OBJECTIVE: To compare the value and limitations of exercise testing, dipyridamole echocardiography, dobutamine-atropine echocardiography, and MIBI-SPECT (technetium-99m methoxyisobutyl nitrile single photon emission computed tomography) during dobutamine infusion in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease. DESIGN: The performance of these four tests was assessed in random order on a consecutive cohort of patients. The presence or absence of coronary artery disease was confirmed by coronary angiography. SETTING:Two tertiary care and university centres. PATIENTS: 102 consecutive patients with chest pain and no previous history of coronary artery disease. Ten patients with left bundle branch block were excluded for further analysis of exercise testing and scintigraphy results. RESULTS: MIBI-SPECT was the most sensitive (87%) but the least specific test (70%). Exercise stress testing had a sensitivity of 66%, which increased to 80% when patients with inconclusive results were excluded. Dipyridamole and dobutamine echocardiography had similar sensitivity (81%, 78%) and specificity (94%, 88%). All four tests had similar accuracy and positive and negative predictive values. Agreement between the echocardiographic techniques was excellent (detection of coronary artery disease 87%, kappa = 0.72; regional analysis 93%, kappa = 0.72; diagnosis of the "culprit" vessel 95%, kappa = 0.92), and it was good between echocardiographic techniques and MIBI-SPECT (diagnosis of the culprit vessel 90%, kappa = 0.84 with dobutamine and 92%, kappa = 0.85 with dipyridamole). CONCLUSIONS: Exercise stress testing has a sensitivity comparable to other tests in patients capable of exercising and with no basal electrical abnormalities. The greatest sensitivity is offered by MIBI-SPECT and the greatest specificity is obtained with stress echocardiography. Redundant information is obtained with dipyridamole echocardiography, dobutamine echocardiography, and MIBI-SPECT.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To compare the value and limitations of exercise testing, dipyridamole echocardiography, dobutamine-atropine echocardiography, and MIBI-SPECT (technetium-99m methoxyisobutyl nitrile single photon emission computed tomography) during dobutamine infusion in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease. DESIGN: The performance of these four tests was assessed in random order on a consecutive cohort of patients. The presence or absence of coronary artery disease was confirmed by coronary angiography. SETTING: Two tertiary care and university centres. PATIENTS: 102 consecutive patients with chest pain and no previous history of coronary artery disease. Ten patients with left bundle branch block were excluded for further analysis of exercise testing and scintigraphy results. RESULTS: MIBI-SPECT was the most sensitive (87%) but the least specific test (70%). Exercise stress testing had a sensitivity of 66%, which increased to 80% when patients with inconclusive results were excluded. Dipyridamole and dobutamine echocardiography had similar sensitivity (81%, 78%) and specificity (94%, 88%). All four tests had similar accuracy and positive and negative predictive values. Agreement between the echocardiographic techniques was excellent (detection of coronary artery disease 87%, kappa = 0.72; regional analysis 93%, kappa = 0.72; diagnosis of the "culprit" vessel 95%, kappa = 0.92), and it was good between echocardiographic techniques and MIBI-SPECT (diagnosis of the culprit vessel 90%, kappa = 0.84 with dobutamine and 92%, kappa = 0.85 with dipyridamole). CONCLUSIONS: Exercise stress testing has a sensitivity comparable to other tests in patients capable of exercising and with no basal electrical abnormalities. The greatest sensitivity is offered by MIBI-SPECT and the greatest specificity is obtained with stress echocardiography. Redundant information is obtained with dipyridamole echocardiography, dobutamine echocardiography, and MIBI-SPECT.
Authors: T Forster; A J McNeill; A Salustri; A E Reijs; E S el-Said; J R Roelandt; P M Fioretti Journal: J Am Coll Cardiol Date: 1993-06 Impact factor: 24.094
Authors: Carolina Valdiviezo; Marietta Ambrose; Vishal Mehra; Albert C Lardo; Joao A C Lima; Richard T George Journal: J Nucl Cardiol Date: 2010-12 Impact factor: 5.952
Authors: Yoshinori Noguchi; Shizuko Nagata-Kobayashi; James E Stahl; John B Wong Journal: Int J Cardiovasc Imaging Date: 2005 Apr-Jun Impact factor: 2.357
Authors: Richard T George; Vishal C Mehra; Marcus Y Chen; Kakuya Kitagawa; Armin Arbab-Zadeh; Julie M Miller; Matthew B Matheson; Andrea L Vavere; Klaus F Kofoed; Carlos E Rochitte; Marc Dewey; Tan S Yaw; Hiroyuki Niinuma; Winfried Brenner; Christopher Cox; Melvin E Clouse; João A C Lima; Marcelo Di Carli Journal: Radiology Date: 2014-05-26 Impact factor: 11.105