M J Potts1, K W Phelan. 1. Department of Pediatrics, University of Illinois College of Medicine, Rockford, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To discover how well new house officers in primary care residency programs perform the mathematical calculations necessary to function effectively in pediatric and nursery settings. DESIGN: Criterion-referenced survey examination testing unit conversion, fluid and rehydration management, and drug-dosing skills. SETTING: Five primary care residences in family practice and pediatrics at urban and community campus sites in Illinois. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-three family practice residents and 11 pediatric residents tested during residency orientations sessions or in conferences during the first 3 months of training. INTERVENTIONS: None. RESULTS: The mean score for all residents was 42%. Pediatric residents (mean score, 57.8%) performed significantly better than family medicine residents (mean score, 34.4%) (P = .002). Conversion from conventional to metric units was more difficult for family practice residents, but pediatric residents also made errors. Pediatric residents were significantly better than family medicine residents at calculation of fluid maintenance requirements (P < .05). Only 5 of 34 residents wrote acceptable fluid orders. Nutritional and drug therapy calculations showed fewer mathematical errors, but neither group routinely wrote medical orders that specified the drugs or formula, concentration, volume required per dose or feeding, route of administration, dosing interval, and duration of therapy. CONCLUSIONS: The potential for serious clinical errors caused by faculty calculation of dosage by house staff officers is high. New residents should have their orders for fluids and drugs double-checked by senior personnel early in their training. Residency programs should provide remedial skills training for house officers with deficiencies in applied mathematics. The medical school faculty needs to assess students' competence in mathematics before allowing independent clinical responsibility.
OBJECTIVE: To discover how well new house officers in primary care residency programs perform the mathematical calculations necessary to function effectively in pediatric and nursery settings. DESIGN: Criterion-referenced survey examination testing unit conversion, fluid and rehydration management, and drug-dosing skills. SETTING: Five primary care residences in family practice and pediatrics at urban and community campus sites in Illinois. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-three family practice residents and 11 pediatric residents tested during residency orientations sessions or in conferences during the first 3 months of training. INTERVENTIONS: None. RESULTS: The mean score for all residents was 42%. Pediatric residents (mean score, 57.8%) performed significantly better than family medicine residents (mean score, 34.4%) (P = .002). Conversion from conventional to metric units was more difficult for family practice residents, but pediatric residents also made errors. Pediatric residents were significantly better than family medicine residents at calculation of fluid maintenance requirements (P < .05). Only 5 of 34 residents wrote acceptable fluid orders. Nutritional and drug therapy calculations showed fewer mathematical errors, but neither group routinely wrote medical orders that specified the drugs or formula, concentration, volume required per dose or feeding, route of administration, dosing interval, and duration of therapy. CONCLUSIONS: The potential for serious clinical errors caused by faculty calculation of dosage by house staff officers is high. New residents should have their orders for fluids and drugs double-checked by senior personnel early in their training. Residency programs should provide remedial skills training for house officers with deficiencies in applied mathematics. The medical school faculty needs to assess students' competence in mathematics before allowing independent clinical responsibility.
Authors: Susan M Abdel-Rahman; Nichole Ahlers; Anne Holmes; Krista Wright; Ann Harris; Jaylene Weigel; Talita Hill; Kim Baird; Marla Michaels; Gregory L Kearns Journal: J Pediatr Pharmacol Ther Date: 2013-04