| Literature DB >> 36034476 |
Meriem Amine1, Wiam Merdma2, Khalid El Boussiri3.
Abstract
Purpose: The objective of this work is to study galvanic corrosion of different couples of prosthetic and implant alloys through the realization of a systematic review. Materials andEntities:
Year: 2022 PMID: 36034476 PMCID: PMC9410998 DOI: 10.1155/2022/4575416
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Dent ISSN: 1687-8728
Figure 1PRISMA flowchart for study selection.
The evaluation of corrosion resistance of the different galvanic couples.
| Study | Galvanic couples | Environment, pH, period, method, area ratio, etc. | Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soares et al. 2021 [ | Annealed microstructured cp Ti G4/CoCrMo | (i) 0.9% NaCl and BB at 225 ppm F at pH 6 and 2 | (i) Acid-treated cp Ti G4 and UFG Ti exhibited better corrosion resistance compared to cp Ti G4 |
| Cp Ti G4 acid treated/CoCrMo UFG Ti1/CoCrMo | (ii) Naturally airy. | (ii) The galvanic couple with the lowest current was nanostructured Ti cp in contact with CoCrMo alloy | |
| (iii) 24 H | |||
| (iv) OCP2 and ZRA3 | |||
| (v) 0.2 | |||
| Mellado–Valero et al. 2018 [ | Ti G2/Au | (i) AS4, SAF pH 6.5, and SAF pH 3 | (i) The NiCrTi alloy shows a very narrow passive |
| Ti G2/NiCrTi | (ii) OCP, CP5, and ZRA. | (ii) Domain, exhibiting transpassive dissolution at most | |
| Ti G2/CoCr | (iii) 30 min for OCP and hours 4 for CP | (iii) Low potential values compared to other materials | |
| Ti G2/CoCr-c | (iv) 0.28: CoCr-c and NiCrTi | (iv) The TiG2/Ti6Al4V couple shows no galvanic effect | |
| Ti G2/Ti6Al4V | (v) 0.5: CoCr, Ti6Al4, and AuPd | ||
| Bortagaray et al. 2016 [ | Ti cp/noble alloys | (i) AS pH 7, 1 | Noble alloys with high gold and palladium content combined with cp titanium implants showed high resistance to galvanic corrosion |
| (ii) Analytical technique by static immersion—3 months | |||
| Cp Ti/Cp Ti | |||
| Ziębowicz, A. et al. 2015 [ | Cp Ti c/Ti6Al4V | (i) A mandibular bone in | Galvanic corrosion hardly occurs in case of coupling between Cp Ti/Ti6Al4V |
| (ii) Tyrode's solution, 37 ± 1°C | |||
| (iii) CP, and EIS6 | |||
| (iv) 6 months | |||
| (v) 1 | |||
| Sola C. 2013 [ | Cp Ti/noble alloys (Pontor®2) | (i) AS, pH of 7.1–37°C | The noble alloy/Ti couple proved to be the most resistant galvanic couple, whereas the noble alloy/Ti6Al4V couple presents the lowest corrosion resistance |
| Ti 6Al4V/noble alloys (Pontor®2) | (ii) OCP, CP, EIS | ||
| (iii) 24 H | |||
| (iv) 0.9 | |||
| Cp Ti/metallic ceramics (NiCr) | (i) SA pH of 7.5 -(ii) NaF added to AS: 3 different concentrations were tested | (i) The best corrosion resistance was presented by the cp Ti pairs compared to the other pairs where the implant was Ti6Al4V | |
| Cp Ti/ceramics | (ii) Titanium implants paired with ceramic-ceramic | ||
| Ti 6Al4V/CM (NiCr) | (iii) Crowns showed the highest corrosion resistance rates compared to the other pairs tested | ||
| Ti 6Al4V/ceramics | (iii) M NaF, M 0,05 NaF and M 0, 1 NaF | (iv) However, the best couple was cp Ti/ceramic | |
| (iv) OCP and EIS | |||
| Tuna et al. 2009 [ | Cp Ti (G4)/Pd | (i) AS, pH 6.7, at 37°C | The cp Ti G4/noble alloys pair showed a galvanic corrosion potential value significantly lower than that of the cp Ti G4/CoCr and cp Ti G4/NiCr pairs and therefore a better resistance to galvanic corrosion |
| Cp Ti (G4)/Au | (ii) PD7, OCP, | ||
| Cp Ti (G4)/NiCr | (iii) 14 H | ||
| Cp Ti (G4)/CoCr | (iv) 0.33 | ||
| Arslan H. et al. 2008 [ | Ti 6Al4V/Au | (i) Ringer at 37°C | The Ti6Al4V/Au pair had the highest resistance to galvanic corrosion, while the Ti6Al4V/NiCr couple presented the least |
| Ti 6Al4V/NiCr | (ii) Absence of oxygen | ||
| Ti 6Al4V/CoCr | (iii) Cp, mixed potential theory | ||
| Oh et Al 2004 [ | Ti cp (G3)/Au | (i) AS at 37°C | The Ti cp (G 3)/Ti cp (G 3) and Ti cp (G3)/gold pairs exhibited relatively low passive current densities. While the implant pairs Co-Cr/Ti and NiCr/Ti had the highest values |
| Ti cp (G3)/NiCr | (ii) OCP, PS8, and PD | ||
| Ti cp (G3)/CoCr | (iii) 5 000s | ||
| Ti cp (G3)/Ti cp (G3) | |||
| Taher and Jabab 2003 [ | Ti cp (G1)/Au | (i) AS fusayama modified at pH: 7,2 | The best couples were Ti/Ti cp, Ti/Or and Ti/Co- Cr, while the Ti/Ni–Cr couple showed unstable galvanic corrosion behavior |
| Ti cp (G1)/NiCr | (ii) Potentiostat | ||
| Ti cp (G1)/CoCr | (iii) 24 H | ||
| Ti cp (G1)/cp Ti (G1) | (iv) 0.78 | ||
| Cortada et al. 2000 [ | Ti cp (G1)/Au | (i) AS, pH: 6.7 at 37° | The titanium implant coupled with a nickel-chromium alloy releases a large amount of ions and the implant coupled with the titanium superstructure has low values of released ions |
| Ti cp (G1)/Pd | (ii) OCP, PD, potentiostat | ||
| Ti cp (G1)/NiCr | (iii) 250 min | ||
| Ti cp (G1)/Ti cp (G2) cast | (iv) 1 | ||
| Ti cp (G1)/Ti cp (G2) machined | |||
| Grosgogeat et al. 1999 [ | Ti cp/CoCr | (i) AS aerated AFNOR pH at 6.737°C | (i) The most unfavorable situation is when a small anode is linked to a large cathode |
| Ti 6Al4V/CoCr | (ii) AS deaerated fusayama 37°C, pH 5 | (ii) There are other possible types of corrosion to consider in addition to galvanic corrosion, such as pitting and crevice corrosion | |
| (iii) OCP, PD, and potentiostat | |||
| (iv) 24 H for OCP | |||
| (v) 15 H for ZRA | |||
| (vi) 1 | |||
| Venugopalan and Lucas 1998 [ | Cp Ti (G2)/Au | (i) AS fusayama 37 | (i) Precious alloys (based on au, Ag, and pd) coupled with titanium were found to be the least susceptible to galvanic corrosion |
| Cp Ti (G2)/AgPd | (ii) OCP and PD | (ii) NiCr and CoCr based alloys coupled to titanium were moderately susceptible to galvanic corrosion | |
| Cp Ti (G2)/CoCrMo | (iii) 6 hours | (iii) Mo added to Ni–Cr based alloys plays a protective role against corrosion while Be has a negative influence | |
| Cp Ti (G2)/NiCrMo | |||
| Cp Ti (G2)/NiCr | |||
| Cp Ti (G2)/NiCrBe | |||
| Reclaru and Meyer 1994 [ | Cp Ti G4/Au | (i) AS fusayama pH 5, 37°C | (i) The coupling of titanium with nonprecious alloys presents a negligible risk with respect to crevice corrosion |
| Cp Ti (G4)/CoCr | (ii) OCP and PD | (ii) Mo added to non-precious alloys plays a protective role against corrosion | |
| Cp Ti (G4)/FeNiCr | (iii) 24 H | ||
| Cp Ti (G4)/NiCrMo | (iv) 1 | ||
| Ravnholt 1988 [ | Cp Ti/Au | (i) Solution de NaCl à 1% aérée | No corrosion current was recorded when gold and CoCr were in contact with titanium |
| Cp Ti/CoCr | (ii) pH 6,25 ± 0.25 à 37 ± 1°c | The changes occurred when the amalgam was in contact with the titanium | |
| PD, potentiostat | |||
| 20 days |
1UFG Ti: ultrafine grained titanium; cold worked nanostructured cp Ti G4; 2OCP: open circuit potential; 3ZRA: zero-resistance-ammeter; 4AS : artificial saliva; 5CP: potentiodynamic curves; 6EIS : electrochemical impedance spectroscopy; 7PD : potentiodynamic curves; 8PS : potentiostatic test.
The influence of fluorinated and acidic media on the galvanic corrosion resistance of the different galvanic couples.
| Study | Galvanic couples | Environment, pH, period, method, area ratio, etc. | Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soares et al. 2021 [ | Microstructured annealed Ti G4/CoCrMo | 0.9% NaCl and BB at 225 ppm of F2 at pH 6 and pH 2 Naturally airy. 24 HOCP3, ZRA4.0.2 | (i) The corrosion resistance of the different couples decreased in the mouthwash solution. |
| Acid-treated Cp Ti G4/CoCrMo | (ii) As the solution became more acidic, an increase in galvanic current values was observed. | ||
| Ti UFG1 / CoCrMo | |||
| Barros, camila 2020 [ | Ti6Al4V/NiCr | (i) 0.9% NaCl at 227 ppm of F-, 2270 ppm F− and 12300 ppm F− | (i) The corrosion resistance of Ti6Al4V decreases with increasing fluoride concentration. |
| (ii) pH 5, 5 and 4, 0 | (ii) This decrease in resistance is more important in an acidic | ||
| (iii) OCP | (iii) Environment fluorinated except ppm 227 of F− at pH 5.5. | ||
| (iv) 15 days | |||
| (v) 1 | |||
| Mellado-valero et al. 2018 [ | Ti G2/Au | (i) ASF pH 6, 5 and ASF pH3 | (i) In the ASF pH 6.5. |
| Ti G2/NiCrTi | (ii) The galvanic corrosion resistance has decreased compared to the results obtained in AS. | ||
| Ti G2/CoCr | (ii) OCP, CP5 and ZRA. | (iii) In the ASF pH 3. | |
| Ti G2/CoCr-c | (iii) 30 min for OCP and 4 hours CP | (iv) The NiCr/Ti alloy loses its passivity and actively dissolves. | |
| Ti G2/Ti6Al4V | (iv) 0.28: CoCr-c and NiCrTi | (v) The TiG2/Ti6Al4V couple shows a huge increase in corrosion rates. | |
| (v) 5: CoCr, Ti6Al4V, AuPd | (vi) The Au alloy showed the most noble electrochemical behavior among all the materials studied. | ||
| Anwar, E.M. et al. 2011 [ | Cp Ti/CM6 (NiCr) | (i) AS pH of 7.5 | The addition of fluoride caused a significant decrease in the corrosion resistance of various couples, mainly those of Ti6Al4V. |
| Cp Ti/CC7 | (ii) NaF added to AS: three different concentrations were tested: | ||
| Ti 6Al4V/CM (NiCr) | (iii) 0, 01 M, M 0, 05 and 0.1 M | ||
| Ti6Al4V/CC | (iv) OCP and EIS8 |
1Ti UFG: cold worked nanostructured cp Ti G4;2 F: fluoride; 3OCP: open circuit potential; 4ZRA: zero-resistance-ammeter; 5PC: potentiodynamic curves; 6CM: ceramic-metal; 7CC: all-ceramic; 8EIS : Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy.
The evaluation of the oxidation surface.
| Study | Galvanic couples | Environment, pH, period, method, area ratio, etc. | Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barros, camila 2020 [ | Ti6Al4V/NiCr | (i) 0.9% NaCl at 227 ppm of F−, 2270 ppm of F− | A significant increase in roughness with increasing fluoride concentration and decreasing pH; the surface of Ti6Al4V coupled with NiCr of 12300 ppm F− solution at pH 4.0 showed an increase in roughness compared to that of 227 ppm F− solution at pH 5.5. |
| (ii) 12300 ppm of F−, pH 5,5 and 4,0 | |||
| (iii) Confocal microscope | |||
| (iv) 15 days | |||
| (v) 1 | |||
| Tuna et al. 2009 [ | Ti cp (G 4)/Pd | (i) AS, pH 6.7, at 37°C | Significant fractures were observed by SEM on the surface of the superstructures of the Ti cpG4/NiCr and Ti cp/CoCr pairs. However, there were still few unaffected areas appearing weakly attached to the surface that could be detected. When the surfaces of the Ti cp/Pd and Au materials were studied, almost no visible effect has been revealed. |
| Ti cp (G 4)/Au | (ii) Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) | ||
| Ti cp (G 4)/NiCr | (iii) 14 H | ||
| Ti cp (G 4)/CoCr | (iv) 0.33 | ||
| Oh and Kim 2004 [ | Ti cp (G3)/gold | (i) AS at 37°C | Black spots were observed by SEM on the surface of the titanium connectors in all pairs. |
| Ti cp (G 3)/NiCr | (ii) Optical microscope. | ||
| Ti cp (G 3)/CoCr | (iii) 5000s | ||
| Ti cp (G 3)/Ti cp (G 3) |
The evaluation of metal ion release.
| Study | Galvanic couples | Environment, pH, period, method, area ratio, etc. | Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barros and Camila 2020 [ | Ti6Al4V/NiCr | (i) 0.9% NaCl at 227 ppm of F−, 2270 ppm of F, and 12300 ppm of F−, pH 5,5 and 4,0 | A concentration of released Ti ions of 174.05 ppm in 12300 ppm of F− at pH 4.0 and 0.059 ppm in 227 ppm of F− at pH 5.5. |
| (ii) ICP-MS1 | Quantification for V ions gave 0,54 ppm in 12300 ppm of F− at pH 4.0 and 0,028 ppm in 227 ppm of F− at pH 5.5. | ||
| (iii) 15 days | |||
| (iv) 1 | |||
| Bortagaray et al. 2016 [ | Ti cp/noble alloys | (i) AS pH 7,1 | Noble alloys with high gold and palladium content combined with cp titanium implants showed minimal release of metal ions into the environment. |
| Ti cp/Ti cp | (ii) Analytical technique by static immersion. | ||
| (iii) 3 months | |||
| Lee JJ. et al. 2015 [ | Ti cp/Ni–Cr–Be | (i) DMEM2 + des | Release of metal ions was enhanced by galvanic corrosion due to contact between the base metal and titanium. |
| Ti cp/NiCr | (ii) L-929 mouse | The amount of metal ions released and the cytotoxicity of the Ni–Cr alloy with beryllium was greater than that of other Ni–Cr alloys not containing beryllium. | |
| Ti cp/Ni-high Cr | (iii) Fibroblast cells. | ||
| (iv) ICP-MS, | |||
| (v) 48 hours | |||
| Yamazoe M. 2010 [ | Ti cp et Ti6Al4V/Ti cp, Ti6Al4V | (i) Lactic acid at 1% at 37°C | The level of Ti ion release was influenced by the microstructure of titanium. It was lower when the grain size was smaller. In the titanium-titanium combinations, the differences in the microstructure of the metal also markedly influenced the ionic release. |
| Ti/noble alloys | (ii) ICPE3, SCLM4 | ||
| With different surface roughness | (iii) 3 months | ||
| Tuna et al. 2009 [ | Cp Ti (G4)/Pd | (i) SA, pH 6.7, at 37°C | Higher total ionic concentration was observed in nonprecious alloys while precious alloys and titanium had much lower ionic concentration. |
| Cp Ti (G4)/Au | (ii) ICP-MS, | ||
| Cp Ti (G4)/NiCr | (iii) 14 H | ||
| Cp Ti (G4)/CoCr | (iv) 0.33 | ||
| Foti et al. 1999 [ | Cp Ti/precious alloy | (i) 8 implants Ti cp in the mandible of three primates | (i) After 2 months. |
| Cp Ti/Ti | (ii) Histological analysis | (ii) Absence of titanium ions on the 48 regions explored. | |
| (iii) 2 months | (iii) The sectors with titanium superstructures. | ||
| (iv) Migration of titanium to the area around the cervical region of the implant occurred in the presence of a precious alloy. This phenomenon did not occur with a titanium superstructure. |
1ICP-MS: inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry; 2DMEM : Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium; 3ICPE: inductively coupled plasma; 4SCLM : atomic emission spectrometry.
Figure 2Intrinsic and extrinsic factors influencing corrosion phenomena.
Figure 3Process of ion release.