Amal Moussa1, Nayla El-Kork2,3, Israa Zeid1, Ehab Salem1, Mahmoud Korek1. 1. Faculty of Science, Beirut Arab University, P.O. Box 11-5020, Riad El Solh, Beirut 1107 2809, Lebanon. 2. Department of Physics, Khalifa University, P.O. Box 127788, Abu Dhabi 51133, United Arab Emirates. 3. Space and Planetary Science Center, Khalifa University, Abu Dhabi 51133, United Arab Emirates.
Abstract
The ground and excited electronic states of the diatomic molecules CaCs and CaNa have been investigated by implementing the ab initio CASSCF/(MRCI + Q) calculation. The potential energy curves of the doublet and quartet electronic low energy states in the representation 2s+1Λ(±) have been determined for the two considered molecules, in addition to the spectroscopic constants T e, ωe, B e, R e, and the values of the dipole moment μe and the dissociation energy D e. The determination of vibrational constants E v, B v, D v, and the turning points R min and R max up to the vibrational level v = 100 was possible with the use of the canonical functions schemes. Additionally, the transition and the static dipole moments curves, Einstein coefficients, the spontaneous radiative lifetime, the emission oscillator strength, and the Franck-Condon factors are computed. These calculations showed that the molecule CaCs is a good candidate for Doppler laser cooling with an intermediate state. A "four laser" cooling scheme is presented, along with the values of Doppler limit temperature T D = 55.9 μK and the recoil temperature T r = 132 nK. These results should provide a good reference for experimental spectroscopic and ultra-cold molecular physics studies.
The ground and excited electronic states of the diatomic molecules CaCs and CaNa have been investigated by implementing the ab initio CASSCF/(MRCI + Q) calculation. The potential energy curves of the doublet and quartet electronic low energy states in the representation 2s+1Λ(±) have been determined for the two considered molecules, in addition to the spectroscopic constants T e, ωe, B e, R e, and the values of the dipole moment μe and the dissociation energy D e. The determination of vibrational constants E v, B v, D v, and the turning points R min and R max up to the vibrational level v = 100 was possible with the use of the canonical functions schemes. Additionally, the transition and the static dipole moments curves, Einstein coefficients, the spontaneous radiative lifetime, the emission oscillator strength, and the Franck-Condon factors are computed. These calculations showed that the molecule CaCs is a good candidate for Doppler laser cooling with an intermediate state. A "four laser" cooling scheme is presented, along with the values of Doppler limit temperature T D = 55.9 μK and the recoil temperature T r = 132 nK. These results should provide a good reference for experimental spectroscopic and ultra-cold molecular physics studies.
The discovery of Bose–Einstein
condensates[1,2] and Fermi gases[3] encouraged researchers
to study ultra-cold molecules. More specifically, ultra-polar molecules
are of high interest as they exhibit a permanent dipole moment that
results from the difference in electronegativity between the atoms,
leading to an anisotropic continuing dipole–dipole interaction[4] in ultra-cold systems. The importance of ultra-cold
polar molecules is that they allow the study of modulated chemical
reactions[5,6] and render descriptive quantum computing
and quantum reproduction of lattice spin versions[7] possible. In addition, they help in the study of experimental
preparation of few-body quantum effects[8] and accurate measurements of the variation of the fine structure
constant α,[9] the proton-to electron
mass ratio μ ≡ mp/me,[10−14] and the electron dipole moment.[15,16] The mixing
of an alkali (AK) atom with an alkaline earth (AKE) atom produces
an AK–alkaline earth (AK–AKE) molecule with one unpaired
electron, which is a polar molecule that has a magnetic dipole moment
in the 2Σ+ ground state. We chose to study
the (AK–AKE) molecule because its constituents were cooled
precisely, and corresponding quantum degenerate systems were already
created.[17−20] To obtain such a molecule, one can hold two laser-cooled atoms by
photoassociation[21] or Feshbach resonance.[22,23] Our team recently proposed the (AK–AKE) molecule, CaK, as
a potential laser-cooling candidate through the Doppler cooling technique.[24] Although theoretical studies have been published
about some (AK–AKE) molecules such as CsSr,[25] MgCs,[26] BaCs,[27] CaK, CaNa, CaRb,[28] and CaLi,[29] there are still data that are missing.This paper has two aims: the first is to fill the missing gap related
to the complete absence of theoretical and experimental data on the
molecule CaCs and some higher electronic states of the CaNa molecule.
The second aim is to investigate whether either of the two molecules
could be cooled down to ultra-cold temperatures using the Doppler
laser-cooling technique. Consequently, in this work, the electronic
structure of these two molecules has been studied using the ab initio
CASSCF/(MRCI + Q) method. The potential energy curves (P.E.C.s), the
spectroscopic constants Te, ωe, Be, Re, and the static and transition dipole moments (T.D.M.s) have been
calculated along with rovibrational constants Ev, Bv, Dv, and the turning points Rmin and Rmax. The calculation of the Franck–Condon
factor, the radiative lifetime, the vibrational branching ratio, the
Doppler limit temperature TD, the recoil
temperature Tr prove the candidacy of
the molecule CaCs only for Doppler laser cooling.In exploring
the practicality of laser cooling of these molecules,
we have found that the CaCs molecule is an appropriate candidate for
Doppler laser cooling where a laser-cooling scheme is presented.
Computational
Approach
The basic measurements and calculations are performed
in the C2 point-group
symmetry with
the help of the computational program MOLPRO,[30] taking advantage of the graphical user interface GABEDIT.[31] The calculations executed by this program have
high accuracy due to the analysis of the electron correlation problem.
The calculations for the ground and excited states of the CaCs and
CaNa molecules are based on the ab initio methods by using the state
averaged complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) followed
by the multireference configuration interaction (MRCI) method with
Davidson correction (+Q). The basis set used for the cesium atom is
the quasi-relativistic energy-consistent pseudo-potential ECP46MWB.
According to this basis set, 46 electrons are considered frozen with
the core of the Cs atom, and as a result, we deal with the cesium
atom as a system of nine active electrons only. For the calcium atom
of the CaCs molecule, we use the cc-pVQZ quadruple-ζ correlation-consistent
polarized basis where all the 20 electrons are considered. Consequently,
the CaCs molecule is considered a system of 29 electrons, with three
valence electrons. For this molecule, the 13 active orbitals in the C2 symmetry are 6σ (Ca:
4s, 4p0, 3d0, 3d ± 2; Cs: 6s, 6p0), 3π
(Ca: 4p ± 1, 3d ± 1; Cs: 6p ± 1), 1δ (Ca: 3d
± 2) distributed into the irreducible representation a1, b1, b2, and a2 as [6, 3, 3, 1]. The calcium atom of the CaNa molecule
has been treated using the quasi-relativistic energy consistent pseudo-potential
ECP10MWB, where 10 electrons were frozen within the core, and the
remaining 10 electrons are considered active electrons within the
considered molecular orbital. The sodium atom Na is treated in all-electron
schemes using the cc-pVQZ basis. Consequently, the CaNa molecule is
considered a system of 21 electrons, with three valence electrons.
For this molecule, the 15 active orbitals in the C2 symmetry are 8σ (Ca: 4s, 4p0, 3d0, 3d ± 2, 5s; Na: 3s, 3p0,
4s), 3π (Ca: 4p ± 1, 3d ± 1; Na: 3p ± 1), 1δ
(Ca: 3d ± 2) distributed into the irreducible representation a1, b1, b2, and a2 as [8, 3, 3, 1]. We used this combination of basis sets
for the two molecules due to the successful results obtained by other
groups and previously published papers[32−35] that used a similar combination
of basis sets for AK–AKE compounds. Additionally, and for more
accuracy and comparison, we used the perturbation theory (Rayleigh–Schrödinger
perturbation theory) RSPT2-rs2 to calculate the spectroscopic constants
for some electronic states for CaCs and CaNa molecules. The RSPT2-rs2
calculations have been done using the same basis sets as the MRCI/CASSCF
method, considering three valence electrons for the two molecules.
By using the same methods and computing packages, we have also calculated
the lowest-lying molecular curves of the CaNa molecule using Aug-cc-pVQZ
for the Na atom.
Results and Discussion
Potential Energy Curves
In this work, we draw the P.E.C.s
for 25 doublet and quartet low-energy electronic states for the CaCs
molecule and 32 doublet and quartet electronic states for the CaNa
molecule as a function of the internuclear distance shown in Figures –8.
Figure 1
Potential energy curves of the lowest 2Σ+ and 2Δ electronic states of the CaCs molecule using
the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.
Figure 8
P.E.C.s of the lowest 4Π electronic
states of
the CaNa molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence
electrons.
Potential energy curves of the lowest 2Σ+ and 2Δ electronic states of the CaCs molecule using
the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.Potential energy curves of the lowest 4Σ(±) and 4Δ electronic states of the CaCs molecule using
the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.Potential energy curves of the lowest 2Π electronic
states of the CaCs molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three
valence electrons.Potential energy curves
of the lowest 4Π electronic
states of the CaCs molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three
valence electrons.Potential energy curves
of the lowest 2Σ+ and 2Δ
electronic states of the CaNa molecule using
the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.P.E.C.s of the lowest 4Σ(±) and 4Δ electronic states of the CaNa molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI
method with three valence electrons.P.E.C.s
of the lowest 2Π electronic states of
the CaNa molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence
electrons.P.E.C.s of the lowest 4Π electronic
states of
the CaNa molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence
electrons.The kind of forces holding the
atoms specify and control the shape
of the obtained curve. Shallow wells are obtained for some electronic
states when the repulsive forces overcome the attractive ones within
the considered range of internuclear distance.The cesium and
the sodium atoms have an unpaired electron; therefore,
they will remain in the doublet state, while the calcium atom Ca exists
either in the singlet or in the triplet state. Since the combination
of a doublet alkali metal atom with a singlet lowest state of alkaline
earth metal results in a doublet state of the molecule, X2Σ+ is the ground state of the two molecules CaCs
and CaNa. Now, the combination between the doublet state of Cs and
Na atoms with the triplet state of a Ca atom results in the quartet
states 4Σ+ of the two molecules.The P.E.C.s of the doublet electronic states of the CaCs molecule
are shown in Figure (2Σ+ and 2Δ electronic
states) and Figure (2Π electronic states). The P.E.C.s of the quartet
states of the CaCs molecule are shown in Figure (4Σ(±) and 4Δ electronic states) and Figure (4Π electronic states).
The P.E.C.s of the doublet electronic states of the CaNa molecule
are shown in Figure (2Σ+ and 2Δ electronic
states) and Figure (2Π electronic states). The P.E.C.s of the quartet
states of the CaNa molecule are shown in Figure (4Σ(±) and 4Δ electronic states) and Figure (4Π electronic states).
The P.E.C.s for the molecule CaNa obtained with the Aug-cc-pVQZ basis
sets for the Na atom are displayed in Figure S1 in the Supporting Information.
Figure 3
Potential energy curves of the lowest 2Π electronic
states of the CaCs molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three
valence electrons.
Figure 2
Potential energy curves of the lowest 4Σ(±) and 4Δ electronic states of the CaCs molecule using
the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.
Figure 4
Potential energy curves
of the lowest 4Π electronic
states of the CaCs molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three
valence electrons.
Figure 5
Potential energy curves
of the lowest 2Σ+ and 2Δ
electronic states of the CaNa molecule using
the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.
Figure 7
P.E.C.s
of the lowest 2Π electronic states of
the CaNa molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence
electrons.
Figure 6
P.E.C.s of the lowest 4Σ(±) and 4Δ electronic states of the CaNa molecule using the CASSCF/MRCI
method with three valence electrons.
Table presents
the lowest dissociation limits of the calculated low-lying electronic
states of the two molecules CaCs and CaNa compared to the combination
of atomic orbital values obtained from the National Institute of Standards
and Technology website (NIST).[36] As a result
of the fluctuations and oscillations in the P.E.C at the long-range
of the internuclear distance R, the dissociation
limits of some of the higher excited molecular states are not achieved,
and consequently, these higher molecular states are not considered.
A good clarification of these fluctuations in the P.E.C is the Born–Oppenheimer
approximation breakdown. The comparison of the dissociation limits
of the investigated P.E.C with those obtained with the NIST database
agrees well with a relative difference of 14% for the first dissociation
limit and 10.9% for the second of the CaCs molecule. For the molecule
CaNa, a good agreement is also attained between the values of the
dissociation limits obtained with NIST and our calculated values with
a relative difference of 0.38 < ΔDe/De < 8.35, except for the fourth
dissociation limit where the relative difference is 19.64%. The corresponding
values of the dissociation energies De are presented in Tables and 3.
Table 1
Lowest
Dissociation Limits of CaCs
and CaNa Molecules
dissociation of atomic levels Ca + Cs
dissociation
energy limit of CaCs levels (cm–1)
molecular states of CaCs
total dissociation energy limit of Ca + Cs atoms (cm–1)
relative
error (%)
Ca (3p64s2, 1S) + Cs (5p66s, 2S)
0a
X2Σ+
0b
0.0
Ca (3p64s2, 1S) + Cs (5p66p, 2P0)
9832a
(2)2Σ+, (1)2Π
11 455b
14
Ca (3p64s4p, 3P0) + Cs (5p66s, 2S)
13 561a
(2)2Π, (3)2Σ+,
(1)4Π, (1)4Σ+
15 228b
10.9
Present work.
Experimental data from the NIST
atomic spectra database.
Table 2
Spectroscopic Parameters for the X2Σ+ and 13 Excited States of the CaCs Molecule
states (2s+1Λ)
method
Te (cm–1)
ΔTe/Te %
Re (Å)
ΔRe/Re %
ωe (cm–1)
Δωe/ωe %
Be (cm–1)
ΔBe/Be %
De (cm–1)
|μe| (au)
X2Σ+
MRCI
0
4.978
+3.6
41.44
–23.9
0.0221
–6.8
894.192
3.762
perturbation
0
5.156
31.52
0.0206
(1)2Π
MRCI
4034.09
+8.2
4.254
–0.3
84.00
+1.9
0.0302
+0.7
6691.755
11.222
perturbation
4366.76
4.240
85.62
0.0304
(2)2Σ+
MRCI
6824.70
+6.9
4.899
+0.08
59.37
+3.9
0.0228
0.0
3890.082
4.189
perturbation
7295.34
4.903
61.68
0.0228
(2)2Π
MRCI
10 912.00
+1.8
4.990
+2.5
41.38
–7.7
0.0220
–5.0
3545.286
2.779
perturbation
11 110.40
5.113
38.17
0.0209
(1)4Π
MRCI
11 855.64
+1.0
4.711
+1.2
60.39
–6.0
0.0248
–2.8
2600.873
9.495
perturbation
11 970.20
4.767
56.79
0.0241
(4)2Σ+
MRCI
13 624.61
+13.4
4.802
–4.3
78.07
+26.9
0.0237
+9.3
6994.970
0.482
perturbation
15 458.38
4.596
99.04
0.0259
(1)2Δ
MRCI
14 747.09
+5.7
4.200
–0.4
81.19
+2.7
0.0310
+1.0
9382.437
11.967
perturbation
15 586.57
4.183
83.42
0.0313
(3)2Π
MRCI
14 819.56
+7.5
4.516
+0.4
67.55
–14
0.0268
–3.0
6104.507
6.275
perturbation
15 928.58
4.589
58.08
0.0260
(1)4Δ
MRCI
14 987.06
+5.36
4.077
+0.2
82.63
+12.5
0.0329
–0.3
9174.208
10.343
perturbation
15 790.82
4.086
92.94
0.0328
(4)2Π
MRCI
17 737.17
+2.0
5.204
–2.8
57.06
+13.7
0.0202
+6.0
6503.924
1.307
perturbation
18 092.90
5.056
64.91
0.0214
(2)4Π
MRCI
19 238.21
+0.08
5.412
–0.6
40.12
+14
0.0187
+1.1
4886.337
2.304
perturbation
19 254.39
5.379
45.75
0.0189
(3)4Π
MRCI
21 112.83
+1.2
5.154
+3.5
48.97
–1.5
0.0206
–5.8
3130.329
5.347
perturbation
21 370.67
5.334
48.23
0.0194
(5)2Π
MRCI
22 048.66
+0.8
4.857
+5.9
55.01
–23.3
0.0232
–10.8
2232.292
1.929
perturbation
22 226.51
5.142
42.20
0.0207
(1)4Σ–
MRCI
22 747.93
+2.0
4.911
+10.7
36.86
–33.0
0.0227
–18.5
1540.725
7.521
perturbation
23 197.12
5.437
24.69
0.0185
Table 3
Spectroscopic Parameters for the X2Σ+ and 26 Excited States of the CaNa Molecule
(Na Atom: cc-pVQZ and aug-cc-pVQZ)
states Λ2s+1
method [reference]
Te (cm–1)
ΔTe/Te %
Re (Å)
ΔRe/Re %
ωe (cm–1)
Δωe/ωe %
Be (cm–1)
ΔBe /Be %
De (cm–1)
ΔDe/De %
|μe| (au)
Δμe/μe %
X2Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: cc-pVQZ basis)[this
work]
0.00
3.759
101.3
0.0817
1721
1.38
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: Aug-cc-pVQZ) [this work]
0.00
3.749
0.3
103.4
2.1
0.0821
0.5
perturbation [this work]
3.851
2.4
91.8
9.4
0.0778
4.8
CASSCF/MRCI[36]
3.670
2.3
103.0
1.6
0.0830
1792
3.9
1.18
14.5
CCSD(T)[27]
3.720
1.0
97.0
4.2
1.5
1453
15.5
1.01
26.8
CASSCF/MRCI[37]
3.665
2.5
103.0
1.6
1802
4.4
1.17
15.2
CASPT2[37]
3.666
2.4
102.6
1.2
1752
1.7
1.09
21.0
CCSD[37]
3.720
1.0
88.5
12.6
1264
26.5
(1)2Π
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: cc-pVQZ basis)[this
work]
6572.57
2.6
3.323
0.00
164.4
0.7
0.1045
0.00
9034
12.0
2.85
20.0
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: Aug-cc-pVQZ) [this work]
6401.98
3.6
3.323
0.69
163.3
2.6
0.1045
1.3
10 275
11.4
2.28
18.9
perturbation
[this work]
6807.73
3.6
3.346
2.97
160.1
4.5
0.1031
10 199
3.4
2.31
CASSCF/MRCI[37]
6825
4.0
3.224
2.94
172.2
4.5
9360
CASPT2[37]
6851
8.8
3.225
2.25
172.2
6.1
CCSD[37]
7211
3.248
175.1
(2)2Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: cc-pVQZ basis) [this
work]
9374.00
0.3
3.919
0.2
119.8
0.4
0.0751
0.4
6226
8.6
0.99
45.4
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: Aug-cc-pVQZ) [this work]
9344.73
1.1
3.927
0.7
120.3
1.2
0.0748
1.5
6815
7.3
0.54
1.0
perturbation [this
work]
9472.78
8.6
3.948
3.1
118.4
3.8
0.0740
6721
2.4
0.98
CASSCF/MRCI[37]
10 261
9.0
3.795
3.0
124.6
4.0
6076
CASPT2[37]
10 305
10.4
3.800
5.6
124.9
7.9
CCSD[37]
10 472
3.696
130.1
(1)4Π
CASSCF/MRCI [this
work]
13 065.21
1.5
3.734
1.34
109.7
6.6
0.0828
2.6
2515
11.1
3.08
19.5
perturbation [this work]
12 872.69
8.2
3.784
2.75
102.4
2.9
0.08060
2832
10.1
2.48
19.8
CASSCF/MRCI[37]
14 238
8.1
3.631
2.78
113.0
3.0
2800
0.9
2.47
CASPT2[37]
14 220
6.6
3.630
2.46
113.1
0.7
2540
CCSD[37]
13 998
3.64
110.5
(2)2Π
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: cc-pVQZ basis) [this
work]
13 708.69
0.7
3.570
0.14
124.2
2.1
0.0905
0.4
3920
21.6
3.25
29.5
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: Aug-cc-pVQZ) [this
work]
13 611.21
2.7
3.565
3.00
126.8
9.5
0.0909
5.7
5003
17.8
4.61
16.9
perturbation [this work]
14 080.64
0.5
3.677
4.98
112.4
11.6
0.0853
4773
14.2
3.91
CASSCF/MRCI[37]
13 786
1.8
3.392
4.92
140.6
11.4
4573
CASPT2[37]
13 966
0.1
3.394
7.31
140.3
15.1
CCSD[37]
13 688
3.309
146.4
(3)2Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: cc-pVQZ basis) [this work]
13 894.96
0.3
4.065
0.54
100.5
2.7
0.0699
0.8
3682
11.9
0.52
30.8
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: Aug-cc-pVQZ) [this work]
13 849.72
1.9
4.043
2.36
97.8
16.7
0.0705
4.7
4180
10.0
0.36
3.9
perturbation [this work]
14 162.47
4.7
4.161
4.32
117.3
8.0
0.0666
4094
7.3
0.50
CASSCF/MRCI[37]
14 585
4.9
3.889
4.37
92.4
4.9
3413
CASPT2[37]
14 622
6.2
3.887
6.10
95.1
22.2
CCSD[37]
14 814
3.817
78.1
(1)4Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI [this
work]
15 390.75
4.4
6.041
7.2
22.9
12.2
0.0316
14.2
176
25.7
1.67
3.0
perturbation [this work]
14 708.90
8.2
6.474
4.9
25.7
4.5
0.0271
237
29.8
1.62
4.8
CASSCF/MRCI[36]
16 775
8.2
5.740
5.0
24.0
3.3
251
12.0
1.59
10.1
CASSCF/MRCI[37]
16 775
5.5
5.735
3.3
23.7
4.8
200
14.5
1.50
CASPT2[37]
16 288
5.838
2.6
21.8
7.4
206
CCSD[37]
5.882
21.2
(4)2Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
17 800.28
3.588
156.5
0.0897
7665
0.03
(1)4Σ–
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
20 017.54
0.3
3.221
0.6
162.3
2.5
0.1111
1.1
11 463
1.27
perturbation [this work]
20 086.76
3.241
166.4
0.1099
(3)2Π
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: cc-pVQZ basis) [this work]
21 289.08
2.5
3.754
0.6
114.4
5.1
0.0819
1.2
4227
4.85
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: Aug-cc-pVQZ) [this work]
20 755.62
3.775
108.5
0.0809
(4)2Π
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: cc-pVQZ basis) [this work]
21 670.05
0.5
3.761
0.6
82.3
5.1
0.0816
0.9
5311
2.65
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: Aug-cc-pVQZ) [this
work]
21 561.58
3.737
86.5
0.0823
(5)2Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI[this
work]
22 223.91
3.726
117.1
0.0832
4692
4.04
(2)4Π
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
22 242.86
0.1
4.037
1.3
107.0
1.9
0.0709
2.7
4792
2.36
perturbation [this
work]
22 266.68
4.089
105.0
0.0690
(2)4Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI [this
work]
23 797.06
0.2
3.964
3.9
92.4
17.0
0.0734
7.3
3183
4.17
perturbation [this work]
23 847.03
4.119
76.7
0.0680
(6)2Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI [this work]
24 767.42
3.926
39.5
0.0744
2169
12.27
(3)4Π
CASSCF/MRCI [this
work]
25 841.54
0.3
4.222
3.0
74.8
6.9
0.0648
5.8
5428
1.36
perturbation [this work]
25 771.95
4.348
69.6
0.06104
(2)2Δ
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: cc-pVQZ basis) [this work]
26 034.51
1.6
3.978
3.4
64.0
28.3
0.0730
7.0
915
3.61
CASSCF/MRCI (Na: Aug-cc-pVQZ) [this
work]
25 605.11
3.842
82.1
0.0781
(1)4Δ
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
26 267.05
4.355
45.3
0.0608
789
2.24
(3)2Δ
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
28 307.45
3.616
121.3
0.0883
3251
0.77
(2)4Δ
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
29 435.36
0.5
3.634
0.2
142.0
6.5
0.0874
0.3
2103
1.83
perturbation [this work]
29 595.75
3.628
132.8
0.0877
(4)4Π 2nd min
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
29 554.57
4.626
56.3
0.0540
1921
4.43
(4)4Π 1st min
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
29 652.33
3.412
148.0
0.0991
1761
0.55
(3)4Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
29 914.75
1.2
3.610
3.5
105.0
6.3
0.0886
6.8
1584
1.74
perturbation [this work]
30 268.02
3.738
98.4
0.0826
(1)4Φ
CASSCF/MRCI [this
work]
30 830.53
3.267
171.5
0.1073
0.92
(4)4Σ+
CASSCF/MRCI[this
work]
31 135.44
4.6
4.027
3.5
114.1
31.0
0.0712
6.9
492
2.97
perturbation [this work]
32 584.45
4.170
78.7
0.0663
(2)2Σ–
CASSCF/MRCI [this work]
32 086.31
0.7
3.687
0.7
106.0
15.5
0.0850
1.5
1.97
perturbation [this work]
32 299.26
3.713
122.4
0.0837
(5)4Σ+ 1st min
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
33 283.47
4.569
65.0
0.0553
7.44
(5)4Σ+ 2nd min
CASSCF/MRCI[this work]
34 600.65
8.002
88.2
0.0168
11.67
(3)4Δ
CASSCF/MRCI[this
work]
35 205.66
4.082
89.0
0.0692
5226
5.17
Present work.Experimental data from the NIST
atomic spectra database.In Figures –8, one can notice some shallow potential energy wells,
which are the evidence of the dominant Coulomb repulsive forces over
the attractive ones. In these figures, for the two considered molecules,
the avoided crossings that occur between the adiabatic states are
the results of an interplay between the ionic state and all other
states. Crossings are also generated due to the strong repulsive behavior
of the electronic states. The positions of crossing and avoided crossing
are provided in Table S1 in the Supporting
Information with their corresponding energy gaps ΔE. As a result, the appearance of a barrier potential and multiple
wells are due to the avoided crossing behavior corresponding to a
crossing in the diabatic picture.
Spectroscopic Parameters
The spectroscopic constants
ωe, Re, Be, Te, and De of the two molecules CaCs and CaNa electronic states
have been calculated by fitting the P.E.C values around the minimum
of the internuclear distance Re to a polynomial
in terms of R. These constants are obtained by using
CASSCF/MRCI and perturbation RSPT2-rs2 methods for 14 electronic states
of the molecule CaCs and 27 electronic states for the molecule CaNa.
They are presented in Tables and 3, respectively. For the molecule
CaCs, no comparison can be made between our calculated values and
those of the literature since they are presented here for the first
time. However, there is an important agreement between the results
we obtained using CASSCF/MRCI and RSPT2-rs2 methods.Our calculated
equilibrium bond distance Re and harmonic
frequency ωe for the ground state X2Σ+ of the CaNa molecule overlap well with those in the three
references,[28,37,38] with relative differences of 1% ≤ ΔRe/Re ≤ 2.5% and 1.2%
≤ Δωe/ωe ≤ 4.2%,
respectively, except for a larger relative difference Δωe/ωe = 10.5%[38] calculated
by using the CCSD method. Our calculated value of Be is very close to that calculated by Gopakumar et al.[28] with a relative difference ΔBe/Be = 1.5%.For the
excited states, our values of Te compare
well with those in the literature for seven excited electronic
states, where the relative differences vary as 0.1%(2)2Π[38] < ΔTe/Te < 10.4%(2)2∑+.[38] Similarly, the
internuclear distance Re also shows a
very good agreement when compared with published data, with a relative
difference of 2.25%[38] ≤ ΔRe/Re ≤ 7.31%.[38] The comparison of our results with the values
of ωe obtained by different techniques in the literature
shows a good agreement with the relative difference of 7%(1)4Π[38] ≤ Δωe/ωe ≤ 1.6%(1)2Π.[38] The comparison of our calculated values of ωe with those obtained by using the CCSD method[38] shows a relative difference of 22.2%. There is no comparison
for the other investigated states since they are calculated here first.The comparison of our calculated values of the spectroscopic constants
by using the Aug-cc-pVQZ basis sets for Na atom in Table with those calculated by using
the cc-pVQZ basis set for the same atom shows an excellent agreement
with the average relative differences of the ground and the studied
excited states ΔTe/Te = 0.97%, ΔRe/Re = 0.29%, Δωe/ωe
= 1.32%, and Δωe/ωe = 0.52%.
Given these values, we estimate that the use of the diffuse Gaussian
basis functions (aug-) for the Na atom has no real effect on the investigated
data of the molecule CaNa.The absence of spectroscopic constants
of some electronic states
is referred to the presence of avoided crossing near the minima of
these states. As a verification of the accuracy of our results given
in Tables and 3, the trend of the spectroscopic constants is presented
in Table , where Te, ωe, and Be decrease for each electronic state with the decrease
of the electronegativity and Re increases
as we go from CaNa to CaCs.
Table 4
Study of the Trend
of the Spectroscopic
Constants of the Different Electronic States of the Molecules CaNa
and CaCs
Permanent Dipole Moment
The permanent dipole moment
of a diatomic molecule is an important parameter since it clarifies
the type of bonding (ionic/covalent) and the polarity of a given molecular
interaction. As stated in the Introduction,
the importance of polar ultra-cold molecules lies in using long-life
interactions among their permanent dipole moments in specific applications.
We have estimated the dipole moment curves (D.M.C.s), representing
the molecular permanent dipole moment variation with the internuclear
distance R, for the 25 lowest doublet and quartet
electronic states of CaCs and the 32 lowest doublet and quartet electronic
states of the CaNa molecule. These curves are plotted in the Supporting
Information, in Figures S2–S9. The
electron density distribution controls the values of the dipole moments.
The geometry of the investigated systems is such that the calcium
atom is chosen to be at the origin for both CaNa and CaCs molecules.
Consequently, a charge transfer from Ca to Cs and from Ca to Na leads
to negative dipole moment values when the charge density is closer
to the Cs and Na atoms. This polarity is indicated as Caδ+Csδ− and Caδ+Naδ− for CaCs and CaNa molecules, respectively.The permanent dipole
moment (PDM) curves for the ground state X2Σ+ of the two molecules CaCs and CaNa are positive with maximum
values |μe| = 1.78 au at R = 4.14
Å and |μe| = 0.691 au at R =
2.92 Å, respectively. The curves reach zero at a large distance
(R = 10 Å), indicating the molecule’s
breaking into a neutral fragment. The absolute values of μe were calculated for both molecules’ ground and excited
states and are tabulated in Tables and 3. It should be noted here
that the abrupt gradient change of the PDM curves is due to the occurrence
of an avoided crossing between the P.E.C.s of two states of the same
symmetry. The positions of the avoided crossings concur with those
of the D.M.C. polarity shifts.The comparison of our calculated
PDM(μe) values
for the ground state (X)2∑+ of the molecule
CaNa shows an almost acceptable agreement with the values present
in the literature with a relative error 14.5%[37] ≤ Δμe/μe ≤
21%.[38] The first excited quartet state
(1)4∑– shows a good agreement
with a relative error 3%[37] ≤ Δμe/μe ≤ 10.1%.[38] The comparison of our calculated values of (μe)
for the excited states (1)2Π, (2)2∑+, (1)4Π, (2)2Π, (3)2∑+ with those published by Pototschnig et
al.[38] shows an acceptable agreement with
a relative error 1% ≤ Δμe/μe ≤ 19.8%. The exception goes when the calculations
were performed by using the ab initio CASPT2 method, with a relative
error 19.5% ≤ Δμe/μe ≤ 45.4%.
Transition Dipole Moment Curves and Radiative
Lifetimes
The T.D.M. is useful for predicting the possible
transitions that
are likely to occur between certain electronic states. In our work,
we investigated and show in Figures and 10 the transition dipole
moment curves (TDMCs) of the allowed transitions from the lowest excited
to the ground X2Σ+ states for the molecules
CaCs and CaNa as a function of the internuclear distance.
Figure 9
Transition
D.M.C.s between the ground state X2Σ+ and
the lowest-excited doublet states of the CaCs molecule
using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.
Figure 10
Transition D.M.C.s between the ground state X2Σ+ and the lowest-excited doublet states of the CaNa molecule
using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.
Transition
D.M.C.s between the ground state X2Σ+ and
the lowest-excited doublet states of the CaCs molecule
using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.Transition D.M.C.s between the ground state X2Σ+ and the lowest-excited doublet states of the CaNa molecule
using the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.For the molecule CaCs, the TDMCs for the transitions X2Σ+–(2)2Π, (1)2Π–(2)2Π, and (2)2Σ+–(2)2Π vanish when R is larger than 10.5 Å where the occurrence of these
transitions
is at a very low probability. For the two transitions X2Σ+–(1)2Π and X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+, the
transitions are maximal for R greater than 11 and
5.54 Å, respectively. The TDMCs for the X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+, X2Σ+–(1)2Π, (2)2Σ+–(2)2Π, and (1)2Π–(2)2Π transitions of the CaNa molecule vanish when R is larger than 9 Å. The transition X2Σ+–(2)2Π is the highest for R greater than 16 Å. We have considered the T.D.M.
values at the equilibrium position Re of
the upper state for each electronic transition to calculate the emission
coefficients proposed by Hilborn[39] for
the two considered molecules, CaCs and CaNa. The T.D.M. value|μ21| and the radiative lifetime τ21 ( where j runs for the underlying
states of the i state), the emission angular frequency
ω21, the Einstein coefficients of spontaneous emissions A21, the oscillator strength constant |f21|, and the classical radiative decay rate
of the single-electron oscillator γcl are presented
in Table . The emission
coefficients for the allowed electronic transitions are given below,
where ν is the transition frequency
between the two states, ε0 is the vacuum permittivity,
and me is the mass of an electron
Table 5
Transition Dipole Moment Values of
the Upper State at its Equilibrium Position |μ|, the Emission
Angular Frequency ω21, the Einstein Spontaneous Coefficients A21, the Spontaneous Radiative Lifetime τspon, the Classical Radiative Decay Rate of the Single-Electron
Oscillator γcl, and the Emission Oscillator Strength f21 of Some Transitions among the Doublet States
of CaCs and CaNa Molecules
transition
|μ21| (au)
ω21 × 10–15 (rad s–1)
A21 (s–1)
τ21 (ns)
γcl × 10–6 (s–1)
|f21|
CaCs
X2Σ+–(1)2Π
0.655
0.760
56 934.23
17 564.12
3.61
0.00526
X2Σ+–(2)2Π
1.698
2.055
7 573 195.06
132.04
26.41
0.09557
(2)2Σ+–(2)2Π
1.355
0.768
253 461.85
3945.37
3.70
0.02280
(1)2Π–(2)2Π
2.386
1.295
3 743 637.51
267.12
10.49
0.11893
X2Σ+–(3)2Σ+
2.471
2.343
23 763 471.39
42.08
34.32
0.23078
X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+
4.595
1.286
13 572 618.85
73.68
10.33
0.43783
CaNa
X2Σ+–(1)2Π
0.037
1.238
769.05
1 300 317.3
9.57
0.000027
X2Σ+–(2)2Π
1.018
2.581
5 389 790.30
185.6
41.65
0.043144
(2)2Σ+–(2)2Π
0.159
0.817
4120.94
242 666.3
4.17
0.000329
(1)2Π–(2)2Π
0.968
1.344
686 368.83
1456.7
11.29
0.020275
X2Σ+–(3)2Σ+
3.881
2.616
81 540 743.90
12.3
42.79
0.635332
X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+
1.668
1.765
4 621 351.20
216.4
19.48
0.079116
The comparison of our data with previous
work is absent since it
is calculated here for the first time.The oscillator strength
expresses the probability of absorption
or emission of electromagnetic radiation in transitions between energy
levels of a molecule. If an emissive state has a small oscillator
strength, nonradiative decay will outpace radiative decay. Conversely,
“bright” transitions will have large oscillator strengths.
From Table , we found
that the largest oscillator strength belongs to the (X)2Σ+–(3)2Σ+ transition
of the molecule CaNa and the most considerable value of the radiative
lifetime is for the transition (X)2Σ+–(1)2Π of the same molecule. Since we are interested in the
transition (X)2Σ+–(1)2Π for the laser cooling of the molecule CaCs, one can notice
that the oscillator strength of this molecule is larger than that
of the molecule CaNa, while the radiative lifetime is shorter. With
these two conditions, the molecule CaCs is more advantageous for experimental
laser cooling than the molecule CaNa.
Vibration–Rotation
Calculation
The vibrational
energy Ev, the rotational constant Bv, and the centrifugal distortion constant Dv for the ground and many excited electronic
states of the CaCs and CaNa molecules are determined by using the
canonical functions approach[40,41] and the cubic spline
interpolation between each two consecutive points of the P.E.C obtained
from the ab initio calculation of the molecule. Then, the calculated
vibrational eigenvalues of energy and the P.E.C of the investigated
states are used to determine the abscissas of the turning points Rmin and Rmax for
each vibrational level. The calculations were done for a large number
of vibrational levels up to v = 100 for deep well
potential, while few vibrational levels were calculated for shallow
well potentials. However, these calculations cannot be achieved for
some electronic states due to crossings and avoided crossing in the
P.E.C near the minima, the existence of double minima, and for very
shallow potentials.The vibrational constants of the investigated
electronic states of the two molecules CaCs and CaNa are collected
and presented in Tables S2 and S3 in the
Supporting Information. There is no comparison with other data for
the ground and the excited states of the molecules CaCs since they
are investigated here for the first time. For the ground state (Χ)2∑+ of the CaNa molecule, the rotational
constants Bv of five vibrational levels
have been found in the literature. The comparison of our calculated
values of these constants with those given in the literature shows
a very good agreement with the relative difference 0.02%[28] ≤ ΔBv/Bv ≤ 2.2%.[28] The comparison for the other vibrational constants of the
investigated electronic states of the molecule CaNa is absent since
they are calculated here for the first time. These theoretical data
will be a good guide for the spectroscopic experimentalists, particularly
the values of Rmin and Rmax that will be compared with the values of the experimental
Rydberg–Klein–Rees potentials.
Laser-Cooling Study
Laser-Cooling
Viability of CaCs Molecule
The small
difference in equilibrium positions ΔRe between the two electronic X2Σ+ and (2)2Σ+ states and X2Σ+ and (2)2Π states of the CaCs molecule directed
our attention to study the laser-cooling feasibility for this molecule.
The primary criteria for direct laser cooling is a highly diagonal
Franck–Condon factors (FCFs) between the ground and a low-lying
excited electronic state. This allows the use of a limited number
of lasers to keep the molecule in a closed-loop cycle.[42] The second criterion that affects a molecule’s
laser-cooling viability is a short radiative lifetime between the
vibrational levels of the involved electronic states. In the present
work, a direct laser cooling is studied between the two electronic
X2Σ+ and (2)2Π states
in the presence of the intervening electronic states (1)2Π and (2)2Σ+ between them.An examination of the table of the spectroscopic constants of the
CaNa molecule shows a large difference between the values of the internuclear
distance at equilibrium Re for the ground
electronic state and that of higher excited states. Such a large difference
usually implies a non-diagonal FCF between the involved states. Consequently,
we aborted further investigations of CaNa laser cooling at this stage.By using the LEVEL 11 program,[43] we
have calculated the FCFs for the transitions X2Σ+–(1)2Π, X2Σ+–(2)2Π, X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+, (1)2Π–(2)2Π, (2)2Σ+–(2)2Π, (2)2Σ+–(1)2Π of the CaCs molecule at the vibrational levels 0 ≤ v″ ≤ 5 of the upper states (2)2Π and 0 ≤ v ≤ 5 of the lower
states X2Σ+. The graphical representation
of the FCF for the cited transitions is shown in Figure , and their corresponding
values are set in Table S4 in the Supporting
Information.
Figure 11
FCF plotting for the transitions (a) (2)2Σ+–X2Σ+, (b) (2)2Π(2)–2Σ+, (c) X2Σ+–(2)2Π, (d) (2)2Σ+–(1)2Π, (e) (2)2Π–(1)2Π, and (f) X2Σ+–(1)2Π of the CaCs molecule using
the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.
FCF plotting for the transitions (a) (2)2Σ+–X2Σ+, (b) (2)2Π(2)–2Σ+, (c) X2Σ+–(2)2Π, (d) (2)2Σ+–(1)2Π, (e) (2)2Π–(1)2Π, and (f) X2Σ+–(1)2Π of the CaCs molecule using
the CASSCF/MRCI method with three valence electrons.We can notice by checking Figure c and the values in Table S5 in the Supporting Information that the FCFs for the
six lowest vibrational
levels of the transition (2)2Π → X2Σ+ of the molecule CaCs are diagonal (f00 = 0.998, f11 = 0.999, f22 = 0.998, f33 =
0.991, f44 = 0.972, and f55 = 0.935). This diagonal nature has also been proven
experimentally and theoretically.[28,38,44] Based on these values of FCFs, we study the direct
laser cooling for this transition (2)2Π →
X2Σ+. The intermediate state (1)2Π has no effect on the cycling cooling of this transition since
the FCFs for the transitions (2)2Σ+–(1)2Π, X2Σ+–(1)2Π, and (2)2Π–(1)2Π
shown in Figure d–f, respectively, are minimal for the lowest vibrational
levels. The intermediate (2)2Σ+ state
cannot be ignored since the FCFs for the transitions X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+ (Figure a) and (2)2Σ+–(2)2Π (Figure b) are significant
for the first three vibrational levels. The laser cooling of molecules
with a non-intervening intermediate electronic state between the cycling
levels has been confirmed for several molecules, with specific requirements.[42−46] These include a higher transition probability and a smaller radiative
lifetime for transitions between the electronic excited and the ground
states than the intermediate one. Completing these criteria would
assure that an intermediate state does not hinder the laser-cooling
cycle. Recently, however, Yuan et al.,[47] Nguyen and Odom,[48] and Li et al.[49] have proposed laser-cooling schemes involving
intervening electronic intermediate states in the cooling cycle. In
the following, we show that within the approximation of spin-free
calculations, the CaCs molecule is suitable for laser cooling through
the cycle X2Σ+–(2)2Π
with the involvement of the intermediate state (2)2Σ+ in the laser-cooling process.To apply a three-step
cooling scheme, one has to investigate the
radiative lifetime, the value of the FCFs, and vibrational loss ratio
between the ground, excited, and intervening states. We denote by v the vibrational states belonging to the ground state X2Σ+, ν′ are the ones belonging
to the intermediate state (2)2Σ+, and
ν″ belongs to the excited states involved in the cooling
loop (2)2Π. To obtain the values of the radiative
lifetime τ, the LEVEL program can be used to calculate the Einstein
coefficients[42] of the ro–vibrational
transitions through the formula[45]μ(r) is the electronic
T.D.M. (in debye),[46]Aν″ν is the Einstein coefficient in
s–1, ΔE is the emission frequency
(in cm–1), J is the rotational
quantum number, and S(J′, J″) is the Hönl–London factor whose
values vary with the nature of the electronic transition. The present
version of the program calculates A only in the case
of singlet–singlet transitions. Given that the states we are
dealing with are doublets, we will be using the following vibrational
approximation instead (consider Λ as the projection of the angular
momentum of an electronic state on the internuclear axis). For the
parallel transitions with ΔΛ = 0, such as the transition
X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+, we useFor the perpendicular transitions
with ΔΛ = ±1,
such as X2Σ+–(2)2Π
and (2)2Σ+–(2)2Π,
the recommended definition of the perpendicular T.D.M.[50] is usually represented byIn the present
work, however, we used the T.D.M. functions in MOLPRO
software as μ, μ, and μ where
the calculated T.D.M. is vertical (given with respect to x, y, and z). In this case, the
Einstein coefficients[50] are divided by
2 and given byThe calculated values of the radiative
lifetime for the transitions
X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+, (2)2Π–(2)2Σ+, and X2Σ+––(2)2Π are given
in Table . We find
a strong correspondence between the value of τ among electronic
transitions (calculated in Table ) and the vibrational state transitions τ0 (Table ).
More specifically, for the transitions X2Σ+–(2)2Π, (2)2Σ+–(2)2Π, and X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+, the electronic transition
radiative lifetimes τ are 132.04, 3945.37, and 73.68 ns, respectively;
the values of τ0 for the same transitions are 136.5,
4050, and 71.8 ns. The highly diagonal FCF (Table S5) for the transition X2Σ+–(2)2Π (Figure c) and the short value of the radiative lifetime 68.3 <
τ0 < 71.4 ns are indicative of a possible laser-cooling
scheme involving these two states.
Table 6
Radiative Lifetimes
τ of the
Vibrational Transitions between the Electronic States X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+, X2Σ+–(2)2Π, and (2)2Σ+–(2)2Π of the CaCs
Molecule
X2Σ+–(2)2Σ+
value
ν′(22Σ+) = 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
ν (X2Σ+) = 0
Avv′
1.151437 × 107
1.962532 × 106
5.683341 × 105
1.114800 × 105
2.341589 × 104
4.344481 × 103
8.972812 × 102
Rvv′
8.266503 × 10–1
1.400070 × 10–1
4.046544 × 10–2
7.914280 × 10–3
1.868120 × 10–3
7.091100 × 10–4
1.613200 × 10–4
1
Avv′
2.317422 × 106
6.674955 × 106
3.148351 × 106
1.573059 × 106
4.793907 × 105
1.421461 × 105
3.500623 × 104
Rvv′
1.663744 × 10–1
4.761911 × 10–1
2.241629 × 10–1
1.116759 × 10–1
3.824573 × 10–2
2.320121 × 10–2
6.293740 × 10–3
2
Avv′
8.454822 × 104
4.775409 × 106
2.473803 × 106
2.889758 × 106
2.520671 × 106
1.148000 × 106
4.570333 × 105
Rvv′
6.069960 × 10–3
3.406776 × 10–1
1.761350 × 10–1
2.051521 × 10–1
2.010988 × 10–1
1.873776 × 10–1
8.216958 × 10–2
3
Avv′
5.354361 × 103
5.721896 × 105
6.013017 × 106
2.735225 × 105
1.570320 × 106
2.758580 × 106
1.884728 × 106
Rvv′
3.844000 × 10–4
4.081999 × 10–2
4.281274 × 10–1
1.941813 × 10–2
1.252799 × 10–1
4.502579 × 10–1
3.388535 × 10–1
4
Avv′
6.403610 × 103
4.299750 × 10–1
1.752144 × 106
5.339973 × 106
1.515287 × 105
2.990324 × 105
1.983343 × 106
Rvv′
4.597300 × 10–4
3.000000 × 10–8
1.247528 × 10–1
3.790998 × 10–1
1.208894 × 10–2
4.880833 × 10–2
3.565834 × 10–1
5
Avv′
8.483919 × 102
2.365979 × 104
5.973875 × 104
3.435269 × 106
3.099584 × 106
9.225905 × 105
6.341689 × 104
Rvv′
6.091000 × 10–5
1.687890 × 10–3
4.253410 × 10–3
2.438794 × 10–1
2.472844 × 10–1
1.505860 × 10–1
1.140166 × 10–2
6
Avv′
3.535833 × 100
8.639941 × 103
2.953637 × 104
4.628698 × 105
4.689579 × 106
8.519738 × 105
1.137650 × 106
Rvv′
2.500000 × 10–7
6.163700 × 10–4
2.102990 × 10–3
3.286043 × 10–2
3.741340 × 10–1
1.390599 × 10–1
2.045370 × 10–1
sum (s–1) = Aν′ν
1.392895 × 107
1.401739 × 107
1.404492 × 107
1.408593 × 107
1.253449 × 107
6.126667 × 106
5.562074 × 106
τ (s) = 1/Aν′ν
7.180000 × 10–8
7.130000 × 10–8
7.120000 × 10–8
7.100000 × 10–8
7.980000 × 10–8
1.630000 × 10–7
1.800000 × 10–7
τ (ns)
71.8
71.3
71.2
71.0
79.8
1163.0
180.0
From the calculated
Einstein coefficients, we additionally calculate
the vibrational branching ratios by taking onto account the intermediate
state for the three transitions using the following formulas[51,52]The obtained values
are given in Table .In setting out a laser-cooling scheme, the number of cycles
(N) for photon absorption/emission should be maximized
to
sufficiently decelerate the molecule in the Doppler laser-cooling
beams.[52,53] The graphical representation of our proposed
scheme is shown in Figure , where lasers are represented by red solid lines along with
their wavelength. The spontaneous decays are represented by dotted
lines with the values of their FCF (fν′ν) and the vibrational branching ratios (Rν′ν). The wavelength of the main pumping laser (2)2Π(v″ = 0) ← X2Σ+(ν = 0) is λ0″ = 916.4 nm. Three re-pumping
laser beams are employed to avoid leakage to lower vibrational levels.
The wavelength of these repumping lasers for the transitions (2)2Π(v″ = 0) ← X2Σ+(ν = 1), (2)2Π(v″ = 0) ← X2Σ+ (ν = 2), and (2)2Π(v″
= 0) ← X2Σ+(ν = 3) are, respectively,
λ0″1 = 918.8 nm, λ0″2 = 923.1 nm, and λ0″3 = 926.4 nm. In this
case, N, which is the reciprocal to the total loss,
is given bywhere
Figure 12
Laser-cooling scheme for the transition
X2Σ+–(2)2Π οf
the molecule CaCs
with the intermediate state (2)2Σ+.
Laser-cooling scheme for the transition
X2Σ+–(2)2Π οf
the molecule CaCs
with the intermediate state (2)2Σ+.For more experimental detail, the parameters L, amax, V,
and T, which are respectively the slowing distance,
the maximum
acceleration, the initial velocity, and temperature are[24,52]where Kb and h are the Boltzmann and
Planck constants and m is the mass of the considered
CaCs molecule.With this value of N, the experimental parameters
given in eq are V = 15.16 m/s, amax = 7.37 ×
103 m/s2, and L = 1.56 cm.
We have
considered the ratio of the number of excited states connected to
the ground state in the main cycling transition (Ne) to the number of ground states connected to the excited
state of the leading cycling transition (Ntot) plus Ne. We have approximated the value
of Ne/Ntot = 1/5 by only taking into account the vibrational ground and excited
states and ignoring any hyperfine structure. The value of the slowing
distance L can be considered as a convenient choice
as it is within the range of the experimental values for a typical
laser cooling setup. By using the calculated experimental parameters
of eq V = 15.19 m/s, Tini = 2.51 K and amax = 7.37 × 103, we find that
the Doppler and Recoil temperatures that can be reached during the
cooling process are[24,54]The molecule’s initial velocity and temperature imply
that
one needs to find a cooling process that would lead to the initial
temperature of 2.51 K before it reaches the nanokelvin regime. Buffer
gas cooling is a flexible method that is applicable to a multitude
of molecules. It consists of thermalizing species through collisions
with a cold buffer gas, whose role is to dissipate the molecules’
translational energy. Buffer gas cooling of calcium-bearing molecules
has been proven successful for species such as CaH, which were cooled
to temperatures close to microkelvin.We model the CaCs molecules
to be produced through a typical laser
ablation technique before being driven into a buffer cooling cell,
to be then sent in the Doppler laser-cooling setup. According to the
hard-sphere collision model, after N collisions in
the buffer gas cell, the molecules are thermalized to the temperature TN, which is given by[52]We consider
the initial temperature Ti = 7000 K as
the typical temperature of the
CaCs molecules as they leave the laser ablation setup, TB = 2 K is the initial temperature of the helium gas in
the buffer gas cell, and TN = 2.51 K is
the precooling temperature of CaCs molecules. From eq , one can find the number of collisions
in the buffer cell N = 224.For a low density
of CaCs molecules, the average distance λ
(mean free path) covered by the molecules between N and N – 1 collisions with the helium gas
of the buffer cell is given by[52]At a low helium density of nHe = 5
× 1014 atom/cm3 and at low temperature,
the scattering cross-sectional value for collisions between CaCs molecules
and He atoms is typically close to σX–He =
10–14 cm2, leading to a value of λ
= 0.0295 cm. By using the rules of the kinetic theory of ideal gases,
the time for thermalizing the molecules of the CaCs in the buffer
cell is then given by[24]where KB is the
Boltzmann constant and .
Conclusions
In this paper, we have reported ab initio
calculations of 25 doublet
and quartet states of the CaCs molecule and 32 doublet and quartet
low-lying energy states of the CaNa molecule. We studied the P.E.C.s
and D.M.C.s of these molecules with three valence electrons at the
spin-free level by using the CASSCF/MRCI method with the basis sets
ECP46MWB and ECP10MWB for Cs and Ca atoms, respectively, while for
the Na atom, we used the two basis aug-ccpVAZ and ccpVAZ. In addition,
the PDMs for the ground and the excited electronic states have been
calculated and for most of the bound states, the spectroscopic constants Te, ωe, Be, Re, and De have been also obtained. Moreover, the ro-vibrational constants Ev, Bv, and Dv with the abscissas of turning points Rmin and Rmax have
been obtained for different vibrational levels of the ground state
and some low-lying electronic states of the two molecules by means
of the canonical function approach. The T.D.M.s have been also determined
for the lowest electronic transitions, along with the emission angular
frequency ω21 and the oscillator strength f21. The calculation of the FCF, the Einstein
coefficients , and
the spontaneous radiative lifetime
for the molecule CaCs shows its candidacy for a direct laser cooling
between the two electronic states X2Σ+ and (2)2Π. The study of this cooling has been done
with the intermediate states (1)2Π and (2)2Σ+ by calculating the vibrational branching ratios,
the number of cycles (N) for photon absorption/emission,
the experimental parameters of this cooling, and the recoil and Doppler
temperatures. The values of the initial required temperature show
the need for a precooling buffer gas cell, in a typical experimental
setup. A laser cooling scheme is presented with four pumping and repumping
lasers whose wavelengths are in the infrared region. These results
open the way for an experimental work on the cooling of the transition
X2Σ+–(2)2Π of
the CaCs molecule, with an intermediate state. Cooling polar molecules
such as CaCs to the microkelvin and nanokelvin range of temperature
could lead to phenomena and discoveries far beyond the focus of traditional
molecular science. More precisely, such studies offer promising applications
such as new platforms for quantum computing, precise control of molecular
dynamics, nanolithography, and Bose–Einstein condensate of
a polar molecule. The electric dipole–dipole interaction may
give rise to a molecular superfluid via Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer
pairing, and it leads to fundamentally new condensed-matter phases
and new complex quantum dynamics.[55]