In the platelet, it is well established that many G-protein- and tyrosine kinase-coupled receptors stimulate phospholipase-C-dependent Ca(2+) mobilization; however, the extent to which secondary activation of adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP)-gated P2X(1) receptors contributes to intracellular Ca(2+) responses remains unclear. We now show that selective inhibition of P2X(1) receptors substantially reduces the [Ca(2+)](i) increase evoked by several important agonists in human platelets; for collagen, thromboxane A(2), thrombin, and adenosine 5'-diphoshate (ADP) the maximal effect was a reduction to 18%, 34%, 52%, and 69% of control, respectively. The direct contribution of P2X(1) to the secondary Ca(2+) response was far greater than that of either P2Y receptors activated by co-released ADP, or via synergistic P2X(1):P2Y interactions. The relative contribution of P2X(1) to the peak Ca(2+) increase varied with the strength of the initial stimulus, being greater at low compared to high levels of stimulation for both glycoprotein VI and PAR-1, whereas P2X(1) contributed equally at both low and high levels of stimulation of thromboxane A(2) receptors. In contrast, only strong stimulation of P2Y receptors resulted in significant P2X(1) receptor activation. ATP release was detected by soluble luciferin:luciferase in response to all agonists that stimulated secondary P2X(1) receptor activation. However, P2X(1) receptors were stimulated earlier and to a greater extent than predicted from the average ATP release, which can be accounted for by a predominantly autocrine mechanism of activation. Given the central role of [Ca(2+)](i) increases in platelet activation, these studies indicate that ATP should be considered alongside ADP and thromboxane A(2) as a significant secondary platelet agonist.
In the platelet, it is well established that many G-protein- and tyrosine kinase-coupled receptors stimulate phospholipase-C-dependent Ca(2+) mobilization; however, the extent to which secondary activation of adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP)-gated P2X(1) receptors contributes to intracellular Ca(2+) responses remains unclear. We now show that selective inhibition of P2X(1) receptors substantially reduces the [Ca(2+)](i) increase evoked by several important agonists in human platelets; for collagen, thromboxane A(2), thrombin, and adenosine 5'-diphoshate (ADP) the maximal effect was a reduction to 18%, 34%, 52%, and 69% of control, respectively. The direct contribution of P2X(1) to the secondary Ca(2+) response was far greater than that of either P2Y receptors activated by co-released ADP, or via synergistic P2X(1):P2Y interactions. The relative contribution of P2X(1) to the peak Ca(2+) increase varied with the strength of the initial stimulus, being greater at low compared to high levels of stimulation for both glycoprotein VI and PAR-1, whereas P2X(1) contributed equally at both low and high levels of stimulation of thromboxane A(2) receptors. In contrast, only strong stimulation of P2Y receptors resulted in significant P2X(1) receptor activation. ATP release was detected by soluble luciferin:luciferase in response to all agonists that stimulated secondary P2X(1) receptor activation. However, P2X(1) receptors were stimulated earlier and to a greater extent than predicted from the average ATP release, which can be accounted for by a predominantly autocrine mechanism of activation. Given the central role of [Ca(2+)](i) increases in platelet activation, these studies indicate that ATP should be considered alongside ADP and thromboxane A(2) as a significant secondary platelet agonist.
Platelets express three receptors gated by extracellular nucleotides: P2X1, P2Y1, and P2Y12 [1,2]. P2X receptors are Ca2+-permeable ligand-gated non-selective cation channels, whereas P2Y receptors are seven transmembrane domain receptors that couple to cellular responses via the activation of heterotrimeric G-proteins [3]. Although adenosine 5′-diphoshate (ADP) was initially believed to act at all three human platelet P2 receptors, it is now clear that ADP and adenosine 5′-triphosphate (ATP) are selective physiological agonists at the platelet P2Y and P2X1 receptors, respectively [4]. The important role that P2Y1 and P2Y12 receptors play during hemostasis and thrombosis is well established [5,6]. In contrast, the relevance of P2X1 receptors to platelet function has been questioned because they rapidly desensitize [4] and their selective activation in vitro evokes a transient shape change without significant aggregation [7]. However, murine models demonstrate an important contribution of this ATP-gated non-selective cation channel to thrombosis, particularly in small arteries [8,9]. One explanation for the major contribution of P2X1 to platelet activation in vivo is that ATP released from dense granules contributes to signaling events following initial stimulation by other agonists. In support of this, human and murine studies have shown a role for P2X1 in the aggregation responses to low doses of collagen and thrombin [8,10,11]. Whilst much work has been conducted to characterize P2X1 involvement in downstream platelet function, the extent to which P2X1 acts independently or in synergy with other secondary mediators during the early stages of platelet activation remains unclear. In the present study, we have used measurements of the key platelet second messenger, intracellular Ca2+ ([Ca2+]i), to examine the relative importance of P2X1 receptors alone and in combination with P2Y receptors in the initial responses to a number of major agonists.
Methods
Preparation of platelet suspensions
Fura-2-loaded washed suspensions of human platelets from informed, consenting donors were prepared using acid citrate dextrose anticoagulant and treated with aspirin (100 μm) and type VII apyrase (0.32 U mL−1) as described elsewhere [7]. The study was approved by the University of Cambridge Human Biology Research Ethics Committee. Platelets were resuspended in nominally Ca2+-free saline (in mm: 145 NaCl, 5 KCl, 1 MgCl2, 10 HEPES, 10 glucose, titrated to pH 7.35 with NaOH) with type VII apyrase (0.32 U mL−1). 2 mm CaCl2 or 2 mm MgCl2 was added to the cuvette 30 s prior to the agonist for studies in the presence and absence of external Ca2+, respectively.
[Ca2+]i measurements
Fura-2 ratiometric fluorescence measurements were conducted at 37 °C in a Cairn spectrofluorimeter system (Cairn Research Limited, Faversham, Kent, UK) and converted to [Ca2+]i as described elsewhere using a dissociation constant for Ca2+ of 224 nm [7].
Reagents
Collagen type I, as a suspension of native fibers from bovine tendon, was the gift of Ethicon Corporation (Somerville, NJ, USA). Collagen-related peptide (CRP) with the sequence H–GPC–(GPO)10–GPCG–NH2 was prepared and cross-linked as described by Morton et al. [12]. ADP was treated with hexokinase as described previously [13] and ATP levels assessed by bioluminescent measurements (ATP Assay Kit, Calbiochem-Novabiochem UK Ltd, Nottingham, UK, or Chromo-lume Kit, Labmedics, Manchester, UK) using a Model 400 lumi-aggregometer (Chrono-log Corporation, Havertown, PA, USA). U46619 and thapsigargin were from Calbiochem-Novabiochem UK Ltd. Cangrelor (AR-C69931MX) was a kind donation from AstraZeneca (Moindal, Sweden). All other reagents, including thrombin receptor activating peptide (TRAP) specific for PAR1, ADP, α,β-meATP, NF449 and MRS2179 were from Sigma-Aldrich (Poole, UK).
Luminescence measurement of ATP secretion
ATP secretion from washed platelet suspensions was measured in a Model 400 lumi-aggregometer as above, following the kit manufacturer’s guidelines. The luminescence channel output was amplified tenfold before acquisition to computer. Platelets used in luminescence studies were loaded with fura-2 to provide parallel measurements of ATP secretion and [Ca2+]i under closely matched conditions. 600 nmα,β-meATP did not interfere with the luciferin-luciferase assay for ATP (Chen, Fung, and Mahaut-Smith, unpublished observations).
Analysis
Sample records of [Ca2+]i are representative of experiments from ≥ four separate donors. The magnitude of Ca2+ responses was assessed from the peak increase above prestimulus level. Average values represent the mean ± SEM, with statistical analysis performed using Student’s paired t-test. Significance is indicated at levels of 0.05 (*), 0.01 (**), 0.005 (***), and 0.001 (****).
Results
Conditions for maximal, selective inhibition of individual platelet P2 receptor subtypes
To assess the relative contribution of the three platelet P2 receptors to [Ca2+]i responses, we first derived conditions that provide maximal block, but with strict limits on selectivity. Thus, whilst 3 μm was the minimum concentration of the suramin derivative NF449 [14] required to completely block P2X1 receptor-evoked Ca2+ influx, it also significantly reduced the ADP (1 μm)-evoked Ca2+ release via P2Y receptors to 83 ± 4% of control (Fig. 1). However, 1 μm NF449 had no significant effect on ADP-evoked Ca2+ release, yet still reduced the peak response via P2X1 receptors to 11 ± 2% of control (Fig. 1B,D). In comparison, P2Y responses to 10 μm ADP were reduced to negligible levels (0.3 ± 0.2%) by 30 μm MRS2179 (Fig. 1C,D), a concentration which has no effect at P2Y12 receptors [15] or P2X1 responses (Fig. 1B). Higher concentrations of MRS2179 were not employed as they started to inhibit P2X1 receptors (Fung, unpublished observations). However, 30 μm MRS2179 can be considered as an effective blocker of most, if not all secondary Ca2+ responses via P2Y receptors as maximal local extracellular concentrations of ADP are likely to be in the range 10–20 μm. This estimation is based upon the surface-attached luciferase measurements of ATP by Beigi et al. [16], and the fact that ATP and ADP are stored at equal concentrations in the dense granules of human platelets [17]. Because 1 μm cangrelor also had no significant effect on P2X1 (Fig. 1B), but maximally inhibits P2Y12 receptor responses [18] without affecting P2Y1 receptors [19], these results establish that 1 μm NF449, 1 μm cangrelor and 30 μm MRS2179 provide maximal, selective antagonism of P2X1, P2Y12 and P2Y1 receptors, respectively. An additional means to selectively inhibit P2X1 receptor Ca2+ influx is desensitization in Ca2+-free medium with α,β-meATP [10,20], which at 600 nm completely abolished P2X1 receptor-evoked Ca2+ increases without influencing ADP-evoked Ca2+ responses (Fig. 1B,D).
Fig. 1
Conditions for maximal, selective inhibition of P2X1 receptors. Effect of different P2 receptor antagonists or pre-addition of α,β-meATP on [Ca2]i responses via P2X1 receptors (A,B, 10 μmα,β-meATP in saline with 2 mm Ca2+) or P2Y receptors (C,D, hexokinase-treated ADP in nominally Ca2+-free saline; 10 μm ADP for MRS 2179, 1 μm ADP for other compounds). (A), (C) Representative recordings. (B), (D) Average peak responses, as percentage of paired controls. 600 nmα,β-meATP was added 90 s prior to the test agonist. In all figures, the asterisks above each bar indicate the ‘P-value’ relative to the paired control; ns, not significant; α,β, α,β-meATP; MRS, MRS 2179; CNG, cangrelor.
Conditions for maximal, selective inhibition of P2X1 receptors. Effect of different P2 receptor antagonists or pre-addition of α,β-meATP on [Ca2]i responses via P2X1 receptors (A,B, 10 μmα,β-meATP in saline with 2 mm Ca2+) or P2Y receptors (C,D, hexokinase-treated ADP in nominally Ca2+-free saline; 10 μm ADP for MRS 2179, 1 μm ADP for other compounds). (A), (C) Representative recordings. (B), (D) Average peak responses, as percentage of paired controls. 600 nmα,β-meATP was added 90 s prior to the test agonist. In all figures, the asterisks above each bar indicate the ‘P-value’ relative to the paired control; ns, not significant; α,β, α,β-meATP; MRS, MRS 2179; CNG, cangrelor.
The major role of P2X1 receptors in collagen-evoked Ca2+ increases does not require co-activation of P2Y receptors and principally involves glycoprotein VI
Selective inhibition of P2X1 receptors with 1 μm NF449 caused a large reduction of the Ca2+ responses stimulated by a low dose of collagen (0.5 μg mL−1; Fig. 2A). The peak was reduced to 18 ± 2% (P < 0.05) of control, similar to the effect of P2X1 desensitization with 600 nmα,β-meATP (reduction to 25 ± 9% of control; Fig. 2E). Importantly, this confirms that α,β-meATP predesensitization has equivalent effects to simple direct blockade with NF449, and desensitization was used as a preferred tool as it permitted greater selective reduction of P2X1 receptor signals. The contribution of P2X1 receptors to collagen-evoked Ca2+ responses was far greater than that of P2Y receptors, as the response was reduced to only 78 ± 3%, 88 ± 10% and 80 ± 4%, respectively, for MRS2179, cangrelor and these two inhibitors combined. Combined blockade of P2X1 and either P2Y1 or both P2Y1 and P2Y12 receptors was not significantly different from block/desensitization of P2X1 alone (P > 0.05; Fig. 2E). Thus, we were unable to further explore possible synergy between P2X1 and P2Y receptors, as reported previously in the platelet [21]. However, this synergy may account for the lack of effect of MRS2179 on top of α,β-meATP despite a small but significant effect of MRS 2179 on its own.
Fig. 2
The major role of P2X1 in collagen-evoked Ca2+ signaling via glycoprotein (GP) VI does not rely upon co-activation of P2Y receptors. Representative (A–D, F) and average (E, G) [Ca2+]i responses to collagen (0.5 μg mL−1, A–E) or collagen-related peptide (CRP; 25 or 250 ng mL−1; F, G). Average responses are shown as the percentage of a paired control. Responses were studied in the presence and absence of α,β-meATP (600 nm, added 90 s prior to agonist), NF449 (1 μm), MRS 2179 (MRS, 30 μm) and cangrelor (CNG, 1 μm), or a combination of these blockers as shown, all added 60 s before agonist. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).
The major role of P2X1 in collagen-evoked Ca2+ signaling via glycoprotein (GP) VI does not rely upon co-activation of P2Y receptors. Representative (A–D, F) and average (E, G) [Ca2+]i responses to collagen (0.5 μg mL−1, A–E) or collagen-related peptide (CRP; 25 or 250 ng mL−1; F, G). Average responses are shown as the percentage of a paired control. Responses were studied in the presence and absence of α,β-meATP (600 nm, added 90 s prior to agonist), NF449 (1 μm), MRS 2179 (MRS, 30 μm) and cangrelor (CNG, 1 μm), or a combination of these blockers as shown, all added 60 s before agonist. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).Selective stimulation of glycoprotein (GP) VI with 25 ng mL−1 CRP [22] evoked a [Ca2+]i response comparable to 0.5 μg mL−1 collagen, which was reduced to 24 ± 5% of control by α,β-meATP pre-addition (Fig. 2F), similar to the effect of P2X1 inhibition on low collagen concentrations. As observed for collagen [20], the percentage contribution of P2X1 to GPVI-dependent signals was less at higher concentrations of CRP (for example α,β-meATP reduced the response to 200 ng mL−1 CRP to only 68 ± 4% of control; Fig. 2G). Together these data suggest that GPVI represents the receptor by which collagen stimulates secondary activation of P2X1 receptors.
P2X1 receptor inhibition by NF449, or desensitization by α,β-meATP, does not block other platelet Ca2+ entry pathways
Platelet G-protein-coupled or tyrosine kinase-linked receptors have been previously proposed to stimulate Ca2+ influx via store-dependent and store-independent pathways [23,24]. We have recently shown that NF449 and α,β-meATP do not affect platelet store-independent cation currents using direct electrophysiological measurements in the megakaryocyte [13]. To assess effects on store-dependent Ca2+ influx, intracellular Ca2+ stores were depleted for 5 min with 1 μm thapsigargin in Ca2+-free medium followed by addition of external Ca2+ (Fig. 3). Neither 600 nmα,β-meATP nor 1 μm NF449 had any significant effect on store-dependent Ca2+ influx as the time to reach [Ca2+]i levels of 500 or 1000 nm following Ca2+ re-addition were unaffected (Fig. 3A–D). The lack of effect of NF449 or α,β-meATP on the initial thapsigargin-evoked Ca2+ influx also confirms that these P2X1-inhibiting reagents do not substantially alter the platelet membrane potential. However, the later phase of the Ca2+ increase in these re-addition experiments was slightly attenuated or delayed by P2X1 receptor inhibition, although this was only significant for the peak response for α,β-meATP pre-addition (decrease to 89 ± 2% of control; P < 0.001) and the time to peak for 1 μm NF449 (increase to 167 ± 18% of control; P < 0.05). A reasonable explanation for these effects is that high levels of Ca2+ lead to ATP secretion [25], which amplifies/accelerates the peak Ca2+ response through P2X1 receptor activation in parallel to store-mediated Ca2+ entry.
Fig. 3
α,β-meATP and NF449 do not block store-dependent Ca2+ influx. Store-dependent Ca2+ influx was measured by addition of 2 mm Ca2+ after depletion of intracellular Ca2+ stores in nominally Ca2+-free saline with the endomembrane Ca2+-ATPase inhibitor, thapsigargin (1 μm). 5 min after thapsigargin treatment, 600 nmα,β-meATP, 1 μm NF449 or a water-vehicle control were added, followed a further 90 s later by 2 mm Ca2+. Representative traces are shown for α,β-meATP (A) and NF449 (B) with their paired control. The average rate of initial Ca2+ increase, as a direct measurement of store-dependent Ca2+ influx, was assessed as the time to 500 nm (C) or 1000 nm (D), while the overall response to Ca2+ re-addition was assessed from the peak increase (E) and time to peak (F).
α,β-meATP and NF449 do not block store-dependent Ca2+ influx. Store-dependent Ca2+ influx was measured by addition of 2 mm Ca2+ after depletion of intracellular Ca2+ stores in nominally Ca2+-free saline with the endomembrane Ca2+-ATPase inhibitor, thapsigargin (1 μm). 5 min after thapsigargin treatment, 600 nmα,β-meATP, 1 μm NF449 or a water-vehicle control were added, followed a further 90 s later by 2 mm Ca2+. Representative traces are shown for α,β-meATP (A) and NF449 (B) with their paired control. The average rate of initial Ca2+ increase, as a direct measurement of store-dependent Ca2+ influx, was assessed as the time to 500 nm (C) or 1000 nm (D), while the overall response to Ca2+ re-addition was assessed from the peak increase (E) and time to peak (F).
Role of P2X1 receptors in thrombin-evoked Ca2+-responses
We next assessed the importance of P2X1 receptors during responses to thrombin, the most potent known Ca2+-mobilizing platelet agonist. The concentration–response curve for thrombin (0.001–4.0 U mL−1) in our platelet preparation is shown in Fig. 4A. Desensitization of P2X1 receptors reduced the peak response to thrombin in a concentration-dependent manner, which was maximal at low to mid-range thrombin concentrations (0.01–0.03 U mL−1; see concentration–response relationship in Fig. 4B and sample records at 0.03 U mL−1 in Fig. 4C). In the absence of external Ca2+, α,β-meATP had no effect on the peak [Ca2+]i increase evoked by 0.03 U mL−1 thrombin (97 ± 2% of the control response; P > 0.05; data not shown), thus this nucleotide does not affect stored Ca2+ levels or thrombin receptors.
Fig. 4
P2X1 contributes to thrombin-evoked Ca2+ responses, particularly at low–mid-range levels of PAR receptor stimulation. (A) Dose–response curve for the peak thrombin-evoked Ca2+ increase; the data were fit by a logistic curve with an EC50 of 0.032 ± 0.009 U mL−1 and a slope of 1.63 ± 0.75. (B) Effect of P2X1 receptor inhibition (90 s pre-exposure to 600 nmα,β-meATP) on the peak thrombin-evoked Ca2+ increase across a range of thrombin concentrations. (C)–(F) Representative (C–E) and average (F) responses (as a percentage of a paired control) to 0.03 U mL−1 thrombin following treatment with 600 nmα,β-meATP, 1.0 µm NF449, 30 µm MRS2179 (MRS) and 1.0 μm cangrelor (CNG), individually or in combination. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).
P2X1 contributes to thrombin-evoked Ca2+ responses, particularly at low–mid-range levels of PAR receptor stimulation. (A) Dose–response curve for the peak thrombin-evoked Ca2+ increase; the data were fit by a logistic curve with an EC50 of 0.032 ± 0.009 U mL−1 and a slope of 1.63 ± 0.75. (B) Effect of P2X1 receptor inhibition (90 s pre-exposure to 600 nmα,β-meATP) on the peak thrombin-evoked Ca2+ increase across a range of thrombin concentrations. (C)–(F) Representative (C–E) and average (F) responses (as a percentage of a paired control) to 0.03 U mL−1 thrombin following treatment with 600 nmα,β-meATP, 1.0 µm NF449, 30 µm MRS2179 (MRS) and 1.0 μm cangrelor (CNG), individually or in combination. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).At a thrombin concentration close to the EC50 (0.03 U mL−1), no significant effect was observed for MRS2179 or cangrelor on the peak thrombin-evoked Ca2+ increase (96 ± 5% and 110 ± 10% of control, respectively; P > 0.05; Fig. 4D–F). This compares with reductions in peak Ca2+ responses to 52 ± 1% and 58 ± 10% of control with α,β-meATP and NF449, respectively. Furthermore, this contribution of P2X1 was not dependent upon interactions with P2Y receptors as α,β-meATP reduced thrombin-evoked Ca2+ increases to the same extent in the presence or absence of both MRS 2179 and cangrelor (P > 0.05; Fig. 4F). The receptor through which thrombin achieved P2X1 stimulation was mainly PAR-1 as the response to an EC50 concentration of TRAP specific for PAR-1 (10 μm) was reduced to 50 ± 6% of the control response by α,β-meATP (not shown), which is not significantly different to the effect of losing P2X1 receptor function during stimulation with 0.03 U mL−1 thrombin (P > 0.05).
Role of P2X1 during activation by the secondary agonists ADP and thromboxane A2
We also examined the role of P2X1 receptors in response to direct stimulation by thromboxane A2 and ADP, two further platelet agonists with important roles in hemostasis and thrombosis. The stable thromboxane A2 analogue, U46619, activated its full range of [Ca2+]i increases over only a narrow range of concentrations; consequently, small and large responses could be achieved with 0.5 and 1.0 μm U46619, respectively. Inhibition of P2X1 receptors caused a marked decrease in the peak [Ca2+]i increase at both these concentrations; peak responses to 1 and 0.5 μm U46619 were reduced to 42 ± 11% and 38 ± 4%, respectively, by 1 μm NF449 and 34 ± 7% and 35 ± 3%, respectively, after α,β-meATP (Fig. 5C,D). Block of P2Y receptors had only small effects on [Ca2+]i responses to U46619 and, as observed for collagen and thrombin, block of both P2X1 and P2Y receptors was not significantly different (P > 0.05) to the effect of P2X1 desensitization alone.
Fig. 5
P2X1 receptors contribute to thromboxane A2 receptor-evoked Ca2+ increases at both high and low levels of stimulation. Representative (A,B) and average (C,D) [Ca2+]i responses to the thromboxane A2 mimetic, U46619, at concentrations that evoke small (0.5 μm; A,C) and large (1 μm; B,D) peak [Ca2+]i responses. (A) and (B) show representative paired traces with and without 600 nmα,β-meATP (90 s exposure) to desensitize P2X1 receptors. (C) and (D) show average peak [Ca2+]i increases as a percentage of a paired control following treatment with 600 nmα,β-meATP, 1.0 µm NF449, 30 μm MRS2179 (MRS), 1.0 µm cangrelor (CNG), individually or in combination. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).
P2X1 receptors contribute to thromboxane A2 receptor-evoked Ca2+ increases at both high and low levels of stimulation. Representative (A,B) and average (C,D) [Ca2+]i responses to the thromboxane A2 mimetic, U46619, at concentrations that evoke small (0.5 μm; A,C) and large (1 μm; B,D) peak [Ca2+]i responses. (A) and (B) show representative paired traces with and without 600 nmα,β-meATP (90 s exposure) to desensitize P2X1 receptors. (C) and (D) show average peak [Ca2+]i increases as a percentage of a paired control following treatment with 600 nmα,β-meATP, 1.0 µm NF449, 30 μm MRS2179 (MRS), 1.0 µm cangrelor (CNG), individually or in combination. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).The role of P2X1 receptors in ADP-evoked responses is difficult to study because of contamination of commercial samples with ATP [26]; however, hexokinase treatment reduces the level of ATP to negligible levels (Fig. 6A). Desensitization of P2X1 receptors had no effect on the Ca2+ response to low concentrations of ATP-free ADP (1 μm, P > 0.05; Fig. 6B,D). However, maximal stimulation of P2Y receptors with 30 μm hexokinase-treated ADP generated a noticeable secondary phase of [Ca2+]i increase, which was abolished by α,β-meATP pre-addition (Fig. 6C). The secondary Ca2+ spike was variable between donors, and overall the average peak ADP-evoked Ca2+ increase was reduced to 69 ± 7% (P < 0.01). The secondary Ca2+ spike was not a result of direct activation of P2X1 receptors by contaminating ATP for two reasons. First, we estimate that the concentration of ATP in 30 μm hexokinase-treated ADP is less than 1 nm, a level that is unable to activate P2X1 receptors. Secondly, any direct P2X1 receptor activation would be rapid; yet the amplitude and rate of initial ADP-evoked Ca2+ increase was not altered by α,β-meATP pre-addition (Fig. 6C). Therefore, it is likely that 30 μm ADP stimulates P2X1 via release of ATP (see below).
Fig. 6
P2X1 receptors contribute to P2Y receptor-evoked Ca2+ responses only at high levels of stimulation. (A) ATP-dependent luminescence signal (from a luciferin:luciferase assay, in arbitrary units) following addition of 5 μm ATP, 100 μm commercial ADP (comm. ADP) and 1 mm ADP after treatment with hexokinase (hex-ADP). (B,C) Representative paired [Ca2+]i responses to 1 or 30 μm ADP (hexokinase-treated) in the presence or absence of 600 nmα,β-meATP (90 s, to desensitize P2X1 receptors). (D) Effect of P2X1 desensitization on peak ADP-evoked [Ca2+]i responses as a percentage of a paired control. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).
P2X1 receptors contribute to P2Y receptor-evoked Ca2+ responses only at high levels of stimulation. (A) ATP-dependent luminescence signal (from a luciferin:luciferase assay, in arbitrary units) following addition of 5 μm ATP, 100 μm commercial ADP (comm. ADP) and 1 mm ADP after treatment with hexokinase (hex-ADP). (B,C) Representative paired [Ca2+]i responses to 1 or 30 μm ADP (hexokinase-treated) in the presence or absence of 600 nmα,β-meATP (90 s, to desensitize P2X1 receptors). (D) Effect of P2X1 desensitization on peak ADP-evoked [Ca2+]i responses as a percentage of a paired control. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).
Early dense granule secretion generates only nanomolar levels of bulk phase ATP
To examine the relationship between ATP release and the time course of secondary P2X1 receptor activation, total ATP levels were measured using luciferin/luciferase added to washed platelet suspensions. Early ATP release was detected in response to 30 μm ADP but not in response to 1 μm ADP (Fig. 7A), which together with the data in Fig. 6 is consistent with a requirement for ATP release for P2X1 activation. Furthermore, early ATP release was observed in response to collagen, thrombin and U46619 at concentrations of these agonists that induce substantial P2X1 receptor activation (Fig. 7A). However, in all cases the early peak ATP increase was only 10–30 nm during the first 30 s, when P2X1 receptors played a major role in the [Ca2+]i increases. To examine the temporal relationship between secretion and Ca2+-mobilization, the P2X1-dependent Ca2+ response to 0.5 μg mL−1 collagen was derived from recordings in the presence and absence of α,β-meATP and compared to the percentage P2X1 receptor activation. The latter was calculated from the ATP concentration–response relationship of P2X1 receptors following complete inhibition of G-protein-coupled receptor Ca2+ responses with a prostacyclin concentration that has no effect on P2X1 receptors (Fung and Mahaut-Smith, unpublished observations; Fig. 7B). This temporal comparison shows that the average extracellular ATP concentration increases with a delayed time course relative to the P2X1-dependent Ca2+ increase. This difference can be accounted for by a predominantly autocrine mechanism of P2X1 receptor activation as ATP increases near the sites of granule release will be larger and more rapid than in the bulk phase.
Fig. 7
Comparison of average bulk phase ATP levels and intracellular Ca2+ responses following stimulation by multiple agonists; evidence for autocrine activation of P2X1 receptors. (A) Effect of collagen (0.5 μg mL−1), thrombin (0.03 U mL−1), U46619 (1 μm) and ADP (1 and 30 μm) on extracellular ATP levels measured using the luciferin–luciferase firefly assay. The peak luminescence signal for a range of known ATP concentrations was used to calibrate the agonist-evoked signals. (B) Superimposition of the P2X1-dependent Ca2+ increase and ATP secretion evoked by 0.5 μg mL−1 collagen. The dashed line corresponds to the peak contribution by P2X1, which occurs when the average extracellular ATP level is predicted to stimulate 10% of maximal P2X1 receptor activation. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).
Comparison of average bulk phase ATP levels and intracellular Ca2+ responses following stimulation by multiple agonists; evidence for autocrine activation of P2X1 receptors. (A) Effect of collagen (0.5 μg mL−1), thrombin (0.03 U mL−1), U46619 (1 μm) and ADP (1 and 30 μm) on extracellular ATP levels measured using the luciferin–luciferase firefly assay. The peak luminescence signal for a range of known ATP concentrations was used to calibrate the agonist-evoked signals. (B) Superimposition of the P2X1-dependent Ca2+ increase and ATP secretion evoked by 0.5 μg mL−1 collagen. The dashed line corresponds to the peak contribution by P2X1, which occurs when the average extracellular ATP level is predicted to stimulate 10% of maximal P2X1 receptor activation. All experiments were conducted in the presence of external Ca2+ (2 mm).
Discussion
An increase in [Ca2+]i is used by a wide range of platelet agonists as a key signal to activate downstream events. On its own, [Ca2+]i increases within the physiological range can activate most functional responses in the platelet including shape change, aggregation, secretion and procoagulant activity, although Ca2+-mobilization normally operates in tandem with other signaling pathways such as tyrosine kinases, PI 3-kinase and inhibition of cAMP production [25,27]. The central role of Ca2+ in hemostasis and thrombosis is demonstrated by the ability of cytosolic BAPTA (a Ca2+ chelator) to block or markedly inhibit a number of mainstream platelet responses such as inside-out activation of αIIbβ3, procoagulant activity and arachidonate production [28-30]. The present study shows, for the first time, that secondary activation of P2X1 receptors represents a major means by which both G-protein-coupled and tyrosine kinase-coupled receptors elevate [Ca2+]i independently of ADP-activated P2Y receptors. This enhancement of the initial Ca2+ responses may explain the previously reported ability of P2X1 receptors to potentiate aggregation at low levels of collagen and thrombin [8,10,11]. This general role of P2X1 receptors as a secondary Ca2+ influx pathway could also help explain the resistance to thrombosis displayed by P2X1−/− mice [8] and the enhanced thrombotic phenotype of mice overexpressing human P2X1 receptors [9].Platelet receptors coupled to phospholipase-C activation mobilize Ca2+ by a combination of IP3-dependent store release and influx across the plasma membrane [25]. The current view is that these influx pathways consist of ion channels activated by either intracellular Ca2+ store depletion (store-operated Ca2+ influx) or the products of PLC such as diacylglycerol (termed store-independent Ca2+ influx) [13,23,24]. We now show that P2X1 receptors should be considered as a significant additional contributor to early Ca2+ influx in the platelet following stimulation by agonists acting via G-protein-coupled receptors and tyrosine-kinase-coupled receptors.We have previously shown that P2X1 is able to potentiate the non-selective cation channel coupled to P2Y receptors in murine megakaryocytes and to accelerate and amplify the P2Y-evoked Ca2+ mobilization in suspensions of human platelets [21]. Although such synergy may exist when both P2X1 and P2Y receptors are active, the present study shows that P2X1 does not rely upon interactions with co-activated P2Y receptors to contribute as a secondary Ca2+-elevating pathway in the platelet. Serotonin release from dense granules also has little or no role in the Ca2+ responses in these experiments as a maximal concentration of serotonin (1 μm) evoked a Ca2+ increase of < 15 nm, and 100 nm methiothepin (a concentration that blocked responses to 1 μm serotonin) had no significant effect on the Ca2+ increase evoked by 1 μm U46619 (109.5 ± 13.2% of control; P > 0.05). A likely explanation for the important independent role of P2X1 is that the primary agonist already stimulates the phospholipase-C-dependent Ca2+ fluxes subsequently targeted by released ADP via P2Y receptors, whereas P2X1 receptor-cation channels represent a separate route for elevating Ca2+. In addition, we show that P2X1 receptors can be activated only when small total amounts of ATP are released, thus allowing this pathway to contribute at low levels of dense granule secretion. Moreover, our experiments were conducted in the presence of apyrase, indicating the ability of ATP to activate P2X1 receptors even in the presence of significant levels of ectonucleotidase activity. The rapid kinetics of P2X1 activation by its ligand [4] most likely account for its efficient activation even in the presence of ectonucleotides. However, this role for ATP should not reduce the well-established importance of other released compounds such as ADP and thromboxane A2. In particular, because P2X1 causes elevation of only Ca2+ (and Na+), stimulation of complementary signaling pathways by P2Y12 receptors remains crucial for collagen and thromboxaneA2 receptor-evoked aggregation [1,2].Two pieces of evidence suggest that secondary activation of P2X1 receptors occurs via an autocrine rather than a paracrine manner. First, the bulk phase ATP level when P2X1 maximally contributes is sufficient to activate less than 10% of P2X1 receptors (Fig. 7B). Secondly, P2X1 receptors contribute to the collagen-evoked Ca2+ increase earlier than the average extracellular ATP increases (Fig. 7B). These observations can be explained when it is considered that, following secretion, the extracellular ATP concentration at the plasma membrane surface will increase earlier, and be far greater in magnitude compared to the average level measured by soluble luciferin:luciferase. Localization of P2X1 receptors at sites of secretion may also explain how ATP release can so efficiently activate P2X1 receptors. Although there is no direct evidence for such localization at present, lipid rafts may play an important role as these microdomains in platelets contain both P2X1 receptors and SNARE proteins, and raft disruption leads to inhibition of P2X1 responses and exocytosis [31,32].In conclusion, we show that P2X1 receptors can represent a significant pathway for early Ca2+-mobilization following activation of a variety of major receptors linked through both G-proteins and tyrosine kinases in the platelet. Thus, P2X1 receptors should be considered alongside store-operated and store-independent channels as an important route for Ca2+ influx, and therefore to be a more significant potential antithrombotic target than previously recognized.
Authors: Patrick Andre; Suzanne M Delaney; Thomas LaRocca; Diana Vincent; Francis DeGuzman; Marzena Jurek; Beverley Koller; David R Phillips; Pamela B Conley Journal: J Clin Invest Date: 2003-08 Impact factor: 14.808
Authors: Gwen Tolhurst; Richard N Carter; Stefan Amisten; Jon P Holdich; David Erlinge; Martyn P Mahaut-Smith Journal: Platelets Date: 2008-06 Impact factor: 3.862
Authors: Junsong Zhou; Yi Wu; Lu Wang; Lubica Rauova; Vincent M Hayes; Mortimer Poncz; David W Essex Journal: J Clin Invest Date: 2015-11-03 Impact factor: 14.808
Authors: Sakthivel Vaiyapuri; Chris I Jones; Parvathy Sasikumar; Leonardo A Moraes; Stephanie J Munger; Joy R Wright; Marfoua S Ali; Tanya Sage; William J Kaiser; Katherine L Tucker; Christopher J Stain; Alexander P Bye; Sarah Jones; Ernesto Oviedo-Orta; Alexander M Simon; Martyn P Mahaut-Smith; Jonathan M Gibbins Journal: Circulation Date: 2012-04-23 Impact factor: 29.690
Authors: C Y Eleanor Fung; Sarah Jones; Adwoa Ntrakwah; Khalid M Naseem; Richard W Farndale; Martyn P Mahaut-Smith Journal: Blood Date: 2012-01-06 Impact factor: 22.113
Authors: Jaione Burzaco; Manuel Conde; Luis A Parada; José L Zugaza; Jean-Paul Dehaye; Aida Marino Journal: PLoS One Date: 2013-06-24 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Ulyana Lalo; Sarah Jones; Jonathan A Roberts; Martyn P Mahaut-Smith; Richard J Evans Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2012-07-31 Impact factor: 5.157