First observation on emergence of strong room-temperature ferroelectricity and multiferroicity in 2D-Ti3C2T x free-standing MXene film.

Two-dimensional (2D) multiferroics are key candidate materials towards advancement of smart technology. Here, we employed a simple synthesis approach to address the long-awaited dream of developing ferroelectric and multiferroic 2D materials, especially in the new class of materials called MXenes. The etched Ti3C2T x MXene was first synthesized after HF-treatment followed by a delamination process for successful synthesis of free-standing Ti3C2T x film. The free-standing film was then exposed to air at room-temperature and heated at different temperatures to form a TiO2 layer derived from the Ti3C2T x MXene itself. The ferroelectric measurement showed a clear polarization hysteresis loop at room-temperature. Also, due to the reported ferromagnetic behavior of Ti3C2T x MXene, our composite could show multiferroic properties at room-temperature. The magnetoelectric coupling test was also performed that showed a clear, switchable spontaneous polarization under applied magnetic field. TiO2 is reported to be an incipient ferroelectric that assumes a ferroelectric phase in composite form. The structural and morphological analysis confirmed successful synthesis of free-standing film and the Raman spectroscopy revealed the formation of different phases of TiO2 and the observed ferroelectricity could be due to structural deformation as a result of the formation of this new phase. The measured value of remanent polarization is 0.5 μC cm-2. This is the first report on the existence of a ferroelectric phase and multiferroic coupling in 2D free-standing MXene film at room-temperature which opens-up the possibility of 2D material-based electric and magnetic data storage applications at room-temperature. This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry.

Introduction

Due to interesting physical and electronic properties for diverse applications, designing two-dimensional (2D) multiferroic materials has been a dream for researchers.[1-3] In multiferroics, two or more ferroic phases are coupled through piezoelectric, magnetoelastic or magnetoelectric (ME) interaction in such a way that one ferroic phase is tuned and controlled by another upon external perturbation and vice versa. In ME interaction, the magnetic field (or electric field) can tune the spontaneous polarization (or magnetization) in a single material or composite thus, providing a unique opportunity to develop smart sensors, non-volatile memories, small electronic devices, etc. that might lead to the miniaturization of electronic gadgets.[4] There are numerous reports on the existence of multiferroic phases in bulk materials however, the miniaturization of electronic devices requires developing multiferroicity in materials in low-dimensions.[5] One possible solution is to develop 2D materials that are smaller in size and easy to synthesize however to the best of our knowledge, experimentally the existence of ferroelectricity in MXenes, and two ferroic phases in 2D materials has not been realized yet. Experimental and theoretical reports on 2D ferroelectrics and multiferroics are listed in Tables 1 and 2.

Experimental and theoretical reports on 2D ferroelectrics

S. No.	Name	MXenes	2D Materials other than MXenes	Experimental/theoretical	Ref.
1	Sc2CO2	✓		Theoretical	6
2	Nb2NF2	✓		Theoretical	7
3	Ti3C2Tx	✓		Experimental	This work
4	SnS		✓	Experimental	8
5	SnSe		✓	Experimental	9
6	d1T-MoTe2		✓	Experimental	10
7	WTe2		✓	Experimental	11
8	BA2PbCl4		✓	Experimental	12
9	2H α-In2Se3		✓	Experimental	13
10	β′-In2Se3		✓	Experimental	14
11	In2Se3		✓	Experimental	15
12	α-In2Se3		✓	Experimental	16
13	SnTe		✓	Experimental	17
14	CnInP2S6		✓	Experimental	18

Experimental and theoretical reports on 2D multiferroics

S. No.	Name	MXenes	2D Materials other than MXenes	Experimental/theoretical	Ref.
1	Hf2VC2F2	✓		Theoretical	19
2	Ti3C2	✓		Experimental	This work
3	SnS		✓	Theoretical	20
4	SnSe		✓	Theoretical	20
5	GeS		✓	Theoretical	20
6	GeSe		✓	Theoretical	20
7	NiI2		✓	Theoretical	21

Ferroelectric materials possess an inherent switchable spontaneous polarization that can be tuned using an external electric field.[22] A very few 2D materials have been predicted to be ferroelectric and the experimental reports on 2D ferroelectrics are even rare. Molybdenum di-sulfide (MoS2), a candidate 2D material from transition metal chalcogenides (TMCs) family, is reported to reveal ferroelectricity under high pressure.[23] The authors created bi-domain polarization under mechanical stress leading to polar distortion in symmetric monolayers generating ferroelectric-type distortion. The binary oxides such as TiO2 are also important material candidates owing to potential applications in dielectric, photocatalysis, etc.[24] TiO2 is also known to be an incipient ferroelectric material that shows ferroelectricity in proximity in its composite form.[25] Y. Yu et al. reported successful generation of local broken symmetry causing observation of ferroelectricity in TiO2.[26] Theoretical predictions also suggest that under high mechanical or uniaxial strain, TiO2 can reveal ferroelectricity at room-temperature however, this is still to be observed experimentally.[25,27]

Transition metal carbides, known as MXenes with general chemical formula MXT, (where, M = Sc, Ti, V, Cr, Zr, Nb, Mo, Hf, Ta and X = C, N while n = 1,2,3), are emerging 2D materials owing to their rich physical and chemical properties suitable for vast avenue of applications such as in transparent conductors,[28,29] supercapacitors,[30-32] transistors,[33-35] electromagnetic shielding,[36] photocatalysis,[37]etc. Sunaina et al. reported presence of ferromagnetism in Ti3C2Tx MXene at room-temperature which was further enhanced upon doping with a magnetic element.[38] Similar studies were also reported in this compound suggesting that Ti3C2T is a good material candidate among MXene family that might be suitable for spintronic applications.[39] Another report on Nb2C MXene reported the diamagnetic-type superconductivity with relatively higher transition temperature of 12.5 K.[40] These reports clearly reveal the hidden potential of MXene in magnetic data storage devices, magnetic sensors, etc. Moreover, J. X. Low reported synthesis of Ti3C2-MXene/TiO2 composite formed by calcination at different temperatures which provides a scheme way to prepare Ti3C2-MXene composites useful for various applications.[41]

In this report, we have employed a simple and cost-effective strategy to develop ferroelectricity in free-standing Ti3C2T MXene film. Since TiO2 is reported to be an incipient ferroelectric, we assumed the emergence of ferroelectricity in MXene-derived TiO2/Ti3C2T free-standing film. To prepare this composite with an optimal TiO2 ratio in the composite, MXene was air-exposed at room-temperature and was heated at higher temperatures. The presence of TiO2 was confirmed using Raman spectroscopy technique. The ferroelectric testing performed at room-temperature clearly showed the ferroelectric hysteresis. Further, the magnetic testing of the free-standing composite film confirmed the existence of ferromagnetism in the compound thus, paving the way to create the multiferroicity in prepared composite. To confirm this assumption, magnetoelectric testing was also performed that showed a clear magnetic-field control of spontaneous polarization suggesting it to be a very good multiferroic 2D material. Our results, presented here, are the first report on existence of ferroelectricity and multiferroicity induced in MXene-derived TiO2/Ti3C2T free-standing film at room-temperature prepared using a simple synthesis approach which will open new avenues for 2D MXene multiferroics to be employed in electric and magnetic data storage applications.

Experimentation

Synthesis of Ti3C2T free-standing MXene film

Ti3C2T MXene was prepared by selectively eliminating ‘Al’ from the Ti3AlC2 MAX phase. The commercial grade Ti3AlC2 MAX powder was used. In a typical process, 1.0 g of sieved Ti3AlC2 MAX phase is immersed in the solution containing Hydrofluoric acid (≥48 wt%, 1 ml HF) (Sigma Aldrich), deionized water (3 ml DI) and hydrochloric acid (37 wt%, (12 M) 6 ml HCl) in a ratio of 1 : 3 : 6 (volume ratio) under constant stirring at 450 rpm for 24 hours at 35 °C. The sieved Ti3AlC2 powder was steadily added in increments over 5–8 min in a Teflon-lined reaction vessel before it was sealed. Once done, it was rinsed with DI multiple times. After each cycle, the supernatant was discarded to eliminate any undesirable adsorbed ions. The sediment was dispersed in DI until the pH reached 7. The etched powder was then collected by filtration and dried overnight at room temperature.

Subsequently, the multilayer (ML)-Ti3C2T MXene was delaminated using LiCl (lithium chloride, 99%).[42] The ML-MXene powder was dispersed in 20 ml of DI, 1 g of LiCl was then added, and the mixture was shaken hard for 8–10 min. The solution was then kept under constant stirring at 300 rpm for 24 h. The resulting intercalated dispersion was centrifuged with DI at 3500 rpm for 5 min; the centrifugation was performed repeatedly until a stable colloidal MXene solution was achieved. Following separation, additional DI was added to the sediment, which was then re-dispersed and centrifuged again. This was repeated until the supernatant produced was dilute. The resulting wet sediment formed a clay-like paste which was centrifuged for 30 min at 3500 rpm to ensure that no ML powder remained. The supernatant MXene solution that remained stable after extended centrifugation was vacuum filtered via Celguard membranes, which were then used to form free-standing films (Fig. 1). The thickness of synthesized Ti3C2T free-standing MXene film was measured by using micro screw gauge which is ∼21 μm. Generally, centrosymmetry is broken when 2D material's surfaces are asymmetrically functionalizes that results in out of plane polarization. So, the 2D layered structure of MXene is favorable for the induction of ferroelectricity if the desired functional groups i.e. O, OH, S, Cl or F are attached on the surface of MXene that play a big role to tune their electronic properties. So, heat treatment is done for the oxidation of Ti3C2T MXene which results in formation of TiO2 which possibly give rise to non-centrosymmetric structure that probably induced the coexistence of in-plane and out of plane electric polarization under the application of external field.[43] For oxidation, it was reported that Ti3C2T gets optimum oxidation by heat treatment.[41] So, the synthesized Ti3C2T MXene film was heat-treated for 2 hours at 100OC (namely HT@100 °C), 150 °C (namely HT@150 °C), and 300 °C (namely HT@300 °C) under an ambient environment.

Fig. 1

Synthesis scheme for production of de-laminated Ti3C2T MXene film.

Ferroelectric/multiferroic measurement setup

For ferroelectric/multiferroic testing, the precision tester from Radiant Technologies Inc. was used. The sample stage for mounting the sample is shown in Fig. 2(a). The prepared Ti3C2T free-standing MXene film was mounted on sample stage has dimensions of about 0.2 cm × 0.4 cm having thickness ∼21 μm. While the copper wire was used to make connection between pins of sample stage (Return (R) and Derive (D)) and Ti3C2T free-standing MXene film as shown in schematic in Fig. 2(b).

Fig. 2

(a) Sample stage, (b) Ti3C2T free-standing MXene film with electrical connections.

Result and discussion

Crystallographic studies of received MAX and synthesized MXene were carried out through X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis (Fig. 3a). The XRD pattern of Ti3AlC2 MAX phase is in good agreement with the literature,[42] referring to JCPDS card# 52-0875. As can be seen from XRD pattern, our MAX phase is free of impurities. After the acidic etching and delamination, as expected, (00l) preferential symmetry of basal planes is observed in MXene flakes (indigo). All the peaks beyond 2θ = 30° are absent in contrast to MAX phase. Also, the higher order (00l) peaks are of very weak intensity. A significant downshifting of (002) peak from 2θ = 9.6° to 2θ = 5.4° is a clear indication of complete exfoliation of MXene via removal of Aluminum layers.[44] This downshift towards a lower angle resulted in an increase in the c-lattice parameter from 18.4 Å of MAX to 32.8 Å in MXene and an increased d-spacing from 9.2 Å to 16.4 Å. The oxidation reflections are not visible in the XRD pattern which is due to the low fraction and smaller size of TiO2 crystallites[45] however, the oxidation of MXene under room-temperature is a well-known phenomenon.[46,47]Fig. 3b exhibits the scanning electron micrograph (SEM) image of the bulk MAX phase while Fig. 3c is the cross-sectional image of delaminated Ti3C2T MXene. The morphological image clearly suggests the successful formation of de-laminated MXene with well separated sheets.

Fig. 3

(a) XRD pattern of Ti3C2Tx MXene (purple) and heat-treated Ti3C2T MXene film (green); inset: XRD of Ti3AlC2 MAX phase, (b) SEM micrographs of Ti3AlC2 MAX and (c) De-laminated Ti3C2Tx MXene film.

Structural and phase transformations were studies through analysis of Raman spectra of the air exposed films heated at 100 °C and 300 °C (Fig. 4). The peaks present at 154 cm−1, 409 cm−1 and 514 cm−1 are ascribed to TiO2 anatase phase.[46,47] The peaks at 154 cm−1, 260 cm−1 and 604 cm−1 confirm the presence of rutile phase.[48] Formation of anatase and rutile phases is due to the partial oxidation of Ti3C2T MXene over the air exposure and heating effects. Moreover, a long time air exposure as well as heating at high temperature resulted in emergence of another phase, i.e. brookite phase of TiO2. The peaks at 197 cm−1 and 409 cm−1 in ambient oxidized and 300 °C heat-treated systems are attributed to the brookite phase of TiO2. These modes were not observed in the sample heated at relatively lower temperature (around 100 °C).[49-52] When heated at high temperature, two broader peaks at ≈1390 cm−1 and ≈1590 cm−1 are characterized as G and D bands of graphitic carbon. Broadening of D and G bands is an evidence of disordered or oxidized carbon, similar to what has been reported for graphene.[53] Presence of TiO2 on the carbon sheets implies that the Ti atoms present in the inner MXene sheets have migrated to the top surface to react with oxygen leaving behind the defects. This kind of outward migration of Ti atoms is similar to the previous studies carried out on TiN.[54,55]

Fig. 4

Raman Spectra of oxidized air-exposed (dark green) and heat-treated samples at 100 °C (orange) and 300 °C Ti3C2T MXene film.

Fig. 5 presents unique ferroelectric, and multiferroic results of the heat-treated de-laminated free-standing Ti3C2T MXene film. Fig. 5a shows spontaneous polarization vs. electric-field hysteresis loops for samples heated at 100 °C (left vertical column) and 150 °C (right vertical column) measured at room-temperature and frequency of 10 Hz that show clear ferroelectric hysteresis effect. As the electric-field is increased, the polarization increases as well due to alignment of the electric dipoles along the electric-field and reaches to the saturation value (maximum polarization) of 1 μC cm−2 and 0.6 μC cm−2 for HT@100 °C and HT@150 °C, respectively at +4 kV cm−1. When the electric field is reduced to zero, the polarization falls to a non-zero remanant polarization value of 0.5 μC cm−2 and 0.28 μC cm−2 respectively for HT@100 °C and HT@150 °C which is a typical signature of hysteresis effect. It is important to note that the polarization–voltage measurements were also performed for air-exposed sample as well as the ones heated at temperatures higher than 150 °C (Fig. S1†) but the ferroelectric hysteresis effect was not observed. The polarization–voltage curve showed typical conductive behavior which either could be due to the under-formed or over-formed TiO2 phase. This concludes that the induced ferroelectric effect remains stable for a narrow temperature range forming a suitable TiO2/Ti3C2T composite ratio. The inset of Fig. 5a shows current–voltage (I–V) measurements performed for HT@100 °C at room-temperature. The current is slightly asymmetric being higher for negative polarity and lower for positive polarity. The I–V results present a typical polarization-switching induced leakage current which is a characteristic of the ferroelectric material.[56,57]Fig. 5b represents electric field versus time (red) and polarization versus time (orange) measurements. The electric field follows linear change with time in positive and negative polarity which polarizes the electric dipoles along positive and negative directions, respectively indicating fine tuning of the polarization. Also, the polarization curve at minimum (0 s) and maximum (100 s) time shows non-zero values which is due to the remanent effect. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first experimental report on existence of ferroelectricity in 2D MXene especially in the de-laminated free-standing film at room-temperature. One possibility for observation of this ferroelectricity in heat-treated MXene is the emergence of TiO2 phase after heat treatment within Ti3C2T MXene. Montanari et al.[58] performed density function calculations on rutile TiO2 and concluded that it can show ferroelectricity under a uniaxial strain or a negative pressure. Yong Liu et al. also predicted a negative pressure induced ferroelectric phase in TiO2.[25] A. Grunebohm et al. computationally studied the effect of strain which induced ferroelectricity in TiO2 and concluded that even a non-uniaxial strain could induce a ferroelectric phase in TiO2 where a small change in strain could produce a large spontaneous polarization.[27] The bond length between Ti–O is also reported to be a key parameter in determining proximity for inducing ferroelectricity where a small perturbation could drive the system ferroelectric.[59-61]Fig. 5c shows the butterfly-like dielectric constant-electric field hysteresis loops measured for HT@100 °C at room-temperature. It is to be noted that the dielectric constant data is plotted for 1000 cycles that shows its high stability. The dielectric constant is initially small due to the small poling but increases at higher electric field and reaches the maximum at around the coercive field. At values closer to the saturation values of polarization, it reduces to its minimum value because all the dipoles get aligned and are unable to respond further to the increase in electric field.[62]

Fig. 5

(a) Ferroelectric hysteresis loops measured for heat-treated de-laminated Ti3C2T MXene film at 100 °C (left vertical column) & 150 °C (right vertical column); inset shows typical leakage current vs. voltage that corresponds to the ferroelectric materials, (b) electric field (left vertical column) and electric polarization (right vertical column) versus time for heat-treated sample at 100 °C, (c) typical dielectric constant as a function of electric fields for heat-treated sample at 100 °C; the data is presented for 1000 cycles showing its reproducibility and stability, (d) the magnetoelectric coupling coefficient versus magnetic-field measured for heat-treated sample at 100 °C.

In order to observe the multiferroic effect in Ti3C2T MXene film, the material must possess at least two ferroic orders (ferromagnetic, ferroelectric, etc.) simultaneously. In an earlier literature, Sunaina et al. reported the existence of ferromagnetism in Ti3C2T MXene at room-temperature.[38] Since, our MXene showed a good ferroelectric response, it could show a multiferroic behavior as well because it was already reported to be a ferromagnet at room-temperature. The results presented in Fig. 5(a–c) clearly suggest that our heat-treated Ti3C2T MXene film could behave like a multiferroic 2D material which can be confirmed by ME coupling effect.

Fig. 5d shows magnetoelectric results of heat-treated Ti3C2T free-standing film measured at room-temperature using multiferroic/ferroelectric precision tester from Radiant Technologies Inc. The figure shows the magnetoelectric coupling coefficient versus applied magnetic field measured at room-temperature. The ME coefficient displays obvious peaks at specific magnetic field values which are close to the magnetic coercivity of the material itself. This suggests that the magnetic domains are strongly coupled with the electric domains which are well-tuned by the external magnetic field at room-temperature. Thus, our heat-treated Ti3C2T film proved to possess strong multiferroic property due to the existence of ferroelectric as well as ferromagnetic orders. It is pertinent to mention that our report is the first experimental evidence on existence of multiferroicity in MXene, especially in the 2D de-laminated free-standing Ti3C2T MXene film. Further studies on this effect in layered materials could enhance practical application scope of MXene in electric and magnetic data storage devices in the fields of spintronics and MXetronics.

Conclusion

We employed a simple approach to induce ferroelectricity and multiferroicity in free-standing heat-treated Ti3C2T MXene film at room-temperature. The successful synthesized free-standing Ti3C2T MXene, the films were heated at different temperatures produce TiO2 layer on top of the Ti3C2T MXene. Raman spectroscopy confirmed the presence of rutile and anatase phases of TiO2. The composite film was tested for ferroelectric measurement that showed a clear hysteresis effect. The measured value of remanent polarization is 0.5 μC cm−2. The effect was attributed to proximity-induced ferroelectricity in TiO2 which was predicted before. Since, Ti3C2T MXene film also reported to be a soft ferromagnet hence, we assumed that the composite film may also possess multiferroic property. To verify this assumption, the magnetoelectric (ME) testing was performed at room-temperature. Interestingly, the film showed a strong ME coupling with a good control of spontaneous polarization via external magnetic field revealing the emergence of strong multiferroic effect as well. Our report is first experimental report on observation ferroelectric as well as multiferroic property in de-laminated heat-treated Ti3C2T MXene film at room-temperature and presents MXene as the potential 2D material candidate for future data storage devices.

Data availability

The data will be available on demand.

Author contributions

Rabia Tahir performed testing and analysis of results, Syedah Afsheen Zahra prepared MXene paper, Usman Naeem helped in sample preparation, Deji Akinwande helped in analysis of results and Syed Rizwan conceived the idea, performed the measurement and analysis.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.