| Literature DB >> 35906997 |
Miriam Sequeira1, Soumya Singh1, Luanna Fernandes1, Leena Gaikwad1, Devika Gupta1,2, Dixon Chibanda2,3, Abhijit Nadkarni1,2.
Abstract
Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) has the fastest growing adolescent population in the world. In addition to developmental changes, adolescents in SSA face health and socioeconomic challenges that increase their vulnerability to mental ill-health. This paper is a narrative review of adolescent mental health (AMH) in SSA with a focus on past achievements, current developments, and future directions in the areas of research, practice and policy in the region. We describe the status of AMH in the region, critical factors that negatively impact AMH, and the ways in which research, practice and policy have responded to this need. Depression, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorders are the most common mental health problems among adolescents in SSA. Intervention development has largely been focused on HIV/AIDS service delivery in school or community programs by non-specialist health workers. There is a severe shortage of specialised AMH services, poor integration of services into primary health care, lack of a coordinated inter-sectoral collaboration, and the absence of clear referral pathways. Policies for the promotion of AMH have been given less attention by policymakers, due to stigma attached to mental health problems, and an insufficient understanding of the link between mental health and social determinants, such as poverty. Given these gaps, traditional healers are the most accessible care available to help-seeking adolescents. Sustained AMH research with a focus on the socioeconomic benefits of implementing evidence-based, contextually adapted psychosocial interventions might prove useful in advocating for much needed policies to improve AMH in SSA.Entities:
Keywords: adolescent; mental health; sub-Saharan Africa
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35906997 PMCID: PMC9544168 DOI: 10.1111/tmi.13802
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Trop Med Int Health ISSN: 1360-2276 Impact factor: 3.918
Adolescent mental health screening and diagnostic tools that have been used in SSA
| Tool | Constructs measured | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) [ | Conduct problems, hyperactivity/inattention, emotional symptoms, peer problems, and prosocial behaviour | Short, quick administration, measures both mental health difficulties and competencies, and can be administered by a non‐professional with minimal training |
Many studies that have used the SDQ in Africa report limited or no validation No contextually established cut‐off scores for SSA Has been used without adhering to developed guidelines in many studies |
|
Patient Health Questionnaire 4‐item version (PHQ‐4) [ Or the longer PHQ‐9 version |
Depression Anxiety | Short and easy to administer. Can be administered by non‐specialist with minimal training. Tested in one study in Tanzania and found to reliably and validly measure core symptoms of depression and anxiety among adolescent girls |
Does not measure severity of depression Needs more testing across different adolescent population groups and other SSA countries |
| 10‐item Centre for Epidemiological Studies Depression (CES‐D 10) [ | Factors indicating depressive symptomatology | Tested with large sample sizes and diverse geographic locations in SSA. Includes data on household‐level socioeconomic indicators |
Not tested for construct validity in SSA. Tested only with extremely poor and rural household populations Validation study reports some degree of reporting bias |
| Beck's Depression Inventory (BDI)‐II (21‐item) [ | Depression |
Short and quick administration (5–10 minutes). Can be used in people ≥13 years Internal consistency established in SSA population. Screening and diagnostic cut off scores for depression established in SSA contexts | Needs validation across different adolescent groups and geographical locations |
| Major Depression Inventory (MDI) [ | Depression | Short and quick. Found to be a reliable and valid measure for depression across diverse adolescent groups in Kenya | Although structural validity established, clinical validation to evaluate the most suitable thresholds not conducted |
| Children's Depression Inventory (CDI) [ | Depression | Validated for use in African settings. Used in multiple settings across SSA | Since it is a self‐report tool, it can increase likelihood of socially desirable responses |
Intervention studies to address adolescent mental health care needs in SSA
| Program title | Year | Country | Intervention details | Key contribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Social skills training [ | 2016 | Nigeria | 8 week, classroom based, teacher delivered intervention to pupils with mild to moderate intellectual disability | Significant improvement in the social skills of pupils |
| Group cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) program [ | 2016 | Nigeria | 5 weekly CBT group sessions delivered by a specialist over 45–60 minutes each | Feasible and effective in reducing depressive symptoms |
| VUKA family program [ | 2014 | South Africa | A 10‐session intervention of approximately 3‐month duration delivered to pre‐adolescents aged 10–13 years and their families. | Improvement in mental health, youth behaviour, HIV treatment knowledge, stigma, communication, and adherence to ART. |
| The Youth Friendship Bench [ | 2021 | Zimbabwe | Culturally contextualised, manualised, peer delivered six‐session problem‐solving therapy to adolescents, 16–19 years of age | Youth reported a positive experience and perceived intervention to offer hope and relief from feelings of isolation and uncertainty, increase manageability of problems, and contribute to feelings of autonomy, resulting in a feeling of optimism about the future |
| Peer group intervention [ | 2021 | South Africa | Peer group clubs designed to build self‐esteem in adolescent girls (aged 15–24), foster supportive peer networks, and provide sexual reproductive health education | Increased self‐esteem, well‐being and perceived social support |
| Shamiri (thrive) Group intervention [ | 2020 | Kenya |
School‐based, group intervention delivered once a week by recently graduated students Later developed into a single session digital intervention |
Significantly reduced depression and anxiety symptoms and improved social support and academic performance relative to a control group Significantly reduced depressive symptoms |
| Sauti ya Vijana (The voice of the youth) group based intervention [ | 2020 | Tanzania | Group‐based mental health and life skills intervention. 10 group sessions (two sessions held jointly with caregivers) lasting approximately 90 minutes and two individual sessions delivered by trained young adult group leaders who use a manualized protocol that is designed to scale in low‐resource settings | Improved ART adherence and virologic outcomes but no change in mental health outcomes |
| Integrated approach to addressing the issue of youth depression in Malawi and Tanzania (IACD) [ | 2019 | Malawi and Tanzania | A ‘hub and spoke’ model for improving mental health care for young people that included interactive, youth‐informed weekly radio programs, mental health curriculum training for teachers and peer educators in secondary schools, and a clinical competency training program for community‐based health workers | Improved mental health care for young people. Promising guide for adolescent mental health policy development |
| The African Guide (AG) [ | 2017 | Tanzania | The AG is a classroom ready curriculum resource addressing all aspects of mental health literacy. Delivered by teachers via classroom activities | Highly significant improvements in teacher's overall knowledge, including mental health knowledge, and curriculum specific knowledge. Teachers' stigma against mental illness decreased significantly following the training. Students' help‐seeking behaviour increased significantly |
| Mental health awareness training [ | 2017 | Nigeria | School‐based 3‐day mental health training for pupils. Didactic lectures, case history presentations, discussions and role‐play were part of the training. | Significant increase in pupils' knowledge about mental illness and improved attitudes towards help‐seeking for mental health problems. |
| Families Matter! Program [ | 2016 | SSA | Evidence‐based intervention for parents and caregivers of 9–12 year olds to promote positive parenting | Increased parental guidance and support for adolescents living with HIV |
FIGURE 1An adolescent speaking to a peer counsellor as part of the Youth Friendship Bench program. The Friendship Bench model, an innovative and evidence based lay counsellor delivered intervention for common mental disorders, has been adapted into the Youth Friendship Bench intervention to address adolescent mental health problems. Sessions are facilitated by youth lay health workers and conducted in community settings like public parks to reach vulnerable populations like pregnant teenagers and juvenile offenders. Participant experiences in this program have been largely positive, perceived to offer hope and relief from negative feelings, increase manageability of problems, and contribute to feelings of autonomy, resulting in a feeling of optimism about the future [28]
Barriers to adolescent mental health care in SSA
| SEF level | Barriers |
|---|---|
| Individual |
Limited mental health literacy and knowledge about services Explanatory models of mental health problems that might obstruct help‐seeking from evidence‐based medicine Presence of other risk factors like HIV/AIDS, orphanhood, poverty and trauma |
| Family |
Caregivers' level of education Lack of mental health literacy in parents Lack of resources to buy food, drugs or other treatment resources Poverty‐related stress Reliance on traditional healing systems |
| Community |
Stigma around both teenage pregnancy and mental illness Stigma affecting adherence and willingness to seek treatment Community violence/mistreatment Endorsement of traditional healing systems Lack of means of transport to the health facilities War, political conflicts, migration |
| Health system |
Limited capacity to recognise mental distress Negative stereotypes expressed by care providers towards adolescent pregnancy and perinatal depression Overwhelming diseases burden from other diseases and conditions Lack of training to provide mental health interventions Infrastructural barriers to create adolescent friendly services Stock outs, understaffing, limited service availability/and lack of integrated care |
| Policy |
Lack of policy guidance on assessing, monitoring, evaluating, integrating and managing of adolescent mental health problems Lack of mental health policies to encourage help‐seeking Lack or poor implementation of mental health legislation for non‐compliance with policies Lack of policies to retain skilled workers and prevent brain drain to high‐income countries |