| Literature DB >> 35967799 |
Bianca Minotti1,2, Marta Antonelli3,4, Katarzyna Dembska3, Davide Marino1, Gabriele Riccardi5, Marilena Vitale5, Ilaria Calabrese5, Francesca Recanati3, Annalisa Giosuè5.
Abstract
It is widely upheld that global food systems are unsustainable. Sustainable diets are gaining prominence as key components to entangle global food system challenges, as well as to transition towards the pathway of the 2030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Hence, sustainable and healthy diets are at the core of much research with the aim to bring together nutritional adequacy, cultural acceptability, environmental sustainability, economic affordability, and shape future consumption patterns. This article contributes to advancing knowledge on sustainable diets by proposing a True Cost Accounting method to assess the cost and impact of the adoption of a more sustainable and healthier diet, using Italy as an illustration. The research analyses the complexity of a diet from an environmental, health, and socioeconomic point of view and defines a new assessment framework that can be replicated and adapted to other contexts. Results show that in Italy, the adoption of a sustainable and healthy diet has a 47% lower carbon footprint and 25% lower water footprint than the current diet, while impacting 13% less on the average income and food monthly expenditure. Also, the desirable diet has a 21% lower impact on the sanitary costs related to cardiovascular disease. This study corroborates that the consumption of the desirable diet would provide a total cost saving of 741 EUR per year per capita, if we consider its impact on the environment, health, and socio-economic costs.Entities:
Keywords: TCA; carbon footprint; healthy diets; sustainable diets; water footprint
Year: 2022 PMID: 35967799 PMCID: PMC9372443 DOI: 10.3389/fnut.2022.974768
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Nutr ISSN: 2296-861X
Daily average consumption of the various food groups in the desirable and the current Italian diet (Source: Authors).
| Food group | Current Italian Diet (g/day) | Desirable diet (g/day) |
| Fruit | 181 | 400 |
| Vegetables | 205 | 400 |
| Legumes | 12 | 46 |
| Nuts | 18 | 30 |
| Refined cereals | 288 | 94 |
| Potatoes | 50 | 50 |
| Wholegrain | 27 | 150 |
| Beef and pork | 124 | 14 |
| Poultry | 41 | 43 |
| Fish | 57 | 103 |
| Eggs | 28 | 43 |
| Dairy products | 571 | 329 |
| (milk, cheese and yogurt) | ||
| Animal fat and tropical vegetable oils | 14 | 3 |
| Non-tropical vegetable oils | 46 | 25−40 |
| Sugars | 79 | 20 |
FIGURE 1TCA model (Source: Authors).
FIGURE 2CO2 emissions associated with the weekly consumption of foods in the desirable and the current Italian diet (Source: Authors).
Price for CO2 per week for the desirable and the current Italian diet (Source: Authors).
| Food group | Current Italian diet | Desirable diet |
| Fruit | 0,03 € | 0,07 € |
| Vegetables | 0,04 € | 0,07 € |
| Legumes | 0,00 € | 0,01 € |
| Nuts | 0,01 € | 0,02 € |
| Refined cereals | 0,13 € | 0,05 € |
| Potatoes | 0,005 € | 0,005 € |
| Wholegrain | 0,01 € | 0,01 € |
| Beef and pork meat | 0,46 € | 0,07 € |
| Poultry | 0,05 € | 0,05 € |
| Fish | 0,05 € | 0,09 € |
| Eggs | 0,03 € | 0,05 € |
| Dairy products | 0,64 € | 0,26 € |
| Animal fat and tropical oils | 0,05 € | 0,01 € |
| Non- tropical oils | 0,03 € | 0,04 € |
| Sugars | 0,03 € | 0,01 € |
| TOT | 1,57 € | 0,82 € |
FIGURE 3Water footprint associated with the weekly consumption of foods in the desirable and the current Italian diet (Source: Authors).
Cost of irrigating water per week due to food consumed in the desirable and the current Italian diet (Source: Authors).
| Food group | Current Italian diet | Desirable diet |
| Fruit | 0,86 € | 1,91 € |
| Vegetables | 0,45 € | 0,88 € |
| Legumes | 0,42 € | 1,63 € |
| Nuts | 2,03 € | 3,38 € |
| Refined cereals | 2,56 € | 0,70 € |
| Potatoes | 0,19 € | 0,19 € |
| Wholegrain | 0,19 € | 1,20 € |
| Beef and pork meat | 6,57 € | 0,90 € |
| Poultry | 1,05 € | 1,10 € |
| Fish | 1,32 € | 2,33 € |
| Eggs | 0,50 € | 0,77 € |
| Dairy products | 7,12 € | 3,62 € |
| Animal fat and tropical oils | 0,55 € | 0,12 € |
| Non- tropical oils | 4,64 € | 3,03 € |
| Sugars | 0,45 € | 0,06 € |
| TOT | 28,92 € | 21,81 € |
Frequency of consumption of the various food groups in the current diet and the desirable one and their impact on the Mediterranean Diet Score (Source: Authors).
| Food group | Food frequency (servings/Month) | Mediterranean Diet Score | ||
| Current | Desirable | Current | Desirable | |
| Wholegrain | 1−4 | > 18 | 1 | 5 |
| Potatoes | 1−4 | 1−4 | 1 | 1 |
| Fruit | 9−12 | > 18 | 3 | 5 |
| Vegetables | 9−12 | > 18 | 3 | 5 |
| Legumes | 5−8 | > 18 | 2 | 5 |
| Fish | 13−18 | > 18 | 4 | 5 |
| Red Meat | > 18 | 1−4 | 0 | 4 |
| Poultry | 9−12 | 9−12 | 2 | 2 |
| Dairy products | > 18 | >18 | 0 | 0 |
| Olive oil | Daily | Daily | 5 | 5 |
| Total | 21 | 37 | ||
FIGURE 4Weekly cost of foods consumed in the desirable and in the current Italian diet.
FIGURE 5Changes in the expenditure for the various foods according to the desirable diet compared to the current Italian diet.
FIGURE 6Affordability index of the desirable and the current Italian diet in reference to the ISTAT monthly food expenditure (2020) (Source: Authors).
FIGURE 7Multi-criteria comparison of the desirable and the current Italian diet based on the results of the study (Source: Authors). Figure 7 has been obtained by calculating the variance for the desirable and the current Italian diet from the average of the results for each variable. The values for each variable highlighted in the results have therefore been divided by the average (between the desirable and the current diet) and multiplied by 100 to obtain the variance showed.
Costs per year per capita for each diet and yearly savings from the desirable diet adoption (Source: Authors).
| Costs per year per capita | Carbon emissions | Irrigation water utilization | Coronary heart disease | Food acquisition | Total |
| Current diet | 81,64 € | 1.503,84 € | 121,37 € | 2.161,64 € | 3.868,49 € |
| Desirable diet | 42,64 € | 1.134,12 € | 95,88 € | 1.854,84 € | 3.127,48€ |
| Saving from desirable diet | 39 € | 369,71 € | 25,49 € | 306,80 € | 741 € |