PURPOSE: Many surveys of adolescent behavior are dependent on self-reported data. We sought to assess the accuracy of adolescent self-report of sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) and pregnancies. METHODS: We randomly selected 149 (118 females, 31 males) adolescents to participate in this accuracy study. Follow-up questionnaires were administered to the 126 patients (99 females, 27 males) who returned after enrollment. Patients were asked about STDs and pregnancies during the follow-up period which ranged from 6 months to 1 year. All patient charts were reviewed to validate post-testing history. RESULTS: Return visits were made by 126 patients (84%). Fifty-one (40%) denied having had an STD at all during the follow-up period but were found to have had at least one STD. Another 11 (9%) admitted having had an STD but had multiple STDs in excess of what they reported. Only 46% of the patients provided accurate information on the follow-up questionnaire. Of the 99 girls who returned for follow-up, the inaccurate patients (10%) consisted of 9 who reported no visits for a pregnancy but had a pregnancy documented in their charts and 1 who underreported her number of pregnancies. Reliability analysis of the accuracy of STD and pregnancy self-report for our patients showed kappas ranging from 0.185 to 0.413 (slight and fair to moderate, respectively). Pearson correlation coefficients were 0.3107 and 0.4364 for STD and pregnancy, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Our patients' histories of visits for STDs and pregnancies are often not substantiated by review of their medical records. The reason for the inaccuracies in self-report of sexual behaviors is unclear. Further research in this area should be done. Physicians must confirm patient history concerning sexual practices through appropriate record review and medical evaluation.
PURPOSE: Many surveys of adolescent behavior are dependent on self-reported data. We sought to assess the accuracy of adolescent self-report of sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) and pregnancies. METHODS: We randomly selected 149 (118 females, 31 males) adolescents to participate in this accuracy study. Follow-up questionnaires were administered to the 126 patients (99 females, 27 males) who returned after enrollment. Patients were asked about STDs and pregnancies during the follow-up period which ranged from 6 months to 1 year. All patient charts were reviewed to validate post-testing history. RESULTS: Return visits were made by 126 patients (84%). Fifty-one (40%) denied having had an STD at all during the follow-up period but were found to have had at least one STD. Another 11 (9%) admitted having had an STD but had multiple STDs in excess of what they reported. Only 46% of the patients provided accurate information on the follow-up questionnaire. Of the 99 girls who returned for follow-up, the inaccurate patients (10%) consisted of 9 who reported no visits for a pregnancy but had a pregnancy documented in their charts and 1 who underreported her number of pregnancies. Reliability analysis of the accuracy of STD and pregnancy self-report for our patients showed kappas ranging from 0.185 to 0.413 (slight and fair to moderate, respectively). Pearson correlation coefficients were 0.3107 and 0.4364 for STD and pregnancy, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Our patients' histories of visits for STDs and pregnancies are often not substantiated by review of their medical records. The reason for the inaccuracies in self-report of sexual behaviors is unclear. Further research in this area should be done. Physicians must confirm patient history concerning sexual practices through appropriate record review and medical evaluation.
Entities:
Keywords:
Adolescent Pregnancy; Adolescents; Age Factors; Americas; Data Analysis; Data Collection; Data Quality; Data Sources; Demographic Factors; Developed Countries; Diseases; Fertility; Infections; Measurement; North America; Northern America; Population; Population Characteristics; Population Dynamics; Prevalence; Reproductive Behavior; Reproductive Tract Infections; Research Methodology; Research Report; Sampling Studies; Sexually Transmitted Diseases; Studies; Surveys; United States; Validity; Youth
Authors: Ali Mirzazadeh; M Antonia Biggs; Amanda Viitanen; Hacsi Horvath; Li Yan Wang; Richard Dunville; Lisa C Barrios; James G Kahn; Elliot Marseille Journal: Prev Sci Date: 2018-05
Authors: Jessica F Magidson; Aaron J Blashill; Melanie M Wall; Ivan C Balan; Shuai Wang; C W Lejuez; Carlos Blanco Journal: J Psychosom Res Date: 2014-01-03 Impact factor: 3.006
Authors: Jacinda K Dariotis; Joseph H Pleck; Freya L Sonenstein; Nan M Astone; Frangiscos Sifakis Journal: J Adolesc Health Date: 2009-03-29 Impact factor: 5.012