| Literature DB >> 21545714 |
Dominic Stoop1, Lisbet Van Landuyt, Etienne Van den Abbeel, Michel Camus, Greta Verheyen, Paul Devroey.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Single blastocyst transfer has the advantage of maximizing the fresh single pregnancy rate. However, in patients with a low number of good quality embryos on day 3, it remains unclear whether immediate embryo transfer or further embryo culture with blastocyst transfer is the most preferable option.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2011 PMID: 21545714 PMCID: PMC3113931 DOI: 10.1186/1477-7827-9-60
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Reprod Biol Endocrinol ISSN: 1477-7827 Impact factor: 5.211
Patient demographics and stimulation characteristics
| eSET with elective day 5 transfer | eSET with transfer day 3 or 5 | Statistical significance | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No. subjects | 341 | 249 | - | |
| Age (years) | 29.94 (3.54) | 31.20 (3.18) | NS | |
| Rank of trial | 0.29 (0.61) | 0.39 (0.68) | NS | |
| Days of stimulation | 9.53 (2.09) | 9.83 (2.22) | NS | |
| Total gonadotropin dose (IU) | 1745.95 (632.93) | 1857.56 (685.55) | NS | |
| Day 3 | Day 5 | |||
| No. subjects | 135 | 102 | ||
| Age (years) | 31.24 (3.23) | 31.30 (3.11) | NS | |
| Rank of trial | 0.36 (0.66) | 0.44 (0.73) | NS | |
| Days of stimulation | 9.94 (2.35) | 9.78 (1.98) | ||
| Total gonadotropin dose ((IU) | 1907.56 (671.37) | 1800.17 (704.74) | NS | |
Embryology data: fresh embryo transfer
| eSET with elective day 5 transfer | eSET with transfer day 3 or 5 | Statistical significance | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IVF | 44/341 (12.90) | 24/247 (9.72) | NS | |
| ICSI | 297/341 (87.10) | 223/247 (90.28) | NS | |
| Mean No. cumulus-oocyte complexes (SD) | 12.33 (7.23) | 11.66 (7.35) | NS | |
| Mean No. metaphase II oocytes | 8.50 (6.26) | 8.27 (6.46) | NS | |
| Mean No. two pronuclei oocytes | 7.46 (5.03) | 7.11 (4.95) | NS | |
| Embryos on day 3 | 2393 | 16901 | - | |
| Embryos on day 5 | 1619 | 8162 | ||
| Embryos transferred fresh | 309 | 237 | - | |
| Embryo fresh transfer rate (%) | 309/1619 (19.09) | 237/13903 (17.05) | NS | |
| Subjects with fresh transfer | 309 | 237 | - | |
| Subjects fresh transfer rate (%) | 309/341 (90.62) | 237/249 (95.18) | <0.05 | |
| Embryos cryopreserved | 640 | 5604 | - | |
| Embryo cryopreservation rate (%) | 640/1619 (39.53) | 5604/14651 (38.22) | NS | |
| Subjects with cryopreservation | 191 | 1665 | - | |
| Subjects cryopreservation rate (%) | 191/309 (61.81) | 166/237 (70.04) | 0.05 | |
| Day 3 | Day 5 | |||
| IVF | 12/135 (8.89) | 10/102 (9.80) | NS | |
| ICSI | 123/135 (91.11) | 92/102 (90.20) | NS | |
| Mean No. cumulus-oocyte complexes (SD) | 9.18 (5.92) | 14.52 (6.25) | <0.05 | |
| Mean No. metaphase II oocytes (SD) | 6.00 (4.31) | 11.01 (6.08) | <0.05 | |
| Mean No. two pronuclei oocytes (SD) | 4.73 (3.00) | 10.05 (4.06) | <0.05 | |
| Embryos on day 3 | 615 | 1000 | - | |
| Embryos on day 5 | NA | 775 | - | |
| Embryos transferred fresh | 135 | 102 | - | |
| Embryo fresh transfer rate (%) | 135/615 (21.95) | 102/775 (13.16) | <0.001 | |
| Embryos cryopreserved | 154 | 363 | ||
| Embryo cryopreservation rate (%) | 154/615 (25.04) | 363/775 (46.84) | <0.001 | |
| Subjects with cryopreservation | 80 | 84 | - | |
| Subjects cryopreservation rate (%) | 80/135 (59.26) | 84/102 (82.35) | <0.001 | |
1 including 75 day 3 embryos from 6 subjects without fresh transfer.
2 including 41 day 5 embryos from 2 subjects without fresh transfer.
3 available day 3 embryos for subjects with fresh day 3 transfer and available day 5 embryos for subjects with fresh day 5 transfer.
4 including 43 embryo cryopreserved on day 3 and 5 in subjects without fresh transfer.
5 including 2 subjects with cryopreserved embryos without fresh transfer.
Fresh embryo transfer outcome
| eSET with elective day 5 transfer | eSET with transfer day 3 or 5 | Statistical significance | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| /cycle | /ET | /cycle | /ET | /cycle | |
| Pregnancy rate (positive hCG) | 141/341 (41.35) | 141/309 (45.63) | 95/249 (38.15) | 95/237 (40.08) | 0.45 |
| Clinical pregnancy rate | 121/341 (35.48) | 121/309 (39.16) | 79/249 (31.73) | 79/237 (33.30) | 0.38 |
| Ongoing pregnancy rate | 118/341 (34.60) | 118/309 (38.19) | 73/249 (29.32) | 73/237 (30.80) | 0.18 |
| Pregnancy loss | |||||
| Miscarriage | 14 | 14 | 10 | 10 | - |
| Ectopic pregnancy | 5 | 5 | 1 | 1 | - |
| Live birth rate | 112/341 (32.84) | 112/309 (36.25) | 72/249 (28.92) | 72/237 (30.38) | 0.32 |
| Mulitple pregnancy rate | 4/341 (1.17) | 4/309 (1.29) | 0/249 (0) | 0/237 (0) | 0.16 |
| Day 3/cycle (%) | Day 5/cycle (%) | ||||
| Pregnancy rate (positive hCG) | 47/135 (34.81) | 48/102 (47.06) | 0.08 | ||
| Clinical pregnancy rate | 39/135 (28.89) | 40/102 (39.26) | 0.10 | ||
| Ongoing pregnancy rate | 36/135 26.67) | 37/102 (36.27) | 0.16 | ||
| Pregnancy loss | |||||
| Miscarriage | 6 | 4 | - | ||
| Ectopic pregnancy | 1 | 0 | - | ||
| Live birth rate | 36/135 (26.67) | 36/102 (35.29) | 0.16 | ||
| Mulitple pregnancy rate | 0/135 (0) | 0/102 (0) | 1 | ||
Efficiency of cryopreservation and pregnancy potential of surviving embryos
| eSET with elective day 5 transfer | eSET with transfer day 3 or 5 | Statistical significance | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No. of embryos cryopreserved | 640 | 517 | ||
| No. of thawing cycles | 188 | 143 | ||
| No. of embryos thawed | 286 | 229 | ||
| No. of embryos surviving | 200 | 150 | ||
| Transferrable survival rate | 200/286 (69.9) | 150/229 (65.5) | NS | |
| Subjects with thawed transfers | 109 | 71 | ||
| Total number of thawed transfers | 171 | 125 | ||
| Total number of clinical pregnancies | 26 | 21 | ||
| Transfer specific pregnancy rate1 | 26/171 (15.2) | 21/125 (16.8) | NS | |
| Subject specific pregnancy rate2 | 26/109 (23.9) | 21/71 (29.6) | NS | |
| Day 3 | Day 5 | |||
| No. of embryos cryopreserved | 154 | 363 | ||
| No. of thawing cycles | 41 | 102 | ||
| No. of embryos thawed | 84 | 145 | ||
| No. of embryos surviving | 39 | 111 | ||
| Transferrable survival rate | 39/84 (46.4) | 111/145 (76.5) | <0.001 | |
| Subjects with thawed transfers | 26 | 45 | ||
| Total number of thawed transfers | 28 | 97 | ||
| Total number of clinical pregnancies | 4 | 17 | ||
| Transfer specific pregnancy rate1 | 4/28 (14.3) | 17/97 (17.5) | NS | |
| Subject specific pregnancy rate2 | 4/26 (15.4) | 17/45 (37.8) | 0.05 | |
1 Total number of pregnancies/total number of thawed transfers
2 Total number of pregnancies/number of subjects with thawed transfers
Frozen embryo transfer outcome
| eSET with elective day 5 transfer | eSET with transfer day 3 or 5 | Statistical significance | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| /cycle (n = 188) | /ET (n = 171) | /cycle (n = 143) | /ET (n = 123) | ||||
| Positive hCG (%) | 34/188 (18.06) | 34/171 (19.88) | 30/143 (21.00) | 30/123 (24.39) | NS | ||
| Clinical pregnancy rate (%) | 26/188 (13.83) | 26/171 (15.20) | 21/143 (14.69) | 21/123 (17.07) | NS | ||
| Ongoing pregnancy rate (%) | 24/188 (12.77) | 24/171 (14.04) | 18/143 (12.56) | 18/123 (14.63) | NS | ||
| Pregnancy loss | |||||||
| Miscarriage | 2/26 (7.69) | 3/20 (20) | NS | ||||
| Ectopic pregnancy | 0 | 1/30 (3.33) | NS | ||||
| Single embryo transfer (%) | 142/171 (83.0) | 96/123 (78.05) | NS | ||||
| Multiple pregnancy rate (%) | 2/24 (8.33) | 1/18 (5.56) | NS | ||||
| Day 3 | Day 5 | ||||||
| /cycle (n = 41) | /ET (n = 26) | /cycle (n = 102) | /ET (n = 97) | ||||
| Positive hCG (%) | 5/41 (12.20) | 5/26 (19.23) | 25/102 (24.51) | 25/97 (25.77) | NS | ||
| Clinical pregnancy rate (%) | 4/41 (9.76) | 4/26 (15.38) | 17/102 (16.67) | 17/97 (17.53) | NS | ||
| Ongoing pregnancy rate (%) | 4/41 (9.76) | 4/26 (15.38) | 14/102 (13.72) | 14/97 (14.43) | NS | ||
| Pregnancy loss | |||||||
| Miscarriage | 0 | 3/17 (17.6) | NS | ||||
| Ectopic pregnancy | 0 | 1/25 (4) | NS | ||||
| Single embryo transfer (%) | 13/26 (50.0) | 83/97 (85.6) | <0.001 | ||||
| Multiple pregnancy rate (%) | ¼ (25) | 0 | NS | ||||
Summary and projected pregnancy rate compensating for the double counting of pregnancies in case a subject has more than one pregnancy
| eSET with elective day 5 transfer | eSET with transfer day 3 or 5 | Statistical significance | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No. of fresh cycles | 341 | 249 | ||
| No. of thawed cycles | 188 | 143 | ||
| Subjects with fresh or thawed clinical pregnancy | 147 | 100 | ||
| Subjects with fresh or thawed ongoing pregnancy | 142 | 91 | ||
| Number of embryos unthawed1 | 38 | 98 | ||
| Clinical pregnancy rate thawed embryos | 26/286 (9.09) | 21/229 (9.17) | NS | |
| Ongoing pregnancy rate thawed embryos | 24/286 (8.39) | 18/229 (7.86) | NS | |
| Projected number subjects with clinical pregnancy2 | 3.45 | 9.68 (1.24+8.44) | ||
| Projected number subjects with a ongoing pregnancy2 | 3.19 | 8.20 (1.24+6.96) | ||
| Projected cumulative clinical pregnancy rate3 | 150.45/341 (44.12) | 109.68/249 (44.04) | NS | |
| Projected cumulative ongoing pregnancy rate3 | 145.19/341 (42.58) | 99.20/249 (39.84) | NS | |
| Day 3 | Day 5 | |||
| No. of fresh cycles | 135 | 102 | ||
| No. of thawed cycles | 41 | 102 | ||
| Subjects with fresh or thawed clinical pregnancy | 43 | 57 | ||
| Subjects with fresh or thawed ongoing pregnancy | 40 | 51 | ||
| Number of embryos unthawed2 | 26 | 72 | ||
| Clinical pregnancy rate thawed embryos | 4/84 (4.76) | 17/145 (11.72) | NS | |
| Ongoing pregnancy rate thawed embryos | 4/84 (4.76) | 14/145 (9.66) | NS | |
| Projected number subjects with clinical pregnancy | 1.24 | 8.44 | ||
| Projected number subjects with a ongoing pregnancy | 1.24 | 6.96 | ||
1 Number of embryos unthawed for subjects with no fresh or thawed pregnancy
2 Projected from the unthawed material among subjects without a fresh or thawed pregnancy, assuming that the pregnancy rate will be the same as for the already thawed material
3 Fresh pregnancies, thawed pregnancies and projected number of pregnancies/number of subjects