| Literature DB >> 35992303 |
Martin Zacharias1, Karl Kashofer1, Philipp Wurm1, Peter Regitnig1, Moritz Schütte2, Margit Neger1, Sandra Ehmann1, Leigh M Marsh3, Grazyna Kwapiszewska3, Martina Loibner1, Anna Birnhuber3, Eva Leitner4, Andrea Thüringer1, Elke Winter1, Stefan Sauer1, Marion J Pollheimer1, Fotini R Vagena1, Carolin Lackner1, Barbara Jelusic1, Lesley Ogilvie2, Marija Durdevic1, Bernd Timmermann5, Hans Lehrach2,5, Kurt Zatloukal1, Gregor Gorkiewicz1.
Abstract
Secondary infections contribute significantly to covid-19 mortality but driving factors remain poorly understood. Autopsies of 20 covid-19 cases and 14 controls from the first pandemic wave complemented with microbial cultivation and RNA-seq from lung tissues enabled description of major organ pathologies and specification of secondary infections. Lethal covid-19 segregated into two main death causes with either dominant diffuse alveolar damage (DAD) or secondary pneumonias. The lung microbiome in covid-19 showed a reduced biodiversity and increased prototypical bacterial and fungal pathogens in cases of secondary pneumonias. RNA-seq distinctly mirrored death causes and stratified DAD cases into subgroups with differing cellular compositions identifying myeloid cells, macrophages and complement C1q as strong separating factors suggesting a pathophysiological link. Together with a prominent induction of inhibitory immune-checkpoints our study highlights profound alterations of the lung immunity in covid-19 wherein a reduced antimicrobial defense likely drives development of secondary infections on top of SARS-CoV-2 infection.Entities:
Keywords: Immunology; Microbiome; Virology
Year: 2022 PMID: 35992303 PMCID: PMC9374491 DOI: 10.1016/j.isci.2022.104926
Source DB: PubMed Journal: iScience ISSN: 2589-0042
Figure 1SARS-CoV-2 tissue distributions, genotyping and virus cultivation
(A) SARS-CoV-2 loads (compared to human glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase, GAPDH) and tissue distributions derived from postmortem sampling (median highlighted). Case numbers are given on the right.
(B) Significant association of qRT-PCR positivity (n-gene) with viral loads determined by RNAseq of lung tissues (Mann-Whitney test).
(C) Distribution of viral reads generated from lung tissues along the SARS-CoV-2 genome. Cumulative coverage of plus and minus strand transcripts is shown (median in bold). Identified nucleotide and amino-acid changes in comparison to the Wuhan reference strain are indicated.
(D) Correlation of SARS-CoV-2 plus and minus strand reads with cultivation (Spearman correlation). Triangles specify cultivation-positive samples. EM picture showing viral particles in Vero CCL-81 cells (arrows).
(E) Cladogram showing detected virus genotypes within a global context. The Wuhan reference strain (center) and the UK variant B.1.1.7 (Ecuador/INSPI-179112/2021) are included for comparisons. The pangolin lineage designation is used to specify viral genotypes.
(F) Dendrogram showing detected viral genotypes. Corresponding mutations in the S protein are indicated and virus strains are color coded accordingly.
Figure 2Lung pathology of lethal covid-19 stratifies into DAD and pneumonia
(A) Histological representation of DAD in lungs. A patchy representation of DAD is shown (left). Hyaline membranes (arrows) as a hallmark lesion of early DAD (top right). Immunohistochemical detection (nucleoprotein antibody) of SARS-CoV-2 infected pneumocytes (bottom right).
(B) (Top) Immunohistochemical detection of SARS-CoV-2 infected respiratory epithelium of the nasopharynx. (Bottom) Correlation between SARS-CoV-2 loads in the nasopharyngeal mucosa and lung tissue determined by qRT-PCR (Spearman correlation).
(C) Scoring of prevalent histopathology patterns in lungs. Cases are ordered according to duration of disease.
(D) Correlation analysis of early and late DAD histopathology features and disease duration (Spearman r).
(E) Main discrimination of lung pathology according to DAD and pneumonia patterns. Cases are ordered according to alveolar neutrophil scores.
(F) Serum C-reactive protein (CRP) and interleukin-6 (IL-6) levels in DAD and pneumonia cases (Mann-Whitney test).
(G) Correlation analyses of neutrophil abundance and clinical parameters (Spearman r; Mann-Whitney test).
Figure 3Microbiome alterations and agents of secondary infections in covid-19 lungs
(A) Annotation of non-human transcripts to microbial sequences with PathSeq and MetaPhlAn, respectively (hits per million; Kruskal-Wallis test).
(B) Significantly increased bacterial, fungal and viral reads in the pneumonia category of covid-19 (PathSeq annotation, Kruskal-Wallis test).
(C) Bacterial reads significantly correlate with neutrophil counts but not with the post-mortem interval (Spearman correlation).
(D) Richness and evenness in the bacterial component of the lung microbiome (based on the 16S rRNA gene marker; Kruskal-Wallis test).
(E) Beta-diversity analysis (PCA based on unweighted UniFrac and Bray-Curtis distance) clearly separates DAD and pneumonia cases of covid-19 from controls (16S rRNA gene; PERMANOVA, Kruskal-Wallis test).
(F) Summary of bacterial, fungal and viral microbes prevalent in covid-19 lungs. Shown are microbes detected by cultivation, RNA and/or DNA sequencing (red labeled taxa were also spuriously found in controls).
(G) Dominant pathogens causing secondary infections in covid-19 lungs compared to controls (summary of cultivation and deep sequencing).
(H) Microscopic representation (H&E) of bacterial (left, case #16) and fungal (middle, case #18) pathogens in lung tissues. Epstein-Barr virus RNA positivity in lung tissue (EBV RNA in-situ hybridization, case #11).
Figure 4The lung metatranscriptome mirrors the major death categories DAD and pneumonia
(A) Hierarchical clustering shows depleted (cluster 1) and enriched (cluster 2) genes (n = 4,547; adj. P< 0.05) in lung tissue of covid-19 cases compared to controls.
(B) Gen set enrichment analysis (canonical pathways) of major depleted (top) and enriched (bottom) pathways in covid-19 lungs.
(C) PCA based on differentially expressed genes clearly discriminates DAD cases and cases with secondary pneumonia of covid-19 from controls.
(D) Venn diagram specifying differentially expressed genes in DAD as the major discriminator followed by pneumonia (adj. P< 0.05, LFC≥0.58).
(E) Volcano plot showing the top 25 significantly deregulated genes in secondary pneumonia versus DAD. Several macrophage genes are increased.
Figure 5Cellular deconvolution stratifies lung pathology sub-groups
(A) Hierarchical clustering based on cell-type enrichments derived from xCell analysis indicates a specific grouping of samples.
(B) Scheme indicating cell clusters which discriminate different groups.
(C) Top induced genes in the respective cell clusters determining the specific grouping (Kruskal-Wallis test).
Figure 6Macrophage and complement C1q induction in covid-19 lungs
(A) Immunohistochemical counting of CD163 positive macrophages shows induction in covid-19 compared to controls (Mann-Whitney test).
(B) Both M1 and M2 macrophages are specifically increased in “DAD2” compared to “DAD1” (grouping according to xCell analysis; Kruskal-Wallis test).
(C) Heatmap of complement genes specifies C1q induction in a subgroup of DAD cases and in pneumonia.
(D) C1q protein (29 kDa) is significantly increased in covid-19 lung tissue compared to controls (reference human GAPDH; Mann-Whitney test).
(E) Significant induction of C1q detected by immunohistochemistry (Mann–Whitney test) and different staining patterns in covid-19 lungs; top left & middle: C1q staining of alveolar cells; top right: double immunohistochemistry staining (red: C1q, nuclear black: TTF-1) shows C1q staining of alveolar macrophages; bottom left: intravascular C1q staining; bottom middle: free C1q specific staining of proteinaceous fluid in the alveolar space; bottom right: double immunohistochemistry staining (red: C1q, nuclear black: TTF-1) shows C1q staining of pneumocytes (TTF-1 positive).
Figure 7Signatures of immune-impairment in covid-19 lungs
(A) The tolerogenic leukocyte receptors LAIR-1 and LILRB4 are mainly induced in “DAD2” and “pneumonia” (Kruskal–Wallis test).
(B) Spearman correlation of RNA expression of LAIR-1 and LILRB4 with C1q chains and induced collagen types (Spearman r; p∗<0.05 to p∗∗∗<0.001).
(C) Significant induction of TGFβ1 transcription (Kruskal-Wallis test). Protein measurement by immunohistochemistry and western blotting does not reveal a significant difference of covid-19 lungs to controls (Mann-Whitney test).
(D) Strong induction of immune checkpoint inhibitors in covid-19 (order according to z-score).
(E) LAG3 transcriptional induction (Kruskal-Wallis test) and increased lymphocyte staining with LAG3 immunohistochemistry in covid-19 lung tissue (Mann-Whitney test).
(F) Simultaneous transcriptional induction of immune checkpoint inhibitors in covid-19 lungs compared to controls (Pearson correlation; p∗<0.05, p∗∗∗<0.001).
(G) Hierarchical clustering of immune checkpoint inhibitors in covid-19 cases shows a different grouping of samples with high viral loads (transcript abundance) versus samples with the histological pneumonia category (clustering: average linkage; distance measure: Pearson).
| REAGENT or RESOURCE | SOURCE | IDENTIFIER |
|---|---|---|
| Anti-SARS-CoV-2 nucleoprotein monoclonal rabbit antibody | Sino Biological | Cat# 40143-R019; clone: 019; RRID: |
| Anti-CD68 monoclonal mouse antibody | Ventana Medical Systems | Cat# 790-2931; clone: KP-1; RRID: |
| Anti-CD163 monoclonal mouse antibody | Ventana Medical Systems | Cat# 760-4437; clone: MRQ-26; RRID: |
| Anti-TTF1 monoclonal mouse antibody | Cell Marque | Cat# 343M-96; clone: 8G7G3/1; RRID: |
| Anti-TGFß1 polyclonal rabbit antibody | Santa Cruz Biotechnology | Cat# SC-146; RRID: |
| Anti-TGFß polyclonal rabbit antibody | Cell Signaling Technology | Cat# 3711; RRID: |
| Anti-LAG3 polyclonal rabbit antibody | Abcam | Cat# ab180187; clone: EPR4392(2); RRID: |
| Anti-C1q polyclonal rabbit antibody | Agilent | Cat# A0136; RRID: |
| Anti-GAPDH monoclonal rabbit antibody | Cell Signaling Technology | Cat# 2118; clone: 14C10; RRID: |
| HRP-linked ECL Anti-Rabbit IgG | GE Healthcare | Cat# NA934; RRID: |
| Dako REAL TM EnVision TM HRP rabbit/mouse detection-system | Agilent | Cat# K5007; RRID: |
| ultraView DAB detection-system | Roche | Cat# 760-500; RRID: |
| SARS-CoV-2 strains from study | This study | N/A |
| Bacterial and fungal strains from study | This study | N/A |
| Autopsy tissue and body fluid samples | This study | N/A |
| Respiratory tract swabs | This study | N/A |
| Thioglycollate broth | Oxoid | Cat# CM0173 |
| OptiPro SFM medium | Gibco | Cat# 12309019 |
| L-Glutamine | Gibco | Cat# 11539876 |
| Penicillin-Streptomycin (10.000 U/ml) | Gibco | Cat# 11548876 |
| TRIzol® | Invitrogen | Cat# 15596026 |
| RIPA buffer | Sigma | Cat# R0278 |
| Pefabloc | Roche | Cat# 11429868001 |
| cOmpleteTM Mini | Merck | Cat# 11836153001 |
| PhosSTOPTM | Roche | Cat# 4906845001 |
| Laemmli buffer | Bio-Rad | Cat# 1610737EDU |
| MagNA Lyser green beads tubes | Roche | Cat# 03358941001 |
| Maxwell 16 LEV simplyRNA blood kit | Promega | Cat# AS1310 |
| QIAamp Viral RNA Mini Kit | Qiagen | Cat# 221413 |
| High-Capacity cDNA Reverse Transcription Kit with RNase inhibitor | Applied Biosystems | Cat# 4374966 |
| SuperScript III One-Step RT-PCR System with Platinum Taq High Fidelity DNA Polymerase mastermix | ThermoFisher | Cat# 12574018 |
| SYBR Green PCR Mastermix | Applied Biosystems | Cat# 4309155 |
| Ampure XP beads | Beckman Coulter | Cat# A63881 |
| NEBNext Fast DNA Fragmentation & Library Prep Set for Ion Torren kit | New England Biolabs | Cat# E6285L |
| KAPA RNA HyperPrep Kit with RiboErase (HMR) for Illumina® platforms | KAPABIOSYSTEMS | Cat# KR1351 |
| 16s Complete PCR Mastermix kit | Molzym | Cat# S-020-0250 |
| QiaQick gel extraction kit | Qiagen | Cat# 28706X4 |
| Ponceau S solution | Sigma | Cat# P7170 |
| ECL Select Western Blot Reagent | Amersham | Cat# 12644055 |
| RNAlater | ThermoFisher | Cat# AM7024 |
| 16S rRNA gene-, ITS- and RNAseq data | European nucleotide archive (ENA) | Acc. no. PRJEB45873 |
| Vero CCL-81 cells | European Collection of Authenticated Cell Cultures | ECACC 84113001 |
| RdRp_SARSr-F GTGARATGGTCATGTGTGGCGG | ( | N/A |
| RdRp_SARSr-P2 | ( | N/A |
| RdRp_SARSr-R CARATGTTAAASACACTATTAGCATA | ( | N/A |
| N_Sarbeco_F CACATTGGCACCCGCAATC | ( | N/A |
| N_Sarbeco_P | ( | N/A |
| N_Sarbeco_R GAGGAACGAGAAGAGGCTTG | ( | N/A |
| 2019-nCoV_N1-F GACCCCAAAATCAGCGAAAT | N/A | |
| 2019-nCoV_N1-R TCTGGTTACTGCCAGTTGAATCTG | N/A | |
| 2019-nCoV_N2-F TTACAAACATTGGCCGCAAA | N/A | |
| 2019-nCoV_N2-R GCGCGACATTCCGAAGAA | N/A | |
| 2019-nCoV_N3-F GGGAGCCTTGAATACACCAAAA | N/A | |
| 2019-nCoV_N3-R TGTAGCACGATTGCAGCATTG | N/A | |
| RP-F AGATTTGGACCTGCGAGCG | N/A | |
| RP-R GAGCGGCTGTCTCCACAAGT | N/A | |
| GAPDH_f CCTCCACCTTTGACGCT | N/A | |
| GAPDH_r TTGCTGTAGCCAAATTCGTT | N/A | |
| CoV_gen_f1 TAAAGGTTTATACCTTCCCAGG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r1 CAGATGTGAACATCATAGCATC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f2 AAAGAGCTATGAATTGCAGACACC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r2 GGAGGGTAGAAAGAACAATACA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f3 GATGCTATGATGTTCACATCTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r3 CAGAATCTGGATGAAGATTGCCAT | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f4 TGTATTGTTCTTTCTACCCTCC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r4 CTCCATCCAAATAAGTTGGACCAA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f5 ATGGCAATCTTCATCCAGATTCTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r5 CACATCACCATTTAAGTCAGGGAA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f6 TTGGTCCAACTTATTTGGATGGAG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r6 CACTCTGCAACTAAGCCAAA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f7 TTCCCTGACTTAAATGGTGATGTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r7 GCCAGTAACTTCTATGTCAGATTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f8 TTTGGCTTAGTTGCAGAGTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r8 CACTAGTAGATACACAAACACCAG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f9 CAATCTGACATAGAAGTTACTGGC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r9 CCAGCCTGTACCAAGAAATTA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f10 CTGGTGTTTGTGTATCTACTAGTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r10 CCAACCATGTCATAATACGCAT | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f11 TAATTTCTTGGTACAGGCTGG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r11 CCAACTTACGTTGCATGGCTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f12 ATGCGTATTATGACATGGTTGG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r12 GGATGATCTATGTGGCAACGG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f13 CAGCCATGCAACGTAAGTTGG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r13 GGTGGTATGTCTGATCCCAATATT | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f14 CCGTTGCCACATAGATCATCC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r14 GCATGTTAGGCATGGCTCTATCA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f15 AATATTGGGATCAGACATACCACC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r15 GGTCGTAACAGCATTTACAA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f16 TGATAGAGCCATGCCTAACATGC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r16 GTCTCAGGCAATGCATTTAC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f17 TTGTAAATGCTGTTACGACC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r17 GCTTCTCTAGTAGCATGACACCC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f18 GTAAATGCATTGCCTGAGAC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r18 CACATGGACTGTCAGAGTAATAGA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f19 GGGTGTCATGCTACTAGAGAAGC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r19 CACTTAGATGAACCTGTTTGCGC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f20 TCTATTACTCTGACAGTCCATGTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r20 GACTAGAGACTAGTGGCAATAA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f21 GCGCAAACAGGTTCATCTAAGTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r21 GCAAATCTGGTGGCGTTAAA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f22 TTATTGCCACTAGTCTCTAGTC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r22 GAGGAGAATTAGTCTGAGTCT | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f23 TTTAACGCCACCAGATTTGC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r23 GCTCTGATTTCTGCAGCTCTAATT | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f24 AGACTCAGACTAATTCTCCTC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r24 CCTTGGAGAGTGCTAGTTGCC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f25 AATTAGAGCTGCAGAAATCAGAGC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r25 GGCATAGGCAAATTGTAGAAGACA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f26 GGCAACTAGCACTCTCCAAGG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r26 GTGAAACTGATCTGGCACGTAACT | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f27 TGTCTTCTACAATTTGCCTATGCC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r27 CCATAGGGAAGTCCAGCTTCTG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f28 AGTTACGTGCCAGATCAGTTTCAC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r28 GTCCTCCCTAATGTTACACA | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f29 CAGAAGCTGGACTTCCCTATGG | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r29 TTTGTATGCGTCAATATGCTT | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_f30 TGTGTAACATTAGGGAGGAC | This study | N/A |
| CoV_gen_r30 TTTGTCATTCTCCTAAGAAGC | This study | N/A |
| 16S_515_f TGCCAGCAGCCGCGGTAA | ( | |
| 16S_806_r GGACTACCAGGGTATCTAAT | ( | |
| ITS1 TCCGTAGGTGAACCTGCGG | ( | |
| ITS2 GCTGCGTTCTTCATCGATGC | ( | |
| R (v4.1) | N/A | |
| GISAID SARS-CoV-2 (hCoV-19) database | GISAID | |
| clustalw (v2.1) | ( | |
| figtree (v1.4.4) | ||
| STAR | ( | |
| bowtie2-2.4.1 | ( | |
| HTSeq (v0.12.4) | G Putri, S Anders, PT Pyl, JE Pimanda, F Zanini Analysing high-throughput sequencing data in Python with HTSeq 2.0 | |
| xCell | ( | |
| edgeR | ( | |
| Gene set enrichment analysis online tool | ( | |
| Single-cell atlas database SCovid | ( | |
| MetaPhlAn2 (v2.6.0) | ( | |
| Pathseq (GATK v4.1.0.0) | ( | |
| QIIME2 (v. 2020.6) | ( | |
| LEfSe | ( | |
| DADA2 | ( | |
| UNITE reference database | (Nilsson et al., 2018) Nilsson RH, Larsson K-H, Taylor AFS, Bengtsson-Palme J, Jeppesen TS, Schigel D, Kennedy P, Picard K, Glöckner FO, Tedersoo L, Saar I, Kõljalg U, Abarenkov K. 2018. The UNITE database for molecular identification of fungi: handling dark taxa and parallel taxonomic classifications. Nucleic Acids Research, | |
| SILVA reference database | ( | |
| bcftools (v1.3.1) | ||
| Incscape (v0.92) | ||
| fastx (v0.0.13) | ||
| seqclean | ||
| samtools | ( | |
| GraphPad PrismTM | ||
| ImageJ | ||
| BioRender | ||
| eSwab | Copan | Cat# 80490CEA |
| Inform EBER Epstein Barr Virus early RNA kit | Ventana | Cat# 800-2824 |
| ISH invers blue detection-system | Ventana | Cat# 800-092 |
| Genbox anaer | bioMérieux | Cat# 45534 |
| Blood agar | BD Diagnostics | Cat# 256506 |
| MacConkey agar | BD Diagnostics | Cat# 215197 |
| Chocolate agar | BD Diagnostics | Cat# 257456 |