BACKGROUND: Advance directives promise to preserve patient autonomy, but research indicates that end-of-life preferences can be influenced by the way in which questions are posed. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether preferences expressed by geriatric patients on advance directives are influenced by the default response inherent in the question. DESIGN: Mailed survey containing 1 of 3 versions of an advance directive. SETTING: General internal medicine outpatient medical practice. PARTICIPANTS: Outpatients aged 65 or older (n = 106, response rate = 27%). INTERVENTIONS: In the "withhold" version of the survey, participants indicated situations where they would want treatments withheld (i.e., the default preference was in favor of treatment). In the "provide" version, participants indicated situations where they would want treatment provided (i.e., the default preference was against treatment). In the forced-choice control version, participants made an explicit decision to withhold or provide treatment for each situation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Participants' treatment preferences. RESULTS: Preferences differed by condition, F(2, 103) = 3.61, MSE = 0.09, eta2 = .07, p = .03. Participants tended to express the default preference, and thus, were more likely to favor treatment in the "withhold" condition than in the "provide" condition. Preferences in the forced-choice control condition were intermediate. CONCLUSIONS: The default inherent in a question can impact preferences for medical treatment. This default effect limits the utility of advance directives.
BACKGROUND: Advance directives promise to preserve patient autonomy, but research indicates that end-of-life preferences can be influenced by the way in which questions are posed. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether preferences expressed by geriatric patients on advance directives are influenced by the default response inherent in the question. DESIGN: Mailed survey containing 1 of 3 versions of an advance directive. SETTING: General internal medicine outpatient medical practice. PARTICIPANTS: Outpatients aged 65 or older (n = 106, response rate = 27%). INTERVENTIONS: In the "withhold" version of the survey, participants indicated situations where they would want treatments withheld (i.e., the default preference was in favor of treatment). In the "provide" version, participants indicated situations where they would want treatment provided (i.e., the default preference was against treatment). In the forced-choice control version, participants made an explicit decision to withhold or provide treatment for each situation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Participants' treatment preferences. RESULTS: Preferences differed by condition, F(2, 103) = 3.61, MSE = 0.09, eta2 = .07, p = .03. Participants tended to express the default preference, and thus, were more likely to favor treatment in the "withhold" condition than in the "provide" condition. Preferences in the forced-choice control condition were intermediate. CONCLUSIONS: The default inherent in a question can impact preferences for medical treatment. This default effect limits the utility of advance directives.
Authors: P H Ditto; J H Danks; W D Smucker; J Bookwala; K M Coppola; R Dresser; A Fagerlin; R M Gready; R M Houts; L K Lockhart; S Zyzanski Journal: Arch Intern Med Date: 2001-02-12
Authors: Scott D Halpern; George Loewenstein; Kevin G Volpp; Elizabeth Cooney; Kelly Vranas; Caroline M Quill; Mary S McKenzie; Michael O Harhay; Nicole B Gabler; Tatiana Silva; Robert Arnold; Derek C Angus; Cindy Bryce Journal: Health Aff (Millwood) Date: 2013-02 Impact factor: 6.301