Vid Jazbec1,2, Roman Jerala1,3, Mojca Benčina1,3. 1. Department of Synthetic Biology and Immunology, National Institute of Chemistry, Hajdrihova 19, SI-1001 Ljubljana, Slovenia. 2. Interfaculty Doctoral Study of Biomedicine, University of Ljubljana, SI-1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia. 3. EN-FIST Centre of Excellence, Trg Osvobodilne fronte 13, SI-1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Abstract
Highly regulated intracellular calcium entry affects numerous cellular physiological events. External regulation of intracellular calcium signaling presents a great opportunity for the artificial regulation of cellular activity. Calcium entry can be mediated by STIM proteins interacting with Orai calcium channels; therefore, the STIM1-Orai1 pair has become a tool for artificially modulating calcium entry. We report on an innovative genetically engineered protease-activated Orai activator called PACE. CAD self-dimerization and activation were inhibited with a coiled-coil forming peptide pair linked to CAD via a protease cleavage site. PACE generated sustained calcium entry after its activation with a reconstituted split protease. We also generated PACE, whose transcriptional activation of NFAT was triggered by PPV or TEV protease. Using PACE, we successfully activated the native NFAT signaling pathway and the production of cytokines in a T-cell line. PACE represents a useful tool for generating sustained calcium entry to initiate calcium-dependent protein translation. PACE provides a promising template for the construction of links between various protease activation pathways and calcium signaling.
Highly regulated intracellular calcium entry affects numerous cellular physiological events. External regulation of intracellular calcium signaling presents a great opportunity for the artificial regulation of cellular activity. Calcium entry can be mediated by STIM proteins interacting with Orai calcium channels; therefore, the STIM1-Orai1 pair has become a tool for artificially modulating calcium entry. We report on an innovative genetically engineered protease-activated Orai activator called PACE. CAD self-dimerization and activation were inhibited with a coiled-coil forming peptide pair linked to CAD via a protease cleavage site. PACE generated sustained calcium entry after its activation with a reconstituted split protease. We also generated PACE, whose transcriptional activation of NFAT was triggered by PPV or TEV protease. Using PACE, we successfully activated the native NFAT signaling pathway and the production of cytokines in a T-cell line. PACE represents a useful tool for generating sustained calcium entry to initiate calcium-dependent protein translation. PACE provides a promising template for the construction of links between various protease activation pathways and calcium signaling.
Intracellular free calcium ions (Ca2+) serve as secondary
messengers that are essential for the correct functioning of several
cell processes, from short-term muscle contraction to long-term changes
in gene expression;[1] if their temporal
concentration within cells is not carefully controlled, various severe
cell dysfunctions can occur. Ca2+/calcineurin/nuclear factor
of activated T-cells (NFAT) signaling modulates immune response with
the transcriptional regulation of cytokines and chemokines in immune
cells; NFAT activity is critical for Th cell differentiation.[2] An assembly of plasma membrane- and endoplasmic
reticulum (ER)-based ion channels and transporters orchestrates the
concentration of intracellular Ca2+. The duration and amplitude
of the Ca2+ signal produced by opening these channels govern
a Ca2+-dependent signaling response.[3]Store-operated Ca2+ entry is a Ca2+ current
that responds to the depletion of Ca2+ in the ER and is
facilitated by the ER membrane resident sensor molecule stromal interaction
molecule 1 (STIM1) and the plasma membrane Ca2+ release-activated
Ca2+ (CRAC) channel Orai1. Depletion of Ca2+ in the ER leads to conformational changes in the STIM1 ER domain,
resulting in the exposure of the effector domain of the molecule,
the CRAC activating domain (CAD, amino acid residues 342–448).[4,5] This domain binds to the intercellular C-terminus of the Orai1 channel
and renders the channel open.[6] Studies
have shown that CAD alone or even its truncated version STIM/Orai
activating region (amino acid residues 344–442) is sufficient
to fully activate the channel.[7] The monomeric
CAD forms a distinct letter R shape, which consists of four α-helical
regions. Structural and mutagenic analysis of the domain has also
shown that CAD dimerization is vital to Orai activation, and identified
important residues enabling dimerization.[8] In the same study, it has also been shown that the mutation of residues
L347, W350, and L351 of α helix 1 (CC2) and W430, I433, and
L436 of α helix 4 (CC3), which form interactions between the
helices, hinders the ability to activate Orai1.The designed
mobilization of Ca2+ to activate transcriptional
activity has already been used in the field of optogenetics, in which
light-sensitive protein domains serve as switches to activate the
effector domain from the ER calcium sensor protein STIM1[9−11] or the CRAC channel Orai1.[12] The role
of Ca2+ as a transcriptional regulator has been explored
in the combination with NFAT as a Ca2+-regulatory domain.[9,13,14] The activation of the NFAT signaling
pathway depends on long Ca2+ signals that keep the dephosphorylated
NFAT in the cell nucleus.[15] As CRAC current
is used to maintain such signals,[16] its
components are promising tools for the activation of the artificial
NFAT pathway. To date, the modulation of the STIM1 pathway has involved
the use of intact STIM1 domain architecture. We seek to explore the
possibility of regulating the intermolecular contacts of the CAD domain.
Proteolytic activity has already been described as a fast and modular
output of a synthetic circuit.[17,18] Proteolytic cleavage
is an irreversible process, and the proteolytically processed effectors
could facilitate the sustained signals. Although light as in optogenetics
provides good regulation of effectors’ activity, for sustained
activity a prolonged exposure to light is required.[10] Therefore, we reasoned that designing inactive variants
of the CAD domain that could help regain its biological activity through
proteolytic cleavage might be possible.In this study, we developed
the proteolytically activated CRAC
effector (PACE), a genetically engineered mediator between proteolytic
activity and calcium influx. The coiled-coil peptide pair P3:P4,[19−21] genetically fused to a CAD activating domain, was introduced to
inhibit CAD activity. A tobacco etch virus protease cleavage site
(TEVs) or a plum pox virus protease cleavage site (PPVs) introduced between CAD and a coiled-coil segment enabled
the activation of PACE by a defined protease that could be chemically
regulated. The chemically reconstituted split protease activated PACE
and triggered the long sustained Ca2+ entry and transcriptional
activity of NFAT. Thus, PACE represents a useful tool for regulating
Ca2+ entry and initiating physiologically relevant NFAT
activation, which was demonstrated with the expression of cytokines
in Jurkat T-cells.
Results
Engineered Orai Activators
ER-transmembrane STIM proteins
are important regulators of Orai channels. STIM1 is composed of an
ER-Ca2+ sensing domain, transmembrane helix, cytosolic
CAD domain inhibited by an inhibitory domain composed of three alpha-helices,
and an unstructured lysine-rich C-terminal domain.[22] A Ca2+-dependent structural rearrangement of
the STIM1 dimer exposes the CAD domain that activates Orai. A CAD
domain alone tends to bind and open Orai channels; therefore, we used
it as a template to design an engineered Orai activator. The binding
of alpha-helices α1 (CC2) and α4 (CC3) and the subsequent
dimerization of the domain are recognized to be crucial for the ability
of CAD to bind to the channel.[23] To prevent
spontaneous CAD dimerization and activation, we used intramolecular
P3 and P4 coiled-coil forming peptides as steric hindrances to force
CAD into an inactive conformation.[24] P3
peptide was fused to the N-terminus of CC2, and P4 was added to the
C-terminus of CC3 (Figure A). P3 and P4 peptides form a rigid parallel coiled-coil dimer
that prevents spontaneous CAD dimerization. For the activation of
CAD, the protease recognition site was introduced between the coiled-coil
forming peptide and the CAD domain. The effect of the engineered Orai
activators was tested using a reporter plasmid with 10 repeats of
the transcription activator-like effector (TALE) binding site upstream
of a minimal promoter (10TALE_Pmin-fLuc) expressing reporter firefly
luciferase and a plasmid expressing an engineered NFAT-based transcription
factor mNFAT:TALE:VP16:KRΦ[13] (Figure A). The activity
of transcription factor depends on the retention in the nucleus; therefore,
constructs capable of generating sustained Ca2+ influx,
which promote dephosphorylation of the transcription factor, are favored.
The CAD domain was N terminally linked to mCherry;[25] we added a Myc tag at the N terminal of mCherry to enable
protein visualization (Figure B).
Figure 1
Coiled-coil P3:P4 peptide pair inhibits CAD. (A) Scheme of an engineered
activator of Orai. The P3 and P4 peptides form a coiled-coil that
prevents the self-activation of CAD. The protease cleaves the TEVs between P3 and CAD and enables the dimerization of CAD into
an active form. The protease-activated CAD activates Ca2+-dependent ion channel Orai. The Ca2+ influx activates
the synthetic NFAT-based transcription factor, translocation in the
nucleus, and expression of a gene of interest. (B) Engineered Orai
activator. The structure of the CAD domain from STIM1 is highlighted
above. Legend: red and orange, mCherry with Myc-tag; blue and violet,
P3 and P4 coiled-coil peptides; gray, CAD; dark yellow, TEVs. (C–E) Constitutive activity of the engineered NFAT-based
transcription factor in the presence of CAD (C), P3-CAD (D), or CAD-P4
(E) effector in HEK293 cells. (F) The inactive P3-CAD-P4 effector
fails to activate the NFAT-based transcription factor in HEK293 cells.
(G) Immunodetection of the uncleaved and cleaved P3-TEVs-CAD-P4 variant in HEK293T cells using anti-Myc antibodies. (H) Localization
of mCherry-tagged P3-TEVs-CAD-P4 in HEK293 cells. The scale
bar represents 20 μm. (I) The P3-TEVs-CAD-P4 effector
exhibits the activation of an engineered NFAT-based transcription
factor in the presence of TEV protease in HEK293T cells. One day after
transfection, the HEK293T cells were lysed, and reporter activity
was measured. The amounts of transfected plasmids are listed in Table S1. The bars represent the mean ±
s.d.; n = 4 biologically independent cell cultures.
Statistical significance and fold change are indicated above the bars.
Statistical analyses and the corresponding p-values
are listed in Table S5.
Coiled-coil P3:P4 peptide pair inhibits CAD. (A) Scheme of an engineered
activator of Orai. The P3 and P4 peptides form a coiled-coil that
prevents the self-activation of CAD. The protease cleaves the TEVs between P3 and CAD and enables the dimerization of CAD into
an active form. The protease-activated CAD activates Ca2+-dependent ion channel Orai. The Ca2+ influx activates
the synthetic NFAT-based transcription factor, translocation in the
nucleus, and expression of a gene of interest. (B) Engineered Orai
activator. The structure of the CAD domain from STIM1 is highlighted
above. Legend: red and orange, mCherry with Myc-tag; blue and violet,
P3 and P4 coiled-coil peptides; gray, CAD; dark yellow, TEVs. (C–E) Constitutive activity of the engineered NFAT-based
transcription factor in the presence of CAD (C), P3-CAD (D), or CAD-P4
(E) effector in HEK293 cells. (F) The inactive P3-CAD-P4 effector
fails to activate the NFAT-based transcription factor in HEK293 cells.
(G) Immunodetection of the uncleaved and cleaved P3-TEVs-CAD-P4 variant in HEK293T cells using anti-Myc antibodies. (H) Localization
of mCherry-tagged P3-TEVs-CAD-P4 in HEK293 cells. The scale
bar represents 20 μm. (I) The P3-TEVs-CAD-P4 effector
exhibits the activation of an engineered NFAT-based transcription
factor in the presence of TEV protease in HEK293T cells. One day after
transfection, the HEK293T cells were lysed, and reporter activity
was measured. The amounts of transfected plasmids are listed in Table S1. The bars represent the mean ±
s.d.; n = 4 biologically independent cell cultures.
Statistical significance and fold change are indicated above the bars.
Statistical analyses and the corresponding p-values
are listed in Table S5.To adjust for the best response, we titrated the
amount of CAD-coding
plasmid (Figure C)
and used 20 ng of CAD in subsequent experiments, as this concentration,
compared with A21387 calcium ionophore, achieved full activation (Figure S1). The addition of a P3 peptide to the
N terminus (P3-CAD) or of P4 to the C terminus of CAD (CAD-P4) did
not prevent the spontaneous activation of Orai and the transcriptional
activation of mNFAT:TALE:VP16:KRΦ (Figure D, 1E). However, when
combined in the same polypeptide chain, P3 and P4 formed a stable
intramolecular coiled-coil structure. This motif functions as a restraint
that separates the ends of α helices 1 and 4 of the CAD domain.
The P3-CAD-P4 construct, therefore, lost its ability to trigger the
Ca2+-dependent transcriptional activation of a reporter
(Figure F), thus confirming
the feasibility of our concept. To introduce the controlled activation
of the engineered Orai activator, we added seven amino acid-long TEVs between helix P3 and the CAD domain (Figure B) and confirmed the cleavage of the engineered
CAD with TEV protease (Figure G). The P3-TEVs-CAD-P4 construct was localized
in the cytosol similar to wt CAD (Figure H). Cotransfection of a plasmid expressing
TEV protease in cells expressing P3-TEVs-CAD-P4 and mNFAT:TALE:VP16:KRΦ
transcription factor activated the expression of a reporter (Figure I). The transcriptional
activity in cells with coexpressed TEV protease was 2.5 times higher
than that in cells with no protease. However, the expression of the
reporter was also detected in cells with no protease present, indicating
the self-activation of the engineered Orai activator, which might
be due to the insertion of TEVs that added a flexible linker
between P3 and CAD.
Proteolytically Activated Activators of Orai
To extend
the distance between α1 and α4 helices and thus prevent
the spontaneous formation of active CAD, the peptide EEEEKKKKEEEEKK
with a high helical propensity[26] was added
between the coiled-coil peptide and the CAD helix. The rigid helix-forming
peptide was added C-terminally of P3 or N-terminally of P4, forming
P3h-TEVs-CAD-P4 or P3-TEVs-CAD-hP4, respectively
(Figure A, 2B). While the addition of a rigid helix in the construct
P3h-TEVs-CAD-P4 reduced the background signal, it also
attenuated activation with a TEV protease (Figure A; S2A). No improvement
in activity was determined when a rigid helix was inserted between
CAD and P4 peptide in P3-TEVs-CAD-hP4 (Figure B; S2B), although the TEV protease effectively cleaved the P3 peptide from
CAD (Figure S3).
Figure 2
Proteolytically activated
CRAC effector variants. (A–D)
Transcriptional activity of the engineered mNFAT-based transcription
factor in the presence of CRAC activators: (A) P3h-TEVs-CAD-P4, (B) P3-TEVs-CAD-hP4, (C) P3h-TEVs-CAD-TEVs-P4, and (D) P3-TEVs-CAD-TEVs-hP4 in
HEK293T cells. (Left) Structural model of the effector. For clarity,
mCherry was not depicted. Schemes depict proteolytically activated
CRAC effector variants. The rigid helix was inserted between the coiled-coil
peptides P3 and P4 and the TEVs site. Legend: red, mCherry
with Myc-tag; blue and violet, P3 and P4 coiled-coil peptides; gray,
CAD; dark yellow, TEVs; orange, rigid helix. (E) Protease-induced
transcriptional activity of the NFAT-based transcription factor in
the presence of PACE in HEK293T cells. (F) Immunostaining of HEK239T
cells expressing PACE variants in the absence or presence of TEV protease
with anti-Myc antibodies. (G) Localization of PACE in HEK293 cells.
The scale bar represents 20 μm. One day after transfection,
the cells were lysed, and reporter activity was measured. The bars
represent the mean ± s.d.; n = 4 biologically
independent cell cultures. Statistical significance and fold change
are indicated above the bars. Statistical analyses and the corresponding p-values are listed in Table S5. The amounts of transfected plasmids are listed in Table S1.
Proteolytically activated
CRAC effector variants. (A–D)
Transcriptional activity of the engineered mNFAT-based transcription
factor in the presence of CRAC activators: (A) P3h-TEVs-CAD-P4, (B) P3-TEVs-CAD-hP4, (C) P3h-TEVs-CAD-TEVs-P4, and (D) P3-TEVs-CAD-TEVs-hP4 in
HEK293T cells. (Left) Structural model of the effector. For clarity,
mCherry was not depicted. Schemes depict proteolytically activated
CRAC effector variants. The rigid helix was inserted between the coiled-coil
peptides P3 and P4 and the TEVs site. Legend: red, mCherry
with Myc-tag; blue and violet, P3 and P4 coiled-coil peptides; gray,
CAD; dark yellow, TEVs; orange, rigid helix. (E) Protease-induced
transcriptional activity of the NFAT-based transcription factor in
the presence of PACE in HEK293T cells. (F) Immunostaining of HEK239T
cells expressing PACE variants in the absence or presence of TEV protease
with anti-Myc antibodies. (G) Localization of PACE in HEK293 cells.
The scale bar represents 20 μm. One day after transfection,
the cells were lysed, and reporter activity was measured. The bars
represent the mean ± s.d.; n = 4 biologically
independent cell cultures. Statistical significance and fold change
are indicated above the bars. Statistical analyses and the corresponding p-values are listed in Table S5. The amounts of transfected plasmids are listed in Table S1.To preserve a low background signal and augment
the activation
with a protease, we added the second protease cleavage site between
the CAD domain and the P4 coiled-coil forming peptide (Figure C, 2D). This indeed improved the fold activation between the proteolytically
activated and inactive systems (Figure C, S2C; P3h-TEVs-CAD-TEVs-P4; Figure D, S2D; P3-TEVs-CAD-TEVs-hP4). However, it also increased the background
signal. A rigid helix was then inserted at the N-terminal site of
the P4 peptide, providing a P3h-TEVs-CAD-TEVs-hP4 construct, which we named PACE (Figure E, S2E). The TEV
protease-cleaved PACE, as shown by Western blot, with two bands presenting
the product, cleaved at the first or second TEVs (Figure F).PACE was
expressed in the cytosol, forming bright spots (Figure G); unexpectedly,
we also observed the colocalization of inactive PACE with overexpressed
Orai1 (Figure S4A), as it is characteristic
of CAD.[25,27] The observed bright spots of PACE, which
were probably the results of the intermolecular binding of coils P3
and P4, were also detected in the presence of TEV protease, although
the removal of mCherry:P3 and P4 was expected after processing with
protease (Figure H, S4B). On the basis of the optimization of constructs
combining CC segments, a single α-helical segment, and a protease
cleavage site, we managed to obtain a PACE construct characterized
by a low background signal and as high as 15.5-fold activation in
the presence of a TEV protease (Figure E). This construct was used in subsequent experiments.
Switched Activation of PACE and Influx of Calcium
In
our effort to produce a switchable modulator of CRAC, we used a split
TEV protease, which consists of N- and C-terminal fragments of the
TEV protease fused to either FKBP and FRB (the heterodimerization
of which is inducible with rapamycin [RAPA]) or to ABI and PYL1 (the
heterodimerization of which is inducible with abscisic acid [ABA])[17] (Figure A, 3B). Efficient chemical-regulated
activation mediated by the PACE effector was achieved by stimulation
with RAPA or ABA, which spontaneously passes the cell membrane and
enables the split TEV protease to reconstitute and cleave recognition
sites on PACE. Active PACE then triggered an influx of Ca2+ and Ca2+-dependent transcription.
Figure 3
Kinetics of chemically
regulated PACE activation through a split
TEV protease. (A, B) Scheme of the design of PACE activation with
RAPA (A) or ABA (B). The split TEV protease is activated with RAPA
or ABA, and the active TEV protease cleaves off the intramolecular
inhibitory P3:P4 coiled-coil. (C, D) The Ca2+ influx after
the addition of RAPA (C) or ABA (D) was observed under a confocal
microscope using CalRed dye. Twenty regions of interest with one to
five cells in which we could identify mCherry fluorescence were selected,
and the ratio of their fluorescence at 525 and 660 nm is shown as
a time-dependent graph and heat map. A time-lapse video of a region
for each experiment is available in Supplementary Videos S1 and S2. The amounts of
transfected plasmids for all microscopy experiments are listed in Table S3. (E, F) HEK293T cells expressing PACE
and the split TEV protease were induced by 3 μM RAPA (E) or
100 μM ABA (F). Six hours later, firefly luciferase reporter
activity was measured. The amounts of transfected plasmids for all
luciferase experiments are listed in Table S1. One day after transfection, the cells were lysed, and reporter
activity was measured. The bars represent the mean ± s.d.; n = 4 biologically independent cell cultures. Fold change
is indicated above the bars. Statistical analyses and the corresponding p-values are listed in Table S5.
Kinetics of chemically
regulated PACE activation through a split
TEV protease. (A, B) Scheme of the design of PACE activation with
RAPA (A) or ABA (B). The split TEV protease is activated with RAPA
or ABA, and the active TEV protease cleaves off the intramolecular
inhibitory P3:P4 coiled-coil. (C, D) The Ca2+ influx after
the addition of RAPA (C) or ABA (D) was observed under a confocal
microscope using CalRed dye. Twenty regions of interest with one to
five cells in which we could identify mCherry fluorescence were selected,
and the ratio of their fluorescence at 525 and 660 nm is shown as
a time-dependent graph and heat map. A time-lapse video of a region
for each experiment is available in Supplementary Videos S1 and S2. The amounts of
transfected plasmids for all microscopy experiments are listed in Table S3. (E, F) HEK293T cells expressing PACE
and the split TEV protease were induced by 3 μM RAPA (E) or
100 μM ABA (F). Six hours later, firefly luciferase reporter
activity was measured. The amounts of transfected plasmids for all
luciferase experiments are listed in Table S1. One day after transfection, the cells were lysed, and reporter
activity was measured. The bars represent the mean ± s.d.; n = 4 biologically independent cell cultures. Fold change
is indicated above the bars. Statistical analyses and the corresponding p-values are listed in Table S5.One of the important advantages of chemically regulated
Ca2+ influx regulators is their potential to trigger fast
responses.
The kinetics of Ca2+ influx after PACE activation were
monitored in vivo in HEK293 cells using the calcium indicator CalRed.
While ionophore produced an immediate and lasting influx of calcium
into the cytosol compared with untreated cells (Figure S5A, S5B), RAPA or ABA induced a smaller but significant
Ca2+ influx 300 s after the addition of a chemical inductor
(Figure C, 3D). No cytotoxicity of ABA or RAPA in combination
with PACE was observed on HEK293T cells (Figure S6A, S6B).Next, we examined whether ABA or RAPA could
be used to induce the
activation of PACE and the transcriptional activation of the synthetic
Ca2+-responsive NFAT-based transcription factor. The induction
of reporter expression was detected only in the presence of PACE and
RAPA or ABA (Figure E, 3F; Figure S6C, S6D, comparison with CAD), with as high as a 15-fold increase with the
addition of 3 μM RAPA and a 3-fold increase with the addition
of ABA. The addition of gadolinium chloride blocked transcriptional
activation (Figure S6E, S6F), demonstrating
that the PACE effector activated calcium-dependent ion channels, most
likely through Orai.
Construction of a Logic OR Gate-PACE Effector with Dual Regulation
TEV protease is commonly used in synthetic biology; it does not
interfere with cellular processes in human or bacterial cells because
of its high specificity for the cleavage site.[28] To expand the toolbox of PACE effectors, the TEVs recognition site was changed to a PPVs cleavage site
(NVVVHQA). The lengths of TEVs and PPVs are
the same, but the proteases are orthogonal.[29] Three additional PACE variants were prepared, and they contained
PPVs at the first, second, or both cleavage sites (Figure A, 4B, S7A). Surprisingly, we observed
significant differences in the background activation of the PACE variants.
No inhibition of CAD activity was observed for unactivated PACE variants
with the PPVs positioned between P3 and CAD (Figure S7B, S7C). On the other hand, a type of
protease cleavage site between CAD and P4 peptide had no impact on
background activity (Figure C, 4D). While the second site enabled
the activation of PACE with either protease, the substitution of the
first site for the PPVs rendered PACE constitutively active.
The PPV and TEV proteases cleaved the PACE variants, generating predicted
fragments (Figure E, S7D). We also assessed the activity
of the PACE with two different sites in combination with one or both
proteases present. Although a single cleavage was sufficient to promote
Ca2+ signaling (10-fold for either TEV or PPV protease),
the removal of both inhibitory coiled-coil peptides from CAD renders
additional activation to CAD about 23-fold (Figure F, S7E).
Figure 4
PACE effector
with dual regulation. (A) PACE variants with various
combinations of TEVs and PPVs protease recognition
sites. (B) The scheme depicts proteolytically activated CRAC effector
variant P3h-TEVs-CAD-PPV-hP4, with TEVs and
PPVs depicted in yellow and red, respectively. (C, D, F)
Dual-luciferase assay of PACE variants in the presence of TEVs and/or PPVs. (E) Immunodetection of PACE without
and in the presence of coexpressed TEV or PPV protease stained with
anti-Myc antibodies. (G) Scheme of the combination of two chemically
induced split proteases and PACE-OR. (H) Dual-luciferase assay of
PACE-OR in the presence of split TEVp and split PPVp. Folds are presented for the same concentration of plasmid
as in (F). The amounts of transfected plasmids for all luciferase
experiments are listed in Table S1. One
day after transfection, the cells were lysed, and reporter activity
was measured. The bars represent the mean ± s.d.; n = 4 biologically independent cell cultures. Statistical significance
and fold change are indicated above the bars. Statistical analyses
and the corresponding p-values are listed in Table S5.
PACE effector
with dual regulation. (A) PACE variants with various
combinations of TEVs and PPVs protease recognition
sites. (B) The scheme depicts proteolytically activated CRAC effector
variant P3h-TEVs-CAD-PPV-hP4, with TEVs and
PPVs depicted in yellow and red, respectively. (C, D, F)
Dual-luciferase assay of PACE variants in the presence of TEVs and/or PPVs. (E) Immunodetection of PACE without
and in the presence of coexpressed TEV or PPV protease stained with
anti-Myc antibodies. (G) Scheme of the combination of two chemically
induced split proteases and PACE-OR. (H) Dual-luciferase assay of
PACE-OR in the presence of split TEVp and split PPVp. Folds are presented for the same concentration of plasmid
as in (F). The amounts of transfected plasmids for all luciferase
experiments are listed in Table S1. One
day after transfection, the cells were lysed, and reporter activity
was measured. The bars represent the mean ± s.d.; n = 4 biologically independent cell cultures. Statistical significance
and fold change are indicated above the bars. Statistical analyses
and the corresponding p-values are listed in Table S5.Next, the P3h-TEVs-CAD-PPV-hP4 (PACE-OR)
was combined
with the ABA-inducible split TEVp and RAPA-inducible split
PPVp proteases (Figure G, 4H). The addition of ABA
or RAPA alone or in combination induced the corresponding cleavage
and activation of PACE-OR. However, the 14-fold increase in reporter
expression was detected with the addition of both inducers together,
compared to a 4.8- and 3.5-fold increase with the addition of only
ABA or RAPA, respectively.
PACE-Regulated IL2 and TNFα Production in Jurkat T-Cells
To confirm Ca2+ influx with PACE for the regulation
of a physiologically relevant function, we aimed to design a system
that triggers the activation of T-cells mediated via Ca2+ and regulated by chemical signals. For this purpose, we introduced
PACE and chemically regulated protease into T-cells, in which the
activation of an NFAT signaling pathway should be triggered via Ca2+ influx. We electroporated plasmids expressing PACE and the
split TEV protease into the T-cell line. Jurkat T-cells are a well-established
cell line,[30] a model for T-cell activation,
which enabled us to test the production of interleukin 2 (IL-2), a
versatile cytokine responsible for T-cell growth, the differentiation
of regulatory T-cells, and the mediation of activation-induced cell
death.[31] Transcription of IL-2 is NFAT
and AP-1 dependent; therefore, an additional coactivator, phorbol
12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA), is needed to induce upregulation of
IL-2 transcription.[32,33] The electroporated Jurkat T-cells
were subjected to PMA and ABA or RAPA stimulation (Figure A). ABA and RAPA, in combination
with PMA, induced the synthesis of IL-2 (Figure B); however, ABA-induced IL-2 production
was higher than that induced by RAPA. We also observed the production
of tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNFα), which is regulated by
NFAT as the key transcription factor (Figure C); TNFα is an important cytokine involved
in immune response.[34] Taken together, PACE
represents a tool for generating sustained Ca2+ entry to
initiate NFAT dependent protein translation.
Figure 5
Induction of T-cell activation
by a chemical signal using PACE-mediated
Ca signaling. (A) Entry of ABA into cytosol enables the reconstitution
of functional TEV protease, which cleaves PACE at its recognition
sites. The cleaved PACE dimerizes and opens the Orai1 Ca2+ channel. An increase in cytosolic Ca2+ activates calmodulin
and thus calcineurin, which dephosphorylates NFAT, enabling it to
enter the nucleus. Interleukin 2 promoter requires an additional transcription
factor for NFAT, AP-1,[33] which is achieved
by the downstream effect of the addition of PMA. (B, C) ELISA assay
for IL-2 (B) and TNFα (C) production in Jurkat T-cells expressing
PACE and the split TEV protease. Production was induced with PMA and
3 μM RAPA, PMA, or 100 μM ABA. The amounts of transfected
plasmids for all ELISA experiments are listed in Table S4. One day after transfection, the cells were centrifuged,
and the supernatant was taken for ELISA. The bars represent the mean
± s.d.; n = 3 or 6 biologically independent
cell cultures. Fold changes are indicated above the bars. Statistical
analyses and the corresponding p-values are listed
in Table S5.
Induction of T-cell activation
by a chemical signal using PACE-mediated
Ca signaling. (A) Entry of ABA into cytosol enables the reconstitution
of functional TEV protease, which cleaves PACE at its recognition
sites. The cleaved PACE dimerizes and opens the Orai1 Ca2+ channel. An increase in cytosolic Ca2+ activates calmodulin
and thus calcineurin, which dephosphorylates NFAT, enabling it to
enter the nucleus. Interleukin 2 promoter requires an additional transcription
factor for NFAT, AP-1,[33] which is achieved
by the downstream effect of the addition of PMA. (B, C) ELISA assay
for IL-2 (B) and TNFα (C) production in Jurkat T-cells expressing
PACE and the split TEV protease. Production was induced with PMA and
3 μM RAPA, PMA, or 100 μM ABA. The amounts of transfected
plasmids for all ELISA experiments are listed in Table S4. One day after transfection, the cells were centrifuged,
and the supernatant was taken for ELISA. The bars represent the mean
± s.d.; n = 3 or 6 biologically independent
cell cultures. Fold changes are indicated above the bars. Statistical
analyses and the corresponding p-values are listed
in Table S5.
Discussion
We have designed an engineered proteolysis-based
Orai activator
named PACE. The PACE activator domain CAD originates from STIM1 and
is composed of CC2 and CC3 helices that spontaneously associate and
dimerize.[8] To prevent spontaneous CAD activation,
coiled-coil forming peptides P3 and P4 were introduced. P3 and P4
form a stable, rigid coiled-coil dimer[20] that restrains the formation of an active CAD by forming an intramolecular
dimer that separates the N- from the C-terminus of CAD. Insertion
of a protease cleavage site between CAD and an inhibiting coiled-coil
enabled the controlled activation of PACE. Because of the nature of
the proteolytic activity, which irreversibly activates the protein,
PACE can induce long, sustained Ca2+ currents that activate
the Ca2+/calcineurin/NFAT signaling pathway either for
engineered NFAT-based transcription factors or native NFAT. To increase
the signal-to-background ratio, coiled-coil forming peptides were
extended with rigid helix forming peptides.The inactive PACE
is mainly a cytosol-based protein with minor
interactions with membrane-based Orai channels. While designed for
intramolecular interactions, P3 and P4 coiled-coil forming peptides
could also make intermolecular connections, which can likely explain
the higher-order structures of PACE, detected as bright spots. Despite
the formation of higher-ordered structures, the desired regulation
was nevertheless achieved, and the activity of PACE was not significantly
reduced, nor did such interactions increase unwanted Orai activation,
which means that such assemblies still inhibit CAD activity. The use
of coiled-coil peptides with Kd in the
nanomolar range (e.g., N5:N6, Tm = 76
°C)[19] did not improve the fold of
activation (data not shown), which likely suggests multiple weak interhelical
interactions.PACE also provided a template for the variation
of protease recognition
sites. In addition to the TEV protease cleavage site, we tested the
activation of PACE with an orthogonal PPV protease.[29] Interestingly, the replacement of TEVs at the
first site between P3 and CAD with PPVs reduced the signal-to-background
ratio. On the other hand, the substitution of the second TEVs site between CAD and P4 with PPVs maintained a high signal-to-background
ratio. The difference between the first and second cleavage sites
probably occurred because the second cleavage site is flanked by a
Gly-Pro-Gly and Gly-Ser-Gly peptide sequence, which enables substantial
flexibility. The first cleavage site was retained without flanking
peptides, as the TEVs cleavage site sequence proved to
be sufficient. By combining TEVs at the first protease
cleavage site and PPVs at the second one, an effective
“OR” logic gate was created with an added feature of
a 2-fold higher signal when cleaved at both sites. This can be explained
by the fact that for full activation of PACE, a cleavage at both sites,
between P3 and CAD, and between CAD and P4, is necessary. During designing
PACE, it became evident that activated PACE with two protease cleavage
sites generates more efficient transcriptional activation probably
due to more effective activation of Orai channels. Activation by two
possible inputs enables the design of more complex synthetic biological
circuits. This was exploited with the inducible activation of PACE-OR
in combination with ABA or RAPA-induced TEVp or PPVp protease. As proteases can be activated in a variety of ways,
PACE enables the existing protease-based circuits[17,18,35,36] to be coupled
with Ca2+ signaling networks of the cell.With externally
activated split proteases, we have determined the
kinetics of PACE activation. Compared with the rapid Ca2+ influx triggered by ionophore, PACE activation is slower (8–16
min). The delay in Ca2+ influx can be attributed to the
time required for RAPA or ABA entry and to the reconstitution of split
protease reconstitution. The PACE activation time is comparable to
the activation time of cyclic luciferase reporter using ABA or RAPA-inducible
split TEV proteases.[17] Compared to activation
of optogenetic constructs by light, PACE response to activation is
delayed also due to the lack of the polybasic region, which is present
at the C-terminus of native STIM and anchor active CAD in the proximity
of Orai channel.[11] A lower amplitude of
Ca2+ was observed for PACE compared with ionophore; however,
this could be beneficial, as it causes less damage to cells and activates
different cell responses.[37] The selection
and evaluation of PACE constructs were based on their ability to activate
NFAT based signaling; therefore, the intracellular Ca2+ amplitude and the rate of Orai activation were not considered in
the selection process as they were secondary to the sustainability
of Ca2+ signals.As the construction of PACE was
based on its ability to activate
NFAT-based transcription factors, we tested its ability to activate
native NFAT pathways in T-cells. PACE activated NFAT in a T-cell line,
as detected with the secretion of IL-2 and TNFα. The expression
of IL-2 requires the presence of PMA-activating AP1 in addition to
NFAT.[33] TNFα expression, in which
NFAT1 transcription is sufficient, was also enhanced with PMA.[38] However, protein expression using PACE was comparable
to the existing optogenetic CRAC activators in both luciferase assay[10] and IL-2.[39] In T-cells,
the transcriptional activation of NFAT with RAPA was less effective
than that with ABA because of the immunosuppressing abilities of the
RAPA upstream of the AP-1 signaling pathway.[40]Synthetic biology research, especially optogenetics, has developed
a varied toolbox of calcium current effectors.[41] Each of them, however, is a standalone element and does
not allow integration into larger and more elaborate synthetic networks.
The PACE constructs presented in this study and dual protease site
variant PACE-OR bridge this gap between existing synthetic circuits
that regulate protease activity and the calcium current, and they
enable the construction of larger and more elaborate biological circuits.
With the possible switching of protease cleavage sites, PACE provides
a robust scaffold for coupling not only synthetic circuits but also
any existing well-defined protease activity, such as caspases or cathepsins,
to calcium influx.
Materials and Methods
Cloning and Plasmid Construction
Orai1-GCaMP6f and
mCherry-CAD were gifts from Michael Cahalan (Addgene plasmid # 73564; http://n2t.net/addgene:73564; RRID: Addgene_73564; Addgene plasmid # 73566; http://n2t.net/addgene:73566; RRID: Addgene_73566, respectively). All plasmids were constructed
using the Gibson assembly method, and their sequences are listed in Table S6.
Cell Culture
The embryonic kidney HEK293T and HEK293
cell lines (ATCC) were cultured in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s
medium (DMEM; Invitrogen) supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum
(Gibco) at 37 °C in a 5% CO2 environment. In experiments
with GdCl3, Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium
without phosphate (DMEM; Invitrogen) supplemented with 10% fetal bovine
serum (Gibco) was used. Jurkat cells were cultured in Roswell Park
Memorial Institute 1640 Medium (RPMI; Invitrogen) supplemented with
10% fetal bovine serum.
Transfection, Electroporation, and Stimulation
For
dual luciferase assays, 2 × 104 HEK293T cells were
seeded per well in 96-well plates (Corning). For confocal microscopy
experiments, 5 × 104 HEK293T cells were seeded per
well in an eight-well chamber slide (Ibidi). For Western blot experiments,
5 × 105 HEK293T cells were seeded per well in six-well
plates (Corning). At 50–70% confluence, HEK293T cells were
transfected with a mixture of DNA and polyethylenimine (PEI, linear,
Mw 25000; Polysciences, catalog no. 23966). Per 500 ng DNA, 6 μL
of PEI stock solution (0.324 mg/mL, pH 7.5) was used. Twenty-four
hours after transfection, the culture medium was replaced with a fresh
medium, and the cells were stimulated with the indicated concentrations
of ionophore (calcium ionophore A23187, Sigma-Aldrich), RAPA (Sigma-Aldrich),
or ABA (Goldbio) for 6 h. Calcium ionophore A23187 was prepared as
a 10 mM stock solution in DMSO, RAPA as 1 mM stock, and ABA as 50
mM stock. The phRL-TK plasmid (Promega), encoding the Renilla luciferase,
was used as a transfection efficiency control in the luciferase experiments.
An empty pcDNA3 plasmid (Invitrogen) was used to equalize the total
DNA amounts under different experimental conditions.Jurkat
cells were electroporated using the Neon Transfection System at a
concentration of 2 × 107 cells/mL with three pulses
of 1600 V using 100 μL tips.
Dual Luciferase Assays
Cells were lysed 24 h after
transfection or 6 h after induction of RAPA, ABA, or ionophore using
25 μL of 1 × Passive lysis buffer (Promega) per well. Firefly
luciferase (fLuc) and Renilla luciferase (rLuc) activities were measured
using the dual luciferase assay (Promega) on an Orion II microplate
reader (Berthold Technologies). Relative luciferase units were calculated
by normalizing fLuc to the constitutive rLuc in each sample.
Immunoblotting
HEK293T cells (2 × 105) were seeded in 12-well plates (Techno Plastic Products). The next
day, at a confluence of 50–70%, the cells were transiently
transfected with a mixture of DNA and PEI (8 μL PEI/1000 ng
DNA). Forty-eight hours post-transfection, the cells were washed with
1 mL PBS and lysed in 100 μL 1 × Passive lysis buffer (Promega).
The cells were lysed for 20 min on ice and centrifuged for 15 min
at 14 000 rpm to remove cell debris. The total protein concentration
in the supernatant was determined using the BCA assay.Proteins
from the supernatant were separated on 12% SDS-PAGE gels (200 V, 45
min) and transferred to a nitrocellulose membrane (350 mA, 60 min).
Membrane blocking, antibody binding, and membrane washing were performed
using an iBind Flex Western device (ThermoFisher) according to the
manufacturer’s protocol. The primary antibodies were mouse-anti
Myc (Cell Signaling Technology 2276; diluted 1:2000). The secondary
antibodies were HRP-conjugated goat antimouse IgG, diluted 1:3000
(Jackson ImmunoResearch 115-035-003). The secondary antibodies were
detected with an ECL Western blotting detection reagent (Super Signal
West Femto; ThermoFisher) according to the manufacturer’s protocol.
Confocal Microscopy
For the analyses of fluorescent
protein-expressing cells, live cells were imaged 1 day after transfection.
During microscopy, the cells were kept in a chamber at 37 °C.
To maintain the physiological pH, 10 mM 4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulfonic
acid (HEPES) pH 7.4 (from 1 M stock solution) was added to the media.
Microscopic images were obtained using a Leica TCS SP5 inverted laser
scanning microscope on a Leica DMI 6000 CS module equipped with an
HCX Plane-Apochromat lambda blue 63× objective and a numerical
aperture of 1.4 (Leica Microsystems). A 50 mW 405 nm diode laser was
used for GCaMP6f and excitation (emission between 420 and 460 nm),
and a 10 mW 543 nm laser was used for mCherry excitation (emission
between 550 and 650 nm).For calcium imaging, we used CalRed
ratiometric dye (ATT Bioquest 20591), which was added to the cells
for 1 h at a concentration of 10 g/mL before exchanging it for the
usual medium with an addition of 10 mM HEPES. Microscopic timelapse
images were obtained using a Leica TCS SP5 inverted laser scanning
microscope on a Leica DMI 6000 CS module equipped with an HCX Plane-Apochromat
CS 40× objective and a numerical aperture of 1.25 (Leica Microsystems).
A 10 mW 488 nm laser was used for CalRed excitation (emission in the
Ca2+ unbound state between 497 and 545 nm, emission in
the Ca2+ bound state between 617 and 696 nm). Leica LAS
AF software was used for acquisition, and ImageJ software (National
Institute of Mental Health, Bethesda, USA) was used for image processing.
ELISA
Jurkat cells were seeded into a 96-well plate
24 h after electroporation at a concentration of 1.5 × 106 cell/mL with the addition of 50 ng/mL PMA (Sigma-Aldrich
P1585), RAPA, ABA, or ionophore. After 24 h, the cells were centrifuged,
and the supernatant was taken and used for ELISA for Il2 (IL-2 Human
Uncoated ELISA Kit 50-246-332, Thermo Fisher Scientific) and TNFα
(TNF alpha Human Uncoated ELISA Kit with Plates 88-7346-22, Thermo
Fisher Scientific), which were conducted following the manufacturer’s
instructions. Absorbance was measured with a Synergy Mx automated
microplate reader (BioTek) at 450 and 620 nm using Gen5 software.
Absorbance at 620 nm was used for background correction and was subtracted
from the absorbance at 450 nm.
Statistical Analysis
The data are presented as mean
values ± s.d. of four independent biological repeats within the
same experiment. Graphs and statistical analyses were prepared in
GraphPad Prism 8. For the analysis of the activity of variants with
different protease recognition sites, unpaired Student t test was used, with 0 ng of constructs serving as the control for
comparison. For the analysis of protease-based constructs without
active protease, one-way ANOVA was used with Dunnett’s multiple
comparisons test as a post hoc analysis. The mean of each condition
was compared with the mean of the control (0 ng of the construct added).
For the analysis of the activity of the activated constructs, an unpaired
Student t test was used between the same concentration
of constructs in the presence and absence of active protease. Statistical
analysis is depicted in Table S5.