Leeway and constraints in the forced evolution of a regulatory RNA helix.

The start of the coat protein gene of RNA phage MS2 adopts a well-defined hairpin structure of 12 bp (including one mismatch) in which the start codon occupies the loop position. An earlier expression study using partial MS2 cDNA clones had indicated that the stability of this hairpin is important for gene expression. For every -1.4 kcal/mol increase in stability a 10-fold reduction in coat protein was obtained. Destabilizations beyond the wild-type value did not affect expression. These results suggested that the hairpin was tuned in the sense that it has the highest stability still compatible with maximal ribosome loading. Employing an infectious MS2 cDNA clone, we have now tested the prediction that the delta G 0 of the coat protein initiator helix is set at a precise value. We have introduced stabilizing and destabilizing mutations into this hairpin in the intact phage and monitored their evolution to viable species. By compensatory mutations, both types of mutants quickly revert along various pathways to wild-type stability, but not to wild-type sequence. As a rule the second-site mutations do not change the encoded amino acids or the Shine-Dalgarno sequence. The return of too strong hairpins to wild-type stability can be understood from the need to produce adequate supplies of coat protein. The return of unstable hairpins to wild-type stability is not self-evident and is presently not understood. The revertants provide an evolutionary landscape of slightly suboptimal phages, that were stable at least for the duration of the experiment (approximately 20 infection cycles).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)