CD137 (4-1BB) is a co-stimulatory receptor on immune cells and Nectin-4 is a cell adhesion molecule that is overexpressed in multiple tumor types. Using a series of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-based linkers, synthetic bicyclic peptides targeting CD137 were conjugated to Bicycles targeting Nectin-4. The resulting bispecific molecules were potent CD137 agonists that require the presence of both Nectin-4-expressing tumor cells and CD137-expressing immune cells for activity. A multipronged approach was taken to optimize these Bicycle tumor-targeted immune cell agonists by exploring the impact of chemical configuration, binding affinity, and pharmacokinetics on CD137 agonism and antitumor activity. This effort resulted in the discovery of BT7480, which elicited robust CD137 agonism and maximum antitumor activity in syngeneic mouse models. A tumor-targeted approach to CD137 agonism using low-molecular-weight, short-acting molecules with high tumor penetration is a yet unexplored path in the clinic, where emerging data suggest that persistent target engagement, characteristic of biologics, may lead to suboptimal immune response.
CD137 (4-1BB) is a co-stimulatory receptor on immune cells and Nectin-4 is a cell adhesion molecule that is overexpressed in multiple tumor types. Using a series of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-based linkers, synthetic bicyclic peptides targeting CD137 were conjugated to Bicycles targeting Nectin-4. The resulting bispecific molecules were potent CD137 agonists that require the presence of both Nectin-4-expressing tumor cells and CD137-expressing immune cells for activity. A multipronged approach was taken to optimize these Bicycle tumor-targeted immune cell agonists by exploring the impact of chemical configuration, binding affinity, and pharmacokinetics on CD137 agonism and antitumor activity. This effort resulted in the discovery of BT7480, which elicited robust CD137 agonism and maximum antitumor activity in syngeneic mouse models. A tumor-targeted approach to CD137 agonism using low-molecular-weight, short-acting molecules with high tumor penetration is a yet unexplored path in the clinic, where emerging data suggest that persistent target engagement, characteristic of biologics, may lead to suboptimal immune response.
Checkpoint inhibitor antibodies have revolutionized
immunotherapy
in cancer, however, first-generation immune co-stimulatory receptor
agonist antibodies have shown limited success in the clinic.[1−3] CD137 (4-1BB) is an important co-stimulatory receptor expressed
on activated CD8+ T cells, activated CD4+ helper T cells, B cells,
regulatory T cells, natural killer cells, and natural killer T cells.[4,5] The anti-CD137 monoclonal antibody agonist urelumab has demonstrated
efficacy in clinical trials but clinical utility was limited by on-target
hepatotoxicity.[2] A new generation of monoclonal
antibodies (mAbs), antigen-binding fragments (Fabs), designed ankyrin
repeat proteins (DARPins), and other modalities that address the challenges
of the first-generation CD137 agonist molecules are now under evaluation
in the clinic.[6−11] While these molecules have shown promising preclinical results,
as recombinant protein modalities, they still share common limitations
with their predecessors that may eventually limit their clinical utility,
including poor penetration into solid tumors, long-circulating terminal
half-lives, and high potential for immunogenicity.[12,13]Macrocyclic peptides discovered using different de novo screening/selection
technologies have recently graduated from molecules with interesting
biology, limited by nondrug-like properties, to bona fide clinical
assets addressing unmet medical needs in numerous therapeutic areas.[14−16] Bicyclic peptides, or Bicycles, are a class of
highly constrained peptides characterized by the formation of two
loops when the linear peptide is cyclized around a trivalent scaffold. Bicycles are currently being explored in the clinic as an
inhibitor of kallikrein for ocular indications and Bicycle toxin conjugates (BTCs) for targeted delivery of cytotoxic payloads
into tumors.[17,18]We sought to expand the
utility of Bicycles as
differentiated tumor-targeted and tumor antigen-dependent CD137 agonists.
We hypothesized that these molecules may offer two advantages over
other modalities: (1) their small size (4–10 kDa) compared
to large recombinant biological molecules such as mAbs (150 kDa) results
in high tumor penetrance and may afford a more native-like immune
synapse when a tumor antigen is employed as a surrogate for CD137L
and (2) a short systemic exposure may prevent T-cell exhaustion/activation-induced
cell death of lymphocytes. In contrast to checkpoint inhibition, where
complete saturation of the receptors drives the reversal of immunosuppression,
intermittent target engagement that reflects the physiological context
of T-cell co-stimulation may be more appropriate for a CD137 agonist.[19,20]The first series of these Bicycle tumor-targeted
immune cell agonists (Bicycle TICAs) was recently
reported, and the generalizability and modularity of the approach
along with the application of Bicycle TICAs targeting
EphA2 to treat tumors preclinically were described.[21] We have also progressed a second program targeting Nectin-4-expressing
tumors. Nectin-4 is highly expressed in a wide range of solid tumors,
including bladder cancer, breast cancer, including triple-negative
breast cancer, gastric/upper gastrointestinal (GI) cancer, non-small
cell lung cancer, ovarian cancer, melanoma, and pancreatic cancer.[22,23]Here, we describe the genesis of BCY11863 (BT7480), starting
from
the first Bicycle TICA synthesized to the clinical
candidate and present a retrospective analysis of the effects of different
variables on potency and efficacy. A medicinal chemistry approach
to optimizing this type of dual tumor/immune cell targeting moiety
is unprecedented in the literature because this is the first example
of a class of fully synthetic and <10 kDa MW ligands that can co-ligate
a target antigen on tumor cells and a co-stimulatory receptor on immune
cells. Through this medicinal chemistry campaign, the roles of linker
length, affinity, stoichiometry, hinge composition, pharmacokinetics,
and target expression were elucidated to develop the first-in-class
clinical candidate Bicycle TICA. The pharmacology
of BT7480 has recently been described and it is currently undergoing
clinical trial (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT05163041).[24]
Results
In Vitro Proof of Concept
To (a) explore the possibility
of directing CD137 agonism to Nectin-4-expressing tumors and (b) assess
the potential of tumor antigen Nectin-4 to provide a scaffolding function
to oligomerize and present a CD137 Bicycle to immune
cells in a manner that leads to tumor antigen-dependent activation
(Figure A), a previously
identified Nectin-4-targeting Bicycle was adopted
as a starting point. The initial design involved directly conjugating
this chemically optimized Nectin-4-binding bicyclic peptide together
with its 10-sarcosine linker with an additional PEG12 linker to a
CD137-binding Bicycle, resulting in BCY8854 (Figure B). BCY8854 retained
binding to both receptors with individual affinities to Nectin-4 and
CD137 determined by surface plasmon resonance (SPR) to be KD = 2.8 and 108 nM, respectively (Table S1). When this simple prototype bispecific
compound was added to a coculture system containing a murine colon
adenocarcinoma cell line engineered to express Nectin-4 (MC38-Nectin-4)
or the corresponding parental line that does not endogenously express
Nectin-4 (MC38) and a CD137-overexpressing Jurkat reporter cell line
(hereby, referred to as the tumor cell/CD137 reporter coculture assay),
dose-dependent agonism of CD137 was observed only in the presence
of the Nectin-4-expressing MC38 clone (Figure C). As anticipated for a bispecific molecule
that forms ternary complexes, BCY8854 showed reduced agonism at concentrations
above 300 nM. This is referred to as a “hook effect”
and is anticipated to be seen at concentrations, where one or both
targets become limiting.[25] CD137 agonism
was also observed with BCY8854 in coculture with human tumor cell
lines HT1376 and NCI-H292 that endogenously express Nectin-4 and a
CD137-overexpressing Jurkat reporter cell line but not with a Nectin-4
null PC3 cell line.[21]
Figure 1
First Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA demonstrates
Nectin-4-dependent CD137 agonism. (A) Schematic illustration of Nectin-4-dependent
CD137 agonism induced by BCY8854. (B) Structure of BCY8854 with a
linker composed of Peg12 and Sar10 and affinities to CD137 and Nectin-4
as measured by SPR. (C) CD137 reporter coculture assay activity with
MC38 (Nectin-4 negative) or MC38-Nectin-4 tumor cells after treatment
for 6 h with BCY8854. Data are mean (n = 2 replicates).
(D) Pictorial representation of BCY10000, where Nectin-4 bicycle,
linker, and attachment point are the same as BCY8854, but the CD137
bicycle is replaced with higher affinity analogue. The binding affinities
(KD) to CD137 and Nectin-4 as measured
by SPR are also shown. (E) HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay activity
of BCY8854 and BCY10000. Data are mean ± s.d (n = 3 replicates) and represented as fold induction over the background
of a luciferase reporter gene driven by an element that responds to
CD137 stimulation. Data in panels (C) and (E) were fit using log (agonist)
vs response–variable slope (four parameters) in GraphPad Prism
V.8.4.3.
First Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA demonstrates
Nectin-4-dependent CD137 agonism. (A) Schematic illustration of Nectin-4-dependent
CD137 agonism induced by BCY8854. (B) Structure of BCY8854 with a
linker composed of Peg12 and Sar10 and affinities to CD137 and Nectin-4
as measured by SPR. (C) CD137 reporter coculture assay activity with
MC38 (Nectin-4 negative) or MC38-Nectin-4 tumor cells after treatment
for 6 h with BCY8854. Data are mean (n = 2 replicates).
(D) Pictorial representation of BCY10000, where Nectin-4 bicycle,
linker, and attachment point are the same as BCY8854, but the CD137
bicycle is replaced with higher affinity analogue. The binding affinities
(KD) to CD137 and Nectin-4 as measured
by SPR are also shown. (E) HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay activity
of BCY8854 and BCY10000. Data are mean ± s.d (n = 3 replicates) and represented as fold induction over the background
of a luciferase reporter gene driven by an element that responds to
CD137 stimulation. Data in panels (C) and (E) were fit using log (agonist)
vs response–variable slope (four parameters) in GraphPad Prism
V.8.4.3.A parallel medicinal chemistry effort undertaken
(manuscript in
preparation) to optimize the potency of the CD137-binding Bicycle led to the discovery of BCY7965 with an improved
affinity of 4 nM as measured by SPR (Table S1). Incorporation of this higher affinity CD137 binder in BCY10000
improved the in vitro potency (EC50) by fourfold and Emax by 1.5 fold in the HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture
assay (Figure D,E).
BCY8854 and BCY10000 demonstrated the proof of concept for a Nectin-4-dependent Bicycle TICA approach and served as the starting point for
further medicinal chemistry optimization efforts.
Exploring Affinity, Linker Length, and Attachment Point
Due to the modular nature of the Bicycles, several
analogues of BCY8854 and BCY10000 were synthesized to explore the
effects of affinity, linker length, and attachment point of the Bicycles on the potency. Three attachment points on the
CD137 Bicycle were explored, where one of the amino
acid side chains was replaced with primary amine groups for conjugation:
C-terminal Ala → Dap, Glu3 → Lys3, and dAla4 →
dLys4. Similarly, two attachment points for conjugation to the Nectin-4 Bicycle were explored: N-terminal amine and dAsp3 →
dLys3 substitution (Figure A and Table S7). These attachment
points did not significantly impact binding to their respective targets,
i.e., substitution of these positions with alternate amino acids had
little to no impact on affinity (data not shown). The linkers evaluated
spanned a range of lengths from 79 atoms (linker 1) to 8 atoms (linker
4) (Figure B). Ten Bicycle TICAs (synthesis and full structure in the Supporting Information) were assessed in the
HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay using BCY10000 as the plate
control. Remarkably, changing the linker length (Figure B) and attachment point (Figure A) led to no significant
changes in activity (EC50 and Emax) indicating
a high degree of flexibility of the binding mode of the bispecific
molecules (Figure A and Table S2). For example, BCY10572
which contains a Nectin-4 Bicycle (BCY8116, Table S7) conjugated via the N-terminus (Figure A) to a PEG5 linker
(linker 3, Figure B) via an amide bond and a CD137 Bicycle (BCY8928, Table S7) via click chemistry has a similar EC50
and Emax in the HT1376/CD137 coculture
reporter assay to BCY11374, which has the same Nectin-4 and CD137 Bicycles as BCY10572 but contains a much shorter linker
(linker 4, Figure B). One exception to the lack of differences in potency in the series
was BCY10571. BCY10571 has a PEG5 linker (linker 3, Figure B) and Lys3 attachment on the
CD137 Bicycle, which exhibited an EC50 two- to threefold
weaker than similar compounds with either dLys4 (BCY10572) or C-terminal
Dap (BCY10573) attachment.
Figure 2
Chemical structures of representative CD137
and Nectin-4 Bicycles and linkers used in the synthesis
of Bicycle TICAs. (A) Structure of CD137-binding
bicycle (left). One of the
three positions highlighted was modified to incorporate nucleophilic
amine containing amino acids (Lys3, dLys4, C-terminal Dap). Nectin-4-binding Bicycle (right) with N-terminal amine or dAsp3 →
dLys3 substitution used for conjugation highlighted. (B) Structure
of four linkers used to assess the impact of linker length on the
potency of Bicycle TICAs. Dashed bonds represent
the attachment point to Nectin-4- or CD137-binding Bicycle via an amide bond.
Figure 3
Exploring the structure–activity relationship of
1:1 Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA. (A) Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs containing the same CD137 and Nectin-4 binders,
but different
linker lengths and attachment point (structures in Figure ) were assessed in the HT1376/CD137
reporter coculture assay. Individual EC50 and Emax (fold induction over background) were reported as points,
geometric means as crossbars, and the number of replicates (n) shown on the Emax plot. Colors
represent the linkers and shapes represent the attachment points on
the Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycles (B, C) EC50 (nM) determined
in HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay of Bicycle TICAs that have the (B) same CD137 Bicycles (BCY8928)
but different Nectin-4 Bicycles or (C) same Nectin-4 Bicycle (BCY8116) but different CD137 Bicycles plotted against binding affinities (KD) to (B) Nectin-4 and (C) CD137 as measured by SPR. EC50 was reported
from at least three independent experiments. SPR (KD) was measured using at least four concentrations of Bicycle TICA to obtain kon, koff, and KD. Adjusted R2 and p value are reported
from the linear regression model of mean EC50 (nM) vs KD (nM).
Chemical structures of representative CD137
and Nectin-4 Bicycles and linkers used in the synthesis
of Bicycle TICAs. (A) Structure of CD137-binding
bicycle (left). One of the
three positions highlighted was modified to incorporate nucleophilic
amine containing amino acids (Lys3, dLys4, C-terminal Dap). Nectin-4-binding Bicycle (right) with N-terminal amine or dAsp3 →
dLys3 substitution used for conjugation highlighted. (B) Structure
of four linkers used to assess the impact of linker length on the
potency of Bicycle TICAs. Dashed bonds represent
the attachment point to Nectin-4- or CD137-binding Bicycle via an amide bond.Exploring the structure–activity relationship of
1:1 Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA. (A) Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs containing the same CD137 and Nectin-4 binders,
but different
linker lengths and attachment point (structures in Figure ) were assessed in the HT1376/CD137
reporter coculture assay. Individual EC50 and Emax (fold induction over background) were reported as points,
geometric means as crossbars, and the number of replicates (n) shown on the Emax plot. Colors
represent the linkers and shapes represent the attachment points on
the Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycles (B, C) EC50 (nM) determined
in HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay of Bicycle TICAs that have the (B) same CD137 Bicycles (BCY8928)
but different Nectin-4 Bicycles or (C) same Nectin-4 Bicycle (BCY8116) but different CD137 Bicycles plotted against binding affinities (KD) to (B) Nectin-4 and (C) CD137 as measured by SPR. EC50 was reported
from at least three independent experiments. SPR (KD) was measured using at least four concentrations of Bicycle TICA to obtain kon, koff, and KD. Adjusted R2 and p value are reported
from the linear regression model of mean EC50 (nM) vs KD (nM).The impact of the Bicycle TICA
binding affinity
to both targets on CD137 agonism was evaluated. Two sets of Bicycle TICAs were selected for analysis: (a) compounds
with the same CD137 Bicycle (BCY8928), but different
Nectin-4 Bicycles (Nectin-4 KD range (20-fold): 0.7–14 nM), and (b) compounds with
the same Nectin-4 Bicycle (BCY8116), but different
CD137 Bicycles (CD137 KD range (20-fold): 3.4–73 nM) (see CSV file in the Supporting Information). Evaluation of this series
in the HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay system and SPR binding
experiments to both Nectin-4 and CD137 (Figure B,C) demonstrated that the potency of the Bicycle TICA is correlated to the binding affinity for both
monomers (p-value of 2.1 × 10–6 and 0.004, respectively). However, the EC50 was much more sensitive
to the affinity to Nectin-4 (adjusted R2 = 0.96) than to CD137 (adjusted R2 =
0.50). Indeed, improving the CD137 affinity from 73 nM (BCY9399) to
3.5 nM (BCY11375) only improved the EC50 by 3.6-fold while improving
the Nectin-4 affinity from 14 nM (BCY11858) to 0.67 nM (BCY12579)
resulted in improvement of EC50 by 12-fold (Tables S1 and S2). This indicates that the binding affinity of the
tumor-targeting Bicycle had a more substantial impact
on potency than modulating the immune cell engaging arm.
Exploring Valency
CD137 on immune cells is activated
by engagement with its native ligand CD137L, a homotrimeric protein
found on antigen-presenting cells.[26] Agonistic
CD137 antibodies achieve different degrees of receptor activation
via antibody-mediated dimerization and through higher-order clustering
by Fc receptors.[27] To explore the impact
of valency of both the Nectin-4- and CD137-binding arms on the activity
of the Bicycle TICAs, a series of hinges with different
valencies were synthesized (Figure A) and the ratios of Nectin-4 and CD137 binders were
controlled using orthogonal or sequential conjugation steps (Supporting Information). Significant improvements
in both EC50 (8.3-fold) and Emax (2.0-fold)
were observed in the HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay when the
ratio of Nectin-4/CD137 was changed from 1:1 (BCY10572) to 1:2 (BCY10918)
using a trimesic acid/PEG10 based 3-armed hinge (hinge 1, Figure ) with similar improvements
seen with the 1:2 molecule (BCY11027) synthesized using hinge 2. There
were no significant improvements in EC50 or Emax by increasing the valency further from 1:2 to 1:3, which
was synthesized using hinge 3 (Figure A). Additionally, and as previously described, homotrimers
of CD137 Bicycles can achieve potent agonism of CD137
independent of tumor antigen binding.[21] As the design goal for the Bicycle TICA was complete
dependence on tumor targeting for activity, a 1:3 molecule, such as
BCY11022, that could potentially be active in nontumor tissues was
not pursued further. The 2:2 molecule BCY12970 synthesized using hinge
4 was 2.9-fold more potent than the 1:2 format with a similar Emax (Figure ). While this was a modest improvement, it was not
substantial enough to warrant the potentially more complex manufacturing
steps that would come in later stages of development. A 2:1 Nectin-4/CD137
(BCY11384) valency synthesized using hinge 2 was also considered,
but the Emax was lower with no improvement
in EC50 compared to 1:1 format (Table S2). The 1:2 Nectin-4/CD137 valency was therefore selected as the lead
format for further medicinal chemistry optimization.
Figure 4
Exploring the structure–activity
relationship of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs by modulating
the ratio of CD137 and Nectin-4 Bicycles. (A) Structure
of four hinges used to assemble
different ratios of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycles into Bicycle TICAs. (B) EC50 and (C) Emax (fold induction over background) of Bicycle TICAs
determined in HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay. Individual data
from each experiment shown as points, geometric mean as crossbars,
and number of replicates on the bottom of Emax plot. Shapes represent hinge or linker, and color represents valency
of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycles in the Bicycle TICA. The global test for significance was performed using a Kruskal–Wallis
nonparametric test. Multiple pairwise tests with BCY10572 as a reference
group were performed using the Mann–Whitney U test.
Exploring the structure–activity
relationship of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs by modulating
the ratio of CD137 and Nectin-4 Bicycles. (A) Structure
of four hinges used to assemble
different ratios of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycles into Bicycle TICAs. (B) EC50 and (C) Emax (fold induction over background) of Bicycle TICAs
determined in HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay. Individual data
from each experiment shown as points, geometric mean as crossbars,
and number of replicates on the bottom of Emax plot. Shapes represent hinge or linker, and color represents valency
of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycles in the Bicycle TICA. The global test for significance was performed using a Kruskal–Wallis
nonparametric test. Multiple pairwise tests with BCY10572 as a reference
group were performed using the Mann–Whitney U test.
Exploring the Structure–Activity Relationships of 1:2 Bicycle TICAs
A commercially available 1:2 hinge
(hinge 5, Figure A)
was adopted to improve the synthetic tractability of the 1:2 Bicycle TICAs. Using this hinge, a series of molecules were
created that explored the effect of modifications to the CD137 and
Nectin-4 binders on the potency, solubility, and pharmacokinetics
of the 1:2 Bicycle TICAs. This series of molecules
was compared to 1:1 Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs
that had the same set of Nectin-4- and CD137-binding Bicycles in the HT1376/CD137 coculture reporter assay. The 1:2 format had
4.8-fold lower EC50 compared to the 1:1 format (geometric mean EC50
= 0.46 vs 2.2 nM) and 1.8-fold higher Emax (geometric mean Emax = 64 vs 36 fold
induction over background) (Figure B). When compared like for like according to substitutions
of amino acids within the CD137-binding arm of the molecule, the trend
for potency is similar (Figure C). A detailed analysis of the structure–activity relationship
based on substitutions to the CD137 Bicycle and its
impact on binding affinity in the context of the cocrystal structure
is described elsewhere (manuscript under preparation). Interestingly,
substitutions that significantly weakened the binding affinity to
CD137 (Asp9 → Glu, Asn) substantially reduced the activity
in the 1:1 format, but when incorporated into the 1:2 format, the
impact on EC50 (14 and 12 nM, respectively) and Emax (25- and 11-fold induction over background, respectively)
was less severe. Having two CD137 binders may induce higher-order
clustering or provide enhanced affinity through avidity effects, and
this may explain the greater retained activity for the 1:2 format.
Consistent with this hypothesis, it was demonstrated by SPR that 1:2
molecules BCY12486 and BCY12487 bound to immobilized CD137 with an
apparent KD of around ∼8 nM, whereas
the 1:1 analogues (BCY12378 and BCY12481) bind with KD of 878 and 2.37 μM, respectively (Figure S1).
Figure 5
Exploring the structure–activity
relationship of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs by introducing
point mutations to CD137-binding Bicycle. (A) Structure
of hinge 5. (B) Box and whisker plot
of the geometric mean of EC50 and Emax of each Bicycle TICA (excluding substitution Asp9
→ Asn and Asp9 → Glu that substantially impacted binding
affinity) synthesized in the 1:1 format using linker 3 and 1:2 format
using hinge 5 in the determined in HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture
assay. The test for significance was performed using the Mann–Whitney
U test. (C) EC50 and Emax of Bicycle TICAs from the HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay shown as individual
data points with geometric mean represented as crossbars. The x-axis represents point mutations to the CD137 Bicycle of the Bicycle TICA as compared to BCY12379 (linker
3, 1:1) and BCY12485 (hinge 5, 1:2).
Exploring the structure–activity
relationship of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs by introducing
point mutations to CD137-binding Bicycle. (A) Structure
of hinge 5. (B) Box and whisker plot
of the geometric mean of EC50 and Emax of each Bicycle TICA (excluding substitution Asp9
→ Asn and Asp9 → Glu that substantially impacted binding
affinity) synthesized in the 1:1 format using linker 3 and 1:2 format
using hinge 5 in the determined in HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture
assay. The test for significance was performed using the Mann–Whitney
U test. (C) EC50 and Emax of Bicycle TICAs from the HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture assay shown as individual
data points with geometric mean represented as crossbars. The x-axis represents point mutations to the CD137 Bicycle of the Bicycle TICA as compared to BCY12379 (linker
3, 1:1) and BCY12485 (hinge 5, 1:2).
Functional Activity of Bicycle TICAs against
Primary Immune Cells
The HT1376/CD137 reporter coculture
assay system enabled us to quickly screen many Bicycle TICAs as the first filter in our screening cascade. To confirm that
this activity translated to primary human immune cells, HT1376 tumor
cells were cocultured with human peripheral blood mononuclear cells
(PBMCs) from healthy donors and treated with anti-CD3 to stimulate
CD137 expression on immune cells. Key molecules at each stage of the
optimization campaign were evaluated in this assay. BCY8854, BCY10000,
BCY10572, BCY11385, BCY11864, BCY12587 (Figure A) and BCY11863[24] all led to a dose-dependent increase in secretion of proinflammatory
cytokines IFNγ and IL-2 (Table S3). This experiment was repeated in multiple donors: BCY11863 and
its close analogue BCY11385 were the two most potent Bicycle TICAs in this assay (Table S3). No IL-2
or IFNγ secretion was observed with BCY13144, a 1:2 Bicycle TICA, where the Nectin-4 Bicycle was modified by replacing two tryptophans with their corresponding
D-enantiomers to abrogate binding to Nectin-4. Surprisingly, the potency
of BCY12587 in the primary immune cell assay was about 10-fold lower
compared to the reporter assay coculture system. We hypothesize that
the reduced affinity of the CD137 Bicycle incorporated
in BCY12587 (1:2 Nectin-4/CD137 valency) to its target is masked by
avidity effects of the dimeric CD137 moiety in the overexpressing
CD137 reporter system. But in activated primary immune cells that
have more physiologically relevant levels of CD137, the avidity effects
may be diminished highlighting the need to evaluate these Bicycle TICAs in assays using a physiologically relevant
immune cell population.
Figure 6
In vitro functional activity and in vivo pharmacodynamics
of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA. (A) Human PBMCs cocultured
with HT1376 cell
line were treated with anti-CD3 (OKT3) to induce CD137 expression
and Bicycle TICAs were added. (B) Human PBMCs cocultured
with mouse MC38 cell line or MC38-Nectin-4 were treated with anti-CD3
(OKT3) and BCY11864 or BCY12797 was added to the coculture system.
(A, B) IFNγ released into the coculture supernatant was measured
after 48 h. Data are mean/SD (n = 3 replicates).
Data were fit using log(agonist) vs response–variable slope
(four parameters) in GraphPad Prism V.8.4.3. (C) BCY11864 increases
the numbers of cytotoxic CD8+ T cells in contrast to vehicle and monomethyl
auristatin E (MMAE). MC38-Nectin-4 tumors injected with vehicle, BCY11864,
and MMAE were evaluated for the presence of cytotoxic T cells (CD8+/GzB+)
by immunohistochemistry (IHC) 24 h after microinjection. Pink: CD8;
aqua: GzB; yellow: fluorescent tracking marker FTM; blue: nucleus
(4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI)). (D) Quantitation of
double positive CD8+/GzB+ cells from tumor tissues normalized to total
CD8+ cells. **p < 0.001, one-way ANOVA with Dunnett’s
post-test.
In vitro functional activity and in vivo pharmacodynamics
of Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA. (A) Human PBMCs cocultured
with HT1376 cell
line were treated with anti-CD3 (OKT3) to induce CD137 expression
and Bicycle TICAs were added. (B) Human PBMCs cocultured
with mouse MC38 cell line or MC38-Nectin-4 were treated with anti-CD3
(OKT3) and BCY11864 or BCY12797 was added to the coculture system.
(A, B) IFNγ released into the coculture supernatant was measured
after 48 h. Data are mean/SD (n = 3 replicates).
Data were fit using log(agonist) vs response–variable slope
(four parameters) in GraphPad Prism V.8.4.3. (C) BCY11864 increases
the numbers of cytotoxic CD8+ T cells in contrast to vehicle and monomethyl
auristatin E (MMAE). MC38-Nectin-4 tumors injected with vehicle, BCY11864,
and MMAE were evaluated for the presence of cytotoxic T cells (CD8+/GzB+)
by immunohistochemistry (IHC) 24 h after microinjection. Pink: CD8;
aqua: GzB; yellow: fluorescent tracking marker FTM; blue: nucleus
(4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI)). (D) Quantitation of
double positive CD8+/GzB+ cells from tumor tissues normalized to total
CD8+ cells. **p < 0.001, one-way ANOVA with Dunnett’s
post-test.
In Vivo Pharmacodynamics of a Bicycle TICA
after Intratumoral Microdosing
We sought to next evaluate
the pharmacodynamics of the Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs in vivo. We used BCY11864 (1:2 format) as a tool compound
for this purpose. We first confirmed that BCY11864 was functionally
active in PBMCs (stimulated with anti-CD3) cocultured with the Nectin-4-expressing
clone of murine colon adenocarcinoma cells (MC38-Nectin-4) to be used
in the in vivo model (Figure B).The effect of BCY11864 in Nectin-4-overexpressing
MC38 tumor microenvironment was then explored in huCD137 C57Bl/6 mice
using the comparative in vivo oncology (CIVO) platform.[28] The CIVO platform operates by injecting microdoses
of drugs directly into accessible tumor tissues in trackable columns,
where tissues can be analyzed after resection for the effect of the
drug treatment in the tumor. MC38-Nectin-4 tumors were microdosed
with vehicle, the microtubule inhibitor monomethyl auristatin E (MMAE)
and BCY11864 and analyzed 24 h later for CD8 and Granzyme B (GzB)
expression by immunohistochemistry (IHC). An increase in the proportion
of CD8+/GzB+ double positive cells of total CD8+ cells was observed
in BCY11864 injection sites compared to the vehicle or MMAE injection
sites demonstrating a significant increase in cytotoxicity of the
CD8+ T-cell population (Figure C,D). Interestingly, the increase in GzB+ cells by BCY11864
was not limited to CD8+ cells, indicating that BCY11864 treatment
can activate other cytotoxic cell types beyond CD8+ T cells in tumor
tissues either directly or indirectly. The identity of the other GzB+
cells is still unknown. The in vitro and in vivo studies with BCY11864
demonstrate that immunomodulation with Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs is consistent with the mechanism of CD137 co-stimulation.
Optimization of Pharmacokinetics
Bicyclic peptides
are generally characterized by relatively short-circulating half-lives
and rapid, renal elimination. However, unlike biologics, the pharmacokinetic
parameters of these compounds can be tuned using medicinal chemistry.
To elucidate the impact of medicinal chemistry on the pharmacokinetics
of the Bicycle TICAs, key molecules from each round
of chemical optimization were evaluated in Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats.The plasma concentration–time profiles of the Bicycle TICAs in SD rats after IV bolus administration demonstrate a range
of different in vivo exposure profiles that were obtained during the
lead optimization process (Figure ). The 1:1 compound BCY10000 had a clearance (CL) of
19 mL/min/kg with a half-life of 0.36 h when dosed intravenously (Figure A–C). Replacement
of the Sar10-PEG12 linker (linker 1, Figure B) with a shorter PEG5 linker (linker 3, Figure B) improved the half-life
of the resulting molecule BCY10573 to 0.96 h. Moving the attachment
point in the CD137 Bicycle (BCY11014 → BCY8928, Table S7) from the C-terminal residue (Dap—BCY10573)
to a position central to loop 1 (dLys4—BCY10572) did not result
in a change to the CL (18 mL/min/kg) or half-life (0.93 h). Removal
of the C-terminal alanine residue of the CD137 Bicycle from BCY10572 along with a Pro to Glu substitution at position 2
(BCY12377) resulted in a decrease in the CL of twofold to 7.8 mL/min/kg
with an increase in terminal half-life to 1.8 h (Figure A). BCY10918, the initial 1:2
Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA containing a trimesic
acid hinge and PEG10 linker (hinge 1, Figure A), but the same Nectin-4 and CD137 Bicycles as the 1:1 BCY10572 had a CL of 9.1 mL/min/kg and
half-life of 1.8 h (Figure B,C). Replacing the trimesic acid hinge with another trifunctional
linker (tri(carboxyethyloxyethyl)amine) (hinge 2, Figure A, BCY11027) decreased the
half-life to 0.59 h.
Figure 7
Characterization of pharmacokinetics of the Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs in rats. (A) Plasma concentration–time
profile of representative 1:1 Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs BCY10000, BCY10572, or BCY12377 after being dosed intravenously
(IV, bolus) at 2 mg/kg in SD rats. (B) Plasma concentration–time
profile of representative 1:2 Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs BCY12590, BCY10918, BCY11863, or BCY12587 after being dosed
intravenously (IV, bolus) at 2 mg/kg in SD rats. (A, B) Data are mean
± SD (n = 3 animals/compound). (C) Clearance
(CL), volume of distribution at a steady state (Vdss) and resulting terminal half-life for all Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs assessed for pharmacokinetics in SD rats.
Mean values are shown using crossbar with individual animal data as
points on the plot.
Characterization of pharmacokinetics of the Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs in rats. (A) Plasma concentration–time
profile of representative 1:1 Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs BCY10000, BCY10572, or BCY12377 after being dosed intravenously
(IV, bolus) at 2 mg/kg in SD rats. (B) Plasma concentration–time
profile of representative 1:2 Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs BCY12590, BCY10918, BCY11863, or BCY12587 after being dosed
intravenously (IV, bolus) at 2 mg/kg in SD rats. (A, B) Data are mean
± SD (n = 3 animals/compound). (C) Clearance
(CL), volume of distribution at a steady state (Vdss) and resulting terminal half-life for all Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs assessed for pharmacokinetics in SD rats.
Mean values are shown using crossbar with individual animal data as
points on the plot.A series of 1:2 compounds that incorporated the
simple and commercially
available hinge 5 (N-(acid-PEG3)-N-bis(PEG3-azide)) (Figure ) were also evaluated. BCY11864, with the lower affinity CD137 Bicycle (BCY7744, Table S7) exhibited
a half-life of 0.95 h. Replacing the CD137 binder with the higher
affinity BCY8928 (Table S7) led to BCY11863,
which had a CL of 8.5 mL/min/kg and a terminal half-life of 3.6 h,
significantly extended over BCY11864. Other modifications to BCY11863
such as changing the attachment point on the CD137-binding Bicycle to the C-terminal Dap residue (BCY11385), removing
the C-terminal alanine from the CD137-binding Bicycle (BCY12485) or removing the C-terminal alanine and substituting Pro
for Glu at position 2 (BCY12484) did not significantly change the
CL or half-life compared to BCY11863.Replacing D-Asp3 and Asp6
on the Nectin-4 Bicycle in BCY11863 to D-Glu and
Glu (BCY12590), respectively, increased
the clearance from 7.7 to 39 mL/min/kg resulting in a half-life of
only 0.37 h. Removal of the C-terminal alanine and replacement of
N-terminal acetylated cysteine to 3-mercaptopropanoic acid (BCY12587)
in BCY11863 decreased the CL to 4.5 mL/min/kg and increased the half-life
to 17 h (Figure B,C).The plasma protein binding of selected molecules was also characterized
by ultracentrifugation to determine free drug concentrations in vivo
as well as to calculate unbound CL and volume of distribution at steady
state (Table S4). The Nectin-4 Bicycle TICAs exhibited moderate plasma protein binding
with an unbound fraction in plasma (fu,p) ranging from 0.088 to 0.37. Analysis of unbound pharmacokinetic
parameters indicates that increases in half-life are primarily driven
by increases in unbound Vdss of the Bicycle TICAs.
Characterization of Solubility
High solubility of drug
candidates is desirable as it can reduce formulation challenges and
enable more flexibility in clinical dosing strategies. Both BCY10572
(1:1, 29 mg/mL) and BCY11863 (1:2, 20 mg/mL) had high thermodynamic
solubility in 50 mM phosphate buffer at pH 7.4 while the solubility
of BCY12587 was found to be much lower (3.1 mg/mL).
Antitumor Activity in Mouse Models
BCY10572 and BCY11863
were selected for further characterization in efficacy studies because
they represented two different classes of the Bicycle TICAs (1:1 and 1:2 format respectively), and both had good solubility.The Nectin-4 Bicycle (BCY8116) binds to mouse,
rat, monkey, and human Nectin-4, however, the CD137-binding Bicycle (BCY8928) binds only to human and monkey CD137.
BCY10572 (1:1 Bicycle TICA) antitumor activity was
initially evaluated in either wild-type (wt) Balb/c or huCD137-Balb/c
(with knock-in of the extracellular domain of human CD137) mice bearing
Nectin-4-expressing CT26 (CT26-Nectin-4) tumors. Both compounds were
first evaluated with the in vitro CD137 reporter coculture assay to
confirm that CD137 activation would be achieved with the CT26-Nectin-4
cell line (Figure A). The pharmacokinetic profiles of both compounds after intraperitoneal
(IP) dosing were assessed in CD-1 mice and found to be similar (Figure B).
Figure 8
Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA cause tumor regression
in vivo. (A) Jurkat-CD137 reporter cells were cocultured with CT26
clone overexpressing Nectin-4 (CT26-Nectin-4) and treated with BCY10572
(1:1 Bicycle TICA), BCY11863 (1:2 Bicycle TICA), or CD137L. Data are mean ± s.d. (n ≥
3 replicates). (B) Plasma concentration of BCY10572 and BCY11864 when
dosed at 15 mg/kg by intraperitoneal injection to CD-1 mouse. (C,
D) CT26-Nectin-4 tumor-bearing huCD137-Balb/c (C) or wild type Balb/c
(D) mice were treated with daily doses of vehicle or BCY10572 (1 or
5 mg/kg) and tumor growth was monitored. Data are mean ± standard
error of the mean (SEM) (n = 5 mice/treatment cohort).
TV: tumor volume.
Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA cause tumor regression
in vivo. (A) Jurkat-CD137 reporter cells were cocultured with CT26
clone overexpressing Nectin-4 (CT26-Nectin-4) and treated with BCY10572
(1:1 Bicycle TICA), BCY11863 (1:2 Bicycle TICA), or CD137L. Data are mean ± s.d. (n ≥
3 replicates). (B) Plasma concentration of BCY10572 and BCY11864 when
dosed at 15 mg/kg by intraperitoneal injection to CD-1 mouse. (C,
D) CT26-Nectin-4 tumor-bearing huCD137-Balb/c (C) or wild type Balb/c
(D) mice were treated with daily doses of vehicle or BCY10572 (1 or
5 mg/kg) and tumor growth was monitored. Data are mean ± standard
error of the mean (SEM) (n = 5 mice/treatment cohort).
TV: tumor volume.Potent antitumor activity was observed in huCD137-Balb/c
mice with
1 and 5 mg/kg daily (QD) intraperitoneal (IP) dosing of BCY10572.
Unsurprisingly, no BCY10572 antitumor activity was observed in wt
Balb/c mice due to the lack of cross-reactivity to mouse CD137 (Figure C,D). BCY11863 (1:2)
was also evaluated in the CT26-Nectin-4/huCD137 mouse model and, at
5 mg/kg QD, significant antitumor activity was observed.[24] Based on these preliminary in vivo activity
results, both compounds were further profiled to identify the lead
candidate.
Characterization of the Pharmacokinetics in Nonhuman Primates
(NHPs)
To identify a final candidate molecule, the translatability
of the pharmacokinetics of BCY10572 and BCY11863 from rodents to higher
species was evaluated in cynomolgus monkeys. Each compound was infused
for 30 min in NHPs (n = 2 animals/compound) at a
dose of 1 mg/kg. BCY10572 had a mean plasma clearance of 30 mL/min/kg
and a Vdss of 0.6 L/kg, resulting in half-life
of 0.5 h. The high clearance of BCY10572 was not predicted from pharmacokinetics
in rats. BCY11863, on the other hand, had a plasma clearance of 3.3
mL/min/kg and a Vdss of 0.6 L/kg, resulting
in a terminal half-life of 5.3 h in this study (Figure A). Pharmacokinetic data from follow-up studies
of BCY11863 in NHPs are described elsewhere.[24] BCY11863 exhibited linear pharmacokinetics in doses ranging from
1 to 30 mg/kg in mouse, enabling the development of exposure-response
models in the preclinical efficacy models (Figure B).
Figure 9
Bicycle TICA pharmacokinetics
across preclinical
species and antitumor activity in the MC38 syngeneic model. (A) Plasma
concentration–time profile and pharmacokinetic parameters (table
insert) after infusion of 1 mg/kg of BCY10572 or BCY11863 over 30
min in NHPs (cynomolgus monkeys). Data are mean (n = 2 animals/compound). (B) Exposure (AUCinf) of BCY11863
plotted as a function of dose after administration of 1, 5, 10, and
30 mg/kg nominal dose of BCY11863 in CD-1 mice. (C) Unbound clearance
(CL), volume of distribution (Vdss), and
terminal half-life of BCY11863 plotted against mean body weight (wt)
of mouse (n = 4), rat (n = 6), and
NHPs (n = 8). (D) MC38-Nectin-4 tumor growth in huCD137
C57Bl/6 mice with Q3D dosing of vehicle or BCY11863 (n = 6/cohort, last dose given on day 15). The number of complete responders
(CRs) is indicated in the figure. (E) Simulated plasma concentration–time
profile of BCY11863 after multiple doses at 1 and 10 mg/kg Q3D in
mice.
Bicycle TICA pharmacokinetics
across preclinical
species and antitumor activity in the MC38 syngeneic model. (A) Plasma
concentration–time profile and pharmacokinetic parameters (table
insert) after infusion of 1 mg/kg of BCY10572 or BCY11863 over 30
min in NHPs (cynomolgus monkeys). Data are mean (n = 2 animals/compound). (B) Exposure (AUCinf) of BCY11863
plotted as a function of dose after administration of 1, 5, 10, and
30 mg/kg nominal dose of BCY11863 in CD-1 mice. (C) Unbound clearance
(CL), volume of distribution (Vdss), and
terminal half-life of BCY11863 plotted against mean body weight (wt)
of mouse (n = 4), rat (n = 6), and
NHPs (n = 8). (D) MC38-Nectin-4 tumor growth in huCD137
C57Bl/6 mice with Q3D dosing of vehicle or BCY11863 (n = 6/cohort, last dose given on day 15). The number of complete responders
(CRs) is indicated in the figure. (E) Simulated plasma concentration–time
profile of BCY11863 after multiple doses at 1 and 10 mg/kg Q3D in
mice.The mean PK parameters of BCY11863 from multiple
studies scaled
well across the preclinical species (Figure C and Table S5), supporting an allometric scaling approach for human PK prediction.
Based on these findings, BCY11863 was selected as the lead candidate.
Further Characterization of Candidate BCY11863
As the
lead Bicycle TICA candidate, BCY11863 was more extensively
profiled in vitro and in vivo.[24] In additional
studies using the CT26 model described earlier, it was observed that
the antitumor activity for BCY11863 could be achieved even when dosed
Q3D.[24] This indicated that a positive pharmacologic
effect with Bicycle TICAs can be achieved without
sustained plasma concentrations, which is markedly different from
the exposure approaches taken with the recombinant bispecific CD137
agonists currently under clinical development. The reasonably short-circulating
half-life of BCY11863 in mice (Figure B, 2.3 h after IP injection) therefore permits a further
exploration of the effect of intermittent plasma exposure on antitumor
activity.Mice bearing subcutaneous MC38-Nectin-4 tumors were
treated with BCY11863 at 1 and 10 mg/kg Q3D IP. BCY11863 was efficacious,
reducing tumor growth and inducing complete responses (CRs) with the
rate of CRs ranging from 4/6 (1 mg/kg Q3D) to 6/6 (10 mg/kg Q3D) by
day 40 (Figure D).
The plasma concentration–time profiles for BCY11863 dosing
regimens in mice were simulated to assess the amount of time in a
dosing cycle that the concentration was maintained at or above the
average EC50 required to induce IFNγ and IL-2 secretion (Figure E). The 1 mg/kg Q3D
dosing regimen that led to robust efficacy had a plasma PK profile
that maintained concentrations over EC50 for approximately 1 day out
of a 3 days dosing cycle. Further extension of this work described
elsewhere showed that a dosing regimen (5 mg/kg at 0 and 24 h) which
would lead to nearly continuous target coverage over the first 2 days
of the weekly dosing cycle also achieved maximum antitumor activity,
however, longer exposures did not improve antitumor activity.[24] The potent target-dependent immune activation
combined with translatable pharmacokinetics of BCY11863 in preclinical
species and robust antitumor immunity achieved with intermittent dosing
in mouse efficacy models supports once a week dosing in the clinic.
Discussion and Conclusions
Synthetic and low-molecular-weight
tumor-targeted immune agonists
represent a unique opportunity to create differentiated molecules
that can be chemically tuned to achieve different structural and functional
properties. These tunable attributes mean that compounds can be optimized
to elicit the desired pharmacology and to create a molecule that has
sufficiently strong pharmaceutical properties to warrant advancement
to clinical development. Our goal was to discover a Nectin-4-targeted
CD137 agonist clinical candidate that had the optimal in vivo characteristics
to elicit the desired immune cell response by co-ligating Nectin-4
and CD137 and that could be dosed once a week in the clinic. To this
end, we deployed a multipronged approach to optimize the affinity
to both targets, linker length, binder stoichiometry, solubility,
and pharmacokinetic properties.The in vitro structure–activity
relationships of the 1:1
Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICAs elucidated the rules
for modulating potency, with affinity to the tumor antigen having
the largest impact as compared to the affinity to the co-stimulatory
receptor. Given the complex structures of other bispecific modalities,
a general lack of sensitivity of the potency to linker length was
a surprising finding. This lack of sensitivity to linker length may
be specific for BCY8116 binding to Nectin-4, and this result may not
translate to another Bicycle-based tumor-targeted
immune cell agonist. However, it is intriguing to speculate that the
small size and relative flexibility of linkers may permit tuning of
the distance between both target proteins at the synapse between tumor
and immune cells in a manner that may be more challenging to achieve
with larger recombinant protein modalities. By exploring the valency
of the Bicycles, it was demonstrated that the 1:2
format (Nectin-4/CD137) was the optimal balance of potency, Emax, target dependency, and manufacturing feasibility.
We are currently exploring these structure–activity parameters
in the context of other Bicycle tumor-targeted immune
cell agonists, which will test the generality of these observations.We previously described Bicycle toxin conjugates
(BTCs) that have short plasma half-lives but have profound antitumor
activity in vivo with a weekly dosing regimen.[18] The most likely basis for this result is that the pharmacokinetic
and functional properties lead to rapid delivery of the toxin payload
MMAE in the tumor where it is retained. For the Bicycle tumor-targeted immune cell agonists, we hypothesized that the co-engagement
of Nectin-4 and CD137 and activation of the immune response would
require relatively longer exposures compared to BTCs because the Bicycle TICA functions by providing a signal to tumor-infiltrating
immune cells that require some duration of action rather than deposition
of a payload, which can, in principle, occur in a very short time.
Common approaches for modulating the pharmacokinetics of peptide-based
therapeutics include lipidation, pegylation, or extended-release formulations.[15,29−31] Pegylation to extend half-life requires conjugation
to relatively high MW PEGs (20–40 kDa), and this would significantly
increase the size of the Bicycle TICA and could limit
tumor penetration, a key design feature of the Bicycle TICAs. Lipidation can increase half-life and can encourage high
tumor uptake.[32] This approach was not pursued
due to a risk of nontumor targeted CD137 activation mediated by nonspecific
tissue binding and because hydrophobicity can increase biodistribution
to the liver, where CD137 agonism presents severe hepatotoxicity risks.[33] Therefore, the impact of structural changes
to the bicyclic peptides and the linkers was evaluated to determine
if a suitable PK profile could be attained without the need to append
half-life extending moieties. Analysis of the pharmacokinetic data
from the Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA series showed
(Table S4) that the molecules with longer
half-lives were driven mostly by higher unbound volume of distribution
with differences in unbound CL being more subtle.BCY10572 and
BCY11863 were deemed suitable for candidate consideration
since they had good potency and exposure based on rodent studies.
BCY10572 is a 1:1 Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA with
nanomolar potency; BCY11863 is a 1:2 Nectin-4/CD137 Bicycle TICA with subnanomolar potency. BCY10572 showed a very high clearance
in NHPs (Figure A).
This combined with its slightly weaker in vitro potency (Tables S2, and S3) and the observed translatability
of the pharmacokinetic profile and robust antitumor activity of BCY11863
with an intermittent dosing schedule in MC38-Nectin-4 syngeneic mouse
models led to nomination of BCY11863 as the developmental candidate.[24] BCY11863 allows us to explore the potential
of a short-acting CD137 agonist in the clinic, which then differentiates
it from other modalities, addressing this target with a tumor-targeted
bispecific approach.We believe that transient but potent agonism
of CD137 (and other
tumor necrosis factor receptor (TNFR) family members) may be superior
to prolonged receptor agonism. Based on recent clinical data, maintaining
a persistently high level of target engagement in bispecific modalities
may lead to ineffective signaling and lead to a suboptimal immune
response.[34] If this is the case, this opens
up the possibility of using Bicycles with superior
tissue penetration and short-circulating exposure to target other
co-stimulatory receptors (e.g., OX40) in this class that have failed
in the clinic, possibly due to the physiochemical properties of the
drug. In contrast to both the second generation of tumor-targeted
and nontargeted CD137 agonists undergoing clinical development, this
approach may achieve the perfect balance of potent tumor-localized
activity and short peripheral exposure to drive efficacy while providing
a wider safety margin and preventing overstimulation and activation-induced
cell death of the immune cells.As a clinical candidate, BCY11863
was renamed BT7480, an homage
to the phage clones from which it originated. It presents us with
the opportunity to explore a differentiated molecule against a promising
target in a crowded therapeutic space that has the potential to positively
impact patients’ lives.
Experimental Section
Methods for synthesis and purification
of Bicycle TICAs can be found in the Supporting Information. Lead compounds including
those used in in vivo efficacy studies
were >95% purity as measured by high-performance liquid chromatography
(HPLC). All compounds had purities of >90% by HPLC with one exception
noted in Table S8. The HPLC traces of all Bicycle TICAs used in in vivo efficacy and ADME studies
are available in the Supporting Information.
Cell Lines and Reagents
HT1376, NCI-H292, PC3, and
CT26 cells were obtained from ATCC (American Type Culture Collection).
MC38 cells were obtained from the National Cancer Institute (L-159-2018/1).
CT26 and MC38 cells were engineered to express mouse Nectin-4 (NM_027893.3)
as described.[21] Human peripheral blood
mononuclear cell (PBMC) isolation was described.[21]Recombinant proteins: human CD137 (92 204B, R&D
Systems) and human CD137L (2295-4L-025, R&D Systems) were purchased.
Human Nectin-4 (residues 32–349) and rat Nectin-4 (residue
31–347) with a gp67 signal sequence and C-terminal FLAG tag
were cloned into pFastbac-1 and baculovirus using standard Bac-to-Bac
protocols (Life Technologies). Sf21 cells at 1 × 106 mL–1 in Excell-420 medium (Sigma) at 27 °C
were infected at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 2 with a P1
virus stock for protein expression. The supernatant was harvested
at 72 h and incubated for 1 h at 4 °C with anti-FLAG M2 affinity
agarose resin (Sigma) followed by a phosphate-buffered saline (PBS)
wash. Resin was subsequently transferred to a column and washed extensively
with phosphate-buffered saline (PBS). Protein was eluted with 100
μg/mL FLAG peptide concentrated to a volume of 2 mL and loaded
onto an S-200 Superdex column (GE Healthcare) in PBS at 1 mL/min.
2 mL fractions were collected and fractions containing Nectin-4 protein
were concentrated.
CD137 Reporter Coculture Assays
CD137 bioassay kits
(Promega) were carried out according to the manufacturer’s
protocol. Briefly, a Jurkat T-cell line engineered to express human
CD137 and a luciferase reporter driven by a response element that
can respond to CD137 ligand/agonist antibody stimulation were cultured
at 37 °C, 5% CO2 for 6 h with or without test article
in coculture with 10,000 cells of indicated tumor cell line. After
6 h, the Bio-Glo Luciferase reagent was added to each well. Luminescence
was measured on a BMG CLARIOStar microplate reader. Fold induction
was calculated as relative light unit (RLU) divided by RLU of background
(no test article) wells.
Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) Assay
CD137: SPR experiments
were performed on a Biacore T200 to determine the ka (M–1 s–1), kd (s–1), and KD (nM) values of peptides binding to human CD137 protein.
Recombinant human CD137 (R&D systems) was resuspended in PBS and
biotinylated using an EZ-Link Sulfo-NHSLC- LC-Biotin reagent (Thermo
Fisher) as per the manufacturer’s suggested protocol. The protein
was desalted to remove uncoupled biotin using spin columns into PBS.
Streptavidin was immobilized onto a XanTec CMD500D chip and biotinylated
CD137 in PBS/0.05% Tween 20 captured to a level of 800–1800
RU. A dilution series of the peptides were prepared in PBS/0.05% Tween
20 with a final dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) concentration of 0.5%. The
top peptide concentration was 500 nM or 10 μM with 6 further
threefold (500 nm), or twofold (10 μM) dilutions in PBS/0.05%
Tween 20. The peptides were injected over the chip at 25 °C at
a flow rate of 90 μL/min with 60 s association and 100–600
s dissociation. After each cycle, a regeneration step (10 μL
of 10 mM glycine pH 2) was employed. Data were corrected for DMSO
excluded volume effects. All data were double referenced for blank
injections and reference surfaces using standard processing procedures
and data processing and kinetic fitting were performed using Scrubber
software, version 2.0c (BioLogic Software). Data were fitted using
a mass transport model allowing for mass transport effects where appropriate.Nectin-4: SPR experiments were performed on a Biacore T200 instrument
to determine the ka (M–1 s–1), kd (s–1), KD (nM) values of peptides binding
to a recombinant human Nectin-4 protein. The protein was randomly
biotinylated in PBS using the EZ-Link Sulfo-NHS-LC-LC-Biotin reagent
(Thermo Fisher) as per the manufacturer’s suggested protocol.
The protein was extensively desalted to remove uncoupled biotin using
spin columns into PBS. Streptavidin was immobilized on a CM5 chip
(GE Healthcare) and biotinylated Nectin-4 in PBS/0.05% Tween 20 captured
to a level of 1200–1800 RU. A dilution series of the peptides
were prepared in PBS/0.05% Tween 20 with a final DMSO concentration
of 0.5%. The top peptide concentration was 100 nM with 6 further twofold
dilutions. The peptides were injected over the chip at 25 °C
at a flow rate of 50 μL/min with 60 s association and dissociation
between 400 and 1200 s depending upon the individual peptide. Data
were corrected for DMSO excluded volume effects. All data were double
referenced for blank injections and reference surfaces using standard
processing procedures and data processing and kinetic fitting were
performed using Scrubber software, version 2.0c (BioLogic Software).
Data were fitted using a simple 1:1 binding model allowing for mass
transport effects where appropriate.
Cytokine Secretion Assays and Cytokine Quantification
Frozen PBMCs from healthy human donors were thawed and washed one
time in room-temperature PBS with benzonase and then resuspended in
RPMI supplemented with 10% heat-inactivated fetal bovine serum, 1×
penicillin/streptomycin, 10 mM HEPES, and 2 mM l-glutamine
(herein referred to as R10 medium). Mouse (MC38 or MC38-Nectin-4)
or human (HT1376) tumor cells were cultured in the appropriate media.
One hundred microliters of PBMCs (1 × 106/mL) and
100 μL of tumor cells (1 × 105/mL) (effector/target
cell ratio 10:1) were plated in each well of a 96-well flat bottom
plate for the coculture assay. A soluble anti-CD3 mAb (100 ng/mL,
clone OKT3; Biolegend) was added to the culture on day 0 to stimulate
human PBMCs. Test, control compounds, or vehicle controls were diluted
in R10 media and 50 μL was added to respective wells to bring
the final volume per well to 250 μL. Plates were covered with
a breathable film and incubated in a humidified chamber at 37 °C
with 5% CO2 for 2 days. Supernatants were collected 24
and 48 h after stimulation, and human interleukin-2 (IL-2) and interferon
gamma (IFNγ) were detected by Luminex. Briefly, the standards
and samples were added to a black 96-well plate. A microparticle cocktail
(provided in Luminex kit, R&D Systems) was added and shaken for
2 h at room temperature. The plate was washed three times using a
magnetic holder. Biotin cocktail was then added to the plate and shaken
for 1 h at room temperature (RT). The plate was washed three times
using a magnetic holder. Streptavidin cocktail was added to the plate
and shaken for 30 min at RT. The plates were washed three times using
a magnetic holder, resuspended in 100 μL of wash buffer, shaken
for 2 min at RT, and read using the Luminex 2000. Raw data were analyzed
using built-in Luminex software to generate standard curves and interpolate
protein concentrations, and all other data analyses and graphing were
performed using Excel and Prism software.
CIVO
A mouse microdosing study was performed in C57BL/6J-hCD137
mice (B-hTNFRSF9(CD137); Biocytogen, Beijing, China) with subcutaneously
implanted Nectin-4-overexpressing (MC38-Nectin-4) tumors (21). Three
anesthetized MC38-Nectin-4 tumor (around 860 mm3) bearing
mice were microdosed transcutaneously with a 2 μL injection
volume of vehicle (25 mM histidine, 10% sucrose pH 7), 120 μM
MMAE, and 1.85 μM BCY11864 using the CIVO device. Inert fluorescent
injection tracking microspheres (FTMs) were added to each needle.
Mice were sacrificed 24 h after dosing, and tumors were fixed with
10% neutral buffered formalin and processed for paraffin embedding
for IHC analysis. Fluorescent IHC analysis was performed for CD8 (clone
D4W2Z; Cell Signaling #98941) and GrzB (clone 16G6, Thermo Fisher
#14-8822) and nuclear staining was done with DAPI (Invitrogen #D3571).
Images were acquired to capture CD8-, GrzB-, and nuclear staining
alongside with the FTM, indicating the injection path.
Pharmacokinetics
Male Sprague-Dawley rats were dosed
with 2 mg/kg (IV bolus) of Bicycle TICA. Male CD-1
mice were dosed at 15 mg/kg BCY11863 or BCY10572 intraperitoneally.
Male naïve cynomolgus monkeys were administered with a 30 min
intravenous infusion of 1 mg/kg BCY11863 or 1 mg/kg BCY10572. The Bicycle TICAs were formulated in 25 mM histidine HCl, 10%
sucrose pH 7. Serial bleeding was performed, and all blood samples
were immediately transferred into prechilled microcentrifuge tubes
containing 2 μL K2-EDTA (0.5 M) as an anticoagulant and placed
on wet ice. Blood samples were immediately processed for plasma by
centrifugation at approximately 4 °C, 3000g.
The precipitant including internal standard was immediately added
into the plasma, mixed well, and centrifuged at 12,000 rpm, 4 °C
for 10 min. The supernatant was transferred into prelabeled polypropylene
microcentrifuge tubes and then quick-frozen over dry ice. The samples
were stored at 70 °C or below as needed until analysis. The supernatant
samples (7.5 μL) were directly injected for liquid chromatography–tandem
mass spectrometry (LC–MS/MS) analysis using an Orbitrap Q Exactive
in positive ion mode to determine the concentrations of Bicycle. Plasma concentration vs time data were analyzed by noncompartmental
analysis (NCA) using the Phoenix WinNonlin 6.3 software program.
Plasma Protein Binding
The plasma protein binding of Bicycle TICAs was measured using ultracentrifugation as
previously described.[35]
Syngeneic Tumor Models
Mouse efficacy studies were
performed in C57BL/6J-hCD137 mice (B-hTNFRSF9(CD137); Biocytogen,
Beijing, China) with subcutaneously implanted MC38-Nectin-4 tumors
or in BALB/c hCD137 and BALB/c WT mice (GemPharmatech, Nanjing, China)
with subcutaneously implanted CT26-Nectin-4 tumors (21).MC38-Nectin-4
tumor-bearing mice were randomized into treatment groups when average
tumor volumes reached 72 mm3 and were treated with
vehicle (25 mM histidine, 10% sucrose, pH 7) or BCY11863 at
1 or 10 mg/kg every 3 days (Q3D ×6). CT26-Nectin-4 tumor-bearing
mice were randomized into treatment groups when average tumor volumes
reached 68 mm3 (in BALB/c huCD137-mice) or 64 mm3 (in WT BALB/c-mice) and were treated with vehicle (25 mM
histidine, 10% sucrose, pH 7) or BCY10572 at 1 or 5 mg/kg daily
until day 15 (BALB/c huCD137-mice) or day 14 (WT BALB/c mice). Tumor
growth was monitored by caliper measurements. Tumor volume
is expressed in mm3 using the formula: V = 0.5a × b2, where a and b are the long and short diameters
of the tumor, respectively. All treatments were administered intraperitoneally
(IP).All of the procedures related to animal handling, care,
and treatment
in the studies were performed according to the guidelines approved
by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of Presage Biosciences
(Seattle, WA) or WuXi AppTec (Beijing, China), following the guidance
of the Association for Assessment and Accreditation of Laboratory
Animal Care.
Simulation of PK for Dosing Regimens in MC38 Syngeneic Model
Efficacy Studies
The plasma concentration–time profiles
after intraperitoneal administration of BCY11863 in CD-1 mice were
analyzed using a two-compartment model (2C) in Phoenix Winnonlin.
The mean PK parameters from the 2C model were used to simulate the
plasma concentration–time profiles for the doses and dosing
regimens in the in vivo efficacy study.
Authors: Marlon J Hinner; Rachida Siham Bel Aiba; Thomas J Jaquin; Sven Berger; Manuela Carola Dürr; Corinna Schlosser; Andrea Allersdorfer; Alexander Wiedenmann; Gabriele Matschiner; Julia Schüler; Ulrich Moebius; Christine Rothe; Louis Matis; Shane Anthony Olwill Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2019-05-28 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Daniel P Teufel; Gavin Bennett; Helen Harrison; Katerine van Rietschoten; Silvia Pavan; Catherine Stace; François Le Floch; Tine Van Bergen; Elke Vermassen; Philippe Barbeaux; Tjing-Tjing Hu; Jean H M Feyen; Marc Vanhove Journal: J Med Chem Date: 2018-03-15 Impact factor: 7.446
Authors: Rui Wang; Chan Gao; Megan Raymond; Gennaro Dito; Dominic Kabbabe; Xiao Shao; Ed Hilt; Yongliang Sun; Irene Pak; Martin Gutierrez; Ignacio Melero; Anna Spreafico; Richard D Carvajal; Michael Ong; Anthony J Olszanski; Christina Milburn; Kent Thudium; Zheng Yang; Yan Feng; Paula M Fracasso; Alan J Korman; Praveen Aanur; Shih-Min A Huang; Michael Quigley Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2019-10-01 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Lisa Pollaro; Sandeep Raghunathan; Julia Morales-Sanfrutos; Alessandro Angelini; Stephan Kontos; Christian Heinis Journal: Mol Cancer Ther Date: 2014-11-07 Impact factor: 6.261
Authors: Neil H Segal; Theodore F Logan; F Stephen Hodi; David McDermott; Ignacio Melero; Omid Hamid; Henrik Schmidt; Caroline Robert; Vanna Chiarion-Sileni; Paolo A Ascierto; Michele Maio; Walter J Urba; Tara C Gangadhar; Satyendra Suryawanshi; Jaclyn Neely; Maria Jure-Kunkel; Suba Krishnan; Holbrook Kohrt; Mario Sznol; Ronald Levy Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2016-10-18 Impact factor: 12.531