| Literature DB >> 36003245 |
M Santhoshkumari1,2, S Hepsibah Sharmil3,4.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Delay in the diagnosis and management of obstetric complications lead to raised mortality rate. This can be curtailed by appropriate implementation of the educational intervention among the health-care providers. Hence, this review aimed to identify the literature evidence of the efficacy of various educational interventions training in the management of obstetric complications.Entities:
Keywords: Educational intervention; mobile application; obstetric emergencies; simulation training
Year: 2022 PMID: 36003245 PMCID: PMC9393949 DOI: 10.4103/jehp.jehp_1392_21
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Educ Health Promot ISSN: 2277-9531
Elements of problem, intervention, comparison, and outcome strategy
| Component | Definition | Descriptors | Keywords |
|---|---|---|---|
| P: Population of interest | Nurses | Neither descriptors nor keywords were adopted. Filters for the workplace were used in the databases | |
| I: Intervention | Educational intervention and learning application | Education of nurses and midwives | Education |
| C: Comparison | - | - | - |
| O: Result/outcome | Increase in the skills of managing obstetric complications | Obstetric complications | Complications of labor |
PICO=Problem, intervention, comparison, and outcome
Figure 1Country-wise inclusion of studies
Flowchart 1Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses flow diagram showing the selection of the included articles
Summary of studies on the efficacy of capacity building educational interventions in the management of obstetric complications
| First author name and year | Region | Study aim | Study design | Study population | Sampling method | Sample size | Data collection procedure | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homaifar | Rwanda | To establish the competency of medical students in the EmOC after a short training course | Pre-test post-test quasi-experimental crossover study | Medical students | Convenience sampling | 65 final year medical students | The assessment score ranges from 0 to 100. The competency assessed in 5 areas of emergency obstetric and neonatal care. Hemorrhage/uterine rupture, hypertensive complications, dystocic labor, postpartum infection, and APGAR score are the areas assessed. The assessment was done before and immediately after and 3 to 9 months after the training course. It is a 2 days training course on obstetric emergencies | There was improvement in obstetric knowledge to 80% after training. 49.2% of the students have retained practical skills. Female students are having high competency rate while comparing to male students. The training course improved the knowledge and skills of the medical students |
| Mechael, 2013[ | Ghana | To assess the use of mobile applications for obstetric emergencies and promotion of health | Quasi-experimental research design | Health workers, laboring women and volunteers | Convenience sampling | 21 health workers, 30 women and 7 volunteers | There are four sessions for knowledge and eight sessions for practice. The period of every meeting was for 45–60 min for each set, which also included 10 min for treatise and responses | There is statistically significant improvement in delivering health care to the laboring women during obstetric emergencies after introducing the mobile application |
| Evans | Malawi, Zanzibar, and Tanzania | To validate the helping mothers Survive: Bleeding after birth training module | Before-after study | Health-care providers | Simple random sampling | 155 | Single-day facility-based training on the management of PPH | There was a significant increase in the knowledge scores to 10% in Malawi, 17% in India, and 11% in Zanzibar between the pre- and post-test scores respectively |
| Walker | Mexico | Simulation-based obstetric and neonatal emergencies (PRONTO course) | Before-after study | Physicians and nurses | Simple random sampling | 450 | Significant increase in knowledge and self-efficacy were noted | The knowledge score of pre-test (50.6) whereas post-test is 66.3 which are 15.7% more. Skills score of pre-test data is 79.4% whereas post-test is 92.6% which is 13.2% higher due to training |
| Moran | South Africa | To describe the scale-up of Emergency Obstetric and Newborn | Before-after study | Midwives | Convenience sampling | 45 | ESMOE: Multi-disciplinary, simulation-based skills and drills using training of trainers approach | There was a significant increase in the knowledge score by |
| Ameh | Ghana, Nigeria, Sierra Leone, Malawi, Kenya, Tanzania, Zimbabwe, Bangladesh, and Pakistan | To assess the knowledge and skills of maternity care providers after EmOC training | Before-after study | Maternity care providers | Purposive sampling | 5757 | Simulation-based training in Emergency obstetric and early newborn complications for 3–5 days | There was a significant difference in the knowledge acquired to more than 10% and skills to 30.6% among the pre- and post-test scores |
| Varghese | India | To test the feasibility, acceptability, and effectiveness of a skills and drills intervention to improve EmOC | Quasi-experimental design with 4 interventional and 4 comparison facilities | Doctors and nurses | Simple random sampling | 6452 in Intervention group and 6329 in comparison group | Emergency drills through role-play conducted every 2 months | The knowledge and skills obtained from skills and drills intervention was not sufficient to translate into improved diagnosis and management of maternal and newborn complications |
| Bolan | Demographic Republic of Congo | To establish the practicability of use of SDA in BEmONC | Pilot cluster randomized trial | Maternal and newborn health workers | Stratified random sampling | 62 health workers | Among 8 health care facilities of central DRC, 4 were randomized an mLearning intervention and 4 to control group with standard practice | Knowledge scores increased significantly from baseline among intervention group compared with controls after 3 months of implementing intervention |
| Sami | Saudi Arabia | To estimate the effectiveness of Simulation-based training program on the management of obstetric emergencies | Quasi-experimental | Nurses and midwives | Convenience sampling | 30 nurses and midwives | The gaining and retention of knowledge and confidence of participants was statistically significant (<0.001) after the simulated training | Sample size was small when compared with requirement of quantitative designs |
| Kumar | Australia | To investigate the use of a structured obstetric and neonatal emergency simulation training program | Pre–post workshop survey design | Medical doctors, midwifery staff, and students of 3 states | Convenience sampling | 150 | Mobile interprofessional workshops were piloted in three areas of India | The focal challenge was deficient in availability of medical back up, funds, planned education, and poor acquiescence from women |
| Pattinson | South Africa | To establish the impact of the EmOC training program on the skills of health-care professionals | A before and after observational study | Maternity and casualty Health-care professionals | Convenience sampling | 3237 health-care professionals working in maternity and casualty (645 doctors, 303 advanced midwives, 2130 professional nurses, and 159 others) | This is a 6 years study | During the period of study, 1248, 333 live births undergone in which 2212 maternal deaths were identified. The cause of death in study settings was reviewed. In other 40 districts, 5961 maternal deaths and 5,439,870 live births were recorded There is a significant reduction of 29.3% in the number of maternal deaths |
| Mathew | India | To assess the procedural skills of nursing students using OSCE scales when station-based expertise preparing and to evaluate the effectiveness of station-based skill training model for teaching procedural skills among nursing students | Pre-experimental one group pre- and post-test design | Nursing students | Simple random sampling | 30 first-year BSc nursing students | Before and after giving station-based skill training, the clinical skills of the students were monitored | Station based skill training model is highly effective which was concluded by mean post-test scores in all three skill procedures. The students’ clinical procedures skills were assessed and evaluated by OSCE |
| Gorantla | India (Uttarpradesh) | To assess the feasibility and benefit of the interprofessional skills training workshop | Exploratory research design | 4th-year medical students and final year of nursing training | Convenience sampling | 67 medical students and 28 midwifery students | A skill station course was formed | All the participants acknowledged that the training was useful, appropriate and helped to increase their self confidence in performing the skills |
| Pajai | India (Maharashtra) | To compare the effectiveness of traditional video demonstration vs. simulation-based training on SimMomin regarding the management of normal labor | Quasi-experimental pilot study | Medical interns | Simple random sampling | 100 trainees interns | Didactic lecture will be taken for 100 interns of the department of OBG | Significant improvement in skill based competencies of trainees who undergo simulation based training compared to those who undergone video based learning for management of normal labor |
PPH=Postpartum hemorrhage, NR=Neonatal resuscitation, EmOC=Emergency obstetric care, RCOG=Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, SDA=Safe delivery application, BEmONC: Basic emergency obstetric and newborn care, DRC=Democratic Republic of the Congo, OSCEs=Objective structured clinical examinations, Nursing Care Standards, iMMRs=institutional Maternal Mortality Rate, OBG=Obstetrics and Gynecology