BACKGROUND: The 2009 influenza A (H1N1) pandemic has required decision-makers to act in the face of substantial uncertainties. Simulation models can be used to project the effectiveness of mitigation strategies, but the choice of the best scenario may change depending on model assumptions and uncertainties. METHODS: We developed a simulation model of a pandemic (H1N1) 2009 outbreak in a structured population using demographic data from a medium-sized city in Ontario and epidemiologic influenza pandemic data. We projected the attack rate under different combinations of vaccination, school closure and antiviral drug strategies (with corresponding "trigger" conditions). To assess the impact of epidemiologic and program uncertainty, we used "combinatorial uncertainty analysis." This permitted us to identify the general features of public health response programs that resulted in the lowest attack rates. RESULTS: Delays in vaccination of 30 days or more reduced the effectiveness of vaccination in lowering the attack rate. However, pre-existing immunity in 15% or more of the population kept the attack rates low, even if the whole population was not vaccinated or vaccination was delayed. School closure was effective in reducing the attack rate, especially if applied early in the outbreak, but this is not necessary if vaccine is available early or if pre-existing immunity is strong. INTERPRETATION: Early action, especially rapid vaccine deployment, is disproportionately effective in reducing the attack rate. This finding is particularly important given the early appearance of pandemic (H1N1) 2009 in many schools in September 2009.
BACKGROUND: The 2009 influenza A (H1N1) pandemic has required decision-makers to act in the face of substantial uncertainties. Simulation models can be used to project the effectiveness of mitigation strategies, but the choice of the best scenario may change depending on model assumptions and uncertainties. METHODS: We developed a simulation model of a pandemic (H1N1) 2009 outbreak in a structured population using demographic data from a medium-sized city in Ontario and epidemiologic influenza pandemic data. We projected the attack rate under different combinations of vaccination, school closure and antiviral drug strategies (with corresponding "trigger" conditions). To assess the impact of epidemiologic and program uncertainty, we used "combinatorial uncertainty analysis." This permitted us to identify the general features of public health response programs that resulted in the lowest attack rates. RESULTS: Delays in vaccination of 30 days or more reduced the effectiveness of vaccination in lowering the attack rate. However, pre-existing immunity in 15% or more of the population kept the attack rates low, even if the whole population was not vaccinated or vaccination was delayed. School closure was effective in reducing the attack rate, especially if applied early in the outbreak, but this is not necessary if vaccine is available early or if pre-existing immunity is strong. INTERPRETATION: Early action, especially rapid vaccine deployment, is disproportionately effective in reducing the attack rate. This finding is particularly important given the early appearance of pandemic (H1N1) 2009 in many schools in September 2009.
Authors: Neil M Ferguson; Derek A T Cummings; Simon Cauchemez; Christophe Fraser; Steven Riley; Aronrag Meeyai; Sopon Iamsirithaworn; Donald S Burke Journal: Nature Date: 2005-08-03 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: R J Whitley; F G Hayden; K S Reisinger; N Young; R Dutkowski; D Ipe; R G Mills; P Ward Journal: Pediatr Infect Dis J Date: 2001-02 Impact factor: 2.129
Authors: J J Treanor; F G Hayden; P S Vrooman; R Barbarash; R Bettis; D Riff; S Singh; N Kinnersley; P Ward; R G Mills Journal: JAMA Date: 2000-02-23 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Joël Mossong; Niel Hens; Mark Jit; Philippe Beutels; Kari Auranen; Rafael Mikolajczyk; Marco Massari; Stefania Salmaso; Gianpaolo Scalia Tomba; Jacco Wallinga; Janneke Heijne; Malgorzata Sadkowska-Todys; Magdalena Rosinska; W John Edmunds Journal: PLoS Med Date: 2008-03-25 Impact factor: 11.069
Authors: Ashleigh R Tuite; Amy L Greer; Michael Whelan; Anne-Luise Winter; Brenda Lee; Ping Yan; Jianhong Wu; Seyed Moghadas; David Buckeridge; Babak Pourbohloul; David N Fisman Journal: CMAJ Date: 2009-12-03 Impact factor: 8.262
Authors: Eve Dubé; Vladimir Gilca; Chantal Sauvageau; Nicole Boulianne; François D Boucher; Julie A Bettinger; Shelly McNeil; Ian Gemmill; France Lavoie; Manale Ouakki Journal: BMC Res Notes Date: 2010-04-14
Authors: Beate Sander; Chris Bauch; David N Fisman; R Fowler; Jeffrey C Kwong; Allison McGeer; Marija Zivkovic Gojovic; Murray Krahn Journal: PLoS Curr Date: 2009-12-17