Jennifer Kielty1, Ross Bowe2, Andrew O'Donoghue3, Karen Sherlock3, Ingrid Browne3, Terry Tan2, Siaghal MacColgain3. 1. Anaesthesia Department, National Maternity Hospital, Holles Street, Dublin 2, Ireland. jenkielty1@gmail.com. 2. Anaesthesia Department, Coombe Women and Infants University Hospital, Cork Street, Dublin 8, Ireland. 3. Anaesthesia Department, National Maternity Hospital, Holles Street, Dublin 2, Ireland.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: This study involves two stand-alone tertiary level maternity hospitals with a combined average of 17,000 births per year, and with approximately 300 obstetric high dependency unit (OHDU) admissions annually. Many midwives feel that working in an OHDU does not constitute normal midwifery work and they have voiced concerns regarding their training in this setting. Midwives and nurses from different departments throughout the two hospitals are often asked to care for the OHDU patients. Co-location and expansion of a new OHDU, as well as a discussion around staffing, prompted this questionnaire. AIMS: The aim of this study was to formally assess midwives' and nurses' attitudes and confidence working in an OHDU. METHODS: After obtaining ethics committee approval, we conducted a survey and collected information on previous training in critical care, level of competence with HDU-related equipment and management of common HDU conditions. RESULTS: In total, 188 staff participated in the survey (38% response rate). The majority (n = 142, 76%) did not feel competent caring for critically ill patients despite almost 40% (n = 69) saying they had experience doing so. Nurses or dual trained midwives were more likely to state they felt competent caring for critically ill patients, with only 2 midwives feeling competent (2.2%) compared to 32 nurses or dual trained staff (34.4%), p < 0.01. One hundred forty-seven (78%) and 136 (72%) respondents felt confident managing major haemorrhage and sepsis respectively. One hundred sixty-nine (89%) respondents would be interested in further training. CONCLUSIONS: A greater proportion of nurses and dual trained midwives feel confident caring for ODHU patients. This survey suggests that a mixture of specialty-trained critical care nurses and midwives is required in order to provide a full complement of HDU care to both the antenatal and postnatal women.
BACKGROUND: This study involves two stand-alone tertiary level maternity hospitals with a combined average of 17,000 births per year, and with approximately 300 obstetric high dependency unit (OHDU) admissions annually. Many midwives feel that working in an OHDU does not constitute normal midwifery work and they have voiced concerns regarding their training in this setting. Midwives and nurses from different departments throughout the two hospitals are often asked to care for the OHDU patients. Co-location and expansion of a new OHDU, as well as a discussion around staffing, prompted this questionnaire. AIMS: The aim of this study was to formally assess midwives' and nurses' attitudes and confidence working in an OHDU. METHODS: After obtaining ethics committee approval, we conducted a survey and collected information on previous training in critical care, level of competence with HDU-related equipment and management of common HDU conditions. RESULTS: In total, 188 staff participated in the survey (38% response rate). The majority (n = 142, 76%) did not feel competent caring for critically ill patients despite almost 40% (n = 69) saying they had experience doing so. Nurses or dual trained midwives were more likely to state they felt competent caring for critically ill patients, with only 2 midwives feeling competent (2.2%) compared to 32 nurses or dual trained staff (34.4%), p < 0.01. One hundred forty-seven (78%) and 136 (72%) respondents felt confident managing major haemorrhage and sepsis respectively. One hundred sixty-nine (89%) respondents would be interested in further training. CONCLUSIONS: A greater proportion of nurses and dual trained midwives feel confident caring for ODHU patients. This survey suggests that a mixture of specialty-trained critical care nurses and midwives is required in order to provide a full complement of HDU care to both the antenatal and postnatal women.