A comparison between the Bain and Magill anaesthetic systems during spontaneous breathing.

The efficiency of the Bain system has been compared with that of the Magill system in ten conscious subjects breathing spontaneously. Air was supplied at fresh flow rates of 150 ml/kg and decreased stepwise at four-minute intervals until a flow of 50 ml/kg was attained. Expired minute volume and end-tidal carbon dioxide concentrations were measured. No rebreathing could be demonstrated with the Magill stystem at flow rates above approximately 70 ml/kg. In contrast, rebreathing was evident at all flow rates with the Bain system. It is concluded that acceptable carbon dioxide levels during spontaneous breathing with the Bain circuit can only be maintained by considerable active hyperventilation when using flow rates of 150 ml/kg and less.