J J De Schipper1,2, Ajm Hermans3, Adc Jaarsma4, F W Noordik5, S A Reijneveld3. 1. Netherlands School of Public and Occupational Health, Utrecht, The Netherlands. j.deschipper@nspoh.nl. 2. NSPOH C/O JJ de Schipper, Postbox 20022, Utrecht, 3502 LA, The Netherlands. j.deschipper@nspoh.nl. 3. Department of Health Sciences, University Medical Center, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands. 4. Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands. 5. Netherlands School of Public and Occupational Health, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Abstract
Evidence-based practice (EBP) significantly improves the quality of healthcare, but its use in community pediatrics has not yet been proven. We aimed to assess how Dutch community pediatricians use scientific findings and apply evidence-based practice in everyday well-child care. We interviewed a purposive sample of 14 community pediatricians in the Netherlands regarding their professional activities in daily practice, focusing on instances in which their professional knowledge was insufficient to address the issue at hand. We transcribed the interviews verbatim, and coded them using ATLAS.ti software. We structured the information using template analysis. Community pediatricians relied largely on guidelines of their own profession. If these were not sufficient, they first consulted other medical specialists or colleagues, or used different sources that they considered reliable. They only rarely performed an EBP search, and if so, only for somatic problems. For psychosocial problems, they used a strategy of extensive interaction with clients and members of multidisciplinary teams. We identified five barriers to performing an EBP search: (1) a conviction that not every community pediatrician needs to be able to perform an EBP search; (2) a conviction that an EBP search is not suitable for psychosocial problems; (3) lack of confidence in one's own abilities to perform an EBP search; (4) limited access to literature; (5) lack of time. CONCLUSIONS: Community pediatricians rely on professional guidelines; this indicates a need to keep these up-to-date and user-friendly. Furthermore, pediatricians should be better trained in performing EBP searches, and in working in multidisciplinary teams, especially for psychosocial problems. WHAT IS KNOWN: • Conducting an evidence-based practice search is considered indispensable to determine the best management of the patient's problem. • Conducting such a search is still considered challenging in many medical disciplines, including pediatrics. WHAT IS NEW: • There is a need to strengthen skills of community pediatricians to find evidence on psychosocial problems and to present this effectively in multidisciplinary teams. • The pediatricians' broad use of other sources of evidence, like experts and online sources, shows the importance of critical evaluation skills.
Evidence-based practice (EBP) significantly improves the quality of healthcare, but its use in community pediatrics has not yet been proven. We aimed to assess how Dutch community pediatricians use scientific findings and apply evidence-based practice in everyday well-child care. We interviewed a purposive sample of 14 community pediatricians in the Netherlands regarding their professional activities in daily practice, focusing on instances in which their professional knowledge was insufficient to address the issue at hand. We transcribed the interviews verbatim, and coded them using ATLAS.ti software. We structured the information using template analysis. Community pediatricians relied largely on guidelines of their own profession. If these were not sufficient, they first consulted other medical specialists or colleagues, or used different sources that they considered reliable. They only rarely performed an EBP search, and if so, only for somatic problems. For psychosocial problems, they used a strategy of extensive interaction with clients and members of multidisciplinary teams. We identified five barriers to performing an EBP search: (1) a conviction that not every community pediatrician needs to be able to perform an EBP search; (2) a conviction that an EBP search is not suitable for psychosocial problems; (3) lack of confidence in one's own abilities to perform an EBP search; (4) limited access to literature; (5) lack of time. CONCLUSIONS: Community pediatricians rely on professional guidelines; this indicates a need to keep these up-to-date and user-friendly. Furthermore, pediatricians should be better trained in performing EBP searches, and in working in multidisciplinary teams, especially for psychosocial problems. WHAT IS KNOWN: • Conducting an evidence-based practice search is considered indispensable to determine the best management of the patient's problem. • Conducting such a search is still considered challenging in many medical disciplines, including pediatrics. WHAT IS NEW: • There is a need to strengthen skills of community pediatricians to find evidence on psychosocial problems and to present this effectively in multidisciplinary teams. • The pediatricians' broad use of other sources of evidence, like experts and online sources, shows the importance of critical evaluation skills.
Authors: Maartje H J Swennen; Geert J M G van der Heijden; Hennie R Boeije; Nanda van Rheenen; Floor J M Verheul; Yolanda van der Graaf; Cor J Kalkman Journal: Acad Med Date: 2013-09 Impact factor: 6.893
Authors: D T Ubbink; H Vermeulen; A M Knops; D A Legemate; K Oude Rengerink; M J Heineman; Y B Roos; C J Fijnvandraat; H S Heymans; R Simons; M Levi Journal: Neth J Med Date: 2011-02 Impact factor: 1.422