Hana Alfaleh1, Gerd Melkus2, Khalid Alo Nasiyabi1, Matthew D F McInnes1, Nicola Schieda3. 1. Department of Medical Imaging, The Ottawa Hospital, 1053 Carling Avenue, Room C159, Ottawa, ON, K1Y 4E9, Canada. 2. The Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, The Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, Ottawa, ON, Canada. 3. Department of Medical Imaging, The Ottawa Hospital, 1053 Carling Avenue, Room C159, Ottawa, ON, K1Y 4E9, Canada. nschieda@toh.ca.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To compare image quality and detection of microscopic fat in adrenal adenomas imaged with 2-D and 3-D chemical shift imaging (CSI) and, to derive parameters which best match 2-D and 3-D-CSI. METHODS: This two-phase, retrospective, and phantom + prospective study was IRB approved. First, a retrospective assessment of 50 consecutive adrenal adenomas imaged at 1.5 T with 2-D (TR minimum, Flip Angle [FA] 70°, TE 2.2/4.4 ms.) and 3-D (TR minimum, FA 10°, TE 2.2/4.4 ms.] CSI was performed. Second, phantom (varied fat: water concentration) experiments guided a prospective assessment of 12 consecutive adrenal adenomas imaged at 1.5 T with 3-D CSI (FA 10°, 18°). Two blinded radiologists independently evaluated: image quality, signal intensity (SI) cancellation (5-point Likert scale), and CSI-index ([SI.In.Phase-SI.Opposed.Phase/SI.In.Phase]*100). RESULTS: 2-D-CSI yielded higher image quality (p < 0.001) and, subjectively (p < 0.001) and quantitatively (p < 0.001) had more SI cancellation from microscopic fat. Proportion of adenomas with no detectable microscopic fat (3-D; 26-36% subjectively, 18-24% quantitatively [CSI-index < 16.5%] versus 2-D; 20-22% subjectively, 6-8% quantitatively) differed (p = 0.008-0.08 subjectively, 0.008-0.03 quantitatively) by CSI technique. Phantom experiments indicated 18°FA 3-D-CSI compared favorably to 70° 2-D-CSI for fat detection between 5% and 50%. In vivo, there was no differences in subjective or quantitative SI cancellation comparing 18°3D-CSI and 2D-CSI (p = 0.16-0.56 and 0.73-0.60). Greater SI cancellation occurred with 18°3D compared to 10°3D-CSI evaluated subjectively (p = 0.003-0.01). CONCLUSION: 2-D CSI has subjectively higher image quality and shows more signal intensity loss from microscopic fat in adrenal adenomas compared to 10° flip angle 3-D-CSI. Increasing the 3-D flip angle to 18° more closely matches depiction of microscopic fat to 2-D-CSI at 1.5 T.
OBJECTIVE: To compare image quality and detection of microscopic fat in adrenal adenomas imaged with 2-D and 3-D chemical shift imaging (CSI) and, to derive parameters which best match 2-D and 3-D-CSI. METHODS: This two-phase, retrospective, and phantom + prospective study was IRB approved. First, a retrospective assessment of 50 consecutive adrenal adenomas imaged at 1.5 T with 2-D (TR minimum, Flip Angle [FA] 70°, TE 2.2/4.4 ms.) and 3-D (TR minimum, FA 10°, TE 2.2/4.4 ms.] CSI was performed. Second, phantom (varied fat: water concentration) experiments guided a prospective assessment of 12 consecutive adrenal adenomas imaged at 1.5 T with 3-D CSI (FA 10°, 18°). Two blinded radiologists independently evaluated: image quality, signal intensity (SI) cancellation (5-point Likert scale), and CSI-index ([SI.In.Phase-SI.Opposed.Phase/SI.In.Phase]*100). RESULTS: 2-D-CSI yielded higher image quality (p < 0.001) and, subjectively (p < 0.001) and quantitatively (p < 0.001) had more SI cancellation from microscopic fat. Proportion of adenomas with no detectable microscopic fat (3-D; 26-36% subjectively, 18-24% quantitatively [CSI-index < 16.5%] versus 2-D; 20-22% subjectively, 6-8% quantitatively) differed (p = 0.008-0.08 subjectively, 0.008-0.03 quantitatively) by CSI technique. Phantom experiments indicated 18°FA 3-D-CSI compared favorably to 70° 2-D-CSI for fat detection between 5% and 50%. In vivo, there was no differences in subjective or quantitative SI cancellation comparing 18°3D-CSI and 2D-CSI (p = 0.16-0.56 and 0.73-0.60). Greater SI cancellation occurred with 18°3D compared to 10°3D-CSI evaluated subjectively (p = 0.003-0.01). CONCLUSION: 2-D CSI has subjectively higher image quality and shows more signal intensity loss from microscopic fat in adrenal adenomas compared to 10° flip angle 3-D-CSI. Increasing the 3-D flip angle to 18° more closely matches depiction of microscopic fat to 2-D-CSI at 1.5 T.
Authors: Myles T Taffel; Robert D Petrocelli; Danielle Rigau; Nicola Schieda; Sumaya Al-Rasheed; Benjamin W Carney; Ryan Chung; Michael L Yao; Michael A Blake; Khaled M Elsayes; Mohamed Badawy; Sergio Klimkowski; Erick M Remer; Adam Wetzel; Amit Pandya; Elaine M Caoili; Michael T Corwin Journal: AJR Am J Roentgenol Date: 2022-10-19 Impact factor: 6.582
Authors: Emily C Bush; Aliya Gifford; Crystal L Coolbaugh; Theodore F Towse; Bruce M Damon; E Brian Welch Journal: J Vis Exp Date: 2018-09-07 Impact factor: 1.355