRNA level [55] | |
| Ribozyme | Glioblastoma [178], prostate carcinoma [179] | Decreases protein level by 73% and proliferative activity below 90% [178]; restores cysplatin sensitivity [179] | |
| asON OGX-001 | Renal carcinoma | Decreases clusterin mRNA level by 64% and increases cell sensitivity to paclitaxel by 80% [59] | |
| asON | Bladder carcinoma | Lowers mRNA level by 74% and protein level by 61.3% [207] | |
| asON G3139 (Genasense™, USA) | Lymphoma [183], leukemia [68, 69] | Lowers bcl-2 mRNA level and Bcl-2 protein level by 60–80% and 80–95%, respectively, hence increasing cell death rate by 76–90%; as a result of apoptosis induction, increases doxorubicin senstivity [68, 69, 183] | |
| Ribozyme | Lymphoma | 5-fold decrease in mRNA level, 3-fold decrease in protein level, and 2-fold increase in apoptosis rate [184] | |
| siRNA | Uteral cervix [185] and pancreatic [189] carcinoma | Suppresses Bcl-2 protein synthesis by 90%, induces apoptosis in 50% of cells [185]; increases proportion of apoptotic cells by 37% [189] | |
| asON | Malignant lung mesothelioma, glioma, mammary carcinoma, lung adenocarcinoma [76], thyroid tumor [77] | 7-8- fold increase in caspase-3 activity, induction of apoptotic cell death in 42.5% of cells [76]; lowers the mRNA level by 75% and protein level by 73%, inhibits cell proliferation by 53%, 11-fold increase in the proportion of apoptotic cells [77] | |
| Ribozyme | Melanoma [78, 79], mammary carcinoma [80] | Lowers mRNA and protein levels 75% and 74% respectively, increases tumor cell sensitivity to chemo- and radio-therapy, no effect without an additional apoptose inducing stimulus [78 - 80] | |
| asON | Chronic myeloleucosis | Complete inhibition of cell growth, apoptosis induction [208] | |
| Maxizyme | Chronic myeloleucosis | 95% decrease in the chimeric gene mRNA, apoptosis induction, tumor cell growth retardation [85] | |
| siRNA | Chronic myeloleucosis | Suppresses BCR-ABL-associated cell growth, 4-fold increase in tumor cell sensitivity to imanitib [87] | |
| DNAzyme | Chronic myeloleucosis | Suppresses protein production by 40-75% [208] | |
| asON | Lung, colon, prostate[190, 191], ovary [192, 193] cancer | 100% suppression of С-raf protein, 80% inhibition of cell proliferation [190 - 192]; growth suppression in various ovary carcinoma lines by 10% to 90% [193] | |
| siRNA | Bladder tumor | Lowers protein level by 37.5% [194] | |
| asON | Colon adenocarcinoma [211], epidermoid carcinoma [212] | Complete MDR phenotype reversal, increases accumulation of doxorubicin in cells 6.4-fold, promotes cell death [211, 212] | |
| siRNA | Human epidermoid carcinoma [215], human pancreatic and gastric carcinoma [217], ovary cancer cells [218], murine lymphosarcoma [219] | MDR1 mRNA level is down by 91% and the P-glycoprotein by 72%-83%, increases cell sensitivity to vinblastin [99, 215], duanorubicin [217] and paclitaxel [218] | |
| Ribozyme | Liver cancer | Reverses MDR phenotype, increases cell sensitivity to vincristin [214] | |
| Ribozyme | Colon cancer | Increases tumor cell sensitivity to chemotherapeutic drugs [101] | |
| asON MG98 | Lung and bladder carcinoma | Restores p16 function, promotes accumulation of hypomethylated from of retinoblastoma protein, inhibits proliferation [107] | |
| asON | Bladder cancer [111, 112] | Decreases the protein level by 97%, increases cytostatic drug sensitivty, increases proportion of apoptotic cells 3-fold, an activates caspase-3 [111, 112] | |
| Ribozyme | Mammary carcinoma | Reduces the length of the telomere tandem repeat region from 5.5 kbp to 3.5 kbp and reduces cell growth rate [224] | |
| asON GTI-2040 (Genasense™, USA) | Lung, bladder carcinoma, fibrosarcoma | Lowers the level of R2 subunit mRNA to below detectable levels [116] | |
| siRNA | Pancreatic adenocarcinoma | Increases tumor cell sensitivity to gemcytabin [198] | |
| asON | Mammary and bladder cancer | Decreases VEGF level by 45–83% and lowers cell survival [124] | |
| siRNA | Ovary, uteral cervical cancer, osteosarcoma | Reduces VEGF expression by 33–53% [125] | |
| Ribozyme Angizyme, Sirna Ther., USA | Lung, colon and mammary carcinoma | Causes specific cleavege of RNA-substrate and effectively lowers mRNA level in cell culture [199] | |
| DNAzyme | Mammary carcinoma | Lowers VEGFR-2 level by 90% and decreses cell survival by 34–65% by inducing apoptosis [200] | |
| asON | Ovary and mammary carcinoma | Additive inhibition of tumor cell proliferation in combination with doxorubicin [205] | |
| Ribozyme Herzyme | Ovary and mammary carcinoma | Lowers neu mRNA levels by 40–60%, thus inhibiting cell growth [131] | |
| asON LY2275796 | Non-Hodgkin lymphoma, lung bladder, colon, porstate and mammary cancer | Decreases eIF4E protein level by 80%; lowers protein levels of Bcl-2, survivin, cyclin D1, С-myc and VEGF; and induces apoptosis [136] | |
| Ribozyme (anti-PTN) | Melanoma | Decreases PTN mRNA level by 75% [140] | |
| Ribozyme (anti-ALK) | Glioblastoma | Decreases PTN activity [143] | |
| Ribozyme | Prostate cancer | Causes complete degradation of MMP9 mRNA [220] | |
| siRNA | Juvenile osteosarcoma | 50% decrease in cell migration [221] | |
| Ribozyme | Prostate and colon carcinoma [152, 222] | 80% suppression of FGF-BP protein synthesis; slowing down of tumor cell proliferation [152, 222] | |
| DNAzyme | Mammary carcinoma | 6-fold decrease of protein level, blocking of proliferation, and 3-fold drop in tumor cell invasion activity [157] | |
| siRNA | Prostate and mammary carcinoma | Inhibits tumor cell adhesion, migration, and proliferation [158] | |
| siRNA | Mammary carcinoma | Inhibits cell migration and invasion by more than 70% [225] |
Results of nucleic acid-based drugs testing in vivo
| RNA-target | Drug | Tumor type | Effect | Trial stage |
| asON ISIS 2503 | Hepatocellular carcinoma [162, 166] | Decreased tumor weight in mice and suppressed metastatic proccesses [162, 166]. Low toxicity, optimized therapy schedule [48, 168], positive response in combination with gemcytabine in 10% of patients; one complete response, 4 partial [48] | Phase II | |
| Ribozyme | Throat, pancreatic and bladder carcinoma, melanoma | Suppresses mouse tumor growth as a result of an increased proportion of apoptotic tumor cells, decreases the invasive potential of the tumor, and increases animal survival time [43–45, 169] | In vivo | |
| siRNA | pancreatic and ovary carcinoma [163, 164], lung cancer [165] | Inhibited tumor growth [163–165] | In vivo | |
| asON AVI-4126 (AVIBioPharma, USA) | Prostate and mammary cancer [50, 51] | Suppresses tumor growth by 80% in mice [50]. Moderate toxicity, accumulation of the drug in tumor tissue [51] | Phase II | |
| siRNA | Mammary carcinoma [177], lymphoma [176] | Opposes tumor progression [177]; decreases с-myc mRNA level in serum down to 15–20% [176] | In vivo | |
| asON ISIS 3521 (AffinitakTM, USA) | Bladder carcinoma, lung and colon cancer [55], ovary cancer [181], colon carcinoma [182] | Completely suppresses tumor growth in mice at a dosage of ISIS 3521 of 0.06–0.6 mg/kg [55]. Moderate toxicity in clinical trial [180]; 3 objective responses to therapy [181]; no response to therapy [182] | Phase II | |
| Clusterin | asON OGX-001 | Renal carcinoma [59], prostate cancer [60] | Caused a 2-fold decrease in tumor volume in mice when used in combination with paclitaxel [62]. Lowered clusterin levels in the patients’ pathological tissues [60] | Phase I/II |
| asON | Melanoma | Completely blocked tumor development from cells transfected with the asON [64] | Ex vivo | |
| asON G3139 (Genasense™, USA) | Lymphomas, lympholeucosis, myeloleucosis [186, 187], melanoma [71], lymphoma [188], lympholeucosis [70], prostate carcinoma [72] | Decreased tumor volume in mice [186], additive antitumor effect of asON G3139 and cysplatin [187]. Moderate toxicity in clinical trial, stabilized the tumor process, improved life quality [188] | Phase II | |
| siRNA | Murine liver Н22 tumor [185], pancreatic cancer [189] | Slowed liver tumor growth in mice by 66.5% [185]; decreased pancreatic cancer heterotransplant volume by 56% [189] | In vivo | |
| asON | Chronic myeloleucosis | 2-fold increase of mice mean survival time [210] | In vivo | |
| asON ISIS 5132 (Neopharm, USA) | Ovary [93, 192] prostate cancer [92], colon adenocarcinoma [94] | Suppressed tumor growth in mice [192]. Moderate toxicity in clinic [195], stabilization of the disease in more than 25% of cases [92, 93] | Phase II | |
| Ribozyme | Colon adenocarcinoma | A virtually complete regression of mouse tumors in an ex vivo experiment, in combination with doxorubicin [98] | Ex vivo | |
| siRNA | Murine lymphosarcoma [99, 219] | A virtually complete regression of mouse tumors in an in vivo experiment, in combination with cyclophosphamide [102] | In vivo | |
| asON MG98 | Non-small cell lung cancer, colon carcinoma, metastatic renal carcinoma and other solid tumors [108, 196, 197] | Regression of tumors in nude mice [196]. No serious side effects, no clinical response from patients [108,196, 197] | Phase II | |
| asON | Glioma | A more than 50% regression of tumor [112] | In vivo | |
| asON GTI-2040 (Genasense™, USA) | Solid tumors | Inhibited tumor growth in all the experimental models studied, maximal effect in renal carcinoma. 95–98% regression [116]. No serious side effects, optimized treatment schedule [117] | Phase II | |
| siRNA | Pancreatic adenocarcinoma | Synergistic siRNA and hemcytabine cytotoxicity [198] | In vivo | |
| asON | Renal carcinoma | Fivefold tumor regression [201] | In vivo | |
| siRNA | Colon and prostate adenocarcinoma [202, 203] | Tenfold retardation of colon adenocarcinoma growth [202] and 1.5-fold inhibition for prostate carcinoma [203], suppresses tumor vascularization [202, 203] | In vivo | |
| Ribozyme Angiozyme, Sirna Ther., USA | Lung carcinoma [199], colon cancer [35, 204], mammary cancer [35] | Growth regression of Lewis lung carcinoma in mice by 92% and 70–80% decrease in metastasis in the lungs [199]. Well-tolerated by patients, lowers VEGFR-1 protein level in tumor cells, stabilizes the disease in 25% of patients [35, 204] | Phase II | |
| DNAzyme | Mammary carcinoma | Causes tumor regression by 75% in mice, reduces vasularization in tumors, and causes cell death in the tumor’s peripherial tissue [200] | In vivo | |
| asON | Ovary and mammary cancer | Synergistic anticancer effect with doxyrubicin [205] | In vivo | |
| Ribozyme Херзим | Mammary carcinoma | Regression of tumors in mice by 89% [206]. Well-tolerated by patients, stabilzes the disease [132] | Phase I | |
| asON LY2275796 | Prostate carcinoma | Tenfold regression of the tumor; has no toxic effect on healthy organs or tissues in mice [136] | ||
| Ribozyme (anti-PTN) | Melanoma | Reduces tumor size by 65%, inhibits vascularization by 70–85%, and induces apoptosis [140] | In vivo | |
| Ribozyme (anti-ALK) | Glioblastoma | Slows tumor growth, increases tumor-bearing mice survival time 2-fold [143] | In vivo | |
| Ribozyme | Metastatic fibrobalsts [220], prostate cancer[147] | Causes an 8-fold decrease in metastasis, a 1/3 increase in mean mouse survival time, and has no effect on primary tumor development [147, 220] | Ex vivo | |
| Ribozyme | Prostate carcinoma | Suppresses tumor development [152] | Ex vivo | |
| DNAzyme | Mammary carcinoma | Suppresses tumor growth 3-fold [157] | In vivo | |
| siRNA | Prostate and mammary carcinoma | Tumor regression [158] | In vivo | |
| siRNA | Mammary carcinoma | Virtually completely inhibits metastasis, lowers CXCR4 mRNA level to 10% [159], and causes tumor regression [223] | In vivo |