R Chung1, Q Pham, L Wojtasik, V Chari, P Chen. 1. Department of Surgery, Huron Hospital, Cleveland Clinic Health System, 13951 Terrace Road, Cleveland, OH 44112, USA. rskchung@hotmail.com
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Although laparoscopic surgery has become widespread during the past decade, no systematic study of the training needs exists. To obtain guidance for planning, we analyzed the national resident operative experience during the past 8 years. METHODS: The laparoscopic experiences of all surgical residents graduating between 1994 and 2001 were subjected to regression analysis. The laparoscopic volume of each trainee and change in ratio of laparoscopic/open operation over time were used to estimate the growth of individual laparoscopic operations in training programs. RESULTS: Laparoscopic surgery constituted only 5.7% of a trainee's total surgical experience in 1994, but comprised 13% by 2001. A resident completing training in 1994 performed 53 laparoscopic operations, of which 79% (42) were cholecystectomies. By 2001, a graduate performed 126 laparoscopic operations, of which 68% (86) were cholecystectomies. During the interim, most laparoscopic operations exhibited growth. Trainee experience in some newer operations has also increased steadily but at a much slower rate. CONCLUSIONS: This descriptive statistical survey of training experience yields a comprehensive picture of the laparoscopic capability of the young surgeon. The growth potential of some newer operations has also been measured. Using these data, guidelines can be drawn as to which operation programs should focus resources on training residents. Since competence depends on exposure, residency training alone may not provide sufficient depth to allow recent graduates to perform the newer operations independently.
BACKGROUND: Although laparoscopic surgery has become widespread during the past decade, no systematic study of the training needs exists. To obtain guidance for planning, we analyzed the national resident operative experience during the past 8 years. METHODS: The laparoscopic experiences of all surgical residents graduating between 1994 and 2001 were subjected to regression analysis. The laparoscopic volume of each trainee and change in ratio of laparoscopic/open operation over time were used to estimate the growth of individual laparoscopic operations in training programs. RESULTS: Laparoscopic surgery constituted only 5.7% of a trainee's total surgical experience in 1994, but comprised 13% by 2001. A resident completing training in 1994 performed 53 laparoscopic operations, of which 79% (42) were cholecystectomies. By 2001, a graduate performed 126 laparoscopic operations, of which 68% (86) were cholecystectomies. During the interim, most laparoscopic operations exhibited growth. Trainee experience in some newer operations has also increased steadily but at a much slower rate. CONCLUSIONS: This descriptive statistical survey of training experience yields a comprehensive picture of the laparoscopic capability of the young surgeon. The growth potential of some newer operations has also been measured. Using these data, guidelines can be drawn as to which operation programs should focus resources on training residents. Since competence depends on exposure, residency training alone may not provide sufficient depth to allow recent graduates to perform the newer operations independently.
Authors: Balazs I Lengyel; Dan Azagury; Oliver Varban; Maria T Panizales; Jill Steinberg; David C Brooks; Stanley W Ashley; Ali Tavakkolizadeh Journal: Surg Endosc Date: 2011-09-23 Impact factor: 4.584
Authors: Byron F Santos; Taylor J Reif; Nathaniel J Soper; Alexander P Nagle; Deborah M Rooney; Eric S Hungness Journal: Surg Endosc Date: 2012-03-22 Impact factor: 4.584
Authors: Aimee K Gardner; Ross E Willis; Brian J Dunkin; Kent R Van Sickle; Kimberly M Brown; Michael S Truitt; John M Uecker; Lonnie Gentry; Daniel J Scott Journal: Surg Endosc Date: 2015-10-20 Impact factor: 4.584
Authors: Lee L Swanstrom; Adrian Park; Marty Arregui; Morris Franklin; C Daniel Smith; Christina Blaney Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2006-04 Impact factor: 12.969
Authors: Yassar Youssef; Gyusung Lee; Carlos Godinez; Erica Sutton; Rosemary V Klein; Ivan M George; F Jacob Seagull; Adrian Park Journal: Surg Endosc Date: 2011-03-24 Impact factor: 4.584
Authors: Nicoleta O Kolozsvari; Giovanni Capretti; Pepa Kaneva; Amy Neville; Franco Carli; Sender Liberman; Patrick Charlebois; Barry Stein; Melina C Vassiliou; Gerald M Fried; Liane S Feldman Journal: Surg Endosc Date: 2012-07-19 Impact factor: 4.584