BACKGROUND: The validity of dietary assessment methods should be established before diet-disease associations are reported. OBJECTIVE: Our objective was to validate a 7-d food diary and a food-frequency questionnaire (FFQ) against independent biomarkers of intake in urine (nitrogen, potassium, and sodium) and blood (plasma ascorbic acid). DESIGN: A total of 146 healthy middle-aged men and women were recruited from the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer UK Norfolk cohort, a free-living cohort of approximately 25000 persons. Over a 9-mo period, urinary nitrogen, potassium, and sodium were estimated from 2-6 complete 24-h urine collections in 134 subjects and plasma ascorbic acid was estimated from 2-3 fasting blood samples in 118 subjects. Subjects completed 2 FFQs and two 7-d food diaries. RESULTS: In men and women combined, correlations between 24-h urinary nitrogen excretion and dietary intake from the 7-d food diary were high (r = 0.57-0.67) compared with those for the FFQ (r = 0.21-0.29). Similarly, correlations between urinary potassium and dietary potassium were higher for the 7-d food diary (r = 0.51-0.55) than for the FFQ (r = 0.32-0.34). There was no overall difference in correlations between plasma ascorbic acid and dietary vitamin C between the 7-d food diary (r = 0.40-0.52) and the FFQ (r = 0.44-0.45). CONCLUSIONS: These data indicate that, despite increased subject burden, the 7-d food diary provided a better estimate of nitrogen and potassium intakes than did the FFQ in this study population. However, with respect to plasma ascorbic acid, both the FFQ and 7-d food diary provided a similar ranking of subjects according to vitamin C intake.
BACKGROUND: The validity of dietary assessment methods should be established before diet-disease associations are reported. OBJECTIVE: Our objective was to validate a 7-d food diary and a food-frequency questionnaire (FFQ) against independent biomarkers of intake in urine (nitrogen, potassium, and sodium) and blood (plasma ascorbic acid). DESIGN: A total of 146 healthy middle-aged men and women were recruited from the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer UK Norfolk cohort, a free-living cohort of approximately 25000 persons. Over a 9-mo period, urinary nitrogen, potassium, and sodium were estimated from 2-6 complete 24-h urine collections in 134 subjects and plasma ascorbic acid was estimated from 2-3 fasting blood samples in 118 subjects. Subjects completed 2 FFQs and two 7-d food diaries. RESULTS: In men and women combined, correlations between 24-h urinary nitrogen excretion and dietary intake from the 7-d food diary were high (r = 0.57-0.67) compared with those for the FFQ (r = 0.21-0.29). Similarly, correlations between urinary potassium and dietary potassium were higher for the 7-d food diary (r = 0.51-0.55) than for the FFQ (r = 0.32-0.34). There was no overall difference in correlations between plasma ascorbic acid and dietary vitamin C between the 7-d food diary (r = 0.40-0.52) and the FFQ (r = 0.44-0.45). CONCLUSIONS: These data indicate that, despite increased subject burden, the 7-d food diary provided a better estimate of nitrogen and potassium intakes than did the FFQ in this study population. However, with respect to plasma ascorbic acid, both the FFQ and 7-d food diary provided a similar ranking of subjects according to vitamin C intake.
Authors: Fengqing Zhu; Anand Mariappan; Carol J Boushey; Deb Kerr; Kyle D Lutes; David S Ebert; Edward J Delp Journal: Proc SPIE Int Soc Opt Eng Date: 2008-03-20
Authors: Peter J Aggett; Jean-Michel Antoine; Nils-Georg Asp; France Bellisle; Laura Contor; John H Cummings; John Howlett; Detlef J G Müller; Christoph Persin; Loek T J Pijls; Gerhard Rechkemmer; Sandra Tuijtelaars; Hans Verhagen Journal: Eur J Nutr Date: 2005-06 Impact factor: 5.614
Authors: Linda Penn; Heiner Boeing; Carol J Boushey; Lars Ove Dragsted; Jim Kaput; Augustin Scalbert; Ailsa A Welch; John C Mathers Journal: Genes Nutr Date: 2010-04-27 Impact factor: 5.523
Authors: Misook L Chung; Debra K Moser; Terry A Lennie; Linda Worrall-Carter; Brooke Bentley; Robin Trupp; Deborah S Armentano Journal: J Card Fail Date: 2006-10 Impact factor: 5.712
Authors: Terry A Lennie; Eun Kyeung Song; Jia-Rong Wu; Misook L Chung; Sandra B Dunbar; Susan J Pressler; Debra K Moser Journal: J Card Fail Date: 2011-01-21 Impact factor: 5.712
Authors: Vanessa A Farrell; Margaret Harris; Timothy G Lohman; Scott B Going; Cynthia A Thomson; Judith L Weber; Linda B Houtkooper Journal: J Am Diet Assoc Date: 2009-05