| Literature DB >> 35886149 |
Sophia Herrera1, Alide Salazar2, Gabriela Nazar3.
Abstract
eHealth interventions use information technology to provide attention to patients with chronic cardiovascular conditions, thereby supporting their self-management abilities.Entities:
Keywords: cardiovascular; chronic diseases; eHealth; interventions
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35886149 PMCID: PMC9318125 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19148296
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 4.614
Figure 1Flowchart for study identification, selection and inclusion. Adapted with permission from: Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman D. The PRISMA group Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement, 2009 [17].
Characterization of Selected Articles.
| Author and Year | Country | Objective | Study Design | Participants | Chronic Condition | eHealth Tool | Evidence Level |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steinman et al., 2020 [ | Cambodia | To understand facilitators and barriers to chronic disease management and the acceptability, appropriateness, and feasibility of mHealth to support chronic disease management and strengthen community-clinical linkages to existing services. | Qualitative exploratory study | 70 patients | ATH and DM2 | Text messages | Level 6 |
| Hermann et al., 2020 [ | Germany | Identifying factors supporting adhesion to digital focuses and wider patient acceptance. | Qualitative with grounded theory focus. | 20 patients with anticoagulant therapy, age > 65 years. | CVA and AMI | Telemonitoring via smartphone | Level 6 |
| Marsh et al., 2020 [ | USA | Exploring portal knowledge among emerging adult patients, with perceived barriers and aids. | Qualitative study | 27 emerging adults with Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus. | DM1 | Virtual health education platform. | Level 6 |
| Gjestsen et al., 2020 [ | Norway | Identify managers’ and professionals’ perspectives on eHealth intervention use. | Qualitative with case-study focus. | 17 health functionaries. | ----------- | Virtual health platform. | Level 6 |
| Zigdom et al., 2020 [ | Israel | Evaluate attitudes among general hospital nurses towards online medical information searching | Cross-sectional quantitative study. | 121 nurses at 3 general hospitals. | ----------- | Online database information search. | Level 6 |
| Ernsting et al., 2019 [ | Germany | Identify factors associated with chronic patients’ mobile health app use. | Quantitative study of secondary data analysis. | 1500 participants in a Web-based survey. | ATH, DM2, CVA, AMI | Pfizer Monitor mobile application | Level 6 |
| Jeffrey et al., 2019 [ | Australia | Evaluate experiences, barriers and aids to app use among people with Type 2 diabetes. | Qualitative | 30 people with DM2 diagnoses. | DM2 | Mobile health application. | Level 6 |
| Mangin et al., 2019 [ | Canada | Examine attitudes and online eHealth record use in patients with chronic cardiovascular disorders | Cross-sectional quantitative study. | 693 patients with primary care chronic cardiovascular conditions. | Chronic unspecified cardiovascular conditions. | Virtual health platform. | Level 6 |
| Milos et al., 2019 [ | Sweden | Exploring senior citizens’ attitudes and beliefs to better understand the factors influencing eHealth adhesion. | Qualitative study | 15 primary care left patients with chronic conditions | Nonspecified chronic cardiovascular conditions. | Mobile health application. | Level 6 |
| Díaz et al., 2019 [ | Ireland | Exploring barriers and aids to institutional-level eHealth technology adoption. | Summary of consensus at eHealth Innovations for Home and Community Care conference. | Doctors, research professors, policymakers and health service representatives. | ------------- | Cardiac telemonitoring. | Level 7 |
| Rhoads et al., 2017 [ | USA | To identify the potential factors that influenced the use of m-health technology and adherence to the control of hypertension symptoms | Nonrandomized controlled study | 48 women | ATH | Telemonitoring of arterialpressure | Level 6 |
| Ernsting et al., 2017 [ | Germany | Exploring reach of smartphone and health app use and their use behavior in chronic patients. | Quantitative correlational study. | Survey of 4144 patients over 35 years old with chronic cardiovascular conditions. | Unspecified chronic conditions. | Mobile health app. | Level 6 |
| Stangeland et al., 2017 [ | Norway | Exploring experiences with a GSD-based eHealth intervention and understanding reasons for leaving it. | Qualitative study. | 12 adults with DM2 who left an eHealth intervention. | DM2 | Mobile health app. | Level 6 |
| Ondiege et al., 2017 [ | England | Exploring hypertension patients’ beliefs and worries about monitoring devices | Qualitative study | 20 cohabitating couples suffering from hypertension | ATH | Arterial pressure telemonitoring. | Level 6 |
| Duplaga et al., 2017 [ | USA | Evaluating skills, technology use and exploring opinions about the health area among nurses. | Quantitative cross-sectional study. | 628 nurses took a questionnaire to evaluate technology use in healthcare | ------------- | Virtual health platform. | Level 6 |
| Granger et al., 2016 [ | Australia | Determining whether greater smartphone-Tablet familiarity was associated with higher eHealth use, | Quantitative correlational study | 1865 participants with cardiovascular conditions who used technology. | Unspecified chronic conditions. | Mobile health app. | Level 6 |
Barriers and aids to eHealth interventions for users, healthcare professionals and healthcare institutions.
| Article | Level | Barriers | Aids |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steinman et al., 2020 [ | Patient |
Limited time and resources to access to pharmacological treatment, clinical support and recommendations of physical activity and healthy diets. Lack of equity in the access to quality and effective chronic care. Living in rural areas Limitations of technology literacy |
The system is seen as an opportunity to remember prescription, clinical analysis and medical consultancy Education on the best practices for the management of chronic diseases at home. Support for those barriers that cannot be easily overcome. Use of voice messages over text messages for familiarity. |
| Hermann M et al., 2020 [ | Patient |
Perception that constant health monitoring promotes feeling of illness. Sensation that technology is only for young people. Including technology in health only increases costs. |
Technology use gives users feelings of autonomy in health management. Support from family or neighbors facilitates use. |
| Marsh K et al., 2020 [ | Patient |
User perception that information portal is extremely general and not lefted on particular user needs. Other, easier information access modes like the Internet exist apart from the portal. |
Sensation that the portal facilitates providers’ access to medical history, supporting diabetes self-management |
| Gjestsen M et al., 2020 [ | Healthcare Professional |
Platform access is only from computers, without considering alternatives including tablets or smartphones. |
Healthcare professionals say that it cuts ER intakes and improves home care quality. Perception that virtual platform mainly benefits senior citizens. |
| Zigdom A et al., 2020 [ | Healthcare Professional |
Low tech literacy. Greater age equals less Internet and tech use. |
Social media experience generates better attitudes towards Internet use for finding healthcare information. |
| Ernsting C et al., 2019 [ | Patient |
Little or no tech literacy. |
Younger people use the app more. More educated people use tech more. |
| Jeffrey B et al., 2019 [ | Patient |
Participant lacked knowledge about apps as healthcare tools. Perception that app use equals more severe illness. Bad rural connections. |
Visual trend representation, intuitive navigation and convenience (e.g., discretion and portability). |
| Mangin D et al., 2019 [ | Patient |
Disuse of technology. Sensation of lack of privacy. Internet connection loss. |
Home internet access. Perception that tech use allows for health self-evaluation, and therefore autonomy. |
| Milos V et al., 2019 [ | Patient |
Incuriosity among seniors about tech use. Sensation of lack of self-confidence in tech use. |
Desire to join due to need for information and learning support. Sensation that tech brings potential health advantages. Users feeling need for speed, access and correct integral information. |
| Díaz Y et al., 2019 [ | Institutional |
Health tech systems stall in project study stages. Lack of funding Lack of awareness about remote monitoring. Anxiety about responsibility for data generated. |
Growing demand in patient services, education and empowerment. |
| Rhoads et al., 2017 [ | Patient |
The use of the system compromises the privacy of the user when sending the data to the reference health left. Using the system daily demands too much time The use of technology generates feelings of anxiety, and discomfort since the measurement values may be not precise enough. |
To have the knowledge to use the system at home Help from close persons to solve mHealth difficulties at home. Feeling that the system warns of risks and avoids complications Easy to use system, clear and understandable. Perceived satisfaction |
| Ernsting C et al., 2017 [ | Patient |
Wealthier people adhere more to tech use Poorer people adhere less to tech use Lower literacy equals lower chance of using Smart devices and mobile health apps. |
Younger patients are likelier to use smart devices and mobile health apps. The better the health status, the more likely patients will use smart devices and mobile health apps. |
| Stangeland S et al., 2017 [ | Patient |
Lack of eHealth intervention participation motivation. Sensation that tech is frustrating. Perception that content is irrelevant and incomprehensible. User preference for doing other activities. Perception that tech loses face-to-face contact. |
Category not included. |
| Ondiege B et al., 2017 [ | Patient |
Batteries in equipment had very short life. Difficulties handling device. Pressure equipment had low sensitivity. |
Sensation of useful telemonitoring. Training prior to program start. |
| Duplaga M et al., 2017 [ | Healthcare professionals |
Distrust among nurses regarding real contributions of tech apps. |
Internet use experience increases professionals’ trust in health apps. |
| Granger D et al., 2016 [ | Patient |
The lower the familiarity with tablets or smartphones, the lower the chance of using this type of tech. |
Better chances of adhering to health interventions when adapted to the needs of each user. Younger and more educated people tended to use technology in healthcare more. |