OBJECTIVE: To compare the rates of and indications for labor induction between a university hospital and two community hospitals and to examine the risk of cesarean delivery among labor induction cases. STUDY DESIGN: Labor induction cases over a six-month period were included (N = 536). Medical records were reviewed by a trained abstractor using a standardized form to determine maternal characteristics, reason for induction and perinatal outcomes. RESULTS: Rates of labor induction were significantly different between the three hospitals: university, 18.2%; community hospital A, 21.4%; community hospital B, 33.7% (P < .001). At the university hospital, 95% of labor inductions were medically indicated using American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) criteria. Forty-four percent of labor inductions at community hospital A and 57% at community hospital B were for elective reasons. Cesarean rates among induction cases were highest at the university hospital (19%) as compared to community hospital A (15%) and community hospital B (11%), although the difference was not statistically significant. Parity, race and cervical status, but not elective induction, were significantly associated with cesarean delivery. CONCLUSION: Labor induction was more frequent in community hospitals but more likely to meet ACOG-approved indications at the university hospital. The more-frequent inductions at the community hospitals did not result in higher cesarean rates.
OBJECTIVE: To compare the rates of and indications for labor induction between a university hospital and two community hospitals and to examine the risk of cesarean delivery among labor induction cases. STUDY DESIGN:Labor induction cases over a six-month period were included (N = 536). Medical records were reviewed by a trained abstractor using a standardized form to determine maternal characteristics, reason for induction and perinatal outcomes. RESULTS: Rates of labor induction were significantly different between the three hospitals: university, 18.2%; community hospital A, 21.4%; community hospital B, 33.7% (P < .001). At the university hospital, 95% of labor inductions were medically indicated using American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) criteria. Forty-four percent of labor inductions at community hospital A and 57% at community hospital B were for elective reasons. Cesarean rates among induction cases were highest at the university hospital (19%) as compared to community hospital A (15%) and community hospital B (11%), although the difference was not statistically significant. Parity, race and cervical status, but not elective induction, were significantly associated with cesarean delivery. CONCLUSION:Labor induction was more frequent in community hospitals but more likely to meet ACOG-approved indications at the university hospital. The more-frequent inductions at the community hospitals did not result in higher cesarean rates.
Authors: Gláucia Virgínia Guerra; José Guilherme Cecatti; João Paulo Souza; Aníbal Faúndes; Sirlei Siani Morais; Ahmet Metin Gülmezoglu; Renato Passini; Mary Angela Parpinelli; Guillermo Carroli Journal: Bull World Health Organ Date: 2011-07-05 Impact factor: 9.408