| Literature DB >> 35703418 |
Arun J Thirunavukarasu1,2, Refaat Hassan1,3, Shalom V Savant1,4, Duncan L Hamilton5,6.
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Premature neonates require regular ophthalmological examination, generally indirect ophthalmoscopy, to screen for retinopathy of prematurity (ROP). Conventional analgesia is provided with topical anesthetic eyedrops and oral sugar solution, but neonates still experience significant pain. Here, the literature base was examined to evaluate the usefulness of other pharmacological analgesics.Entities:
Keywords: analgesic; eye examination; indirect ophthalmoscopy; neonatal; nitrous oxide; opioids; paracetamol; retinopathy of prematurity; screening tools; topical anesthesia
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35703418 PMCID: PMC9543288 DOI: 10.1111/papr.13138
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Pain Pract ISSN: 1530-7085 Impact factor: 3.079
FIGURE 1PRISMA flow‐chart depicting how studies were selected for inclusion in this systematic review: Initial search, duplicate exclusion, title and abstract screening, and full‐text screening. Duplicates were removed by a single researcher; screening was conducted by two researchers, with discussion and a third researcher acting as an arbiter to resolve disagreement
PICOS table summarizing the 11 studies included in the systematic review. Semi‐colons separate distinct experimental arms. Procedures are described in as much detail as provided by the study full‐text
| Citation | Participants | Interventions | Comparisons | Outcomes | Study design |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marsh et al, 2005 | 22 premature neonates undergoing indirect ophthalmoscopy with scleral depression and wire speculum. All patients swaddled for several minutes before examination and held by a nurse during examination. | Proparacaine HCl 0.5% (2 drops immediately prior to examination). | NaCl 0.5% (2 drops immediately prior to examination). | PIPP measured before (5 min, 1 min) examination and during speculum placement. | Randomized double blind placebo‐controlled crossover; two arms. |
| Manjunatha et al, 2009 | 18 premature neonates. All patients given one drop 0.5% proparacaine 0.5% in each eye, 5 min before examination. | Morphine sulfate 200 μg kg−1 (oral dose 60 min before examination); paracetamol 30 mg kg−1 (oral dose 60 min before examination). | Placebo 2 ml kg−1 (oral dose 60 min before examination). | PIPP measured before (5 min) and after (5 min, 30 min, 60 min, 120 min, 180 min). | Randomized double blind placebo‐controlled crossover; three arms. |
| Mehta et al, 2010 | 40 premature neonates undergoing indirect ophthalmoscopy with lid speculum and scleral depression. All patients given nonnutritive pacifier and swaddled during examination. | Proparacaine HCl 0.5% (drops during examination). | Saline (drops during examination). | PIPP measured before (1 min) and after (1 min, 5 min) examinations commenced. | Randomized double blind placebo‐controlled crossover; two arms. |
| Cogen et al, 2011 | 34 premature neonates undergoing indirect ophthalmoscopy with scleral depression. | Proparacaine HCl 0.5% (drops during examination) | Artificial tears (drops during examination). | PIPP measured after speculum insertion, during initial visualization of the retina, and after scleral depression. | Randomized double blind placebo‐controlled crossover; two arms. |
| Mandel et al, 2012 | 40 premature neonates undergoing indirect ophthalmoscopy. All infants swaddled by a nurse throughout examination; one drop proparacaine 0.5% in each eye 1 min before examination; 24% sucrose administered orally at the nurse's discretion, starting 1 min before local anesthetic. | 50% oxygen and 50% nitrous oxide gas mixture (nasal cannula initiated 5 min before examination). | EMONO 50% oxygen 50% nitrogen gas mixture (nasal cannula initiated 5 min before examination). | PIPP measured after speculum insertion and 30 min after examination. | Randomized double blind placebo‐controlled crossover; two arms. |
| Seifi et al, 2013 | 120 premature neonates undergoing ROP screening. All infants given tetracaine 1% eyedrops prior to examination of each eye. | Paracetamol 15 mg kg−1 (oral dose 30 min before examination) and sterile water 0.2 mL (orally administered during examination). | 25% sucrose 0.2 ml (orally administered during examination); sterile water 0.2 ml (orally administered during examination). | PIPP measured during the first and last 45 s of each examination. | Randomized double blind placebo‐controlled crossover; three arms. |
| Nesargi et al, 2015 | 20 premature neonates undergoing indirect ophthalmoscopy. All infants given proparacaine 0.5% drops 10 min prior to examination of each eye. | Proparacaine HCl 0.5% (1 eye‐drop immediately prior to examination) | 25% dextrose 2 mL (oral dose administered 10 min before examination). | PIPP measured during examination of the left eye. | Randomized double blind crossover; two arms. |
| Kabataş et al, 2016 | 114 premature neonates undergoing ROP screening. All infants given 0.5% proparacaine applied 30s before examination. | Paracetamol 15 mg kg−1 (single oral dose 60 min before examination) | 15 ml kg−1 sterile water (single oral dose 60 min before examination). | PIPP measured during examination of the first eye. | Randomized double blind placebo‐controlled crossover; two arms. |
| Hartley et al, 2018 | 31 premature neonates undergoing indirect ophthalmoscopy with scleral indenter and eyelid speculum. All infants swaddled before procedure and given 0.5% proxymetacaine drops before insertion of eyelid speculum. | Morphine sulfate 100 μg kg−1 (single oral dose 60 min before examination). | Placebo 100 μg kg−1 (administered via oral syringe or nasogastric tube 60 min before examination). | PIPP‐R measured 30s after speculum removed post‐examination. | Randomized double blind placebo‐controlled crossover; two arms. |
| Sindhur et al, 2020 | 111 premature neonates undergoing indirect ophthalmoscopy with scleral indenter and eyelid speculum. All infants given 0.5 mL of oral sucrose 24% 1 min prior to examination and 0.5% proparacaine 30s prior. | Fentanyl 2 μg kg−1 (intranasal administration 5 min before examination). | Saline 0.3 ml (intranasal administration 5 min before examination). | PIPP‐R measured during and after (1 min, 5 min) examination. | Randomized double blind placebo‐controlled crossover; two arms. |
| Naik et al, 2021 | 120 premature neonates undergoing indirect ophthalmoscopy with scleral indenter and eyelid speculum. All infants given proparacaine drops prior to examination and swaddled during procedure. | Paracetamol 15 mg kg−1 (single oral dose 30 min before examination) | Conventional analgesia only; expressed breast milk 2 mL (orally administered 2 min before examination). | PIPP measured before (20s), during, and after (2 min) examination. | Randomized single blind crossover; three arms. |
Abbreviations: PIPP, premature infant pain profile; PIPP‐R, premature infant pain profile revised.
FIGURE 2Risk of bias analysis for all of the included studies. Six domains were derived from the Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomized trials, and studies were also specifically screened for any other potential sources of bias. For each study, two researchers evaluated the risk of bias, with discussion and a third researcher acting as arbiter to resolve any disagreements
Results of randomized trials evaluating topical anesthesia for ameliorating the pain of ROP screening
| Citation |
| Experimental arms | Pain scores |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cogen et al, 2011 | 34 | (A) Proxymetacaine | PIPPA = 10.4 | 0.1 |
| (B) Artificial tears | PIPPB = 12.0 | |||
| Marsh et al, 2005 | 22 | (A) Proxymetacaine | PIPPA = 11 | 0.001 |
| (B) Saline drops | PIPPB = 13.5 | |||
| Mehta et al, 2010 | 40 | (A) Proxymetacaine | PIPPA = 10.375 | 0.027 |
| (B) Saline drops | PIPPB = 11.725 | |||
| Nesargi et al, 2015 | 20 | (A) Proxymetacaine | PIPPA = 14.75 | 0.165 |
| (B) Sweet taste | PIPPB = 14.55 |
Abbreviation: PIPP, premature infant pain profile.
Results of randomized trials evaluating alternative pharmaceuticals, defined as anything other than topical anesthesia, for ameliorating the pain of ROP screening
| Citation |
| Experimental arms | Pain scores |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kabataş et al, 2016 | 114 | (A) TA and paracetamol | PIPPA = 12 | 0.01 |
| (B) TA and water | PIPPB = 14 | |||
| Naik et al, 2021 | 120 | (A) TA and paracetamol | PIPPA = 15.83 | 0.72 |
| (B) TA and breastmilk/formula prefeed | PIPPB = 15.44 | |||
| (C) TA | PIPPC = 15.74 | |||
| Seifi et al, 2013 | 120 | (A) TA and sweet taste | PIPPA = 12.9 | <0.001 |
| (B) TA and paracetamol | PIPPB = 9.0 | |||
| (C) TA and water | PIPPC = 13.7 | |||
| Manjunatha et al, 2009 | 18 | (A) TA and paracetamol | PIPPA = 4.600 | 0.083 |
| (B) TA and morphine | PIPPB = 3.500 | |||
| (C) TA and placebo | PIPPC = 6.167 | |||
| Hartley et al, 2018 | 31 | (A) TA and morphine | PIPPA = 11.1 | 0.66 |
| (B) TA and placebo | PIPPB = 10.5 | |||
| Sindhur et al, 2020 | 111 | (A) TA and sucrose and fentanyl | PIPPA = 8.3 | <0.001 |
| (B) TA and sucrose and saline | PIPPB = 11.5 | |||
| Mandel et al, 2012 | 40 | (A) TA and sweet taste and N2O/ O2 gas | PIPPA = 8.5 | 0.94 |
| (B) TA and sweet taste and N2/O2 gas | PIPPB = 8.4 |
Abbreviations: N2, nitrogen; N2O, nitrous oxide; O2, oxygen; PIPP, premature infant pain profile; TA, topical anesthesia.