Fiona Kate Elizabeth McDuff1, Suzanne Dawn Turner. 1. Division of Molecular Histopathology, Department of Pathology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, United Kingdom.
Abstract
Anaplastic Lymphoma Kinase (ALK) is a receptor tyrosine kinase aberrantly expressed in a variety of tumor types, most notably in Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma (ALCL) where a chromosomal translocation generates the oncogenic fusion protein, Nucleophosmin-ALK (NPM-ALK). Whilst much is known regarding the mechanism of transformation by NPM-ALK, the existence of cellular defence pathways to prevent this pathological process has not been investigated. Employing the highly tractable primary murine embryonic fibroblast (MEF) system we show that cellular transformation is not an inevitable consequence of NPM-ALK activity but is combated by p53 and Rb. Activation of p53 and/or Rb by NPM-ALK triggers a potent proliferative block with features reminiscent of senescence. While loss of p53 alone is sufficient to circumvent NPM-ALK-induced senescence and permit cellular transformation, sole loss of Rb permits continued proliferation but not transformation due to p53-imposed restraints. Furthermore, NPM-ALK attenuates p53 activity in an Rb and MDM2 dependent manner but this activity is not sufficient to bypass senescence. These data indicate that senescence may constitute an effective barrier to ALK-induced malignancies that ultimately must be overcome for tumor development.
Anaplastic Lymphoma Kinase (ALK) is a receptor tyrosine kinase aberrantly expressed in a variety of tumor types, most notably in Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma (ALCL) where a chromosomal translocation generates the oncogenic fusion protein, Nucleophosmin-ALK (NPM-ALK). Whilst much is known regarding the mechanism of transformation by NPM-ALK, the existence of cellular defence pathways to prevent this pathological process has not been investigated. Employing the highly tractable primary murine embryonic fibroblast (MEF) system we show that cellular transformation is not an inevitable consequence of NPM-ALK activity but is combated by p53 and Rb. Activation of p53 and/or Rb by NPM-ALK triggers a potent proliferative block with features reminiscent of senescence. While loss of p53 alone is sufficient to circumvent NPM-ALK-induced senescence and permit cellular transformation, sole loss of Rb permits continued proliferation but not transformation due to p53-imposed restraints. Furthermore, NPM-ALK attenuates p53 activity in an Rb and MDM2 dependent manner but this activity is not sufficient to bypass senescence. These data indicate that senescence may constitute an effective barrier to ALK-induced malignancies that ultimately must be overcome for tumor development.
Anaplastic Lymphoma Kinase (ALK) is a member of the insulin receptor tyrosine kinase
family, whose expression is predominately limited to the developing nervous system
and at low levels in adult neuronal cells [1], [2], [3]. Whilst little is known of the
physiological function of ALK, it is rapidly gaining recognition as an important
oncogene in a diverse range of tumor types, including Anaplastic Large Cell Lymphoma
(ALCL), melanoma, breast cancer, non-small cell lung carcinoma, neuroblastoma,
inflammatory myofibroblastic tumors and esophageal squamous cell carcinoma although
its involvement in some of these cancers is still somewhat controversial [1], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9], [10], [11], [12], [13], [14], [15], [16]. Deregulated ALK
expression in each of these cases is the consequence of either activating point
mutations of the full-length protein or chromosomal aberrations including
translocations and inversions which juxtapose the kinase region of ALK to an
oligomerization domain encoded in the partner gene. The oncogenic potential of ALK
has been best demonstrated in ALCL in which it is expressed as a fusion protein,
predominantly juxtaposed to NPM [1]. The NPM portion of NPM-ALK provides an oligomerization
interface to permit dimerization of NPM-ALK monomers, followed by
autophosphorylation and constitutive activation [17]. A direct role for NPM-ALK in
cellular transformation has been shown both in vitro and in vivo,
and such studies have shed light on the mechanism of malignant transformation by
this oncoprotein [18], [19]. These mechanisms include activation of several
downstream signal-transduction pathways, which regulate cell survival, proliferation
and migration [18], [20], [21].The t(2;5) encoding NPM-ALK and the corresponding transcripts have been detected in
the peripheral blood of apparently healthy individuals at a frequency of
48–65% [22], [23]. These findings are in line with the presence of other
known oncogenic translocations in tumor-free donors, such as BCR-ABL [24], [25], IgH-Bcl2 [26], [27] and
PML-RARα [28].
These data indicate that the presence of the oncogenic translocation per
se is not sufficient for tumorigenesis; rather, additional molecular
events are likely required for the cell to become fully transformed and to bypass
barriers such as apoptosis or oncogene-induced senescence (OIS) [29]. Further
evidence for multi-step NPM-ALK-induced lymphomagenesis stems from studies of
NPM-ALK-transgenic mice in which the latency to disease in some cases can be
anything from 9 months to 2 years suggesting a requirement for cooperative mutations
[30], [31]. Hence, these
findings imply that NPM-ALK is necessary but not sufficient for lymphoma
development.The p53 and Rbtumor-suppressor genes are two of the most frequently mutated genes in
humancancer, and the proteins encoded by these genes have multiple tumor-suppressor
functions, not least their roles in apoptosis, transient cell-cycle arrest and
senescence [32]. In
order to investigate whether aberrant ALK activity has the potential to trigger
cellular mechanisms that prevent oncogenic transformation, NPM-ALK was expressed in
primary murine embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs), a genetically amenable and
well-characterized system that has been used extensively in the study of
oncogene-induced senescence and apoptosis. Particular attention was paid to the
potential roles of the p53 and Rb pathways in limiting NPM-ALK-induced
transformation.We show that NPM-ALK induces a cell-cycle arrest with features characteristic of
senescence. We further show that this senescence-like arrest is dependent on the
activity of p53 and Rb, two tumor-suppressor proteins whose activity is frequently
de-regulated in NPM-ALK+ ALCL [33], [34].
Results
NPM-ALK kinase activity induces cell-cycle arrest of primary MEFs with
features of senescence
Early-passage MEFs were transduced by retrovirus with MSCVpuro vectors encoding
NPM-ALK, a kinase-dead mutant of NPM-ALK (K210R), H-Ras V12 or insert-free
vector and were selected in puromycin for three days before their use in the
assays described below. The timeline of the experiment is depicted in Figure 1A.
Figure 1
NPM-ALK expression in primary MEFs inhibits cellular
proliferation.
(A) Experimental design and reference timeframe. Infection refers to
exposure of MEFs to retrovirus, and selection refers to enrichment for
transduced cells with 2 µg/ml of puromycin. (B) MEFs infected with
retrovirus and selected for expression of the indicated genes were
assessed for their ability to proliferate over 6 days
via crystal violet assay. Relative cell growth was
determined by comparing crystal violet optical density values obtained
at 590 nm at each time point with those obtained at day 0. Each time
point was conducted in triplicate in at least 3 separate experiments
using MEFs from independent embryo preparations. Error bars are standard
deviations of the mean.
NPM-ALK expression in primary MEFs inhibits cellular
proliferation.
(A) Experimental design and reference timeframe. Infection refers to
exposure of MEFs to retrovirus, and selection refers to enrichment for
transduced cells with 2 µg/ml of puromycin. (B) MEFs infected with
retrovirus and selected for expression of the indicated genes were
assessed for their ability to proliferate over 6 days
via crystal violet assay. Relative cell growth was
determined by comparing crystal violet optical density values obtained
at 590 nm at each time point with those obtained at day 0. Each time
point was conducted in triplicate in at least 3 separate experiments
using MEFs from independent embryo preparations. Error bars are standard
deviations of the mean.H-Ras V12 is an oncoprotein that induces senescence when expressed in primary
MEFs (Figure 1B and [35]).
Likewise, it was observed that expression of the oncogenic tyrosine kinase
NPM-ALK in MEFs prevented the accumulation of cells as assessed by crystal
violet assay (Figure 1B).
The amount of cell death was similar between control and NPM-ALK-expressing
cells (Figure
S1), indicating that the reduced proliferative capacity of the latter
was primarily due to cell-cycle arrest rather than cell death. Consistent with
this notion, cells remained attached to the plates and DNA synthesis (as
measured by BrdU and PI incorporation) was reduced in NPM-ALK-expressing cells
to a level comparable to that of H-Ras V12-expressing MEFs (Figure 2A). The cell-cycle arrest was
dependent on the kinase activity of NPM-ALK since the kinase-dead K210R mutant
showed the same growth kinetics and cell-cycle profile as vector control cells
(Figures 1B and 2A).
Figure 2
NPM-ALK expression in primary MEFs induces a senescence-like
arrest.
(A) Representative data of flow cytometric cell-cycle analysis following
BrdU incorporation and PI staining. The assay was performed at day 6.
Lower-left box identifies cells with 2n DNA content; upper box
identifies cells in S phase; Lower-right box identifies cells with 4n
DNA content. (B) Graphical representation of cell-cycle analysis (left
panel). Data shows the mean of three independent experiments. Error bars
are standard deviations of the mean. *denotes significance at
p<0.05 using a Student's T-test. Microscopic examination at
×100 magnification showing NPM-ALK cells with 2 nuclei (indicated
by arrows) (right panel). (C) Protein lysates prepared from cells
transduced with and selected for expression of vectors encoding NPM-ALK
(NA) or an empty vector (EV) were examined by Western blot for
expression of the indicated proteins with their respective antibodies
(pp-Rb indicates phosphorylated Rb). (D) Bright-field images of MEFs
(×25 magnification) infected with the indicated retroviruses and
assayed for SA-β-Gal activity (indicated by blue coloring) at day 4
(right panel). The bar chart displays quantification of the senescence
assay. H-Ras-V12-expressing MEFs were used as a positive control for
senescence. At least 200 cells were counted per well (in triplicate in
at least 3 separate experiments using MEFs from independent embryo
preparations). Error bars are standard deviations of the mean.
**denotes significance at p<0.01 using a Student's
T-test.
NPM-ALK expression in primary MEFs induces a senescence-like
arrest.
(A) Representative data of flow cytometric cell-cycle analysis following
BrdU incorporation and PI staining. The assay was performed at day 6.
Lower-left box identifies cells with 2n DNA content; upper box
identifies cells in S phase; Lower-right box identifies cells with 4n
DNA content. (B) Graphical representation of cell-cycle analysis (left
panel). Data shows the mean of three independent experiments. Error bars
are standard deviations of the mean. *denotes significance at
p<0.05 using a Student's T-test. Microscopic examination at
×100 magnification showing NPM-ALK cells with 2 nuclei (indicated
by arrows) (right panel). (C) Protein lysates prepared from cells
transduced with and selected for expression of vectors encoding NPM-ALK
(NA) or an empty vector (EV) were examined by Western blot for
expression of the indicated proteins with their respective antibodies
(pp-Rb indicates phosphorylated Rb). (D) Bright-field images of MEFs
(×25 magnification) infected with the indicated retroviruses and
assayed for SA-β-Gal activity (indicated by blue coloring) at day 4
(right panel). The bar chart displays quantification of the senescence
assay. H-Ras-V12-expressing MEFs were used as a positive control for
senescence. At least 200 cells were counted per well (in triplicate in
at least 3 separate experiments using MEFs from independent embryo
preparations). Error bars are standard deviations of the mean.
**denotes significance at p<0.01 using a Student's
T-test.Cell-cycle analysis of both NPM-ALK- and H-Ras V12-expressing cells revealed a
significant decrease in the percentage of cells with 2n–4n DNA content
(indicating S-phase) and an accumulation of cells with 4n DNA content
(indicating G2/M) (Figure 2A,
B). H-Ras V12 expression in primary cells has previously been
associated with an arrest of cells in the G1 phase of the cell cycle, therefore
to determine whether the accumulation of cells with 4n DNA content was in fact a
result of a G1 tetraploid arrest (DNA synthesis in the absence of cytokinesis)
cells were subjected to microscopic examination and Western blot analysis for
the G2/M marker, cyclin B. At day 4 of the experimental time frame NPM-ALK- and
H-Ras V12-expressing cells containing two nuclei were present at high frequency
in the population (Figure
2B, right panel and data not shown) and, furthermore, Western blot
analysis revealed that Rb was present in NPM-ALK-expressing cells predominantly
in its hypophosphorylated (active) form without up-regulation of the G2/M marker
cyclin B but with down-regulation of cyclin A (Figure 2C). Together, these data support a
predominant tetraploid G1 arrest of NPM-ALK-expressing cells.Consistent with a senescent arrest NPM-ALK-expressing cells did not resume
proliferation after at least a month of culture (data not shown), displayed
typical morphological features of senescent cells, becoming enlarged and
flattened (Figure 2B, right
panel), and a substantial proportion of the cell population stained positively
for Senescence-Associated-β-Galactosidase (SA-β-Gal) activity by day 4
of the experimental time-frame (Figure 2D).
NPM-ALK-induced senescence-like arrest is dependent on p53
H-Ras V12-induced senescence of MEFs requires an intact p19ARF/p53 pathway [35], [36]. To
determine if this is likewise the case for NPM-ALK, we expressed NPM-ALK in
p53-deficient (p53−/−) MEFs and assessed growth and
SA-β-Gal staining shortly after retroviral transduction and selection. In
the absence of p53, NPM-ALK-induced growth arrest was bypassed (Figure 3A) and the cells no
longer stained positively for SA-β-Gal (Figure 3B). In fact, NPM-ALK-expressing
p53−/− MEFs lost contact inhibition, were capable of
proliferation at low density and could grow without a solid support in
soft-agarose, all features consistent with a transformed phenotype (Figure 3C). Despite the
involvement of p53 in NPM-ALK-induced senescence, we did not observe
stabilization of the protein nor induction of its prototypic,
senescence-associated target gene p21 by Western blot analysis,
whereas H-Ras V12 induced both of these proteins at two different time points
(days 1 and 3 of the experimental time-frame; Figure 4A), consistent with previous
observations [35]. We noted that p19ARF, a protein required to
stabilize p53 [37], was induced to only modest levels compared to H-Ras
V12 following NPM-ALK expression, which may account for the lack of detectable
p53 stabilization in these cells (Figure 4A). Moreover, we have previously reported that NPM-ALK
targets p53 for degradation via the MDM2 and JNK pathways in
transformed human ALCL cell lines [33]. Thus, the lack of p53 stabilization is consistent
with our previous findings. Indeed, treatment of NPM-ALK-expressing MEFs with
the MDM2 inhibitor, nutlin-3, for 1, 2 and 4 hours was sufficient to stabilize
p53 to relatively high levels by 2 hours post-treatment, leading to the
induction of p21 and MDM2 (Figure
4B). The return of p53 to basal levels by 4 hours post-treatment may
indicate the activation of alternative p53-degradation pathways. Treatment of
H-Ras V12-expressing cells in the same manner did not lead to further p53
stabilization nor enhanced p21 induction, presumably indicating that the
MDM2-p53 interaction is already maximally disrupted in these cells and also
suggesting that NPM-ALK induces expression of p53 whilst simultaneously enabling
its degradation (p53 expression levels are much higher in the NPM-ALK expressing
cells suggesting that it induces transcription of this protein).
Figure 3
NPM-ALK-induced senescence is p53-dependent.
Early-passage p53 MEFs were
retrovirally transduced with empty (EV), NPM-ALK- (NA), or H-Ras-V12
(Ras)-containing vectors and selected in puromycin as detailed in Fig. 1A before use in
the following experiments: (A) Relative cell growth was determined by
comparing crystal violet optical density values obtained at 590 nm at
each time point with those obtained at day 0. (B) SA-β-Gal activity
was determined at day 4 post-selection. At least 200 cells were counted
per well. (C) Anchorage-independent growth in soft agarose was assessed
by foci formation at weeks 2–3. Each experiment in (A)–(C)
was conducted in triplicate in at least 2 separate experiments using
MEFs from independent embryo preparations. Error bars are standard
deviations of the mean. **denotes significance at p<0.01
using a Student's T test.
Figure 4
NPM-ALK-induced senescence is p53-dependent but is not due to protein
stabilization.
(A) Western blot demonstrating lack of p53/p21/p16/p19 up-regulation in
response to NPM-ALK expression in MEFs at the indicated time points in
comparison to oncogenic H-Ras V12-expressing cells. (B)
NPM-ALK-expressing MEFs treated with the MDM2-antagonist Nutlin-3 for
the indicated times show stabilization of p53 and transcriptional
activity as evidenced by p21 expression, detected by Western blot. (C)
CD2/NPM-ALK transgenic mice when back-crossed onto a
p53 heterozygous background displayed a significant
increase in tumor development suggesting that p53 delays tumor
progression.
NPM-ALK-induced senescence is p53-dependent.
Early-passage p53MEFs were
retrovirally transduced with empty (EV), NPM-ALK- (NA), or H-Ras-V12
(Ras)-containing vectors and selected in puromycin as detailed in Fig. 1A before use in
the following experiments: (A) Relative cell growth was determined by
comparing crystal violet optical density values obtained at 590 nm at
each time point with those obtained at day 0. (B) SA-β-Gal activity
was determined at day 4 post-selection. At least 200 cells were counted
per well. (C) Anchorage-independent growth in soft agarose was assessed
by foci formation at weeks 2–3. Each experiment in (A)–(C)
was conducted in triplicate in at least 2 separate experiments using
MEFs from independent embryo preparations. Error bars are standard
deviations of the mean. **denotes significance at p<0.01
using a Student's T test.
NPM-ALK-induced senescence is p53-dependent but is not due to protein
stabilization.
(A) Western blot demonstrating lack of p53/p21/p16/p19 up-regulation in
response to NPM-ALK expression in MEFs at the indicated time points in
comparison to oncogenic H-Ras V12-expressing cells. (B)
NPM-ALK-expressing MEFs treated with the MDM2-antagonist Nutlin-3 for
the indicated times show stabilization of p53 and transcriptional
activity as evidenced by p21 expression, detected by Western blot. (C)
CD2/NPM-ALKtransgenic mice when back-crossed onto a
p53 heterozygous background displayed a significant
increase in tumor development suggesting that p53delays tumor
progression.Consistent with a role for p53 in the suppression of cellular transformation by
NPM-ALK, transgenic mice in which NPM-ALK expression is driven from the
lymphoid-specific CD2 promoter [30] exhibited accelerated lymphoma development and
increased tumor incidence when the oncogene was expressed on a
p53 heterozygous genetic background relative to NPM-ALK
expression on a p53 wild-type background (p<0.0005) (Figure 4C). These data are
indicative of a p53-imposed delay in tumorigenesis induced by NPM-ALK.In summary, NPM-ALK induces a senescence-like growth arrest that is dependent on
p53 in the absence of further p53 stabilization Alternatively, NPM-ALK induces
concomitant transcription and degradation of p53 protein which equilibrate to
levels sufficient for senescence induction.
p16 is dispensable for NPM-ALK-induced senescence
Another major pathway involved in senescence is the p16/Rb pathway [38]. To
address the role of this pathway in NPM-ALK-induced senescence, NPM-ALK was
initially expressed in p16-deficient
(p16
−/−) MEFs and the expansion of
puromycin-selected cells was assessed by crystal violet assay. We observed that
germline loss of p16 was insufficient to bypass growth arrest
induced by both NPM-ALK and H-Ras V12 (Figure 5A).
Figure 5
Acute mutation of Rb (but not germline loss of p16) permits escape
from NPM-ALK-induced senescence yet the cells remain sensitive to
p53-dependent barriers to transformation.
(A) Early-passage p16 MEFs
were retrovirally transduced with empty (EV), NPM-ALK- (NA), or
H-Ras-V12 (Ras)-containing vectors and selected in puromycin as detailed
in Fig. 1A before
use in a crystal violet assay to assess proliferative capacity. Relative
cell growth was determined by comparing crystal violet optical density
values obtained at 590 nm at each time point with those obtained at day
0. Each time point was conducted in triplicate in at least 3 separate
experiments using MEFs from independent embryo preparations. Error bars
are standard deviations of the mean. (B) Floxed cRblox/lox (Rb-null) or
control cRblox/lox (Rb-WT) MEFs were transduced by retrovirus with empty
(EV) or NPM-ALK- (NA) containing vectors as indicated and used in 3T3
assays to assess long-term proliferative potential. The data shown are
representative of two independent cRb
MEF populations derived from two different embryos. (C) Western blot
analysis showing levels of the indicated proteins in empty-vector and
NPM-ALK-expressing conditional Rb-deficient (Rb-null) MEFs at late
passage (cells post-senescent at passages 18 and 15 are shown from 2
independent MEF preparation experiments). Horizontal lines on the
Western blot indicate repositioning of the gel lanes. (D) Top panel:
images of the soft agarose assay (×25 magnification) demonstrating
that whilst NPM-ALK-expressing cells acutely mutated for
Rb have escaped senescence they do not grow in an
anchorage-independent manner, and therefore are not transformed (for
quantification of data see table 1). Inactivation of p53 by
GSE56 expression in these cells results in transformation (lower right
box). Bottom panel: Western blot showing NPM-ALK and p53 expression in
the different cells used in the soft agarose assay. Experiments were
performed twice with two independent MEF populations. (E) p53 is induced
following NPM-ALK expression in cells acutely mutated for Rb. Lysates
were prepared from MEFs of the indicated genotypes and the levels of Rb,
p53, p19ARF and NPM-ALK determined by Western blot.
“Rb-null” denotes MEFs in which the Rb gene
is acutely mutated by addition of Adenovirus expressing Cre-recombinase,
and “Rb-WT” denotes MEFs infected with a control
Cre-recombinase-deficient Adenovirus.
Acute mutation of Rb (but not germline loss of p16) permits escape
from NPM-ALK-induced senescence yet the cells remain sensitive to
p53-dependent barriers to transformation.
(A) Early-passage p16MEFs
were retrovirally transduced with empty (EV), NPM-ALK- (NA), or
H-Ras-V12 (Ras)-containing vectors and selected in puromycin as detailed
in Fig. 1A before
use in a crystal violet assay to assess proliferative capacity. Relative
cell growth was determined by comparing crystal violet optical density
values obtained at 590 nm at each time point with those obtained at day
0. Each time point was conducted in triplicate in at least 3 separate
experiments using MEFs from independent embryo preparations. Error bars
are standard deviations of the mean. (B) Floxed cRblox/lox (Rb-null) or
control cRblox/lox (Rb-WT) MEFs were transduced by retrovirus with empty
(EV) or NPM-ALK- (NA) containing vectors as indicated and used in 3T3
assays to assess long-term proliferative potential. The data shown are
representative of two independent cRb
MEF populations derived from two different embryos. (C) Western blot
analysis showing levels of the indicated proteins in empty-vector and
NPM-ALK-expressing conditional Rb-deficient (Rb-null) MEFs at late
passage (cells post-senescent at passages 18 and 15 are shown from 2
independent MEF preparation experiments). Horizontal lines on the
Western blot indicate repositioning of the gel lanes. (D) Top panel:
images of the soft agarose assay (×25 magnification) demonstrating
that whilst NPM-ALK-expressing cells acutely mutated for
Rb have escaped senescence they do not grow in an
anchorage-independent manner, and therefore are not transformed (for
quantification of data see table 1). Inactivation of p53 by
GSE56 expression in these cells results in transformation (lower right
box). Bottom panel: Western blot showing NPM-ALK and p53 expression in
the different cells used in the soft agarose assay. Experiments were
performed twice with two independent MEF populations. (E) p53 is induced
following NPM-ALK expression in cells acutely mutated for Rb. Lysates
were prepared from MEFs of the indicated genotypes and the levels of Rb,
p53, p19ARF and NPM-ALK determined by Western blot.
“Rb-null” denotes MEFs in which the Rb gene
is acutely mutated by addition of Adenovirus expressing Cre-recombinase,
and “Rb-WT” denotes MEFs infected with a control
Cre-recombinase-deficient Adenovirus.
Table 1
Loss of p53 function is required for anchorage-independent growth of
NPM-ALK-expressing conditional Rb-null post-senescent MEFs.
1st infection (P3)(MSCVpuro vector)
2nd infection (P15–18)(MSCVneo vector)
Number of Foci
Empty
Empty
0±0
Empty
GSE56
0±0
NPM-ALK
Empty
0±0
NPM-ALK
GSE56
118±11
P = passage.
Acute mutation of Rb permits bypass of NPM-ALK-induced senescence but is
insufficient for transformation
It has previously been shown that following germline mutation of
Rb, the protein product of which is the downstream target
of p16, the Rb-related proteins p107 and p130 can functionally compensate in
certain cellular contexts [39], [40]. Therefore to determine a direct role for the Rb
pathway in NPM-ALK-induced senescence, NPM-ALK was expressed in conditional
Rb-knockout (cRb) MEFs
in which the Rb gene can be irreversibly ablated at will
via the addition of Adenovirus expressing Cre-recombinase
recognizing LoxP-flanked sequences in exon 3 of the Rb gene
(Figure
S2A and [40]). MEFs were infected and selected according to the
protocol shown in Figure S2B. Following passage according to a
standard 3T3 protocol (see materials and
methods) we observed that NPM-ALK-expressing MEFs invariably overcame
any initial growth deficit at early passage and exhibited robust proliferation
for at least two months (Figure
5B). Paradoxically, Western blot analysis of lysates harvested from 2
independent cell populations cultured under the same conditions at passage 18
and 15 respectively revealed that both p19ARF and p53 levels were highly
elevated in NPM-ALK-expressing cells (Figure 5C). Furthermore, p53 was functional
in floxed cRb NPM-ALK-expressing cells as
revealed by the inability of the cells to adopt a transformed phenotype (loss of
contact inhibition and growth in an anchorage-independent manner) unless p53
function was simultaneously disrupted via co-infection with a
retrovirus encoding the p53 dominant-negative peptide, GSE56 (Figure 5D and Table 1). GSE56 antagonizes
p53 function through interaction with its oligomerisation domain, subsequently
resulting in the dramatic accumulation of inactive p53 [41] (Figure 5D). Thus, Rb functional loss permits
bypass of NPM-ALK-induced senescence but transformation is nevertheless
prevented due to p53-imposed restraints. This interplay between the p53 and Rb
pathways in senescence bypass and transformation has previously been described
for H-Ras V12 and indicates that p53 can act downstream of Rb in the prevention
of cellular transformation [40], [42].P = passage.
Rb is required for NPM-ALK-mediated p53 degradation
The data presented in Figure
5C further revealed that in the absence of Rb, NPM-ALK activity was
sufficient to induce p53 (compare lack of p53 induction in NPM-ALK-expressing
cells in wild-type MEFs in Figure
4A and p53 induction in Rb-deficient MEFs in Figure 5C), suggesting that Rb is required
for the previously described mechanism of NPM-ALK-mediated p53 degradation [33]. This
requirement for Rb was also confirmed in early passage MEFs where p19ARF
remained only modestly induced (Figure 5E), and warrants further investigation.
Discussion
Much work has been performed to delineate the mechanism of transformation by
oncogenic ALK, with most studies focusing on the activity of NPM-ALK and its role in
the genesis of ALCL [18], [19], [21]. Carcinogenesis is generally regarded as a multi-step
process requiring an undefined number of mutations and/or epigenetic changes that
confer specific growth advantages and/or permit bypass of tumor-suppressive
mechanisms [29].
Using primary cell lines we demonstrate here that NPM-ALK triggers a durable
proliferative arrest via activation of the p53 and Rb pathways with
many features characteristic of senescence. These data indicate that loss of p53 or
Rb function permits bypass of NPM-ALK-induced cell-cycle arrest, with p53
loss-of-function also leading to transformation. Whilst the p53
gene is rarely mutated in ALK+ ALCL [43] - indeed
p53 mutations are uncommon in a range of hematopoietic cancers
[44] – we
have previously shown that p53 function is disrupted in ALK+ ALCL
cell lines through NPM-ALK-mediated p53 degradation in a manner that depends on the
activities of MDM2 and JNK [33]. We likewise demonstrate here a dependency on MDM2, as
well as Rb, to target p53 for degradation in NPM-ALK-expressing MEFs, albeit at an
insufficient level in this case to disrupt p53 function entirely, thus triggering
growth arrest and preventing transformation. However, in the context of incipient
tumor cells in vivo, it is possible that other undefined molecular
events co-operate with NPM-ALK to abrogate p53 function (see Figure 6).
Figure 6
NPM-ALK paradoxically induces transcription and degradation of p53 to
generate an equilibrium whereby the dominating residual levels of p53 are
sufficient to induce senescence.
We propose that NPM-ALK induces transcription of p53 whilst also stabilizing
MDM2 and Rb with the effect of attenuating p53 activity. However,
equilibrium is reached whereby residual p53 protein is sufficient to set in
place a senescence pathway.
NPM-ALK paradoxically induces transcription and degradation of p53 to
generate an equilibrium whereby the dominating residual levels of p53 are
sufficient to induce senescence.
We propose that NPM-ALK induces transcription of p53 whilst also stabilizing
MDM2 and Rb with the effect of attenuating p53 activity. However,
equilibrium is reached whereby residual p53 protein is sufficient to set in
place a senescence pathway.The prevention of p53 stabilization and p21 induction following NPM-ALK expression in
MEFs may at first glance appear at odds with a role for p53 in preventing
NPM-ALK-induced senescence. These data suggest that basal levels of p53 are
sufficient to mediate the growth arrest response. Indeed, p53 exists at low basal
levels under homeostatic conditions to be functionally activated in response to
cellular stress. This can occur as a result of covalent modifications that disrupt
the C-terminal negative regulatory domains of p53 tetramers, leading to
conformational changes compatible with DNA binding and transactivation of
p53-responsive genes [45]. Thus, whilst p53 expression was not detectably increased
in response to NPM-ALK activity, there remains the possibility that the basal levels
of p53 present are transcriptionally active as a consequence of NPM-ALK-induced
post-translational modifications. Furthermore, the repertoire of p53-responsive
genes transcribed may be different to H-Ras-V12-expressing cells due to the presence
of lower levels of active p53. Thus, p53-transcriptional targets other than p21 may
be transcribed to mediate NPM-ALK-induced senescence.In support of a role for p53 in suppressing NPM-ALK-induced lymphomagenesis, we
observed accelerated lymphoma development in CD2/NPM-ALK-transgenic mice expressing
a single allele of p53 (Figure 4C). Assessing the nature of the
tumor-suppressor mechanism governed by p53 in this instance of lymphomagenesis is
severely hampered by the fact that a dysplastic, pre-tumorigenic state has not been
identified in any of the mouse models of ALCL described to date, nor in patients.
This is in contrast to the genesis of many solid tumors which can be traced through
a series of well-defined histopathological changes in tissue architecture from a
benign tumor through to its malignant conversion. Although it remains technically
challenging to identify a putative precursor cancer lesion that may occur anywhere
in the lympho-hematopoietic compartment, senescence has been identified as an
anti-tumor mechanism in mouse models of lymphoma development driven by oncogenic Myc
or N-Ras [46],
[47]. Thus,
identifying a role for senescence in the suppression of NPM-ALK-driven
lymphomagenesis may yet be possible.Germline loss of p16 is not sufficient to bypass NPM-ALK-induced
senescence; however, given the occurrence of functional compensation by related
proteins in biological systems we cannot exclude the possibility that sporadic loss
of p16 during tumor evolution is sufficient to circumvent senescence. Nevertheless,
mutations or epigenetic modifications affecting the p16 gene are
not common in ALCL [48]. In contrast, the Rb gene is frequently
mutated or the encoded protein hyperphosphorylated (and therefore inactive) in
ALK+ ALCL [34]. Consistent with this observation, we found that acute
mutation of Rb, which mimics sporadic mutation and limits
functional compensation by the Rb-related proteins p107 and p130, circumvents
NPM-ALK-induced senescence. We propose that loss of Rb function in the evolution of
NPM-ALK+ ALCL may be sufficient to counteract NPM-ALK-induced
activation of cell-cycle checkpoints, permitting unabated and unchecked progress
through the cell cycle. In this manner the likelihood of acquiring additional
mutations necessary for full-blown or more aggressive malignancy, such as those
affecting p53 function, may be enhanced.Whilst MEFs do not represent the physiological target of NPM-ALK in lymphomagenesis
(indeed, the ALCL cell of origin remains unknown), this work has highlighted the
potential existence of tumor-suppressive barriers during the development of ALCL.
Moreover, given that the transforming activity of NPM-ALK seems to be confined to
the ALK portion of the protein through activation of the kinase domain [17], this work
also raises the possibility that p53 and/or Rb activation followed by cell-cycle
arrest may constitute a more wide-spread phenomenon in the genesis of other cancers
in which ALK is aberrantly activated. It furthermore provides a rationale to explore
senescence induction as a potential therapeutic strategy in ALK-driven cancers.
Materials and Methods
Cells
MEFs (derived from E12.5-E13.5 embryos) and Phoenix cells were cultured in
Dulbecco's Modified Eagles Medium (DMEM) containing 4500 mg/L D-Glucose and
110 mg/L Sodium Pyruvate (Sigma-Aldrich), 10% fetal calf serum (FCS;
Invitrogen, Paisley, UK), 2 mM L-glutamine (Invitrogen) and 1% Penicillin
and Streptomycin (Gibco, Scotland, UK). MEFs were utilized at passage 1–2.
cRb and
p16MEFs were kindly provided
by Prof. Julien Sage (Stanford University, CA) and Prof. Pier Giuseppe Pelicci
(European Institute of Oncology, Milan, Italy) respectively.
Antibodies
Cyclin B1 (V152) and MDM2 (ser166) antibodies were purchased from Cell Signaling
Technologies (Danvers, MA); Cyclin A, α-tubulin and β-actin from
Sigma-Aldrich (Poole, UK); p19 (5-C3-1), p21 (F-5) and MDM2 (SMP14) from Santa
Cruz (Heidelberg, Germany); p53 (CM5) from Novocastra (Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, UK);
Rb (G3-245) from BD Biosciences (Oxford, UK); ALK from Zymed (San
Francisco).
Inhibitors
MEFs were treated with 10 µM of a racemic mixture of the MDM2 antagonists,
Nutlin-3a and Nutlin-3b (Calbiochem), for the indicated periods at
37°C/5% CO2.
Plasmids
HumanNPM-ALK cDNA was cloned into the Murine Stem Cell Virus (MSCV) puro vector.
MSCVpuroK210R was generated via site-directed mutagenesis of
MSCVpuroNPM-ALK using a site-directed mutagenesis kit (Stratagene, Cheshire,
UK), following the manufacturer's protocol. Primer pairs K210R_Forward
5′-CCCTGCAAGTGGCTGTGAGGACGCTGCCTGAAGTGTTGC-3′
and K210R_Reverse 5′-GCAACACTTCAGGCAGCGTCCTCACAGCCACTTGCAGGG-3′
were used. GSE56 was cut from pL56-RAS (a gift from Dr Andrei Gudkov, Roswell
Park Cancer Institute, NY) and ligated into MSCVneo. pBabepuroH-Ras V12 was a
gift from Dr Masashi Narita (Cambridge Research Institute, UK).
Retroviral and adenoviral infection of MEFs
Phoenix cells were transfected with the indicated plasmid vector(s) and a murine
packaging “helper” construct, ϕ, using Fugene transfection
reagent (Roche, West Sussex, UK) following the manufacturer's protocol. At
48 hours post-transfection, the virus-containing media was harvested from the
phoenix cells, filtered through a 0.45 µm filter, supplemented with 4
µg/ml polybrene (Sigma-Aldrich) and used to infect
8×105–1.2×106 MEFs in a 10 cm dish
at 32°C/5% CO2. MEFs were selected in 2 µg/ml
puromycin (Sigma-Aldrich) 48 hours post-infection for 2–3 days or 300
µg/ml geneticin (Gibco) for 7–10 days.Adenovirus expressing recombinant Cre-recombinase from a CMV promoter (AdCre) and
insert-free adenovirus control (AdEmpty) were purchased from the Gene Transfer
Vector Core, University of Iowa, IA. Virus (5 µl) was added to
8×105–1.2×106 Cre-responsive MEFs
seeded into a 10 cm tissue-culture dish in 10 ml complete media, followed by
incubation at 37°C/5% CO2 for 72 hours. A second round of
infection was performed 16–24 hours later.
Western blot analysis
Western blot was performed as previously described (32), using RIPA buffer (50 mM
Tris-HCl, pH 7.4; 1% NP-40; 0.25% Na-deoxycholate; 150 mM NaCl;
0.1% Sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS); 1 mM Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid
(EDTA); 1 mM Phenylmethylsulphonyl fluoride (PMSF); 2 mM
Na3VO4; 20 mM NaF; and protease inhibitor cocktail
tablet (Roche)) to lyse the cells.
Proliferation assays
Crystal violet assays were performed by seeding MEFs into 12-well plates at a
density of 2.5×104 cells/well (in triplicate) which were fixed
following incubation for the indicated times with 1% glutaraldehyde
(Sigma-Aldrich) in PBS. Cells were washed with PBS, stained with 0.1%
crystal violet (Sigma-Aldrich) for 30 minutes and crystal violet extracted with
10% (v/v) acetic acid (Sigma-Aldrich) in distilled water. The OD at 590
nm was measured with a 1420 Multilabel VICTOR3 plate reader (PerkinElmer,
MA).A 3T3 assay was performed according to the protocol of Todaro and Green [49]. In brief,
cells were passaged every 3 days at 1.2×106 cells in 10 cm
plates even in the absence of growth between passages. If the cell number
declined, cells were maintained at an equivalent density by seeding at
3×105 in a 5 cm plate or at 1×105 in a 3.5
cm plate. Population doubling was calculated using the
equation:Nf is the final cell number counted after 3 days, and Ni is
the initial cell number seeded.
Apoptosis
Cells were washed twice in cold PBS followed by resuspension in binding buffer
(0.01 M 4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulfonic acid [HEPES],
0.14 M NaCl and 2.5 mM CaCl2). The cells were incubated with 5
µl APC-conjugated Annexin V antibody (BD Biosciences) and 5 µg/ml PI
at room temperature in the dark for 15 minutes before analysis on a FACSCalibur
cytometer (BD Biosciences). Data were analyzed using FlowJo software (TreeStar,
Ashland, OR).
Cell-cycle analysis
1×106 cells in 10 cm dishes were incubated with 10 µM BrdU
for 4 hours followed by fixation with 70% ice-cold ethanol/30%
PBS. Cells were washed twice in PBS, resuspended in 500 µl 2 M HCl and
incubated for 20 minutes at RT, then rinsed twice in wash buffer (0.5%
bovine serum albumin [BSA, Sigma-Aldrich] in PBS). A 0.1 M solution of
sodium borate (500 µl) (Sigma-Aldrich) was then added followed by
incubation at room temperature for 2 minutes, followed by 2 rinses in wash
buffer. Cells were resuspended in 20 µl fluorescein isothiocyanate
(FITC)-conjugated mouse anti-BrdU monoclonal antibody (BD Biosciences) and
incubated for 20 minutes in the dark. Cells were then washed twice and
resuspended in 500 µl PBS, 0.1 mg/ml RNase A (Sigma-Aldrich), 0.4 mg/ml PI
(Sigma-Aldrich) and incubated at 37°C for 30 minutes. Cells were then passed
several times through a 25-gauge needle and analyzed on a FACSCalibur cytometer
(BD Biosciences). A minimum of 20,000 events were collected per sample and the
data analyzed using FlowJo software.
SA-β-Gal assay
2.5×104 cells/well of a 12-well plate (in triplicate) were fixed
with 0.5% glutaraldehyde for 15 minutes at RT. Cells were washed twice in
1 M MgCl2 (Sigma-Aldrich) in PBS, pH5.5 and incubated in 1 ml of
X-Gal staining solution (1 mg/ml X-gal [Sigma-Aldrich], 0.12 mM
K3Fe[CN]6, 0.12 mM
K4Fe[CN]6, 1 mM MgCl2 in PBS at
pH5.5) overnight at 37°C. The cells were washed 3 times in dH2O
and images captured with a Leica D-LUX 3 camera mounted onto a Labovert
microscope at ×100 magnification. The percentage of cells staining
positive (blue color) for β-galactosidase activity was determined by
counting the cells by eye at ×40 magnification. At least 200 cells were
counted per well.
Mice
CD2/NPM-ALKtransgenic mice were produced as detailed in [30]. The
p53mice were kindly provided
by Prof. Terry Rabbitts, Leeds Institute for Molecular Medicine, UK and were
bred on a C57/BL6 background. All mice were housed under spf conditions at the
University of Cambridge in accordance with UK Home Office guidelines. The
genotypes of the mice were determined as described in [30] and [50], except that the primer
directed against the neo cassette in the latter case had the sequence
5′-TCC TCG TGC TTT ACG GTA
TC-3′. The Kaplan-Meier curve and log-rank test were
generated in MedCalc.
Statistical analysis
Data were analyzed using a Student's two-tailed T test (assuming equal
variance). Data were considered significant when p values were less than
.05.NPM-ALK does not induce apoptosis. Annexin V versus PI staining
of day 4 primary MEFs followed by FACS analysis demonstrates that NPM-ALK
does not induce apoptosis relative to vector-control MEFs. Results are
representative of 3 independent experiments. At least 10,000 events were
collected for each genotype.(TIF)Click here for additional data file.Ablation of Rb in NPM-ALK-expressing MEFs. (A) Western Blot
analysis of Rb and NPM-ALK expression in early passage
cRb MEFs infected with
Cre-recombinase-expressing (+) or Cre-recombinase-deficient Adenovirus
(−) for 72 hours, followed by infection with vector-only or
NPM-ALK-encoding retrovirus for 48 hours. (B)
Experimental design and time-frame for assays using
cRb MEFs.(TIF)Click here for additional data file.
Authors: J Sage; G J Mulligan; L D Attardi; A Miller; S Chen; B Williams; E Theodorou; T Jacks Journal: Genes Dev Date: 2000-12-01 Impact factor: 11.361
Authors: B Maes; V Vanhentenrijk; I Wlodarska; J Cools; B Peeters; P Marynen; C de Wolf-Peeters Journal: Am J Pathol Date: 2001-06 Impact factor: 4.307
Authors: B Lawrence; A Perez-Atayde; M K Hibbard; B P Rubin; P Dal Cin; J L Pinkus; G S Pinkus; S Xiao; E S Yi; C D Fletcher; J A Fletcher Journal: Am J Pathol Date: 2000-08 Impact factor: 4.307