R H Dolin1. 1. Kaiser Permanente, La Palma, CA 90623, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To analyze the temporal aspects of symptoms, including their temporal uncertainty, in order to develop a high-level conceptual data model representation of this domain. DESIGN: A basic tenet of existing temporal models is that events occur not only relative to a particular date or time, but also relative to the time of some other event. The time an event occurs, particularly when the event is a symptom being recalled by a patient or collected by a busy provider, is frequently incomplete or uncertain, and this uncertainty must also be represented in a temporal data model. The object-oriented modeling technique used in this study is becoming popular among U.S. medical informatics standards developers. RESULTS: A conceptual data model for the temporal aspects of symptom data, including temporal uncertainty, has been developed. The object-oriented modeling approach used enables the temporal objects and attributes defined in this model to be inherited by other medical objects, such as problems. CONCLUSIONS: The temporal comparators presented here have previously been defined, and may serve as the basis for standardizing the terms used to describe how one event temporally relates to another. In an attempt to achieve domain completeness, this study concentrated more on developing a model that is highly expressive than on developing one that is easily queried. This trade-off in representation versus "queryability" will require further analysis and may require modifications to the underlying model.
OBJECTIVE: To analyze the temporal aspects of symptoms, including their temporal uncertainty, in order to develop a high-level conceptual data model representation of this domain. DESIGN: A basic tenet of existing temporal models is that events occur not only relative to a particular date or time, but also relative to the time of some other event. The time an event occurs, particularly when the event is a symptom being recalled by a patient or collected by a busy provider, is frequently incomplete or uncertain, and this uncertainty must also be represented in a temporal data model. The object-oriented modeling technique used in this study is becoming popular among U.S. medical informatics standards developers. RESULTS: A conceptual data model for the temporal aspects of symptom data, including temporal uncertainty, has been developed. The object-oriented modeling approach used enables the temporal objects and attributes defined in this model to be inherited by other medical objects, such as problems. CONCLUSIONS: The temporal comparators presented here have previously been defined, and may serve as the basis for standardizing the terms used to describe how one event temporally relates to another. In an attempt to achieve domain completeness, this study concentrated more on developing a model that is highly expressive than on developing one that is easily queried. This trade-off in representation versus "queryability" will require further analysis and may require modifications to the underlying model.
Authors: William F Styler; Steven Bethard; Sean Finan; Martha Palmer; Sameer Pradhan; Piet C de Groen; Brad Erickson; Timothy Miller; Chen Lin; Guergana Savova; James Pustejovsky Journal: Trans Assoc Comput Linguist Date: 2014-04
Authors: L Ohno-Machado; J H Gennari; S N Murphy; N L Jain; S W Tu; D E Oliver; E Pattison-Gordon; R A Greenes; E H Shortliffe; G O Barnett Journal: J Am Med Inform Assoc Date: 1998 Jul-Aug Impact factor: 4.497