OBJECTIVE: This prospective study was intended to determine if helical CT arteriography plus conventional radiography is sufficiently accurate to replace and less costly than excretory urography and conventional renal arteriography, the techniques currently used to examine living renal donors. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Patients underwent CT arteriography with a helical CT scanner. Conventional radiographs were obtained during the pyelographic phase to evaluate the urothelium. Findings on CT arteriograms were compared with findings on conventional arteriograms and at surgery. RESULTS: Of 57 patients who underwent CT arteriography, 46 also underwent conventional arteriography and 40 underwent surgery. For those 46 patients, we found agreement between results of CT arteriography and conventional arteriography in 89% of kidneys. For those 40 patients, we found agreement between results of CT arteriography and findings at surgery in 90% of kidneys and agreement between results of conventional arteriography and findings at surgery in 87% of kidneys. Of the 57 patients, six (11%) had findings on CT angiograms that precluded further consideration for donation. CONCLUSION: Eight to ten percent of renal arteries are not seen on renal arteriograms when compared with findings at surgery. Our results indicate that CT arteriography is as accurate as conventional arteriography at revealing the number of vessels that perfuse and drain the kidneys and can replace conventional arteriography. Use of CT angiography plus conventional radiography instead of excretory urography and conventional arteriography can result in a 35-50% reduction in cost of the imaging studies in potential renal donors.
OBJECTIVE: This prospective study was intended to determine if helical CT arteriography plus conventional radiography is sufficiently accurate to replace and less costly than excretory urography and conventional renal arteriography, the techniques currently used to examine living renal donors. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Patients underwent CT arteriography with a helical CT scanner. Conventional radiographs were obtained during the pyelographic phase to evaluate the urothelium. Findings on CT arteriograms were compared with findings on conventional arteriograms and at surgery. RESULTS: Of 57 patients who underwent CT arteriography, 46 also underwent conventional arteriography and 40 underwent surgery. For those 46 patients, we found agreement between results of CT arteriography and conventional arteriography in 89% of kidneys. For those 40 patients, we found agreement between results of CT arteriography and findings at surgery in 90% of kidneys and agreement between results of conventional arteriography and findings at surgery in 87% of kidneys. Of the 57 patients, six (11%) had findings on CT angiograms that precluded further consideration for donation. CONCLUSION: Eight to ten percent of renal arteries are not seen on renal arteriograms when compared with findings at surgery. Our results indicate that CT arteriography is as accurate as conventional arteriography at revealing the number of vessels that perfuse and drain the kidneys and can replace conventional arteriography. Use of CT angiography plus conventional radiography instead of excretory urography and conventional arteriography can result in a 35-50% reduction in cost of the imaging studies in potential renal donors.
Authors: Elizabeth C Lorenz; Terri J Vrtiska; John C Lieske; John J Dillon; Mark D Stegall; Xujian Li; Eric J Bergstralh; Andrew D Rule Journal: Clin J Am Soc Nephrol Date: 2010-01-14 Impact factor: 8.237