| Literature DB >> 36230196 |
Siti Nurmilah1, Yana Cahyana1, Gemilang Lara Utama1,2, Abderrahmane Aït-Kaddour3.
Abstract
Sodium is a necessary nutrient for regulating extracellular fluid and transferring molecules around cell membranes with essential functions. However, the prevalence of some diseases is related to unnecessary sodium intake. As a result, a particular problem for the food industry remains a matter of sodium content in foods. It is considered that customer acceptance is associated with salt perception dynamics related to the evolution of food production. It is a significant challenge and technique to minimize the salt content of various foods and provide replacement products with substantial reductions in salt levels. This review summarizes salt reduction strategies related to health problems based on traditional review methodology, with practical and methodological screening performed to determine the appropriate reference sources. Various technological (salt replacement, food reformulation, size and structural modifications, alternative processing, and crossmodal odor interaction) and behavioral strategies (memory process, gradual salt reduction, and swap) are identified in this work, including a deeper understanding of the principles for reducing sodium content in foods and their effect on food characteristics and potential opportunities for the food industry. Thereby, the food industry needs to find the proper combination of each strategy's advantages and disadvantages to reduce salt consumption while maintaining product quality.Entities:
Keywords: hypertension; low salt; salt reduction; salty food; strategy
Year: 2022 PMID: 36230196 PMCID: PMC9564303 DOI: 10.3390/foods11193120
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Foods ISSN: 2304-8158
Figure 1(A) Salt–hydrogel marbles and hollow-shell particle production; (B) Possible outcomes in the fabrication of salt marbles. Reproduced from Ref. [69] with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry.
Figure 2Various morphological forms of salt crystals: (A) cubic rock salts; (B) aggregate sea salts; (C) flaked sea salts; and (D) pyramidal sea salts. Reprinted with permission from Refs. [73,74,77]. Copyright 2022 Elsevier Licenses No. 5402170471962, 5402170729257, and 5402170140464.
Figure 3(A) Inhomogeneous sodium distribution of coarse-grained salt crystals (2−3.5 mm, 1.25%) and (B) homogeneous sodium distribution of salt crystals (<2 mm, 1.5%) Adapted with permission from [79]. Copyright 2013 American Chemical Society.
Figure 4Experience crossmodal sequential processes to improve salty perception. Adapted from Ref. [4] with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry.
Summary of various treatments to reduce salt levels and their impact on food characteristics.
| Food Category | Strategy | Treatment | Characteristics of Food Effects | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||
| Durum wheat bread | Reduced Salt | Decrease of 50% NaCl (10–20 g/kg NaCl). | Less intensely colored crust and a weaker toasted aroma positively affected bread-specific volume and crumb consistency. | [ |
| Wheat bread | Partial salt substitute | Addition of 1.5–3% salt substitute Pansalt® (NaCl 57%, KCl 28%, MgSO4 12%, lysine hydrochloride 2%, silica 1%, and iodine 0.0036%). | Similar effects on bread control sensory attributes, yet unable to maintain the same level of perceived saltiness, produced a perceptible increase in bitter taste and aftertaste in the crust. | [ |
| Brown bread | Partial salt substitute | Salt substitute with potassium (K) (55.2%), magnesium (Mg) (69.0%), and (Ca) calcium (34.8%). | Baking quality, appearance, texture, and taste are acceptable and achieved 32.3% reduced sodium. | [ |
| Wheat bread | Partial salt substitute | Substitution of 40% salt with potassium (K) or calcium chloride (CaCl2) or magnesium (Mg) salts. | There is no negative impact on the rheology of the dough. | [ |
| Wheat flour | Partial salt substitute | Addition of 25% substitution of KCL, MgCl2, and CaCl2. | No difference in the dough production timing and the dough’s stability increases. | [ |
| Bread | Partial salt substitute | Replacement: | -In partial replacement (75% and 50% Na or K gluconate), there was no change in the bread rheology or volume, nor was there any significant effect on overall desire. | [ |
| Ground beef patties | Salt mixture | Addition of low-sodium salts with 2% Pansalt® (PS) | Detrimental impact on sensory quality of ground beef bread made using Pansalt® combination compared to bread containing NaCl. | [ |
| Bread | Partial salt substitute | 0.3% addition of KCl combined with glutamate | Because it covers the bitter aftertaste, it is acceptably sensory and achieves 75% reduced NaCl | [ |
| Bread | Partial salt substitute | Potassium (K) salt replaces 30% sodium | Sensory characteristics are acceptable | [ |
| Wheat bread crust | Coarse-grained NaCl | In addition, coarse-grained NaCl (2−3.5 mm) | Increased saltiness as a result of sensory contrast, yet faster sodium release during mastication while preserving taste quality and achieving 25% reduced NaCl | [ |
| Pizza crust | Partial salt replacement | Replace 30% NaCl by KCl or coarse-grained NaCl (0.4–1.4 mm) | Enhancement of saltiness through taste contrast and an accelerated sodium delivery measured and achieved 25% reduced NaCl. | [ |
| Bread | Encapsulated salts | Encapsulated salt | No apparent loss of the salty flavor and achieved 50% reduced NaCl | [ |
| Sheeted dough | Encapsulated salts | Holding 50% of the salt in the dough recipe to maintain the dough properties and save 25% as salt grains | Enhance the saltiness perception and achieve 25% reduced NaCl | [ |
|
| ||||
| Prato | Salt reduction | 25% and 50% salt reduction | -25% reduction has a similar peptide profile, hardness, and sensory acceptability. | [ |
| Mozzarella | Salt reduction | 50–60% salt reduction | Lowering salt by up to 50% boosted melting and slightly reduced stretch, whereas reducing salt by 60% inhibited melting. | [ |
| Cheddar | Salt reduction | Salt reduction of 0.5–3% | Reducing salt has a negative impact on the taste and texture. | [ |
| Cheddar | Partial mineral salt replacement | Addition of 298–388 mg CaCl2 and MgCl2, | Significant off-flavor in cheese (bitter, soapy, and metallic taste) | [ |
| Mozzarella | Partial mineral salt replacement | Addition of <25% KCl | It has a higher pH, metallic taste, and moisture content than cheeses with a higher K concentration. However, it melted with less hardness. | [ |
| Cheddar | Partial replacement of mineral salts | Addition of 60% low-sodium mixture of NaCl and KCl | Adding KCl at a level that maintains Aw leads to a slight bitterness, controllable salinity, and acceptable consumer acceptance. The same effective salt-to-moisture ratio. | [ |
| Cheese | Partial salt replacement-based emulsifying salts | Application of hydrocolloids: | The products containing 1% ( | [ |
| White cheese | Partial salt replacement | Application of hydrocolloids: guar gum, carrageenan, xanthan gum, and gelatin | Reduced salt in the brine ≤8% caused no defects because stabilizers prevented water entry into the cheese by retaining water. | [ |
| Feta cheese | Salt replacement and alternate processes | Addition of KCl and milk ultrafiltration treatment at a volumetric concentration factor of 4.5:1 | Adding KCl promoted syneresis, and only 25% replacement by KCl had the maximum sensory acceptance. | [ |
| Processed cheese | Partial salt replacement | Xylooligosaccharide (XOS), salt reduction, and taste enhancers (arginine and yeast extract) addition. | Enhanced the rheological, physicochemical, and sensory attributes. | [ |
|
| ||||
| Dry-cured loin and fermented sausage | Partial salt replacement | KCl, potassium lactate, and glycine addition | Significant flavor defects were detected with replacement of >30% in both products replaced with K-lactate and KCl, and loss of cohesiveness at a replacement rate of >50% with glycine and > 30% with K-lactate. | [ |
| Fermented sau-sage | Partial salt replacement | Addition of KCl (40%), K-lactate (30%), and glycine (20%) addition | Resulting in flavor and texture defects and having little effect on | [ |
| Packaged cooked meat | Partial salt replacement | Sodium diacetate, potassium lactate, and combination 2–3% addition. | Sensory quality and shelf life were increased while lowering NaCl levels by 40%. | [ |
| Ham | Partial salt replacement | 70:30% NaCl:KCl or | No organoleptic or quality changes were observed compared to control. | [ |
| Fermented cooked sausages | Partial salt replacement | KCl concentrations of 50% and 75% substitute and MSG, disodium guanylate, lysine, disodium inosinate, and taurine are added | Masking unpleasant flavors produced by lower salt levels | [ |
| Chicken breast meat | Partial salt replacement | Sodium tripolyphosphate and β-glucan addition and HPP at 40 °C and 600 MPa pressure | There is a negligible effect on color properties. | [ |
| Bologna sausage | Partial salt replacement | Citrus fiber addition | Most physical, chemical, and sensory aspects did not change. | [ |
| Ready-to-eat chicken breast | Partial salt replacement and alternative processing | Replacing 50% NaCl with KCl and HHP at 600 MPa for 3 min | The salt replacement did not affect the microbial counts, and HHP processing improved the hardness and sensory attributes of the sodium-reduced | [ |
| Dry cured loin | Partial salt replacement | The salt substitute contained 39.7 g/100 g of NaCl, 51.3 g/100 g of KCl, and a mixture of L-histidine and L-lysine (9.0 g/100 g) | Decrease of 53.79% in Na | [ |
| Chicken meat batters | Alternative processing strategy | Heat under pressure (HUP) treatment at 200 MPa 75 °C, 30 min | Improved the gel qualities, resulting in glossy coarse, loose gels with high water loss, and low acceptability. | [ |
|
| ||||
| Shoestring potatoes | Reducing the size of particle salt mixture | Reducing particle sizes of salt mixture (NaCl, MSG, and KCL) of 60 μm and 88 μm | No, significantly changing the sensory quality and achieved a sodium decrease of 69% | [ |
| Shoestring potatoes | Reducing the size of particle salt | Reducing particle sizes of 26 µm particles | Maintained the same perception of salty taste and sensory quality and achieved a sodium decrease of 51% | [ |
| Cheese crackers | Reducing the size of particle salt | Reducing 3 logs from regular salt to nano spray-dried salt | Maintained low counts of yeasts and absence of molds, did not adversely influence sensory quality attributes and achieved a sodium decrease by 25–50% | [ |
|
| ||||
| Tomato soup | Salt reduction | Internalized salt solution stabilized with nonchemically modified waxy rice starch (WRS) and octenyl succinic anhydride (OSA) | Enhanced for gelatinized WRS compared to OSA starch stabilized emulsions and achieved a sodium decrease of 25% | [ |
|
| ||||
| Cooked fish batter | Salt reduction and alternative processing | The isolated and combined effect of UV-C (0.310 J/cm2) and high hydrostatic pressure (HHP; 300 MPa for 5 min at 25 °C) | The treatments did not affect sodium chloride concentration, redness, yellowness, cohesiveness, springiness, or resilience and were reduced by 25% NaCl. | [ |
| Smoke-Flavored trout | Salt mixture and alternative processing strategy | Substitution of NaCl with 30% combined with spray dryer | Higher hygroscopicity and saltiness because of their lower bulk density and existence of agglomeration, surface roughness, and macro pores. | [ |
| Smoke-flavored salmon | Partial salt replacement | Addition of 50% KCl with smoke flavoring by water vapor permeability bags | It did not significantly affect the quality and shelf-life | [ |
| Cold-smoked salmon | Salt reduction and alternative processing | Sodium-reduced samples (2.7–3.7 g salt/100 g) with cold smoking + vacuum packaging | Regarding aerobic and anaerobic mesophilic counts, organoleptic properties, texture, color, and the growth of | [ |
| Fish ball | Partial salt replacement | Addition of 20% KCl +15% | Physicochemical and sensory evaluation, emulsion stability, cooking yield, and overall acceptability | [ |
| Fermented fish | Partial salt replacement | Addition of 25% and 50% KCl | Higher hardness, adhesiveness, and springiness | [ |
| Salmon | Partial salt replacement | -70% NaCl + 30% KCl | -70% NaCl with KCl had | [ |
| Fermented shrimp paste | Partial salt replacement | In addition, 25 and 50% KCl | Reduced lipid oxidation, oxidative rancidity, and antioxidant activities were maintained. | [ |
| Sushi (tuna and shrimp) | Salt microspheres | -Addition of 87–99% hollowed microsphere of regular salt crystals | -The quality of sushi products made from tuna or shrimp was preserved by hollowed microsphere salt | [ |
| Seabass sausages | Salt reduction and partial salt replacement | -50% NaCl + 50% oleoresins microcapsules | -Replacement of 50% NaCl with KCl microcapsules or oleoresin showed the best results in reducing Na content (30.9–36.3%) while maintaining sausage quality. | [ |
| Smoked sea bass ( | Partial salt replacement and cold smoking | Addition of 50% NaCl + 50% KCl | Effective in preventing lipid peroxides and keeping the total volatile basic nitrogen value is below the decay threshold. Salt substitution with the K did not change the quality of smoked fillets. | [ |
| Smoked salmon ( | Partial salt replacement | -75% NaCl + 25% KCl + 0.1% commercial masking agent | No significant difference in physicochemical properties in the smoke sample with 50% KCl, while the sample with 25% substitute did not show a difference with control (100% NaCl) | [ |
| Salmon pate ( | Partial salt replacement | 20% NaCl + 80% substitute with KCl | Substitution of 80% with Saltwell® at a reduction of 22% sodium does not affect microbial activity. In comparison, there were small differences in three of the twelve sensory attributes evaluated (coherent texture, salty taste, and canned fish taste). | [ |