BACKGROUND: Controversy over the relationship of preformed lymphocytotoxic antibodies and liver graft outcome remains. Because graft loss associated with preformed lymphocytotoxic antibodies probably occurs early after transplant, analysis of long-term survival is of questionable value. We therefore prospectively analyzed the effect on short- and long-term graft survival of the presence of lymphocytotoxic alloantibody in 207 primary adult liver allograft recipients. METHODS: Pretransplant serum was tested for donor-specific lymphocytotoxic antibodies and panel-reactive antibodies (PRA) using donor splenic lymphocytes and lymphocytes obtained for routine tissue typing. RESULTS: A positive crossmatch was detected in 24 recipients (11.5%): T-cell positive in 11 recipients and B-cell positive in 13 recipients. PRA were detected in 68 of 179 recipients tested (37.4%). High T-cell PRA (>55%) was detected in 17 recipients, and high B-cell PRA was detected in 20 recipients. Low PRA (<15%) against T cells was detected in 19 recipients and against B cells in 24 recipients. Graft failures occurred in 5 of 24 (21%) crossmatch-positive recipients and in 7 of 172 (4%) crossmatch-negative recipients. Graft survival was significantly lower in crossmatch-positive recipients at 1 month after transplant (chi-square=10.3, P=0.00133) but not at 3 months or 1 year. Causes of early graft loss were associated with immunological mechanisms, whereas later losses were due to nonimmunological mechanisms. CONCLUSIONS: Early graft loss may be increased in those recipients who are crossmatch positive. However, the logistical problems and consequences associated with allocation probably outweigh the benefits of prospective crossmatching.
BACKGROUND: Controversy over the relationship of preformed lymphocytotoxic antibodies and liver graft outcome remains. Because graft loss associated with preformed lymphocytotoxic antibodies probably occurs early after transplant, analysis of long-term survival is of questionable value. We therefore prospectively analyzed the effect on short- and long-term graft survival of the presence of lymphocytotoxic alloantibody in 207 primary adult liver allograft recipients. METHODS: Pretransplant serum was tested for donor-specific lymphocytotoxic antibodies and panel-reactive antibodies (PRA) using donor splenic lymphocytes and lymphocytes obtained for routine tissue typing. RESULTS: A positive crossmatch was detected in 24 recipients (11.5%): T-cell positive in 11 recipients and B-cell positive in 13 recipients. PRA were detected in 68 of 179 recipients tested (37.4%). High T-cell PRA (>55%) was detected in 17 recipients, and high B-cell PRA was detected in 20 recipients. Low PRA (<15%) against T cells was detected in 19 recipients and against B cells in 24 recipients. Graft failures occurred in 5 of 24 (21%) crossmatch-positive recipients and in 7 of 172 (4%) crossmatch-negative recipients. Graft survival was significantly lower in crossmatch-positive recipients at 1 month after transplant (chi-square=10.3, P=0.00133) but not at 3 months or 1 year. Causes of early graft loss were associated with immunological mechanisms, whereas later losses were due to nonimmunological mechanisms. CONCLUSIONS: Early graft loss may be increased in those recipients who are crossmatch positive. However, the logistical problems and consequences associated with allocation probably outweigh the benefits of prospective crossmatching.
Authors: Joshua P Waldman; Thomas Vogel; Christopher Burlak; Constantin Coussios; Javier Dominguez; Peter Friend; Michael A Rees Journal: Xenotransplantation Date: 2013-07-04 Impact factor: 3.907
Authors: Isabel Legaz; Francisco Boix; Manuela López; Rafael Alfaro; José A Galián; Santiago Llorente; Jose A Campillo; Carmen Botella; Pablo Ramírez; Francisco Sánchez-Bueno; José A Pons; María R Moya-Quiles; Alfredo Minguela; Manuel Muro Journal: J Clin Med Date: 2020-03-05 Impact factor: 4.241