Zahra Amirkhani1, Mansoureh Movahedin2, Nafiseh Baheiraei3, Ali Ghiaseddin4. 1. Department of Anatomical Sciences, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran. 2. Department of Anatomical Sciences, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran. Email: movahed.m@modares.ac.ir. 3. Tissue Engineering and Applied Cell Sciences Division, Department of Anatomical Sciences, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran. 4. Adjunct Research Associate Professor at Chemistry Department, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, USA.
Investigations into the progress of spermatogenesis in vitro began early
last century (1), although the differentiation of spermatogonial stem cells (SSCs) into
sperm cells remained a challenge. In the 1960s and 1970s, testis tissue culture was used to
evaluate the process of spermatogenesis. In those experiments, spermatogenesis progressed as
far as meiosis but haploid cells were never formed (2). In the 1980s, cell culture was used
instead of tissue culture, but the development of fertile sperm cells remained problematic
(3). Although there are many ways of culturing tissue fragments, the gold standard is the
interphase method in which specimens are positioned at the interphase between the culture
medium and a gas layer (4). By isolating seminiferous tubules acquired from immature mice,
Sato et al. (5) generated fertile sperm using ex vivo culture. However, the
overall duration and efficiency of spermatogenesis were not close to those reported
in vivo.Capillaries around a tissue provide oxygen and nutrients, as well as removing waste
effectively, thereby supporting tissue homeostasis. Because it lacks such a microcirculatory
network, the interphase method cannot provide the appropriate in vivo-like
conditions. Researchers have tried innovative circulatory mechanisms to improve their
culture systems (6, 7). To maintain physiological functions more efficient than conventional
methods, microfluidic devices and bioreactors have been developed recently to culture testis
tissue pieces (8-11). Different types of perfusion bioreactors have also been developed and
have yielded more favourable results compared with static culture (12-14). In this study, a
mini-perfusion bioreactor was designed that was capable of successfully sustaining
spermatogenesis from immature mouse testis tissue fragments incubated for 8 weeks. This
device provided sufficient nutrients and oxygen for tissue culture for having an in
vitro model to study spermatogenesis progression during maturation of neonatal
testicular tissue. The fertility of sperm generated in the bioreactor system will be
addressed in future studies. Finally, the dynamic culture method described here must be
assessed in human testicular tissue culture to determine its potential utility in addressing
male infertility.
Materials and Methods
Design of the mini-perfusion bioreactor system
In this experimental study, the mini-perfusion bioreactor
system is composed of three polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS)
layers (Sylgard 184, Dow Corning, Germany)-upper,
middle and lower annular rings-with a central cylindrical
cavity and a porous polyvinylidene fluoride membrane
filter (pores size 0.22 µm, Millipore, Germany). The lower
layer is composed of a medium flow chamber (5 mm wide
and 5 mm high) and a channel for continuously supplying
culture medium from a perfusion pump to an outlet. The
middle layer comprises a tissue chamber of the same size.
The culture medium was drawn through the inlet by a
syringe pump at a rate of 15, 27, 50 and 100 µL/hour. The
porous membrane was placed between the flow channel
and the tissue chamber to separate sample tissues from the
flowing medium. The upper layer was a waste material
chamber. The thickness of the PDMS layers was 5 mm
each (15).
Agarose support gel preparation for tissue culture
The method described by Yokonishi et al. (16) was used to prepare the agarose support
gel. In brief, 1.5% w/v agarose solution (Carl Roth, Germany) was prepared and sterilised.
Segments measuring 10×10×5 mm3 were arranged using a scalpel blade under
sterile conditions. The segments were then placed in a six-well plate containing
alpha-minimum essential medium (αMEM; Bio-Ideal, Iran) supplemented by10% Knockout Serum
Replacement (KSR, Gibco, UK), 60 ng/mL progesterone (Invitrogen, UK), 30 ng/mL
beta-estradiol (PeproTech, Germany), 20 ng/mL epithelial growth factor (EGF, PeproTech),
10 ng/mL human basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF, PeproTech), 10 ng/mL human glial cell
linederived neurotropic factor (GDNF, PeproTech) and 10 ng/ mL leukemia inhibitory factor
(LIF, Royan Institute, Iran) as the culture medium.
Animals
Six-day-old NMRI neonatal male mice provided by
the Pasteur Institute of Iran were used as the source of
testis tissue. The mice were maintained at an ambient
temperature of 22°C and a 12/12 hours light/dark cycle.
This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of
Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran (IR.TMU.
REC.1395.522).
Culture of testis tissues
Two groups of neonatal mouse testis were created for this study: tissue cultivated in the
perfusion bioreactor and on agarose gel. For each group, 12 mouse pups were euthanised and
the testes were removed, decapsulated, fragmented (1 mm3 in size) and randomly
allocated to either the bioreactor or the agarose gel. In the bioreactor group, the tissue
was placed in the middle chamber. Assessments were performed after 2 and 8 weeks of
culture. For static cultures, testis fragments were placed on agarose stands in a six-well
culture plate, and medium was added to one-half to four-fifths the height of the agarose
gel. The medium was changed twice a week. The culture incubator conditions were maintained
under 5% CO2 and 34°C temperature (5).
Viability test of the tissue during the culture
For checking the cytotoxic effects of the bioreactor
components and accessories, the cell suspension
was exposed to PTFE tubes, PDMS and bioreactor
accessories for 72 hours under normal culture conditions.
Cell viability was assessed at the beginning of culture
and after 72 hours by Trypan blue staining. Moreover,
after 8 weeks of culture by capturing multiple images, the
viability of the cells in the tissue was assessed based on
morphology
Histology, morphology and functional examinations
Specimens were fixed with Bouin’s fixative and
embedded in paraffin wax. Sections were cut and
stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) or Weigert’s
hematoxylin and periodic acid-schiff (PAS, Merck,
Germany). All sections were examined using a light
microscope (Zeiss, Germany) (17). After 8 weeks of
culture, the tissues were mechanically dissociated using
needles to release the spermatid and sperm for evaluation
on an inverted microscope (Zeiss Axiovert 40 CFL) (9).
Papanicolaou staining was performed to assess the
sperm-like cell morphology (18). A Diff-Quick staining
kit (Faradid Pardaz Pars Inc., Iran) was utilized to assess
sperm morphology. Smears were firstly stained with
Diff-Quick staining solutions I and II for 25 seconds.
Afterwards, they were washed in distilled water. In the
Diff-Quick smears, acrosomes stain pink or light purple,
and the sperm nucleus, midpiece and tail stain dark
purple (19). Double staining was performed to assess the
acrosome reaction. Briefly, the smears were fixed with
3% glutaraldehyde for 30 minute, and the slides were
stained with Bismarck brown (0.8% in deionised water,
pH=1.8) for 10 minute and then with Rose Bengal (0.8%
in 0.1 M Tris buffer, pH=5.3) for 25 minutes. Spermlike cells with acrosomes that stained bright brown were
considered to be sperm-like cells with an intact acrosome
region (20).
Expression of promyelocytic leukaemia zinc finger (Plzf), Tekt1 and
Tnp1 genes in testicular tissue fragments were evaluated after 2 and 8
weeks. Total RNA was extracted from the tissue fragments from both groups using RNX-Plus™
(CinnaGen, Iran) following the manufacturer’s recommendation. The RNA concentration was
then determined using an ultraviolet spectrophotometer (Eppendorf Company, Germany). cDNA
synthesis was performed using a RevertAid™ First Strand cDNA Synthesis kit (Fermentas,
Germany) and oligo (dT) primers. For the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) reactions,
primers for Plzf, Tekt1 and Tnp1 genes were designed.
Designed primers were blasted using the NCBI website (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/) (21)
and were synthesised by a commercial source (CinnaGen, Iran) (Table S1, See Supplementary
Online Information at www.celljournal.org). PCR was performed using Master Mix and SYBR
Green I (Fluka, Switzerland) in an Applied Biosystems StepOne™ instrument (Applied
Biosystems, UK). Melting curve analyses were used to confirm the quality of the PCR
reactions. A standard curve was used to determine the efficiency for each gene
(logarithmic dilution series of cDNA from the testes). The reference gene
β-actin and the target genes were amplified in the same run. This
process was repeated and duplicated three times for all target and reference genes. The
reference genes were relatively equal, and the target gene expression levels were
normalised to that of the reference gene.
Immunohistochemistry
The identity of SSCs, spermatocytes and spermlike cells was verified by tracking the promyelocytic
leukaemia zinc finger protein (PLZF), synaptonemal
complex protein 3 (SCP3) and acrosin binding protein
(ACRBP) (22-24). These markers were detected after 8
weeks of culture. For immunohistochemistry, primary
antibody, mouse monoclonal anti-mouse antibody
against PLZF, SCP3 or ACRBP (1:100, Santa Cruz
Biotechnology, Germany) was added and the samples
were incubated at 4°C overnight. The secondary antibody
Alexa 488-conjugated anti-mouse IgG (1:200, Sigma,
Germany) was added for 2 hours at 37°C in the dark. For
nuclear staining 4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI,
1:200, Sigma, Germany) was applied for 1 minute. The
specimens were observed with a fluorescence microscope
(Olympus, type CH2, Japan). To quantify the results,
germ cells were defined as cells that stained positive for
PLZF, SCP3 and ACRBP. The results are reported as the
percentage of germ cells that were positive for the protein
of interest relative to the entire population. From each
sample, 5 sections were randomly selected and after highmagnification photography (magnification: x400), 5 fields
from each section were analyzed by image-j software.
Statistical analysis
The data was analysed using one-way analysis of
variance followed by Tukey’s post hoc test and are
shown as mean ± standard deviation (SD). Calculations
were performed using SPSS (Version 15.0, SPSS Inc.,
USA). Each data point represents the average of three
separate experiments, and five repeats were performed
for each experiment. A P≤0.05 was considered to be
significant.
Results
Organ culture
Neonatal mouse testicular tissue was cultured on
agarose gel and in a mini-perfusion bioreactor (Fig.1A,
B). The tissue samples were positioned on agarose gel
and in the tissue chamber of the bioreactor (Fig .1C-F).
In the agarose cultures, we observed necrotic changes, a
hallmark of degenerative changes in the tissue, as darkened
regions in the central parts (Fig.2B, (f) white arrow).
In the bioreactor, the tissue samples were positioned in
the tissue chamber. For the best flow rate, histological
analyses were done (Fig .S1, See Supplementary Online
Information at www.celljournal.org) and the best flow
rate (27 µl/hour) was chosen for the tissue culture in
the bioreactor, the central areas of the testicular tissue
remained viable, which suggests that this tissue received
vital ingredients from the medium.
Fig.1
Schematic diagram of the neonatal mouse testicular tissue organ culture. A.
Testicular tissue pieces placed on agarose gel, B. In the
bioreactor. C. Agarose gel hexahedrons stand transferred to 6-well
culture plates. D. Testicular tissue was cut to small pieces and placed
on agarose gel (black arrows). E. Mini-perfusion bioreactor device.
F. Testicular tissue fragments in the tissue chamber of the perfusion
bioreactor system (red arrow).
Fig.2
Results of viability assessment of cells, H&E staining and photomicrograph of the testicular
sections. A. Cell suspension 3 days after culture with PTFE (a), PDMS
(b), and bioreactor accessories (c). Viability assay graph of cells after 72 hours of
this co-culture (d). B. H&E staining and photomicrographs of
testicular tissue fragments day 0, 8 weeks of agarose gel and bioreactor culture
(e-g). White arrow; Degenerative regions, Black arrows; Sperm cells. H&E images
(scale bars e-g: 10 μm, magnification: x1000). PTFE; Polytetrafluoroethylene and PDMS;
Polydimethylsiloxane.
Schematic diagram of the neonatal mouse testicular tissue organ culture. A.
Testicular tissue pieces placed on agarose gel, B. In the
bioreactor. C. Agarose gel hexahedrons stand transferred to 6-well
culture plates. D. Testicular tissue was cut to small pieces and placed
on agarose gel (black arrows). E. Mini-perfusion bioreactor device.
F. Testicular tissue fragments in the tissue chamber of the perfusion
bioreactor system (red arrow).
Viability assessment of cells and tissues
Sertoli cells and spermatogonial cells were cultured
with PTFE, PDMS and bioreactor accessories. After 72
hours, viability assay was done by Trypan blue staining,
there was no cytotoxic reaction monitored after this
co-culture (Fig .2A). Progression of spermatogenesis
in organ culture was assessed by bright field and H&E
staining for 8 weeks (Fig .2B). In the bioreactor, the
central regions of the testicular tissue remained viable,
and sperms were distinguished (Fig .2Bg, black arrows).
Meanwhile in agarose culture, the central region was
degenerated (Fig .2Bf, white arrow) and there was no
evidence of existing sperm cells.Results of viability assessment of cells, H&E staining and photomicrograph of the testicular
sections. A. Cell suspension 3 days after culture with PTFE (a), PDMS
(b), and bioreactor accessories (c). Viability assay graph of cells after 72 hours of
this co-culture (d). B. H&E staining and photomicrographs of
testicular tissue fragments day 0, 8 weeks of agarose gel and bioreactor culture
(e-g). White arrow; Degenerative regions, Black arrows; Sperm cells. H&E images
(scale bars e-g: 10 μm, magnification: x1000). PTFE; Polytetrafluoroethylene and PDMS;
Polydimethylsiloxane.
Histology, morphology, and functional examinations
Spermatogenesis was maintained in the peripheral
areas of the tissue samples cultured on agarose gel
(Fig.3A, a, B, b). Histology showed seminiferous
tubules exhibiting spermatogenesis in all tissue areas
in the tissue cultured in the bioreactor. Different stages
of spermatogenesis were seen in different regions of
the tissue. Bioreactor cultures showed sperm-like cells
after 8 weeks of culture (Fig.3C, c, D, d, Fig .4a). It is
noteworthy that tissue integrity was preserved in both
groups. In the tissue cultured on agarose gel, tubules
were not observed centrally, probably because of the
hypoxic conditions and limited access to nutrients. In
the agarose gel cultures, no sperm cells were observed
in the suspension produced by tissue dissociation
(Fig .4b). By contrast, after removal of tissue from the
bioreactor and mechanical dissociation, sperm-like
cells were observed (Fig .4c), and staining showed that
they appeared as normal sperm (Fig .4d-f).
Fig.3
Progression of spermatogenesis in organ culture. A, B. H&E staining after 2 and
8 weeks of agarose gel culture, respectively. Higher magnification images of A and B
(a, b). C, D. H&E staining after 2 and 8 weeks of bioreactor culture,
respectively. Higher magnification images of C and D (c, d). Green arrow;
Spermatogonia, Red arrow; Spermatocyte (c). Green arrow; Spermatogonia, Red arrow;
Primary spermatocyte, Yellow arrow; Secondary spermatocyte, Blue arrow; Spermatid,
Arrow head and black arrows; Long spermatids or sperm-like cells (d) [scale bars: 200
μm, magnification: x100 (A, B, D), 30 μm, magnification: x400 (C), 10 μm,
magnification: x1000 (a-d)].
Fig.4
Staining to assess the morphology and function of sperm. After removal of testicular tissue from
the bioreactor and mechanical dissociation, Papanicolaou and Diff-Quick staining were
used to assess sperm morphology. Sperms were stained by a double staining protocol for
acrosome reaction. A. Periodic acid-schiff (PAS) staining after 8 weeks
of bioreactor culture (a). Black arrows in (a); Sperm cells. Agarose gel culture
dissociation (b). Arrow indicates a sperm cell with flagella found in dissociated
tissue in the bioreactor group (c). B. Papanicolaou staining (d).
Diff-Quick staining (e). Acrosome reaction (f) (scale bars: 10 μm, magnification:
x1000).
Progression of spermatogenesis in organ culture. A, B. H&E staining after 2 and
8 weeks of agarose gel culture, respectively. Higher magnification images of A and B
(a, b). C, D. H&E staining after 2 and 8 weeks of bioreactor culture,
respectively. Higher magnification images of C and D (c, d). Green arrow;
Spermatogonia, Red arrow; Spermatocyte (c). Green arrow; Spermatogonia, Red arrow;
Primary spermatocyte, Yellow arrow; Secondary spermatocyte, Blue arrow; Spermatid,
Arrow head and black arrows; Long spermatids or sperm-like cells (d) [scale bars: 200
μm, magnification: x100 (A, B, D), 30 μm, magnification: x400 (C), 10 μm,
magnification: x1000 (a-d)].Staining to assess the morphology and function of sperm. After removal of testicular tissue from
the bioreactor and mechanical dissociation, Papanicolaou and Diff-Quick staining were
used to assess sperm morphology. Sperms were stained by a double staining protocol for
acrosome reaction. A. Periodic acid-schiff (PAS) staining after 8 weeks
of bioreactor culture (a). Black arrows in (a); Sperm cells. Agarose gel culture
dissociation (b). Arrow indicates a sperm cell with flagella found in dissociated
tissue in the bioreactor group (c). B. Papanicolaou staining (d).
Diff-Quick staining (e). Acrosome reaction (f) (scale bars: 10 μm, magnification:
x1000).
Molecular assessment
2 and 8 weeks after 3D culture, bioreactor and agarose gel groups were compared with
neonatal testis. Plzf expression was significantly lower (P≤0.05) in both
the bioreactor and agarose gel groups than in fresh neonatal testis. However,
Plzf expression did not differ significantly between the bioreactor and agarose
gel groups (Fig .5A, B). Tekt1 and Tnp1 expression also
did not differ significantly between the groups after the 2-week culture period (Fig .5A).
Tekt1 and Tnp1 expression after the 8-week culture was
significantly higher (P≤0.05) in all groups compared with fresh neonatal testis (Fig .5B).
8 weeks after 3D culture, the bioreactor and agarose gel groups were compared with adult
testis. Additionally, Plzf gene expression indicated that there was no
significant difference between the groups. Tekt1 expression was
significantly lower in both culture groups than in adult mice testicular tissue but did
not differ significantly between the two groups. Tnp1 expression was
significantly lower in the agarose group than in the adult mice testicular tissue after 8
weeks but did not differ significantly between the bioreactor culture and adult mouse
testicular tissue (Fig .5C).
Fig.5
Gene expression in testicular tissue fragments in experimental groups. Expression of
Plzf, Tekt1 and Tnp1 gene was assessed in tissues
cultured in the bioreactor and on agarose gel for 2 and 8 weeks. A-C.
Expression level was normalised to that of β-actin and is represented as mean ± SD
after three repeats of the experiments. *; P<0.05 versus neonate and #;
P<0.05 versus adult. Similar symbols indicate no significant differences
between those groups.
PLZF protein was expressed in the tissues that showed
spermatogonial cells. SCP3 protein, was detected in the
spermatocytes and in ACRBP-positive cells, indicating
the existence of sperm-like cells (Fig .6). Quantification of
the immunohistochemical staining indicated that PLZF
expression was significantly lower (P<0.05) in adult tissue
and both the bioreactor and agarose groups than in neonatal
tissue. However, there was no difference at 8 weeks between
the bioreactor culture and adult expression levels. At 8 weeks,
PLZF expression was significantly reduced in the agarose gel
group compared with that of the adult tissue and bioreactor
groups. At 8 weeks, the SCP3 and ACRBP expression levels
were significantly lower in both the agarose and bioreactor
groups than in adult tissue but did not differ significantly
between the bioreactor and agarose gel groups (Fig .6).
Fig.6
Immunohistochemistry of neonatal mouse testicular tissue after 8 weeks of organ culture.
B, H, N. Expression of specific protein of spermatogonial cells (PLZF),
spermatocytes (SCP3) and spermatozoa (ACRBP) in the bioreactor and E, K,
Q. On agarose gel, respectively. A-P. Nuclei were stained by
DAPI. C-R. The merged images. S-U. Expression of specific
protein in experimental groups. Data are represented as mean ± SD of experiments
performed in triplicate. #; P<0.05 versus adult and *; P<0.05 versus
neonate. a and b indicate P<0.05 versus the respective between the bioreactor
and agarose gel (scale bars: 10 μm).
Gene expression in testicular tissue fragments in experimental groups. Expression of
Plzf, Tekt1 and Tnp1 gene was assessed in tissues
cultured in the bioreactor and on agarose gel for 2 and 8 weeks. A-C.
Expression level was normalised to that of β-actin and is represented as mean ± SD
after three repeats of the experiments. *; P<0.05 versus neonate and #;
P<0.05 versus adult. Similar symbols indicate no significant differences
between those groups.Immunohistochemistry of neonatal mouse testicular tissue after 8 weeks of organ culture.
B, H, N. Expression of specific protein of spermatogonial cells (PLZF),
spermatocytes (SCP3) and spermatozoa (ACRBP) in the bioreactor and E, K,
Q. On agarose gel, respectively. A-P. Nuclei were stained by
DAPI. C-R. The merged images. S-U. Expression of specific
protein in experimental groups. Data are represented as mean ± SD of experiments
performed in triplicate. #; P<0.05 versus adult and *; P<0.05 versus
neonate. a and b indicate P<0.05 versus the respective between the bioreactor
and agarose gel (scale bars: 10 μm).
Discussion
3D tissue culture is an effective technique for the
preservation and development of various tissues, including
germinal tissues. In this study, we developed a mini-scale
perfusion bioreactor and compared it with agarose gel for
3D culture of immature mouse testicular tissue. Inside
the body, capillaries around a tissue provide oxygen and
nutrients and clear waste effectively, thereby supporting
tissue homeostasis (9).SSCs and A-pair/A-aligned spermatogonia have been
suggested to be limited to the surrounding vasculature
and interstitial tissue around the seminiferous tubules
(25). A number of factors are responsible for diffusion
within culture, such as cell density, tissue thickness and
concentration of the materials on the tissue surface (26).
In 3D cultures, static flow might lead to the formation of
passive gradation of materials that will be equilibrated
over the long term. Therefore, a forced but controlled
culture medium perfusion is indispensable (27).In the method using agarose gel, extensive induction of spermatogenesis did not
happen because seminiferous tubules on the agarose gel merged to create a dome-shaped
structure even if initially extended flat. As a result, the supply of nutrients and oxygen
to the central region was insufficient, which led to necrotic and degenerative changes in
the tissue (9). Thus, for the lack of microcirculatory system, the agarose gel method cannot
provide conditions similar to those in vivo. Given the failure of the
static culture methods, dynamic culture methods seem to be more effective in increasing
spermatogenesis and producing haploid cells in a more effective 3D culture system that
provides optimal conditions that simulate the physiological environment of the body. These
conditions include temperature, oxygen and carbon dioxide content, mechanical, chemical and
electrical stimulation, and improved access to nutrients and elimination of waste. Together,
these factors should help to prevent necrosis in the central region of the tissue.In this study, it was shown that the mini-perfusion
bioreactor could induce more efficient spermatogenesis
than the agarose gel method when loaded with mouse
testis tissue and that this effect was consistent for 8
weeks. We had hypothesised that a dynamic culture
system would adequately supply the tissue with oxygen
and nutrients through the effective exchange of molecules
in culture medium streaming across the tissue surface
(28). Throughout the 8 weeks of culture on agarose gel,
spermatogenesis was maintained only in the peripheral
parts of the tissue. We suggest that, apart from the effective
transfer of molecules between testis tissue and the culture
medium, the tissues inside the mini-perfusion bioreactor
were supplied with a greater amount of oxygen through
the PDMS. If so, this would reduce oxygen toxicity in
comparison with direct exposure (29-31).It is also possible that the tissue chamber of the miniperfusion bioreactor might also help to replicate the
chemical environment of the body. For example, the porous
membrane that disconnects the tissue chamber from the
streaming medium, should increase the retention of the
secreted molecules in the chamber. It is important to
maintain efficient exchange and balance of molecules
between the tissue and the medium (32). A dynamic
system will achieve such a balance more easily than a
static system, which is why it was suggested that the
mini-perfusion bioreactor we used better fulfills this
requirement compared with the agarose gel method.The findings suggest that the mini-perfusion bioreactor
can promote differentiation up to the stage of post-meiotic
spermatozoa. It was concluded that the mini-perfusion
bioreactor may be useful for developing a dynamic culture
system for the maturation of premeiotic mouse germ cells
to post-meiotic levels as well as morphologically normal
spermatozoa. Such findings are consistent with those of
Komeya et al. (9, 33).Molecular changes in germ cells are useful for stimulating spermatogenesis. Our
real-time PCR analysis of specific markers (Plzf, Tekt1 and
Tnp1) after 8 weeks of culture in the bioreactor and agarose gel revealed
the presence of premeiotic, meiotic and post-meiotic cells, respectively.
Tnp1 expression after 8 weeks was significantly lower in the agarose
group than in the adult mouse testicular tissue but did not differ significantly between the
bioreactor culture and adult mouse testicular tissue. The mini-perfusion bioreactor provided
sufficient nutrients and oxygen for tissue culture. In the tissue cultured on agarose gel,
tubules were not observed centrally, probably because of the hypoxic conditions and limited
access to nutrients. In the agarose cultures, we observed necrotic and degenerative changes
in the central parts of tissue. Therefore, expression was lower in the agarose group after 8
weeks of culture compared to the bioreactor and adult groups. Yokonishi et al. (34) reported
the presence of spermatid cells and sperm, which resulted in the formation of embryos.
Aflatoonian et al. (35) reported the successful in vitro production of
postmeiotic spermatid cells. Alrahel et al. (36) reported the expression of the post-meiotic
gene, Tnp1, but only at the molecular scale and not beyond meiosis.Immunohistochemical analyses have shown that
epithelial cells express PLZF, SCP3, and ACRBP
proteins, which are exclusive to SSCs, spermatocytes
and spermatozoa, respectively. Our immunofluorescence
analysis of the tissues after 8 weeks of culture in the
bioreactor and agarose gel on these specific markers
(PLZF, SCP3, ACRBP) showed the presence of
premeiotic, meiotic, and post-meiotic cells.Our results are in line with those of Mohaqiq et al.
(37). Immunohistochemical studies of Rahmani et al.
(38) showed the expression of the premeiotic marker
PLZF in SSCs and undifferentiated spermatogonia. The
immunohistochemical analysis of Gharenaz et al. (39)
verified that PLZF-positive cells (spermatogonial stem
cells) and SYCP3-positive cells (spermatocytes) exist in the seminiferous tubules. Also in the agarose gel
cultures, no sperm were observed in the suspension
produced by tissue dissociation. By contrast, after
removal of tissue from the bioreactor and mechanical
dissociation, sperm- like cells were observed,
suggesting that maturation to elongated spermatids is
stopped on the agarose gel culture.We were able to improve the culture conditions for testis tissues using our
bioreactor for tissue culture. Bioreactor systems may prove valuable for preventing ischemia
and facilitating the long-term culture of testis tissue. However, further research is needed
to investigate the effects of enriching the culture medium with different supplements and
growth factors. In the bioreactor system we are able to culture the tissue pieces (size 1
mm3) but in the microscale dynamic culture systems only the seminiferous
tubules can be cultured in the microchannels. Also at the end of the culture period, tissue
removal from the middle chamber of the bioreactor is easily performed, but the extraction of
the seminiferous tubules from the microchannels of other devices seems more complicated and
difficult (40). Our bioreactor device is very simple, easy to use or user friendly, and more
economically feasible than existing ones. Bioreactors can be optimised further by adjusting
parameters including tissue chamber dimensions (particularly height), PDMS wall thickness,
medium flow speed, and membrane porosity, and pore size. Such optimizations and other
improvements of the culture medium could pave the way for developing new organ culture
methods in the future.
Conclusion
The culture of testis tissues was improved by using a
mini-perfusion bioreactor. Future studies are needed to
determine the optimal culture conditions, for example
the speed of flow of the medium and size of the tissue
chamber. Optimisation of the culture conditions, including
the culture medium may help to improve the methods for
organ cultivation.