Francois Lemaire1. 1. Assistance Publique Hôp de Paris, Hôpital H. Mondor, Paris 12 University, Créteil, France. francois.lemaire@hmn.aphp.fr
Abstract
PURPOSE OF THE REVIEW: Emergency research is possible only if informed consent is waived. Recent legislations have specifically addressed this issue, both in the US and in Europe. RECENT FINDINGS: In the US, a specific regulation was enacted in 1996. Due to the added complexity, few trials have used this design. The necessity to inform the community in which a trial is supposed to take place, though feasible, is burdensome and time consuming. In the EU, directive 2001/20/CE forgot to specify particular rules for research in emergency conditions. After 2004, national legislations were supposed to implement the directive in order to enhance homogeneity within Europe, but actually showed an extreme diversity, with some countries allowing waiver of consent in emergency situations and others refusing it. SUMMARY: Due to the active lobbying of emergency and intensive care specialists, the situation is slowly improving, with most national legislations recognizing the specificities and difficulty of emergency research.
PURPOSE OF THE REVIEW: Emergency research is possible only if informed consent is waived. Recent legislations have specifically addressed this issue, both in the US and in Europe. RECENT FINDINGS: In the US, a specific regulation was enacted in 1996. Due to the added complexity, few trials have used this design. The necessity to inform the community in which a trial is supposed to take place, though feasible, is burdensome and time consuming. In the EU, directive 2001/20/CE forgot to specify particular rules for research in emergency conditions. After 2004, national legislations were supposed to implement the directive in order to enhance homogeneity within Europe, but actually showed an extreme diversity, with some countries allowing waiver of consent in emergency situations and others refusing it. SUMMARY: Due to the active lobbying of emergency and intensive care specialists, the situation is slowly improving, with most national legislations recognizing the specificities and difficulty of emergency research.
Authors: Chad G Ball; Francis Sutherland; Andrew W Kirkpatrick; Elijah Dixon; Anthony R Maclean; Lloyd A Mack; David V Feliciano; Ravi R Rajani; Riyad Karmy-Jones; W Donald Buie; Walley J Temple; Grace S Rozycki; Alan Simeone Journal: Can J Surg Date: 2010-10 Impact factor: 2.089
Authors: Osama O Zaidat; David S Liebeskind; Randall C Edgell; Catherine M Amlie-Lefond; Junaid S Kalia; Andrei V Alexandrov Journal: Neurology Date: 2012-09-25 Impact factor: 9.910
Authors: Anita Kurt; Hope M Kincaid; Charity Curtis; Lauren Semler; Matthew Meyers; Melanie Johnson; Beth A Careyva; Brian Stello; Timothy J Friel; Mark C Knouse; John C Smulian; Jeanne L Jacoby Journal: West J Emerg Med Date: 2017-07-17