Post-translational glycosylation of proteins results in complex mixtures of heterogeneous protein glycoforms. Glycoproteins have many potential applications from fundamental studies of glycobiology to potential therapeutics, but generating homogeneous recombinant glycoproteins using chemical or chemoenzymatic reactions to mimic natural glycoproteins or creating homogeneous synthetic neoglycoproteins is a challenging synthetic task. In this work, we use a site-specific bioorthogonal approach to produce synthetic homogeneous glycoproteins. We develop a bifunctional, bioorthogonal linker that combines oxime ligation and strain-promoted azide-alkyne cycloaddition chemistry to functionalize reducing sugars and glycan derivatives for attachment to proteins. We demonstrate the utility of this minimal length linker by producing neoglycoprotein inhibitors of cholera toxin in which derivatives of the disaccharide lactose and GM1os pentasaccharide are attached to a nonbinding variant of the cholera toxin B-subunit that acts as a size- and valency-matched multivalent scaffold. The resulting neoglycoproteins decorated with GM1 ligands inhibit cholera toxin B-subunit adhesion with a picomolar IC50.
Post-translational glycosylation of proteins results in complex mixtures of heterogeneous protein glycoforms. Glycoproteins have many potential applications from fundamental studies of glycobiology to potential therapeutics, but generating homogeneous recombinant glycoproteins using chemical or chemoenzymatic reactions to mimic natural glycoproteins or creating homogeneous synthetic neoglycoproteins is a challenging synthetic task. In this work, we use a site-specific bioorthogonal approach to produce synthetic homogeneous glycoproteins. We develop a bifunctional, bioorthogonal linker that combines oxime ligation and strain-promoted azide-alkyne cycloaddition chemistry to functionalize reducing sugars and glycan derivatives for attachment to proteins. We demonstrate the utility of this minimal length linker by producing neoglycoprotein inhibitors of cholera toxin in which derivatives of the disaccharide lactose and GM1os pentasaccharide are attached to a nonbinding variant of the cholera toxin B-subunit that acts as a size- and valency-matched multivalent scaffold. The resulting neoglycoproteins decorated with GM1 ligands inhibit cholera toxin B-subunit adhesion with a picomolar IC50.
It is estimated that half of all proteins
undergo glycosylation
making it the most common post-translational modification.[1,2] The complex, nontemplated biosynthetic pathways that introduce N-
and O-linked glycans lead to high glycoprotein diversity, incorporating
large numbers of highly complex oligosaccharides.[3−5] While total
chemical synthesis of glycoproteins has recently gained in popularity,[6−9] methods for non-native glycan conjugation to make neoglycoproteins
(a glycoprotein with a non-native linkage)[10] remain important for glycoscience and glycotechnology.[11] For many years, nucleophilic lysine side chains
have been exploited through reductive amination[12] for the production of glycoconjugate vaccines.[13−15] However, this approach offers little control over the site or abundance
of glycosylation due to the high prevalence of lysine on the surface
of proteins.[16] Cysteine residues have instead
been used to gain more control, as their natural low surface abundance[17] makes them useful reactive handles in site-specific
protein engineering. Davis and co-workers, among others, have developed
many ways in which cysteine can be exploited for the production of
synthetic glycoproteins, including disulfide formation and chemical
mutagenesis via a dehydroalanine intermediate.[18−20] However, adding additional cysteine residues into a protein can
introduce potential challenges, including disruption of protein folding,
lowering expression levels.[21]Advances
in expanding the genetic code to introduce noncanonical
amino acids into proteins[22−25] have opened up new chemistries for protein modification,
including copper-catalyzed azide–alkyne cycloaddition (CuAAC).[26,27] However, despite the widespread application of the CuAAC reaction,
including in the glycosylation of engineered proteins,[19,28−31] the presence of copper catalyst used in CuAAC is not without its
pitfalls.[32] The use of cyclooctynes, rather
than unstrained alkynes, in azide–alkyne reactions offers an
alternative, copper-free biorthogonal route to covalent protein modification
reactions.[33,34] Such strain-promoted alkyne–azide
cycloaddition (SPAAC) reactions[33,34] have proved effective
for the synthesis of neoglycoproteins through genetic incorporation
of a bicyclononyne amino acid[35] or through
the use of cyclooctyne groups in complex multistep linker systems.[36]Another important objective for neoglycoprotein
preparation is
the derivatization of unprotected glycans with suitable reactive groups
for their attachment to the proteins.[37,38] In this regard,
oxime chemistry allows the latent aldehyde function of reducing sugars
to be exploited to make a hydrolytically stable linker.[39,40] The reaction can be catalyzed by anilines,[41−43] and is also
applicable to the modification of proteins containing aldehyde groups,
for example, through N-terminal oxidation.[44−47] We have previously used oxime
ligation to a protein-derived aldehyde in the preparation of neoglycoproteins,[44] in a case where CuAAC ligations with the protein
proved problematic. However, this approach required extensive chemoenzymatic
synthesis to generate complex derivatized glycans with a reactive
handle.In the work that we report here, our aim was to develop
a simpler,
flexible approach to neoglycoprotein synthesis that could be used
for the functionalization of either chemically derivatized or reducing
sugars. Our approach is to use a heterobifunctional linker, which
combines an alkoxyamine for oxime formation with a strained alkyne
for SPAAC conjugation (Figure ). Thus, a single linker could be used either to connect a
reducing sugar to an azide-functionalized protein or an azido-sugar
to a protein with an N-terminal serine or threonine residue (following
oxidation to generate an N-terminal glyoxyl residue).
Figure 1
Cartoon representation
of a bifunctional linker containing cyclooctyne
and oxyamine functionalities that can be used to attach carbohydrates
(yellow and blue circles) to proteins (orange) through oxime and SPAAC
ligations.
Cartoon representation
of a bifunctional linker containing cyclooctyne
and oxyamine functionalities that can be used to attach carbohydrates
(yellow and blue circles) to proteins (orange) through oxime and SPAAC
ligations.Our strategy is exemplified through the synthesis
of neoglycoprotein
inhibitors of cholera toxin adhesion. Cholera toxin produced by Vibrio cholerae is the archetypal example of the
AB5 bacterial toxin family that also includes E. coli heat-labile toxins and shiga-like toxins
that cause severe diarrheal diseases.[48] Cholera toxin has a single toxic A-subunit, which is an ADP-ribosyl
transferase that is delivered into cells by a pentameric B-subunit
(CTB) that is a sugar-binding protein that recognizes the glycolipid
ganglioside GM1 (monosialotetrahexosylganglioside) and fucosylated
structures.[49−51] Inhibition of these protein–carbohydrate interactions
can prevent the toxin from entering cells and thus prevent its toxic
effects. Multivalent glycoconjugates have frequently been investigated
as inhibitors of CTB adhesion.[52−55] We have previously reported that neoglycoproteins
based on a nonbinding mutant of the CTB (W88E, Figure ) that have glycans
matching the spacing and valency of the CTB binding sites are potent
inhibitors of CT adhesion.[44] Here, we investigate
the effect of linker length and site of attachment to the protein
scaffold on the activity of such inhibitors.
Results and Discussion
Synthesis of a New Bifunctional Linker
Among the many
strained alkynes that have been extensively reviewed,[24,56,57] bicyclo-[3.0.0]-nonyne (BCN)
reported by Dommerholt et al.[58] offered
a desirable combination of symmetry and short linker length while
maintaining a good balance between reaction kinetics and hydrophobicity.[34] The known exo- and endo-isomers of bicyclononyne alcohol 1(58) were each converted to phthalimide-protected
oxyamines 2 under Mitsunobu conditions in 71–86%
yield (Scheme ). The
free oxyamines 3 could be accessed following deprotection
of 2 by MeNH2 in anhydrous methanol. Oxyamines 3 were found to be particularly susceptible to reaction with
any traces of aldehydes or ketones present within the laboratory,
and so all further reactions involving 3 were performed
following in situ deprotection of 2 in
laboratories in which acetone was not in use.
Scheme 1
Synthesis of Novel
Bifunctional Linkers 3 and 5 Starting with
Either 1- Or 1-
(a) N-hydroxyphthalimide,
DIAD, PPh3, DCM, room temperature (rt), 5 h, 2- 71%; 2- 86%.
(b) Methanolic methylamine, rt, 5 min; 3- was isolated in 64%; 3- was
always used directly in subsequent reactions without isolation. (c)
Only the exo-isomer of 2 was used for
this reaction (i) NaOMe, MeOH, 30 min. (ii) MeI, MeOH, 1 h, quantitative.
(d) iPrMgBr, toluene, rt, 2 h, 60% yield.
Synthesis of Novel
Bifunctional Linkers 3 and 5 Starting with
Either 1- Or 1-
(a) N-hydroxyphthalimide,
DIAD, PPh3, DCM, room temperature (rt), 5 h, 2- 71%; 2- 86%.
(b) Methanolic methylamine, rt, 5 min; 3- was isolated in 64%; 3- was
always used directly in subsequent reactions without isolation. (c)
Only the exo-isomer of 2 was used for
this reaction (i) NaOMe, MeOH, 30 min. (ii) MeI, MeOH, 1 h, quantitative.
(d) iPrMgBr, toluene, rt, 2 h, 60% yield.While condensation of sugars with primary O-alkyloxyamines
typically leads to products with the open-chain oxime configuration,
condensation with N,O-dialkyloxyamines will lead
to glycosylamines that preserve the pyranose ring of the original
sugar.[59] Therefore, the N-methyl derivative 5 was synthesized from the exo-isomer of intermediate 2 using a different
deprotection strategy. The phthalimide protecting group was first
subjected to ring-opening with excess sodium methoxide followed by in situ methylation of the nitrogen using methyl iodide
to yield the Weinreb amide 4. Cleavage of Weinreb amide 4 using isopropyl Grignard reagent (step d in Scheme ) yielded linker 5 in 60% yield. The development of two differentiating deprotection
methods provides a facile route to both linkers 3 and 5 from the same intermediate.
BCN Derivatization of Reducing Sugars
Using lactose
as a model oligosaccharide (Scheme ), oxime ligation was carried out with linker 3- using either a methanol/chloroform
solvent mixture[60] or sodium acetate buffer
(pH 5).[61] In line with previous reports,
reactant concentrations of at least 250 mM were required for effective
conversion to oxime products.[62] The oxime
products were isolated in 69 and 73% yield, respectively. Conveniently,
the hydrophobic properties of the BCN group allow it to be exploited
as a “purification tag” for reverse-phase chromatography
of the conjugation product, thus separating it from the excess lactose.
NMR analysis of the glycoconjugate resulting from a reaction of lactose
and linker 3- showed it exists predominately
in the ring-open form with a ratio of 20:5:14 for isomers 6(E)/6(Z)/7 (Lac-BCN). Reaction of methylaminooxy
linker 5 with lactose was also achieved under the same
conditions to produce exclusively the ring-closed isomer 8 in 40% yield.
Scheme 2
Oxime Ligation of Exo-Linker 3 or 5 to
Unprotected Lactose
Conditions: (a) CHCl3–MeOH (1:1), 50 °C, 24 h (69% 6 + 7); (b) 1 M sodium acetate buffer, pH 5, 50 °C, 24–48
h (73% 6 + 7; 40% 8).
Oxime Ligation of Exo-Linker 3 or 5 to
Unprotected Lactose
Conditions: (a) CHCl3–MeOH (1:1), 50 °C, 24 h (69% 6 + 7); (b) 1 M sodium acetate buffer, pH 5, 50 °C, 24–48
h (73% 6 + 7; 40% 8).
Site-Specific SPAAC Glycosylation of Azido-CTB
We next
sought to use the strained alkyne derivative 6, generated
from lactose, to generate a neoglycoprotein. We used a nonbinding
CTB variant containing azidohomoalanine (Aha) in place of lysine 43
(Figure A, cyan).
We have previously reported an azido-CTB protein,[63] in which Aha was introduced through isosteric replacement
of methionine. In this protein, all native methionine residues had
been mutated to leucine, and a single methionine residue introduced
in place of lysine 43 (M37L-M68L-M101L-K43M). For this work, an additional
mutation of tryptophan 88 (Figure A,B, blue) to glutamate was required to remove the
protein’s native GM1 binding capability.[64] Methionine-auxotrophic E. coli (B834) were transformed with a plasmid (pSAB2.4) harboring the gene
for M37L-M68L-M101L-K43M-W88E CTB (Met-W88E). The protein
was overexpressed in a defined growth medium containing Aha in place
of methionine so that the expressed protein contained Aha at position
43 (M37L-M68L-M101L-K43Aha-W88E CTB; N-W88E).[65,66] Comparison of the deconvolved
electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectra with simulated isotope
patterns for the Aha and Met variants of the protein confirmed successful
incorporation of Aha over methionine in approximately 95% of the CTB
monomers (N-W88E) (Figure S5). Circular dichroism spectroscopy
confirmed N-W88E was identical to wild-type CTB, indicating that the protein was
correctly folded (Figure S6).
Figure 2
(A) Cartoon
(side view) and (B) surface representation (bottom
view) of the cholera toxin B-subunit (CTB) showing lysine 43 (cyan),
which is the site for introduction of azidohomoalanine (Aha); also
highlighted are tryptophan 88 (blue), which is mutated to glutamate
to provide a nonbinding CTB variant CTB-W88E, and threonine
1 (green), which can be oxidized by periodate to introduce an aldehyde
for oxime ligation. (C) Generation of N-W88E by site-directed mutagenesis of azido-CTB,
followed by SPAAC ligation of lactose derivative 6 and N-W88E. (D) Electrospray
ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) time course of SPAAC ligation
of N-W88E and lactose
derivative 6 over first 4 h shows complete conversion
of the azido-CTB to leave a mass spectrometry signal matching that
for the Met-W88E protein.
(A) Cartoon
(side view) and (B) surface representation (bottom
view) of the cholera toxin B-subunit (CTB) showing lysine 43 (cyan),
which is the site for introduction of azidohomoalanine (Aha); also
highlighted are tryptophan 88 (blue), which is mutated to glutamate
to provide a nonbinding CTB variant CTB-W88E, and threonine
1 (green), which can be oxidized by periodate to introduce an aldehyde
for oxime ligation. (C) Generation of N-W88E by site-directed mutagenesis of azido-CTB,
followed by SPAAC ligation of lactose derivative 6 and N-W88E. (D) Electrospray
ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) time course of SPAAC ligation
of N-W88E and lactose
derivative 6 over first 4 h shows complete conversion
of the azido-CTB to leave a mass spectrometry signal matching that
for the Met-W88E protein.Modification of N-W88E with strained alkyne 6 by SPAAC
(Figure C) under optimized
conditions (500 μM N-W88E, 10 equiv of 6, 37 °C, phosphate-buffered
saline (PBS) (pH 7.2)) led
to the quantitative conversion of Aha residues to the triazole derivative
within 4 h ((Lac)N-W88E) (Figure D). Analysis
by ESI-MS also revealed a peak corresponding to the mass of Met-W88E, consistent with the estimated 5% proportion of the
unmodified protein substrate (Figure D). Analysis by sodium dodecyl sulfate poly(acrylamide)
gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) showed only a single band for the neoglycoprotein
(Figure S15). Quantitative modification
of the Aha residues could also be achieved at lower protein concentrations
of N-W88E (100
μM) and 1.5 equiv of 6; however, reaction times
of 10–24 h were required.
Site-Specific N-Terminal Glycosylation of CTB
Having
demonstrated that linker 3 can be used to attach a reducing sugar
to an azide-functionalized protein, we then sought to apply the linker
for attaching an azide-functionalized sugar to a protein aldehyde.
For this study, we first functionalized CTB(W88E) with the endo isomer of oxyamine 3, which could then
be labeled using SPAAC ligation with a glycosyl azide (Figure A). The N-terminal threonine
residue of CTB-W88E (Figure A, green) was oxidized using 5 equiv of sodium
periodate in sodium phosphate buffer. This reaction typically reaches
completion within 5 min in sodium phosphate, whereas the reaction
does not reach completion in phosphate-buffered saline containing
potassium ions, as these are known to hinder periodate reactivity.[67] Oxime ligation of the oxidized-W88E (450 μM) with 10 equiv linker 3- in the presence of aniline (1% v/v) at 37 °C
reached completion within 16 h (Figure C). When the oxidized-W88E was used at
a concentration below 200 μM, a mixture of labeled product and
N-terminal cyclization was observed.[68] For
optimal oxime ligation reactions, an oxidized-W88E concentration
between 400 and 500 μM was required to obtain quantitative labeling
while minimizing precipitation of the product BCN-W88E.
Figure 3
(A) Generation of BCN-W88E by N-terminal oxime ligation
of endo-BCN-ONH23 to W88E, followed
by SPAAC ligation of lactosyl azide 9 and BCN-W88E. (B) ESI-MS of W88E before treatment with NaIO4. (C) ESI-MS of W88E following oxidation with
periodate, desalting and treatment of oxidized-W88E with and aniline, showing the quantitive
formation of BCN-W88E. (D) ESI-MS of SPAAC ligation of BCN-W88E and lactosyl azide 9 after 8 h. Formation
of triazole-W88E (11 730.0 Da) and (Glc)BCN-W88E (11 893.1 Da) as a result of fragmentation within the MS.
(A) Generation of BCN-W88E by N-terminal oxime ligation
of endo-BCN-ONH23 to W88E, followed
by SPAAC ligation of lactosyl azide 9 and BCN-W88E. (B) ESI-MS of W88E before treatment with NaIO4. (C) ESI-MS of W88E following oxidation with
periodate, desalting and treatment of oxidized-W88E with and aniline, showing the quantitive
formation of BCN-W88E. (D) ESI-MS of SPAAC ligation of BCN-W88E and lactosyl azide 9 after 8 h. Formation
of triazole-W88E (11 730.0 Da) and (Glc)BCN-W88E (11 893.1 Da) as a result of fragmentation within the MS.Lactosyl azide 9 was prepared from
lactose through
peracetylation and α-bromination at its reducing terminus,[69] followed by SN2 displacement with
sodium azide. After removal of the acetyl groups with sodium methoxide,
lactosyl azide 9 was conjugated to BCN-W88E using a SPAAC reaction to give (Lac)BCN-CTB in quantitative
yield in under 8 h. Analysis post-reaction by ESI-MS showed fragmentation
peaks corresponding to the loss of terminal galactose and lactose
(Figure D). The reaction
of BCN-W88E in the presence of sodium azide (10 equiv)
confirmed that no reaction occurs over the same time scale (Figure S12), demonstrating that the signal at
11 730 Da (Figure D) was the result of ion fragmentation rather than degradation
of the lactosyl azide prior to reaction with the protein. Furthermore,
the observation of a single band for the product in SDS-PAGE (Figure S16) was also consistent with the complete
reaction of the protein to give (Lac)BCN-W88E.
SPAAC Glycosylation for Synthesis of Neoglycoprotein Inhibitors
of Cholera Toxin Adhesion
Having shown that the nonbinding
CTB variant W88E could be functionalized with simple
disaccharides using linker 3, these glycosylation methods
were applied to the synthesis of a neoglycoprotein inhibitor of the
cholera toxin. Branson et al. used the W88E nonbinding
variant of CTB as a protein scaffold to develop the first neoglycoprotein-based
inhibitor of CTB that matched the geometry of each GM1 ligand with
the pentagonal symmetry of the target protein (Figure A).[44] The neoglycoprotein
was determined to be a highly potent inhibitor of cholera toxin adhesion,
with an IC50 of 104 pM. This evidence supports the idea
that the optimal design for multivalent inhibitors is to match the
distance and geometry of the target binding sites, a hypothesis that
also has support from theoretical studies on enhancing potency.[70] However, we were curious to investigate if changing
the site of glycosylation on the scaffold and length of linker might
affect the activity of such neoglycoproteins. Therefore, we sought
to attach the GM1 oligosaccharide to different sites on the CTB-W88E
variants using bioorthogonal linker 3 (Figure B,C).
Figure 4
(A) Synthetic approach
to a protein-based pentavalent neoglycoprotein
inhibitor by Branson et al. involved oxime ligation of a GM1 derivative
to the N-terminus of a nonbinding CTB variant.[44] (B) SPAAC ligation of a BCN-GM1 11 to the
nonbinding CTB variant with azidohomoalanine incorporated at position
43. (C) SPAAC ligation of β-GM1 azide 13 to the BCN-W88E where linker 3 was site-specifically
ligated to the N-terminus of W88E using oxime ligation.
(A) Synthetic approach
to a protein-based pentavalent neoglycoprotein
inhibitor by Branson et al. involved oxime ligation of a GM1 derivative
to the N-terminus of a nonbinding CTB variant.[44] (B) SPAAC ligation of a BCN-GM1 11 to the
nonbinding CTB variant with azidohomoalanine incorporated at position
43. (C) SPAAC ligation of β-GM1 azide 13 to the BCN-W88E where linker 3 was site-specifically
ligated to the N-terminus of W88E using oxime ligation.GM1os pentasaccharide 10 was produced
by enzymatic
hydrolysis of GM1 ganglioside in a 77% yield using Rhodococcus sp. endoglycoceramidase II (EGCase II, Scheme ).[71] Enzymatic
hydrolysis of GM1 ganglioside avoided the lengthy chemoenzymatic synthesis
used previously.[44,72] GM1os 10 was then
derivatized with linker 3- by oxime ligation at 50 °C for 48 h, to make GM1-BCN
11 (Scheme ). The 1H NMR spectra for GM1-BCN 11 indicated
the presence of several isomers corresponding to the E- and Z-oximes and β-N-glycoside.
Additional oxime signals increased in size over a period of 2 months,
which we tentatively assign as the manno-configured C-2 epimer of GM1-BCN 11 (see Supporting Information Figure S0).
Scheme 3
Enzymatic Hydrolysis of GM1 Ganglioside and Derivatization
of GM1
Oligosaccharide 10
(A) EGCase II, 50 mM
NaOAc buffer
(pH 5), triton X-100 (0.2%), 37 °C, 5 days, 77% yield. (B) 3-, 1 M NaOAc buffer (pH 5), 50 °C,
48 h, 24% yield. (C) NaN3, TEA, H2O, 37 °C,
48 h, ca. 90% conversion to glycosyl azide.
Enzymatic Hydrolysis of GM1 Ganglioside and Derivatization
of GM1
Oligosaccharide 10
(A) EGCase II, 50 mM
NaOAc buffer
(pH 5), triton X-100 (0.2%), 37 °C, 5 days, 77% yield. (B) 3-, 1 M NaOAc buffer (pH 5), 50 °C,
48 h, 24% yield. (C) NaN3, TEA, H2O, 37 °C,
48 h, ca. 90% conversion to glycosyl azide.Once again, the BCN group acted as a purification
tag, allowing
simple purification by reverse-phase chromatography and easy recovery
of the unreacted starting oligosaccharide. While the presence of the
ring-open form of reducing glucose unit differs from the structure
of native GM1, it is unlikely to have any impact on inhibition as
the glucose residue is not engaged in any interactions in the GM1
binding site.[73,74] Furthermore, multivalent glycoconjugates
of GM1 prepared by reductive amination, and thus fixed in the ring-open
form, are known to be effective inhibitors.[75−77] Nevertheless,
even if the ring-closed form were advantageous for binding, the oxime
derivatives are in equilibrium with the ring-closed glycosyloxyamines
and so the system could adopt that configuration if preferable.BCN-derivatized GM1 11 (10 equiv) was attached to N-W88E (500 μM),
and ESI-HRMS confirmed quantitative labeling of the Aha residues in
5 h to give neoglycoprotein (GM1)N-W88E (Figure B). SDS-PAGE analysis was similar to that for (Lac)N-W88E (Figure S15) confirming that this ligation method
is unaffected by increasing glycan complexity from a simple disaccharide
to a branched pentasaccharide.Complex glycosyl azides can be
prepared from their reducing sugars
using 2-chloro-1,3-dimethylimidazolinium chloride (DMC, 12).[35,78] DMC has previously been reported for derivatization
of sialylated N-linked glycans, but not apparently for ganglioside-derived
glycans. One-step conversion of GM1os pentasaccharide 10 to β-GM1 azide 13 was performed using
DMC 12 (10 equiv) and sodium azide (44 equiv) in the
presence of TEA (18 equiv) at 37 °C (Scheme ). NMR and thin-layer chromatography (TLC)
indicated that the reaction stopped after 90% conversion. Extending
reaction time to over 48 h and adding further equivalents of sodium
azide, DMC, or TEA had no further effect on the progress of the reaction.
Therefore, the crude β-GM1 azide 13 was used for
conjugation to BCN-W88E, resulting in complete conversion
of the protein to (GM1)BCN-W88E using the optimized SPAAC
conditions previously used for lactosyl azide 9 (Figure C).
Inhibitor Potency against CTB Binding to GM1
An enzyme-linked
lectin assay (ELLA) was used to determine the IC50 of neoglycoproteins (GM1)N-W88E and (GM1)BCN-W88E for the inhibition of wild-type CTB adhering
to ganglioside GM1-coated microtiter plates. The (GM1)N-W88E and (GM1)BCN-W88E neoglycoproteins were determined to have an IC50 of 457
and 924 pM, respectively (Figure and Table ). The analogous pentavalent lactose neoglycoprotein, (Lac)N-W88E, produced
by SPAAC of compound 6 and N-W88E, demonstrated no inhibition of wild-type
CTB binding to GM1 at concentrations up to 50 μM (data not shown).
Figure 5
Inhibition
of CTB–HRP conjugate binding to GM1-coated microtiter
plates by GM1os (data reproduced from ref (44) under the terms of a Creative
Commons Attribution License) and neoglycoproteins (GM1)N-W88E and (GM1)BCN-W88E, determined by enzyme-linked lectin assay (ELLA). Error bars indicate
the standard error of three measurements.
Table 1
Inhibitory Potential of the (GM1)N-W88E and (GM1)BCN-W88E Neoglycoproteins in Comparison to GM1os, as Determined by ELLA
inhibitor
valency
log(IC50)
IC50 (nM)a
relative potency (per GM1)b
GM1osc
1
–6.27 ± 0.04
530
1 (1)
GM1(CH2)11-W88Ec
5
–9.98 ± 0.08
0.104
5096
(1019)
(GM1)N3-W88E
5
–9.34 ± 0.02
0.457
1160 (231)
(GM1)BCN-W88E
5
–9.03 ± 0.07
0.924
574 (115)
As curve fitting was performed using
log(IC50) as x values, calculated uncertainties
in IC50 are asymmetric about the mean and have thus been
omitted.
Relative potency
values are quoted
compared to monovalent GM1os.
Data reported by Branson et al.[44] for monovalent GM1os and the previous
neoglycoprotein inhibitor GM1(CH)-W88E.
Inhibition
of CTB–HRP conjugate binding to GM1-coated microtiter
plates by GM1os (data reproduced from ref (44) under the terms of a Creative
Commons Attribution License) and neoglycoproteins (GM1)N-W88E and (GM1)BCN-W88E, determined by enzyme-linked lectin assay (ELLA). Error bars indicate
the standard error of three measurements.As curve fitting was performed using
log(IC50) as x values, calculated uncertainties
in IC50 are asymmetric about the mean and have thus been
omitted.Relative potency
values are quoted
compared to monovalent GM1os.Data reported by Branson et al.[44] for monovalent GM1os and the previous
neoglycoprotein inhibitor GM1(CH)-W88E.Both GM1os-based neoglycoprotein inhibitors demonstrate
over 100-fold
enhancement in potency compared to monovalent GM1os (based
on equivalent GM1os concentrations). Both neoglycoproteins
were comparable in potency to the GM1(CH)-W88E reported
previously (Table ).[44] Maintaining the same site of attachment
while decreasing the length of the linker between the pentavalent
scaffold and glycan or changing the site of glycosylation to the opposite
face of the protein scaffold led to IC50 values that were
within an order of magnitude of the GM1(CH)-W88E neoglycoprotein-based inhibitor. The fact that sub-nM IC50 values can be achieved across a range of neoglycoprotein designs
demonstrates the robustness of this strategy for the preparation of
multivalent inhibitors; the difference in potency between the neoglycoproteins
presented in this work and the previously reported neoglycoprotein
is minimal compared to the overall improvement observed over monovalent GM1os (Table ). Nonetheless, the strategy for modification of GM1os presented here was performed in a single step prior to protein conjugation,
compared to the lengthy chemoenzymatic synthesis of the inhibitor
utilizing 11-azidoundecyl GM1.[44,72]
Conclusions
Here, we have developed a dual biorthogonal
glycosylation strategy
for the site-specific engineering of synthetic glycoproteins. The
combination of two bioorthogonal reactive functional groups, oxyamine
and cyclooctyne, into a single linker has demonstrated this to be
a powerful method for synthetic glycosylation of proteins. The use
of a divergent deprotection strategy in the synthesis of the bifunctional
linkers 3 and 5 provides the opportunity
to access both ring-open and ring-closed glycoconjugates. Functionalization
of reducing oligosaccharides with linker 3 also facilitates
efficient reverse-phase purification of the products. While CuAAC
has often been used for the preparation of neoglycoproteins,[28−31] SPAAC has been rarely used for this application; with fast reaction
kinetics and high yields achieved, it offers a very convenient method
for the site-specific production of homogeneous glycoproteins. SPAAC
ligation of the BCN-glycan derivatives to azido-CTB(W88E) or functionalization
of CTB(W88E) with linker 3via oxime
ligation followed by SPAAC reaction with glycosyl azides both provide
efficient routes to the preparation of neoglycoproteins that are potent
multivalent inhibitors of cholera toxin adhesion. Altering the glycan
attachment sites on the protein scaffold leads to only small variations
in activity, demonstrating the robustness of a neoglycoprotein-based
inhibitor strategy for effective inhibition of lectin adhesion. The
bifunctional linkers described here could also be applied to the preparation
of other synthetic protein conjugates, e.g., antibody–drug
conjugates, or for glycosylation of other biomolecules, e.g., lipids or nucleic acids.
Methods
Synthesis of O-((1R,8S,9s)-Bicyclo[6.1.0]non-4-yn-9-ylmethyl)hydroxylamine
(3-) and Ganglioside GM1 Conjugates
Compound 1- ((1R,8S,9s)-bicyclo[6.1.0]non-4-yn-9-ylmethanol
(20 mg, 0.13 mmol)), triphenylphosphine (38 mg, 0.15 mmol), and N-hydroxyphthalimide (24 mg, 0.15 mmol) were dissolved in
anhydrous CH2Cl2 (1.2 mL) under a N2 atmosphere and chilled to 0 °C. Diisopropylazodicarboxylate
(29 μL, 0.15 mmol) was added dropwise, and the solution was
stirred for 10 min at 0 °C, after which the reaction was allowed
to warm at room temperature over 4 h. The reaction mixture was concentrated
in vacuo to yield a yellow residue. Purification by flash column chromatography
(1:9 EtOAc/hexane) yielded the title compound (2-) as a white crystalline solid (37 mg,
94%). Rf 0.58 (3:7 EtOAc/hexane); 1H NMR (500 MHz; CDCl3) δ 1.09–1.02
(m, 2H), 1.56 (app. pent, J = 8.5 Hz, 1H), 1.69–1.60
(m, 2H), 2.25–2.18 (m, 2H), 2.34–2.26 (m, 4H), 4.31
(d, J = 8.0 Hz, 2H), 7.75 (dd, J = 5.4, 3.1 Hz, 2H), 7.83 (dd, J = 5.4, 3.1, Hz,
2H); 13C NMR (125 MHz; CDCl3) δ 17.3,
20.8, 21.5, 29.3, 76.4, 99.0, 123.6, 129.1, 134.6, 163.8; high-resolution
mass spectrometry (HRMS) [ES+] C18H17NO3Na requires 318.1101. Found [M + Na]+ = 318.1099.
Compound 2- (20 mg, 68 μmol) was added
to anhydrous 2 M methanolic methylamine (0.169 mL, 339 μmol)
under nitrogen in an oven-dried flask. The reaction was monitored
by TLC and was found to be complete within 2 min. The product was
diluted in 1:9 EtOAc/hexane and purified by flash column chromatography
(1:9 EtOAc/hexane) to yield a colorless oil (7.2 mg, 64%). Rf 0.25 (3:7 EtOAc/hexane); 1H NMR
(500 MHz; CDCl3) δ 0.96–0.86 (m, 2H), 1.35–1.25
(m, 1H), 1.62–1.52 (m, 2H), 2.34–2.16 (m, 6H), 3.75
(d, J = 7.7 Hz, 2H), 5.41 (br. s, 2H); 13C NMR (100 MHz; CDCl3) δ 17.6, 20.0, 21.6, 29.4,
73.2, 99.1; HRMS [ES+] C10H16NO requires 166.1226.
Found [M + H]+ 166.1225.
β-d-Galactopyranosyl-(1→3)-2-acetamido-2-deoxy-β-d-galactopyranosyl-(1→4)-[(5-acetamido-3,5-dideoxy-d-glycero-α-d-galacto-non-2-ulopyranosylonic
acid)-(2→3)]-β-d-galactopyranosyl-(1→4)-d-glucopyranose (GM1os, 1 mg, 1 μmol) was
suspended in 1:1 CHCl3/MeOH (2 μL) in a 100 μL
PCR tube. Linker 3- (3 μL of
390 mM stock solution in 1:1 CHCl3/MeOH) was added to this
suspension, and the reaction was heated at 50 °C for 48 h using
a PCR thermocycler with a heated lid (105 °C). The crude mixture
was diluted to 100 μL with water, and the product was isolated
by reverse-phase extraction using a C18 SPE cartridge: excess GM1os was removed by extensive washing with water before elution
of the product in 20% aq methanol. The title compound 11, comprising a mixture of open-chain and cyclized isomers, was obtained
as a white solid by lyophilization (0.38 mg, 33%).
Method 2
GM1os (1 mg, 1 μmol) was
dissolved in H2O (2 μL) in a 100 μL PCR tube,
to which NaOAc buffer (1 μL of a 5 M stock solution, pH 5) and
linker 3- (2 μL of a 390 mM
stock solution in 1:1 CHCl3/MeOH) were added, and the reaction
was heated at 50 °C for 48 h using a PCR thermocycler with a
heated lid (105 °C). Completion of the reaction was confirmed
by TLC (2:2:1 BuOH/MeOH/H2O). The crude mixture was diluted
to 100 μL with water, and the product was isolated by reverse-phase
extraction using a C18 SPE cartridge: excess GM1os was
removed by extensive washing with water before elution of the product
in 20% aq methanol. The title compound 11, comprising
a mixture of open-chain and cyclized isomers, was obtained as a white
solid by lyophilization (0.28 mg, 24%).Rf 0.63 (2:2:1 BuOH/MeOH/H2O); 1H NMR
(500 MHz; D2O) δ 0.71–0.84 (m), 1.36–1.46
(m), 1.93 (t, 11.8 Hz), 2.00–2.05 (m), 2.12–2.21 (m),
2.25–2.35 (m), 2.40–2.47 (m), 2.64–2.68 (m),
3.29–4.19 (m), 4.30–4.32 (m, H1), 4.48–4.59 (m, H1″,1 H2), 4.74 (m), 4.93–4.99 (m, H2) 6.93 (d, J = 5.4 Hz, H1), 6.97 (d, J = 4.9 Hz, H1ep), 7.48 (d, J = 6.9 Hz, H1ep), 7.59
(d, J = 5.9 Hz, H1); HRMS C47H75N3O29 +
H requires 1146.4564. Found m/z [M
+ H]+ = 1146.4554.