Exploring the ion selectivity properties of a large number of simplified binding site models.

The ability to discriminate between different cations efficiently is essential for the proper physiological functioning of many membrane transport proteins. One obvious mechanism of ion selectivity is when a binding site is structurally constrained by the protein architecture and its geometry is precisely adapted to fit an ion of a given size. This mechanism is not effective in the case of flexible protein binding sites that are able to deform structurally or to adapt to a bound ion. In this study, the concept of nontrivial ion selectivity arising in a highly flexible protein binding site conceptually represented as a microdroplet of ligands confined to a small volume is explored. The environment imposed by the spatial confinement is a critical feature of the reduced models. A large number of reduced binding site models (1077) comprising typical ion-coordinating ligands (carbonyl, hydroxyl, carboxylate, water) are constructed and characterized for Na(+)/K(+) and Ca(2+)/Ba(2+) size selectivity using free energy perturbation molecular dynamics simulations. Free energies are highly correlated with the sum of ion-ligand and ligand-ligand mean interactions, but the relative balance of those two contributions is different for K(+)-selective and Na(+)-selective binding sites. The analysis indicates that both the number and the type of ligands are important factors in ion selectivity. (c) 2010 Biophysical Society. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.