BACKGROUND: Trust is an important indicator of quality in patient-provider relationships and predicts adherence to certain protective health behaviours. It has been relatively unexplored among low-income or minority women. OBJECTIVES: We explored health care experiences that influence patient trust among low-income women in the USA with respect to professionals and lay health workers (LHWs). METHODS: Focus groups were conducted with 33 prenatal and postpartum women, aged 18-45 years, recruited from community-based public prenatal care programmes. Focus groups were audio-recorded, transcribed, and independently coded by readers. A model of factors associated with trust was developed based on the major thematic categories. RESULTS: Most women were Black (67%) and had completed high school (85%). Factors related to greater trust specific to patient-provider relationships were: continuity of the patient-provider relationship, effective communication, demonstration of caring and perceived competence. Women with less trust in their physicians reported an unwillingness to follow his/her advice. Most women reported having more trusting relationships with LHWs and nurses than with physicians, probably due to greater contact with these staff. Several women with a low level of trust reported experiences of discrimination due to lack of insurance. CONCLUSIONS: Prenatal care presents a unique opportunity for providers to contribute to the elimination of health disparities among low-income women. Improving continuity with public health prenatal care providers and building strong relationships with LHWs may enhance quality of care and contribute to achieving this goal. Better patient-provider communication is also a practical area of focus towards improving patient trust.
BACKGROUND: Trust is an important indicator of quality in patient-provider relationships and predicts adherence to certain protective health behaviours. It has been relatively unexplored among low-income or minority women. OBJECTIVES: We explored health care experiences that influence patient trust among low-income women in the USA with respect to professionals and lay health workers (LHWs). METHODS: Focus groups were conducted with 33 prenatal and postpartum women, aged 18-45 years, recruited from community-based public prenatal care programmes. Focus groups were audio-recorded, transcribed, and independently coded by readers. A model of factors associated with trust was developed based on the major thematic categories. RESULTS: Most women were Black (67%) and had completed high school (85%). Factors related to greater trust specific to patient-provider relationships were: continuity of the patient-provider relationship, effective communication, demonstration of caring and perceived competence. Women with less trust in their physicians reported an unwillingness to follow his/her advice. Most women reported having more trusting relationships with LHWs and nurses than with physicians, probably due to greater contact with these staff. Several women with a low level of trust reported experiences of discrimination due to lack of insurance. CONCLUSIONS: Prenatal care presents a unique opportunity for providers to contribute to the elimination of health disparities among low-income women. Improving continuity with public health prenatal care providers and building strong relationships with LHWs may enhance quality of care and contribute to achieving this goal. Better patient-provider communication is also a practical area of focus towards improving patient trust.
Authors: Maia Ingram; Kerstin M Reinschmidt; Ken A Schachter; Chris L Davidson; Samantha J Sabo; Jill Guernsey De Zapien; Scott C Carvajal Journal: J Community Health Date: 2012-04
Authors: Scott D Rhodes; Facundo M Fernández; Jami S Leichliter; Aaron T Vissman; Stacy Duck; Mary Claire O'Brien; Cindy Miller; Aimee M Wilkin; Glenn A Harris; Dana M Hostetler; Fred R Bloom Journal: J Immigr Minor Health Date: 2011-12
Authors: Monica E Peek; Rita Gorawara-Bhat; Michael T Quinn; Angela Odoms-Young; Shannon C Wilson; Marshall H Chin Journal: Health Commun Date: 2012-10-10
Authors: Shelly-Ann Bowen; Edith M Williams; Chayah M Stoneberg-Cooper; Saundra H Glover; Michelle S Williams; Michael D Byrd Journal: Am J Health Promot Date: 2013 Mar-Apr
Authors: Kristi D Graves; Elmer Huerta; Jennifer Cullen; Elizabeth Kaufman; Vanessa Sheppard; George Luta; Claudine Isaacs; Marc D Schwartz; Jeanne Mandelblatt Journal: Cancer Causes Control Date: 2008-08-15 Impact factor: 2.506