Comparative radioimmunotherapy using intact or F(ab')2 fragments of 131I anti-CEA antibody in a colonic xenograft model.

The therapeutic efficacy of intact and F(ab')2 fragments of a 131I anti-CEA antibody were compared in an established LS174T colonic xenograft model in nude mice. A single IV dose of either 0.5 mCi (18.5 MBq) intact or 1.0 mCi (37 MBq) F(ab')2 fragments significantly delayed tumour growth, and increased survival time to the same extent. Biodistribution studies showed that the more rapid clearance of the fragments from the circulation improved the tumour: normal tissue ratios found for the intact antibody, but reduced the duration and therefore absolute amount of radioantibody localisation (% injected dose/gram) at the tumour site. The tumours received a similar accumulated beta radiation dose, with 4,065 cGy from 0.5 mCi intact antibody and 4,500 cGy from 1.0 mCi F(ab')2 fragments. The dose rate to the tumour was initially higher for the fragments, but fell off more rapidly as clearance occurred. However, the rapid circulatory clearance resulted in a radiation dose of only 995 cGy to the blood, compared with 2,300 cGy for the intact antibody. This suggests that twice the radiation dose could be delivered to the tumour in the form of fragments for the same blood dose from the intact antibody. Fractionating the 1.0 mCi dose of F(ab')2 into three doses of 0.33 mCi (12.2 MBq), given on days 1, 3 and 5, significantly reduced the therapeutic effect of the treatment. The clinical relevance of these findings is discussed.